Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my dad after daughter choked?

137 replies

goodmorningsunny · 23/10/2022 20:20

I had lunch at my parents'. I was feeding my 9mo little bits of soft fruit, she had lots of little bits on her tray. While I was distracted, my dad broke a bit of Dorito off and gave it to her.

She started to choke. Really choke.

I froze in fear. My husband pulled her out of the high chair and my dad pulled her off him, turned her upside down and smacked her hard on the back. Out came the crisp.

My dad shouted "you feed her too much!" Through angry tears and stormed off.

As I was about to leave, he pulled me to the side and angrily said "you know, I saved your daughters life today. It will tear this family apart if she dies. You have to change how you feed her or she will die and it will kill us". He was angry crying. I did tell him that it was him that gave her the thing she choked on and I can't control when other people give her food when I'm not looking but he just said that she was my responsibility and I can't just blame other people.

I'm really sad about this. It's made me feel like a shit mum. It's made me feel like he thinks I don't care about her.

Honestly opinions, was this my fault? Im really doubting myself because of how angry he got. I do know the baby first aid but in the moment, I froze. I'm just so devastated by this and I know my parents are going to give me the cold shoulder for a while now :(

OP posts:
DelurkingLawyer · 23/10/2022 23:01

So glad your LO is ok. The issue isn’t the Dorito (and there seems to be a difference of vie as to whether it’s ok, so his mistake is understandable). It’s the gaslighting DARVO reaction. “You feed her too much” - what the actual fuck? And “You have to be responsible”?!! It’s not like some random in the local park had given it to her. He did it. Understandable to say something mad in the heat of the moment when he was panicking and upset. Taking you aside later and repeating his blaming of you is not on. He needs telling. My dad was the same. Nothing was ever his fault.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/10/2022 22:53

October2020 · 23/10/2022 21:22

Tortilla chips are in the top 10 choking hazards and not recommended until 4. You were all very scared. When you've all calmed down, have a chat and maybe review the top 10 list together.

This doesn’t surprise me. All the comments about crisps being fine are missing the point. Doritos are a completely different consistency than baby crisps or a packet of standard crisps, both of which melt unlike tortilla chips.

katepilar · 23/10/2022 22:51

I hate this. I think its basically the same principal that my father uses - blame everyone around him when he needs to let the steam off. I know they do it because they are severely traumatised but the effect it has on the people they channel it to is also really bad.
YOu havent done anything wrong, he did. Sorry you are being put in situations like this. Must have been very frightening when your baby choked.

otherwayup · 23/10/2022 22:47

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 23/10/2022 20:22

He needs to go on a first aid course

Never would I dangle a kid upside down and hit them in the back!

I work in early years and saved a child's life using that exact technique.
It was over 20 years ago but still haunts me.

I suggest you educate yourself before jumping on a thread to give pointless and incorrect 'advice'

Hope you're ok op Flowers

cansu · 23/10/2022 22:43

He was obviously frightened and deflected the blame. He needs to apologise for being so unpleasant. He no doubt didn't mean any harm when giving her the crisp but has had a nasty shock. Your reaction should depend on whether he is normally a dick.

Cruisebabe1 · 23/10/2022 22:42

greenlampcat · 23/10/2022 21:23

OP- tell him to FO and not project on you. He is an abusive arse by making you feel bad when he was the one who put your child at risk. I seriously would take today as a learning point and minimise contact if he is making you feel insecure and question your parenting skills when it is not your fault. He is gaslighting you - even if it's because it's because it's because he feels awful that's no excuse - he is manipulative. Give yourself from space from him

This!! Keep your distance for a while , your dad sounds a right idiot.

Vegay · 23/10/2022 22:40

@ThatGirlInACountrySong I'm intrigued to know what you were taught.

I was taught baby should be slightly inverted as it changes the gravity for the stuck object. Then five back blows. Yes, you would reduce the pressure compared to an adult, but you still give back blows. Then, turn over, still slightly inverted and give 2 chest thrusts.

So yes, the baby is slightly 'upside down' and being 'hit'. For someone going off instinct, turning the child upside down is a great thing to do.

Main focus here is dislodging object so baby can breathe. I'd rather possibly break bones and cause bruising than be worried about someone thinking I was 'hitting' a child.

popcornfrenzy · 23/10/2022 22:39

What stands out for me OP is that you froze with fear - what happens if you're on your own? Maybe get yourself on a first aid course. Your Dad was wrong in giving baby a Dorito - all you crazies saying it's an ok food - it's bloody well not! I BLW both of my 2 and believe it's the safest way as they learn to chew food properly.

My DS choked on a 20p coin that some random man had given him in his buggy - apparently he was a local gypsy and was crossing my sons palm with silver. I didn't even see him give it to him. Yep, I turned him upside down and shook until whatever he was choking on came out. My son was about 12 months old at the time - I did whatever was necessary to stop him choking and I'm a trained first-aider. So whilst your Dad did cause it - it also solved it...I would be asking for an apology from him.

purpleme12 · 23/10/2022 22:39

Oh my gosh I thought maybe reading the first bit he was lashing out in fear but then when you said what he said later....

This isn't your fault OP

Houseplantmad · 23/10/2022 22:38

My FIL did the same once but he was mortified and traumatised about what had happened. That is the normal reaction, not how your FIL responded.

Moveoverdarlin · 23/10/2022 22:38

Your Dad was shit scared, he sounds like he completely lost it and was petrified. He knows it was his fault and took it out on you. It’s a classic thing to do immediately after you fuck up. Give them some space, of course it wasn’t your fault and I’m glad you told him it was his. But try and move on and not mention it again.

Wiluli · 23/10/2022 22:38

I think it’s nobody’s fault and he just said things and probably knows he is 100% wrong . Just talk with him and tell him it was an accident and he shouldn’t have said what he did to you

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 23/10/2022 22:36

willingtolearn · 23/10/2022 20:25

Your dad gave your daughter a food that was totally unsuitable for her.

This caused her to choke.

He then 'saved the day' and is now guilty and defensive and reflecting that back on you.

He was wrong and irresponsible. He knows this, but seems to have an issue apologising.

Your parents cold shoulder would be reflected right back at them and I would not be allowing them to see my child until your father had apologised.

This.
And it’s bizarre behaviour that he first said “you feed her too much.”
It’s as if he’s immediately got to victim blame —- move the responsibility off himself. If it’d been me giving unsuitable food to dgc and she choked I’d have been full of apologies and immediately said it was my stupid fault.
The only thing he did right was the first aid.
I’d limit your time with them. If this is his attitude towards you your dc will soon become aware of it.

Discovereads · 23/10/2022 22:35

I would be angry too in your shoes. Your dad caused her to choke. Yes he rescued her from the choking, but it wouldn’t have happened if he had not given her a dorito! He owes you an apology for trying to blame you for his mistake.

Perhaps he was terrified and that made him react poorly. But he should after he calms down apologise. If he does give you a cold shoulder then I’m sorry but that indicates a level of toxicity and I would be considering limiting my contact with them.

sjxoxo · 23/10/2022 22:33

He’s clearly reflecting his own issues onto you and is very controlling… don’t let him eat away at you. His issue not yours! Your daughter is ok. He behaved poorly both in the moment and definitely subsequently with you. You are an adult and of course you love your daughter and are not a crap mum. Ignore his horrible words and see them for what they are - his own anxiety. Not your problem - his!! Xx

Medoca · 23/10/2022 22:33

This sounds a very stressful time for you all. I think many of us have been there when a child has choked (albeit just for a second and no intervention is needed) and it is terrifying. From your point of you, you are following the guidelines, for your father, he probably fed you mush, and was surprised you can feed a baby chunky food. He hasn’t read as much as you, and I know crisps aren’t great, he may have not know the difference as to him they were just little pieces of food. What he said after was awful, but bear in mind tensions were high, he thought his grandchild was going to choke to death and was highly emotional. You also thought your child could choke to death and understandably felt the same emotions. I think you should all reflect that nobody wanted harm to your child, they all wanted the best thing for them, and the love for your child is overwhelming. The way your father acted immediately was surely a good thing, and just communicate how your baby should be fed in the future, in a calm no-blame way, should benefit everyone. Good luck OP, I know from experience how scary this is.

Babyroobs · 23/10/2022 22:31

My kids are in their late teens and twenties now but I do wonder whether guidance on feeding babies has changed in recent years. I had a friend round for lunch a few months ago and she was feeding her baby who was about 8/9 months whole strawberries, even hard veg. I remember being quite shocked at the size of the pieces she was giving him as I didn't remember that being the guidance when mine were small and she absolutely is the type of person who would do everything strictly by the book. I was absolutely stunned at the amount he was being given too. Anyway, that's totally off point, it sounds like it was the Dorito that irritated and caused the choking and I reckon your dad was just feeling bad and taking it out on you.

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 23/10/2022 22:27

First of all OP take a deep breath. You’ve had a terrible scare today and it happens more commonly than you know. You were NOT at fault, your dad gave her something that caused her to choke but it was an accident. He has been crying ‘angrily’ because he knows it’s his fault and he’s trying to relieve his own guilt.

I suggest as others have a first aid course for you ALL!

YellowTreeHouse · 23/10/2022 22:26

Fluffluff · 23/10/2022 22:19

This is why I didn't do baby led weaning

Actually research shows that traditional-led weaning babies are more likely to choke than BLW babies because they haven’t been allowed to learn how to chew, swallow or take appropriate size bites.

NCtonotgetroasted · 23/10/2022 22:19

willingtolearn · 23/10/2022 20:25

Your dad gave your daughter a food that was totally unsuitable for her.

This caused her to choke.

He then 'saved the day' and is now guilty and defensive and reflecting that back on you.

He was wrong and irresponsible. He knows this, but seems to have an issue apologising.

Your parents cold shoulder would be reflected right back at them and I would not be allowing them to see my child until your father had apologised.

This ^

Plus I'd not be leaving him unsupervised with her to be honest. Why would he think a dorito is suitable for a 9 month old?

They are sharp, do not melt or crunch easily and highly salted/lots no additives, not a suitable food in addition to the fruit you'd given her.

It's not your fault as I imagine you assumed your daughter would be safe, but you've now seen that he makes poor decisions and blames others for them.

Fluffluff · 23/10/2022 22:19

This is why I didn't do baby led weaning

SirGawain · 23/10/2022 22:12

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 23/10/2022 20:22

He needs to go on a first aid course

Never would I dangle a kid upside down and hit them in the back!

Desperate situations call for desperate measures. This action was exactly the right thing to do. Better a broken bone than a dead child!

Ballcactus · 23/10/2022 22:09

He’s deflecting through guilt and shock.

hesbeingabitofadick · 23/10/2022 22:06

I'm just so devastated by this and I know my parents are going to give me the cold shoulder for a while now

I think you would be fully justified in giving him the cold shoulder.
He could have killed her.

LightDrizzle · 23/10/2022 22:06

Never leave her in their care.