Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think working class shows?

795 replies

MrsBonnie · 23/10/2022 21:00

I work in a lovely school where they’ve all had very different upbringings to me. Very much working class here. Sometimes I think it shows with little things I’ve noticed.

Having sugar in tea, using a tumble drier, not having a cleaner, using the wrong glasses for different drinks (I.E using the same one for everything!)… what else am I missing that excludes me from the club 😂 sometimes I will mention something like the above and get “oh I never use a tumble drier” … then I just think oops have I said something weird there?

Sometimes I think they’re judging me with things I say and do but I hope not! I grew up being homeless at a certain point, council houses, single teen (but amazing) mum, a very specific type of circle. I feel like Mum did everything she could to get us out of that way of life, but I can’t help but feel I don’t belong sometimes. Or that I stick out like a sore thumb. Am I being daft? Imposter syndrome a little bit!

OP posts:
jetadore · 25/10/2022 09:02

Oof, I guess I really put my foot in my mouth there. For one I actually detest the class system in this country and the fact it’s so entrenched, and don’t even want to be framing discussion in these terms.
For two, those who have rightly pointed out that underfunding is the root cause of the decline in education, I totally agree. The point I was trying (badly) to make was that this underfunding teaching has devalued teaching as a profession. In my experience/opinion there are teachers coming through who lack the requisite English, maths skills, computer literacy and even subject knowledge to teach well. There’s a massive teacher shortage and they’re taking anyone. Now before everyone goes ballistic, I’m NOT trying to equate those things with being working class! Teaching is an very undesirable job now for high quality graduates. And I’m NOT saying middle class = high quality. I suppose I’m saying, if a working class person aspires to be middle class they won’t do it via teaching anymore due to the the salary and status. I KNOW this is caused by underfunding making teaching very difficult and stressful. But teaching should aspire to high educational standards (call that an ivory tower if you will) and it doesn’t exclude working class people, because there are top, talented working class graduates, they just don’t end up in teaching!

bluefrog11 · 25/10/2022 08:56

OP I know exactly what you mean. I think the examples you’ve used aren’t particularly representative of what you are trying to say.

I’m from a resolutely WC family (although my mum had definite “aspirations” for my sibling & I) but my DH’s family & most friends are MC. There’s just subtle differences in attitude about things. DH’s mum for instance seem happy to use a £15 basic kettle that she’s had for 8 years yet is unhappy if she doesn’t have a variety of hoidays, mini breaks and “experiences” though out the year plus regular meals out, theatre, etc with a wide circle of friends. Her house is not dirty per se but definitely slightly grubby round the edges, all of their family are the same.

My mum has a sparkling clean house full of on-trend items (from Dunelm mostly!) and a hi-tech fancy kettle. Yet even though she could afford to do more holidays etc she chooses not to, having fun in life just doesn’t seem to be as much of a priority. I’ve noticed the MC people I know have a more positive attitude to life and an attitude of “I deserve this, so I’ll do it.” My mum can be very negative, a “life is tough, get on with it approach.” I hate it and try not to replicate it but I see myself sliding towards the same - I guess it’s hard to change when you’ve brought up with ingrained attitudes.

Mine & DH’s different core attitudes have also been weirdly revealed recently. Starting to think about secondary schools & I am of the opinion that you should do the very best you can by your children even if you have to make sacrifices . I want to send DD to private school - we could just about afford it if I got a better paid job (achievable) and we gave up a few luxuries. Interestingly my dh isn’t willing to sacrifice his lifestyle and thinks she’ll be alright at the local comp. I do think there’s a certain type of MC attitude of being very laissez faire about things like this.

YippieKayakOtherBuckets · 25/10/2022 08:48

jetadore · 25/10/2022 08:23

Agree, I’m a MC teacher and I feel out of place! Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining (not a criticism of working class people, just that teaching has become a working class job, not a profession).

As for OP, just be yourself!

I’m a middle-class teacher who went to Oxford. I cringe to type that but I mention it only to make it clear that you do not speak for me or my colleagues. You are a disgusting snob.

AffronttoBS · 25/10/2022 08:42

@Endlesssummer2022 social mobility not only grinding to a halt, but being reversed, as evidenced by dd s universities application….they seem to assume that if your parents have a degree and have a MC job that generations of the family must have been born with a silver spoon in their mouths.

GUARDIAN1 · 25/10/2022 08:40

jetadore · 25/10/2022 08:23

Agree, I’m a MC teacher and I feel out of place! Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining (not a criticism of working class people, just that teaching has become a working class job, not a profession).

As for OP, just be yourself!

"Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining" WTAF?

This is blatantly a criticism of working class people. Clearly in your opinion not good enough to teach to a high standard. It reminds me of when I started my social work degree back in the 80s and one of my cohort said the trouble with 'poor' children is that they smell. Absolutely appalling. I'm also appalled by your comment. I for one am very pleased my granddaughter will not be taught by a bunch of middle-class, superior-feeling snobs.

Yousee · 25/10/2022 08:37

I feel a Mrs Bucket binge coming on after this thread! 😊
I have a tumble dryer, a cleaner and a DH from the badlands of the east end of Glasgow who "networks" as well as any posh boy. He's unreal.
Having a bit of a class identity crisis on that basis now.
No sugar in my tea though - perish the very thought.

luxxlisbon · 25/10/2022 08:35

Agree, I’m a MC teacher and I feel out of place! Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining (not a criticism of working class people, just that teaching has become a working class job, not a profession).

The standard of education has declined because they lot those poor working class ones go to uni and become teachers?
Teaching is still absolutely a profession, what specifically do you think was of a higher standard when ‘only MC’ people could teach?

I can’t believe you are teaching some of the youth today with attitudes like this.

Blaggertyjibbet · 25/10/2022 08:34

@jetadore wins the award for the most condescending and classist comment on the thread. And that’s saying something for a Mumsnet class thread!

BretonBlue · 25/10/2022 08:33

Benjispruce4 · 25/10/2022 08:29

But teaching didn’t used to be a graduate profession did it?

There have always been university-educated teachers. Teacher training colleges were not universities, however.

ThanksItHasPockets · 25/10/2022 08:32

jetadore · 25/10/2022 08:23

Agree, I’m a MC teacher and I feel out of place! Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining (not a criticism of working class people, just that teaching has become a working class job, not a profession).

As for OP, just be yourself!

Please explain to me how this is not a criticism. My comprehension skills are pretty good and I can’t find a way to interpret this without concluding that you see a correlation between more working-class graduates entering teaching and an overall decline in education standards (which are not declining over time, incidentally. The problem is resources after twelve years of systematic underfunding).

MrsBonnie · 25/10/2022 08:31

@Quveas go back and read my OP, plus the others I’ve posted. You’ve taken my post the opposite way.

OP posts:
Benjispruce4 · 25/10/2022 08:29

But teaching didn’t used to be a graduate profession did it?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 25/10/2022 08:29

I left teaching 2 years ago. All the teachers in my very big school were definitely MC.

Gites in France, holidays in Tuscany, art galleries, film festivals.Shopped in John Lewis. I’ve just sat and in my head gone through every classroom. Everyone was MC.

We had several doctors on the staff.

Endlesssummer2022 · 25/10/2022 08:29

And since when did tumble dryers become a class issue? How strange! I use a combo of airers, dehumidifier, tumble dryer. Hardy clothes go in the tumble dryer (try to avoid using it too much as it’s expensive and creases clothes).

Most clothes go on airer in spare room with dehumidifier as I find they crease less. If its summer, I’ll stick the airer in a corner of the garden. We got rid of our washing line years ago as it didn’t look nice across the garden. My bit of luxury in laundry is that If I’ve left the clothes up on her days in, my cleaner will fold and put away.

If you have a busy life (I work FT), you do what’s most convenient, ‘class’ doesn’t come in to it as its just plain weird.

BretonBlue · 25/10/2022 08:28

jetadore · 25/10/2022 08:23

Agree, I’m a MC teacher and I feel out of place! Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining (not a criticism of working class people, just that teaching has become a working class job, not a profession).

As for OP, just be yourself!

I have read this twice and am trying really hard to understand how you could mean this is as anything other than a criticism of WC teachers.

Teaching remains a graduate profession. It sounds like you want to have a word with the universities who let in all those ghastly working-classes.

Biscuit
Benjispruce4 · 25/10/2022 08:27

For the record what makes you middle class?

Quveas · 25/10/2022 08:26

If you are judging people for not having the right drinking glasses then I am sure that you do stick out - as a snob. You say people are judging you, but your post is nothing but judgements about others.

jetadore · 25/10/2022 08:23

BCBird · 23/10/2022 21:09

I'm a teacher. Proud of being working class. We were few and far between when I started teaching 25years ago. The snobbery was rife. We are everywhere now🤣

Agree, I’m a MC teacher and I feel out of place! Shows why the standard of education in this country is declining (not a criticism of working class people, just that teaching has become a working class job, not a profession).

As for OP, just be yourself!

MBDBBB · 25/10/2022 08:22

My step dad comes from a family who had (at one time) a country “seat”. Beautiful big house, family portraits and silver, the whole shebang. The money was frittered away by some profligate gambler somewhere along the line but he’s still pretty posh (and utterly lovely to boot). He has sugar in his tea…

JustKittenAround · 25/10/2022 08:20

To be clear I meant the actual rich. Working. Class and middle are the same. I’ll limp the poors on it as well.

But those with real wealth network and really have this net of opportunity for themselves. It’s wild.

job didn’t work out? Here’s another fancy opportunity

need to be connected with this special advanced field of study person ? Ok!

You need your daughter in law to get a nice job? Ok! All done!

Just something I noticed.

JustKittenAround · 25/10/2022 08:16

I mean… people with true means don’t sit around discussion the way they clean their clothing…

Growing up poor and rising the ranks I do notice something that is definitely a difference between the poors and middle class.. it’s the ability to network.

blew my mind to watch it in action! The way those with real means (not middle class vs working flapping gums about how much sugar is poured in a cup)… the way they can pick up a phone and BAM things are in motion.

I have spent a lot of my time building a network where I actively help others and connect people. It is something invaluable.

Also I have learned from the truly rich is the way to handle money. So many tricks and ways.

I swear I’ve never heard anyone in my life say anything bad about the sugar tea thing. It’s banal. Actually , while not using a timber dryer is seen as washer woman status … it gets some cache being environmentally friendly.

Im American though. But … I really feel like the power of networking is really something those of middle and “working” (same
thing) could benefit from learning. … if they haven’t

Endlesssummer2022 · 25/10/2022 08:14

AffronttoBS · 25/10/2022 07:50

My parents were peasants in China, my mum was illiterate, I’m the first to go to university. DH and I have now have successful professional and upper managerial careers and live in a naive house in an affluent area. I think the posh kids of just stop oil are a disgrace. I have a tumble drier. So what clas does that make me?

I would say you were first gen middle class like me. I grew up in a firm working class household but was the first of my family to go to uni. A few years ago I claimed I was still working class and got shouted down by colleagues for being ridiculous.

To be honest though I’m not bothered which category others put me in, I’m still going to like what I like, eat what I eat and do what I do. Couldn’t give a monkeys if onlookers describe it as working or middle class behaviour.

We’ll probably be the last generation to wonder where we fit though due to social mobility grinding to a halt.

Spicybananas · 25/10/2022 08:07

MrsPetty · 25/10/2022 01:29

I worked with a woman who very much believed that her working class roots and accent held her back in her career. It was very interesting to hear her perspective. I couldn’t disagree with her. Especially as the hiring panels weren’t generally working class …

I believe her. I’ve had to learn over the years that my working class background (and the fact I do unfortunately sound very common because that’s just what my accent is) can hold me back, and there’s many occasions I’ve had to be really careful how I portray myself around certain people. It’s sad but that’s the same for many people with many different reasons they’re discriminated against.

Blaggertyjibbet · 25/10/2022 08:03

Sniggering to myself at all these people explaining their elaborate clothes drying routines in order to maintain some sort of bafflingly specific ‘tumble dryer-free and therefore a cut above the working class’ badge of honour. The people asserting this—if it is indeed a thing that people actually think—are perhaps overestimating their own social standing. They are too poor for paid help to do the laundry for them, but just high up enough to know they should embrace that weirdly middle middle suspicion of things that make your life easier (with the notable exception of garlic presses, which they profess to be essential and yet do NOT actually save time and in fact bruise the garlic). Upper middles and above have no such hangups, and they certainly wouldn’t spend all day jostling around clothing airers set up in every room. The fussy pieces are either at the cleaners or have been done by hand and are drying on a pulley rack in the utility, but the rest has been put into the dryer by the cleaner.

Doingmybest12 · 25/10/2022 07:51

It is interesting to learn about how others live. Of course people have different cultures and these reflect your upbringing , this will be in part related to class. I am sure some differences in how people live over generations is about the space they have for example to hang wet washing around the place etc. Hopefully you've got lovely colleagues and none of this will matter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread