Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair student loan repayments and UC

65 replies

SLCUC · 23/10/2022 20:14

I've name changed for this as mentioned situation to colleagues...

I currently earn around 28K and student loans deduct £53 a month from my wages. I have the possibility of promotion with just over 10k wage increase. This would mean SLC would deduct around £130 a month. Universal credit take my total wage before student loan deductions so therefore they see that I'm earning more than I actually am receiving, so I'm losing an extra 55p for every pound SLC take. I need to UC due to high rent and childcare but because of the double deduction I will barely be any better off. New role will bring a lot more stress and expectations of unpaid overtime. AIBU to say the method of student loan repayments is really unfair and no other debt penalises people in this way? And It's really not worth getting a higher paid job at the moment given the added stress and lack of financial benefits 😔

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 23/10/2022 21:10

I've done a possible scenario with the amounts you mention.

£10k pay rise translates to say £6k in your bank account = £500 p/mth

Increase in student loan repayment £77 p/mth
UC deduction 500 x 0.55 = £275

£148 p/mth better off
Doesn't seem a lot per day but as you're on UC I would assume that every penny counts and this is a sizeable number of pennies.
Also increased pension contributions.

RandomMess · 23/10/2022 21:10

If op didn't have to back as much of her student loan it won't get written off it would still be there to repay!

She is on the the 2nd scheme and the most harsh in how much you repay versus income.

3ShotsOfEspresso · 23/10/2022 21:10

Also: congrats on the promotion!!!

3ShotsOfEspresso · 23/10/2022 21:09

Could you take a SLC break? Dunno if this is still a thing, but you used to be able to. It might give you the short term ability to make the stress “worth it”.

But regardless, you should take the promotion. The prospects are presumably better, you’ll be a step higher on the salary ladder, so who knows where the next stop will be.

Good luck OP. X

SLCUC · 23/10/2022 21:08

StrataZon · 23/10/2022 21:03

If it's public sector then you will get a much better pension by earning the higher salary for the next 20+ years. If you don't go for the job you are taking a very shortsighted view

I agree with you. Think I was just panicking

OP posts:
SLCUC · 23/10/2022 21:08

DinosaurWarrior · 23/10/2022 21:02

Wait can anyone claim UC if they have rent and childcare?! Why did I not know this was a thing?!

Depends on how many children and household income. Definitely worth a look if you think you might be eligible. I'm the only adult in my house so not sure you'd qualify with 2 ft wages unless both were low and your rent was high etc

OP posts:
StrataZon · 23/10/2022 21:03

If it's public sector then you will get a much better pension by earning the higher salary for the next 20+ years. If you don't go for the job you are taking a very shortsighted view

DinosaurWarrior · 23/10/2022 21:02

Wait can anyone claim UC if they have rent and childcare?! Why did I not know this was a thing?!

lentilly · 23/10/2022 20:50

And the increased pension is definitely not to be sniffed at

lentilly · 23/10/2022 20:50

CMZ2018 · 23/10/2022 20:48

Don’t have the loan or in this case don’t go to university if you can’t afford to pay off the debt stop living off other people and pay your way

Wtf the whole point is the loan levels the playing field a bit so people who want to can go to uni to further their career. They don't have a crystal ball.

Ibouncetothebeat · 23/10/2022 20:49

You may be “barely better off” but surely as long as you are not worse off then it’s worth it. The career progression will eventually allow you to become fully independent and surely that’s the goal and not to rely on universal credit for ever.

luxxlisbon · 23/10/2022 20:49

AIBU to say the method of student loan repayments is really unfair and no other debt penalises people in this way? And It's really not worth getting a higher paid job at the moment given the added stress and lack of financial benefits 😔

It isn’t anything to do with student loans though, its because your used to the UC and aren’t acknowledging the fact that you would be earning that money from yourself. Even with an increase in student loans and a decrease in UC I really doubt you would be worst off with a 10k pay rise.

You agreed to the terms of a student loan before you took it, no point complaining now. It coming out before tax also means when you were earning less you didn’t have to pay it.

lentilly · 23/10/2022 20:49

Will you be earning more overall or not? I mean I guess one way of looking at it is you're earning more so don't need the benefit? Or maybe I'm ot understanding the issue.

CMZ2018 · 23/10/2022 20:48

Don’t have the loan or in this case don’t go to university if you can’t afford to pay off the debt stop living off other people and pay your way

Genevieva · 23/10/2022 20:47

It is a stepping stone to future promotions and pay rises. You will pay off more of your student loan, instead of it continuing to accrue even more interest. In the medium term you will be better off for having the significant pay rise.

SLCUC · 23/10/2022 20:47

Dixiechickonhols · 23/10/2022 20:36

In £38,000 job you will gain experience and can probably earn at that level if you move jobs or get pay rises.
At £28,000 plus benefits you are at mercy of government. If they decide to stop or cut in work benefits you would struggle whereas £38000 is more secure income.
Presumably your top up benefits will reduce as children age out of childcare.

You're absolutely right I know. I guess I'm just having a bit of a panic.

Let me spell it out for those asking why I get top up benefits...I take home around £1750 currently and my rent is £1100, not a lot I can do about that. Plus childcare. Salary calculator says I'll take home around £350 more on new wage, so yes I'd still be entitled to some UC. Trying to think if the longer term... pension etc.

I don't need the degree to do my job. And yes it is depressing, both because of the fact I might never pay it back but also because as a pp said the repayments should have been adjusted given the current situation.

Not sure if new job would open doors elsewhere, it's public sector but would give me more transferable skills.

Appreciate all views to be honest

OP posts:
Overthebow · 23/10/2022 20:46

Look at it another way, why should the benefits system pay for your student loan, which is what would happen if your income was assessed after the repayments? You chose to do the degree and get the loan, you knew the t&cs. You will still have more money than you do now if you take the promotion.

Paq · 23/10/2022 20:45

One word: pension! You will accrue a much better pension as your salary goes up.

RandomMess · 23/10/2022 20:43
Flowers

Back in the day I got family tax credit and 95% of it was the childcare element but they included the income and not the childcare costs.

I ended up reducing my hours slightly so then I was better off!!

Perhaps you could work the new job at 0.8FTE or a 9 day fortnight or similar? Ask for it as a trial?

Capri3 · 23/10/2022 20:42

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

This.

Your promotion could lead to further promotions, or an even better paid job.

You also won’t be paying childcare forever so should see more of an increase in salary in the future.

Tax credits also tend to end when your dc turn 18 so you’ll lose that money then anyway.

If you turn down this promotion, it may not be something that you’re offered again in the future.

LakieLady · 23/10/2022 20:39

It's a bummer, and I hate the whole bloody system, but if your UC was assessed on your pay net of the student loan deduction, the DWP would be effectively covering your repayments.

BrieAndChilli · 23/10/2022 20:37

Your new wage after taxes and student loan etc will be about £500 month more.
you say you will lose 55p for every pound of student loan extra which comes to about £43. So you will still be £450 a month better off.
even if you also lose 55p for every £ of that you will still be a couple of hundred pound better off won’t you? Plus once you lose the childcare or the kids grow up you will lose all you universal credit. At least with the pay increase that will be yours whatever plus you will be less reliant on benefits and any cuts that may happen to that

Headabovetheparakeet · 23/10/2022 20:36

Would the promotion open up roles with other employers? I'd focus on whether taking this promotion might mean you could apply for another job that pays more in a year or two. Then that money would all be yours to keep and you won't have to deal with DWP anymore.

It's frustrating but just accept this as a hump you need to get over and then you will be in a better position.

Dixiechickonhols · 23/10/2022 20:36

In £38,000 job you will gain experience and can probably earn at that level if you move jobs or get pay rises.
At £28,000 plus benefits you are at mercy of government. If they decide to stop or cut in work benefits you would struggle whereas £38000 is more secure income.
Presumably your top up benefits will reduce as children age out of childcare.

TeaPleaseNoLemon · 23/10/2022 20:34

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread