Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my dad after daughter choked?

137 replies

goodmorningsunny · 23/10/2022 20:20

I had lunch at my parents'. I was feeding my 9mo little bits of soft fruit, she had lots of little bits on her tray. While I was distracted, my dad broke a bit of Dorito off and gave it to her.

She started to choke. Really choke.

I froze in fear. My husband pulled her out of the high chair and my dad pulled her off him, turned her upside down and smacked her hard on the back. Out came the crisp.

My dad shouted "you feed her too much!" Through angry tears and stormed off.

As I was about to leave, he pulled me to the side and angrily said "you know, I saved your daughters life today. It will tear this family apart if she dies. You have to change how you feed her or she will die and it will kill us". He was angry crying. I did tell him that it was him that gave her the thing she choked on and I can't control when other people give her food when I'm not looking but he just said that she was my responsibility and I can't just blame other people.

I'm really sad about this. It's made me feel like a shit mum. It's made me feel like he thinks I don't care about her.

Honestly opinions, was this my fault? Im really doubting myself because of how angry he got. I do know the baby first aid but in the moment, I froze. I'm just so devastated by this and I know my parents are going to give me the cold shoulder for a while now :(

OP posts:
October2020 · 23/10/2022 22:00

Don't say that @amkm21 , God forbid we refer to resources that aren't the good old NHS...

(I'm joking, of course, thanks for sharing)

amkm21 · 23/10/2022 21:59

Yanbu.

Your dad shouldn't have given the Dorito. Especially a small piece as it is probably more of a choke risk than a larger chunk as the sensory feedback isn't as great from small pieces.
His reaction was probably out of shock, to me it doesn't really make much sense.

I would suggest some time out to calm down from it all and revisit how you feel in a few days/weeks if needed. Your child's safety is the main priority but you will have to work on repairing the relationship at some point.

I am definitely more paranoid when it comes to foods for my now toddler. I'm a speech and language therapist that works with adults with dysphagia and it has made me quite paranoid about choking with my little one.
The IDDSI website has info on inappropriate foods for babies, and Melanie potock (an American paediatric slt who specialises in swallowing disorders/dysphagia) and solid starts are also quite good resources in general, for those who are interested.

Dotcheck · 23/10/2022 21:58

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 23/10/2022 20:22

He needs to go on a first aid course

Never would I dangle a kid upside down and hit them in the back!

I’ve had to do that before- it worked. And he WAS the one who dislodged the crisp ( which he fed her, and gaslit op about after).

OP
Sounds like a bit of distance is a good idea. Your dad was 100% in the wrong

Daffodilsandtuplips · 23/10/2022 21:56

PS, You’re not a shit mum.

CoastalWave · 23/10/2022 21:56

A child can (and sadly has) choked and died on smooth mashed potato.

Sounds like he's proper panicked. Personally I'd cut him some slack. No harm done.

TheCurseOfBoris · 23/10/2022 21:56

Where did the Dorrito come from? Was it something he was eating or something you were feeding her or were going to?
It's strictly soft foods only at that age and especially not a Dorrito as it's thicker and pointier (sp?) than normal crisps.
If it was something he fed her off his own plate, then he owes you a huge apology.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 23/10/2022 21:55

He’s obviously deflecting his guilt and shock at you. It’s scared him.
I wouldn’t let this go, quietly let him know that you know that he didn’t mean to cause her harm but from now on to be mindful about giving her food she can’t manage.
And yes a First Aid course for everyone is good idea.

Saz12 · 23/10/2022 21:54

My DD chocked on a bit of cheese at about 10 months old. Proper, silent chocking.

GP were in the room at the time, and froze. I managed to dislodge it. It was a horrible experience.

let everyone calm down for a few days before deciding they’re awful people.

lottiegarbanzo · 23/10/2022 21:47

I know my parents are going to give me the cold shoulder for a while now :(

This part is just really, really odd.

October2020 · 23/10/2022 21:46

Raisins should not be given to children below 1 as they are a choking hazard for that age. That's NHS advice!

lottiegarbanzo · 23/10/2022 21:45

You have to change how you feed her or she will die and it will kill us

Was the whole episode a protest against baby-led weaning? Did he (inadvertently, presumably), demonstrate 'the worst thing that could happen' to you?

mummyh2016 · 23/10/2022 21:44

@October2020 one of those pages you linked lists raisins as a choking hazard. Raisins, really?

October2020 · 23/10/2022 21:43

What a strange thing to say. Truly bizarre.

Biscuitsneeded · 23/10/2022 21:43

When I was a kid we took my newly widowed Grandpa. who was a GP, on holiday with us. He was sitting between me and my younger brother on the back seat of the car and my parents gave us a boiled sweet. My brother started to choke on it, but we were on the French motorway and there was nothing my parents could do. My Grandpa turned my brother upside down in a moving car and whacked him on the back and the sweet came flying out. Pretty damn sure he did the correct thing and he saved my brother's life...

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/10/2022 21:42

@October2020 still in the PFB stage then?

JenniferBarkley · 23/10/2022 21:40

I wouldn't have considered a bit of dorito a choking hazard (any more than anything else), but who on earth thinks that's an acceptable food for a baby. Yes he was upset but he was completely in the wrong and should never have spoken to you like that. Could you speak to your mum and tell her you're very upset but will accept a sincere apology?

October2020 · 23/10/2022 21:40

Lol I wish, I really could use some more money.

You choose to do what you like, I choose to use the information that is available to make sensible decisions to protect my child in the best way I can. She isn't going to hate me when she grows up because I didn't let her eat tortilla chips until she was 4. But I would never forgive myself if she choked on something (or worse) because a woman on mumsnet told me that we don't follow the information because it's American 😒

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/10/2022 21:37

@October2020

Are you on commission for these American websites?

In the UK we go by the NHS weaning advice which is different.

Pinkyxx · 23/10/2022 21:37

@goodmorningsunny It's very very frightening when a very young child has difficulty breathing. My DD stopped breathing aged 7 weeks. I'm still not over the experience 13 years later! The hospital had a pediatric first aider come to the home to train me on CPR / first aid afterwards. What your Dad did was spot on. Anyone who says different has no clue and would do well to educate themselves. A bit of dorito is also not a chocking hazard..

Your father's reaction doesn't surprise me I'm not saying it's right, or an appropriate way to behave but when faced with a threat to life people react from a visceral place. Having been there I can understand it. I'd suggest you all cut yourselves some slack and in your shoes I'd be calling my Dad tomorrow to resolve this. Blame has no place in experiences like this, gratitude does.

Brigante9 · 23/10/2022 21:36

He knows he did wrong, he was panicked and overreacted. It was his fault, never let him near food her together. Tell him he never feeds her again.

mintymcclinty · 23/10/2022 21:34

If dad is usually pretty reasonable I’d assume that he was just in shock/terrified/guilty.

I also wonder whether he saw you breaking up pieces of food and giving them to her and he just figured he was doing what you were without really thinking about the fact that it was a crisp. Perhaps he weaned you using traditional methods so hasn’t had to gauge the appropriateness of different foods. And so has blamed the method rather than his actions if you see what I mean. Especially if you’ve had to talk him round to the approach.

For a loving dad/grandad I’d work on just moving past it.

Vegay · 23/10/2022 21:34

Eh? He gave her the crisp, in fact I read halfway down and had to go back up to make sure it was HIM who gave her the dorrito.

Is he a bit weird your dad? I don't mean to be cruel saying that, but his response is very weird. Firstly, I'd ask a parent if I could give their child something to eat, secondly, even if I'd saved that child's life, I'd be extremely apologetic - it was a consequence of his actions.

You did nothing wrong, even freezing. I'm pretty sure you would've dealt with it had you been on your own.

It shouldn't be you who is concerned about the cold shoulder in this case.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 23/10/2022 21:30

October2020 · 23/10/2022 21:22

Tortilla chips are in the top 10 choking hazards and not recommended until 4. You were all very scared. When you've all calmed down, have a chat and maybe review the top 10 list together.

According to what list? I’ve just googled and looked at several pages and not one of them says tortillas.

Grapes, popcorn, apples, nuts, seeds, lumps of peanut butter, marshmallows, hard sweets, raw veg are all commonly listed.

Isahlo · 23/10/2022 21:29

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 23/10/2022 20:26

You did nothing wrong, and a Dorito isn’t a high risk food for choking.

it sounds like it was a terrifying experience and emotions have run high. Is your dad normally so reactionary, or is this a one off?

This.
Young children are allowed crisps

everyone was just really stressed because you all love the baby

Swipe left for the next trending thread