Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class shows?

795 replies

MrsBonnie · 23/10/2022 21:00

I work in a lovely school where they’ve all had very different upbringings to me. Very much working class here. Sometimes I think it shows with little things I’ve noticed.

Having sugar in tea, using a tumble drier, not having a cleaner, using the wrong glasses for different drinks (I.E using the same one for everything!)… what else am I missing that excludes me from the club 😂 sometimes I will mention something like the above and get “oh I never use a tumble drier” … then I just think oops have I said something weird there?

Sometimes I think they’re judging me with things I say and do but I hope not! I grew up being homeless at a certain point, council houses, single teen (but amazing) mum, a very specific type of circle. I feel like Mum did everything she could to get us out of that way of life, but I can’t help but feel I don’t belong sometimes. Or that I stick out like a sore thumb. Am I being daft? Imposter syndrome a little bit!

OP posts:
Pregnancyfood · 26/10/2022 18:07

@Dassams no, from my understanding of this ridiculous system you cannot change class depending on your job / income etc. your children and grandchildren can though.

In the US, I think it’s different and more income based.

Dassams · 26/10/2022 18:06

its the other way round - sadly he / she might be more likely to end up as a CEO due to his class.

Ok, what if he/she grew up 'lower class' but worked hard and became a CEO with a high salary? Do they 'move up' a class or two Confused?

P.s I'm not British originally

Pregnancyfood · 26/10/2022 18:01

@Dassams its the other way round - sadly he / she might be more likely to end up as a CEO due to his class.

My SIL works for a living - in private wealth, having attended Durham and public school. Dad is a member at Boodles, huge country house. She’s clearly not working class just because she has a job.

Dassams · 26/10/2022 17:59

No, it doesn't magically make him/her a different species. It does probably make them a different class.

Why? Because he spends more time in the office? Because he earns more?

I honestly don't see how a more senior employee is in a higher 'class'?!

emmaliz · 26/10/2022 17:56

eastegg · 26/10/2022 15:12

I know! I feel very looked down the nose upon sometimes for my half a spoonful. And can I get certain family members to actually put that half spoonful in without making me practically beg for it? My Mil has known me for about 17 years and still resolutely ignores the fact I take sugar. Took me 5 minutes to learn how she has her tea. I find those sort of basic manners lacking amongst the UMC (her) compared to the LMC/UWC (me).

I have 2! Can you imagine the judgement there. I remember a colleague being so shocked that I had to check I had said sugar and not crack 😂

Fink · 26/10/2022 17:48

Dassams · 26/10/2022 17:46

We are not all working class. I have a very different life from the Chief Executive of the company I work for.

There are way more similarities between you and your CEO. You're both humans who go to work to earn a living.

The CEO may work longer hours, have more responsibilities, earn a higher salary, but that does NOT make him magically belong to a different 'class' Confused

No, it doesn't magically make him/her a different species. It does probably make them a different class. Not everyone who works for a living is working class, by a long shot.

Dassams · 26/10/2022 17:46

We are not all working class. I have a very different life from the Chief Executive of the company I work for.

There are way more similarities between you and your CEO. You're both humans who go to work to earn a living.

The CEO may work longer hours, have more responsibilities, earn a higher salary, but that does NOT make him magically belong to a different 'class' Confused

antelopevalley · 26/10/2022 17:23

We are not all working class. I have a very different life from the Chief Executive of the company I work for.

Dassams · 26/10/2022 16:44

We are all working class.

Exactly. We're all 'working' to earn a living! Let's not feel more important than we are.

Fink · 26/10/2022 16:16

ilovepixie · 26/10/2022 15:48

Is this like Protestants keeping the toaster in the cupboard!😂😂

Yep. And let's not get back into the tray bake & cakes debate! Although it was surprisingly accurate. I've always said you can judge a church's ecclesiology by its biscuit selection.

Fink · 26/10/2022 16:09

Mollymoostoo · 25/10/2022 21:36

We are all working class.
Middle class - The Middleton family, MP's, the PM
Upper class - aristocracy
Get over yourself.

That's not the traditional delineations or how most people understand it. Middle class is subdivided many times over.

The Middletons, the PM, some MPs (e.g. JRM, Johnson et al) are upper-middle class. There are other people who are solidly middle class or lower-middle. Middle class isn't just the super-wealthy non-titled elite.

In any case, it's more complicated nowadays as the (perceived) correlation between money, profession, cultural interests and friendships groups has broken down. There are plenty of people who earn little in professional jobs and are materially poorer than people in classic working-class jobs, or people who are on low incomes but very interested in the arts (often perceived as a middle class marker), or people who are highly educated but haven't taken up a professional job. I find the Great British Class Survey to be quite helpful, much more so than the 20th century definitions which are increasingly irrelevant.

ilovepixie · 26/10/2022 15:48

Is this like Protestants keeping the toaster in the cupboard!😂😂

antelopevalley · 26/10/2022 15:18

BookishKitten · 26/10/2022 14:15

As a foreigner im always amazed at how British people are obsessed about class: trying to hide their working class background, or passing themselves as something they’re not, or seeing the middle-class mimick upper class behaviours and consumer spending. It’s frankly so bizarre.

if people you’re surrounded by exclude you on the basis of class, then why would you want to be around them??

I agree. But if you are poor you still have to be around teachers, Drs, and employers who look down on you and can directly affect the life of you and your children. Trust me I knew as a child which teachers looked down on me and my family. By the time I got to secondary I lied about the job my parents did if any teacher asked.

antelopevalley · 26/10/2022 15:16

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/10/2022 15:06

FreshCop Shocking.

I really hate the word "Chav" it's cruel and derogatory.

I have seen it written on MN 1000's of times over the years.

Agreed. Classism is alive and well.

eastegg · 26/10/2022 15:12

emmaliz · 23/10/2022 21:12

I always wonder why people are so against sugar in hot drinks when many of them consume plenty of sugar in other forms

I know! I feel very looked down the nose upon sometimes for my half a spoonful. And can I get certain family members to actually put that half spoonful in without making me practically beg for it? My Mil has known me for about 17 years and still resolutely ignores the fact I take sugar. Took me 5 minutes to learn how she has her tea. I find those sort of basic manners lacking amongst the UMC (her) compared to the LMC/UWC (me).

EmeraldShamrock1 · 26/10/2022 15:06

FreshCop Shocking.

I really hate the word "Chav" it's cruel and derogatory.

I have seen it written on MN 1000's of times over the years.

Sennelier1 · 26/10/2022 15:00

Let me tell you a memory from my youth. (F.y.i. I'm in Belgium) I must've been 14 or 15 when I was helping out on a rather big reception in a local school. One of the guests was my uncle and he wanted to present me to an elderly man who he said was the lawyer my dad did his apprenticeship with. I knew the name and that this man is a baron. He turned out to be very kind and friendly. He was well dressed but you wouldn't have given him a second look. Later that evening I told my dad I had met his mentor, and that I was impressed by his simple presentation. My dad answered : Daughter, real class is not showy or loud, real class shows itself by discretion. But what most people consider class is in reality the loud behaviour of nouveau-riches.

BookishKitten · 26/10/2022 14:15

As a foreigner im always amazed at how British people are obsessed about class: trying to hide their working class background, or passing themselves as something they’re not, or seeing the middle-class mimick upper class behaviours and consumer spending. It’s frankly so bizarre.

if people you’re surrounded by exclude you on the basis of class, then why would you want to be around them??

antelopevalley · 26/10/2022 14:02

@fresh And I knew it as a child from a very poor family.

FreshCop · 26/10/2022 13:46

These are what some of our teachers are thinking:

Headteacher is accused of calling a pupil 'Jabba the sl**' and mocking 'chavs' in series of tweets from 10 years ago

Smoow · 26/10/2022 13:16

Are you working in a private school?😂
You're over thinking this and hung up on what others think. Just ignore comments and be yourself. Are others making you feel inferior? If yes, then they are bullying

Brackensmomma · 26/10/2022 11:48

I'm working class worked since I left school. Never had a tumble dryer growing up.
In fact only got one 7 years ago. I'm now disabled I must now be middle class 🙃. Why does class status matter so much to people??. As long as people are nice kind and caring especially in a school setting I don't care class matters unless you're bunking off double math.. 🤣

CulturePigeon · 26/10/2022 10:23

Who cares? Just be yourself and be proud.

Someone I knew who went to Oxford to study English was happily very, very northern working class with a rich Bolton accent. When he had to translate the Old English poem, Beowulf, in tutorials, he declaimed it in his local dialect so that the opening exclamation 'Hwaet!' was translated 'Ay up! Listen 'ere!'

He was incredibly popular and respected because he made no attempt to pretend to be what he wasn't - he was perfectly proud to be himself. I know he was very clever and confident, but I think confident is the key idea here.

felizdia · 26/10/2022 10:17

Always a water glass on the table and know the difference between a white wine glass and a red wine glass.
Holding your cutlery correctly is the biggest social giveaway if you don't want to stand out.
The secret is to watch other people before picking up your knife and fork! Just hang back those couple of seconds and discreetly observe, they will never know and you can sit back smugly and confident.
Napkin not serviette.
Sofa not settee/couch
Loo not toilet
and never use the word 'posh' 🤣
...I have a tumble dryer and so do most of my friends!
Personally, I like to judge a person on how they are not where they come from or who their mother is or what they are wearing.
Manners and nice personality cost nothing.

KellyTelios · 26/10/2022 10:09

@NellyBarney thanks for bringing a touch of realism and fresh air to this discussion. Completely agree. We aren't little England anymore, class depictions here are too culture specific and outdated, when considered in the context of especially south UK. If you're raised in the UK, to foreign parents,
you'll have a mixture of habits and class "markers" may differ between cultures.