Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask Headteachers and SLTs is it really that bad?

361 replies

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 19:08

Press since the start of term and now more recently has focussed on schools running out of money. Perhaps having to shorten days to cover outgoings. With more recent news of further austerity and I believe limited funding what do current HTs and members of SLTs think?

what is the solution if more money isn’t available? A lot of money is being swallowed by higher energy bills.

OP posts:
Navigatingnewwaters · 24/10/2022 10:03

My school is taking on new staff

Paris2023 · 24/10/2022 10:00

90% of schools will run out of cash next year, National Association of Head Teachers says

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/12a8b12a-52fa-11ed-b965-3a5f647316f8?shareToken=bfb9274fcd3ce3f753da2b6d7fc51da5

OP posts:
Paris2023 · 24/10/2022 09:59

With let’s say 90% of schools running at a deficit, the priority will be to pay staff of course so they’ll come to school and do their job.

Next steps. Let’s find out who the next Education Secretary will be- then the lobbying begins. I will be writing to my local MP today.

article in The Times:

of schools will run out of cash next year, National Association of Head Teachers says www.thetimes.co.uk/article/12a8b12a-52fa-11ed-b965-3a5f647316f8?shareToken=8c0c32815ced36c7bce2ba3239318d7a School deficit

OP posts:
Legrandsophie · 24/10/2022 09:56

Head’s PA is a bit of a misnomer as a job title. Ours is the head of educational visits, does all the letters and co-ordinates all the communication home, sorts out all SLT diaries and the school calendar and co-ordinates all the meetings in school and all the out of

toomuchlaundry · 24/10/2022 09:37

Exactly @noblegiraffe. Our local MAT had just about balanced the books, but that was with scrimping and saving, so no extra frills. Now looking at a deficit in excess of £1m as announced by the CEO

noblegiraffe · 24/10/2022 09:31

These 5% unfunded payrises turned our healthy budget into a deficit one by April 2023.

I don't think we should be describing budgets before the unfunded pay rises as 'healthy'. Generally desperate measures have already been taken to get them to balance.

TatumHigh · 24/10/2022 09:00

@Relocatiorelocation @DanglingMod @Givenuptotally

The infant class size of 30 is a myth. My first year of teaching early 2000s was a Reception class of 35.

I frequently taught classes of year 1s/year2s of 33/34. County used to direct children to us and even though we were overfull, refusal was futile. You'd get the pupil anyway.

It's been depressing watching the way the Tories have striped schools of money, while having higher expectations of what schools should do. SALT services, all but gone. EP service, all but gone. OT services, all but gone. Vision/deaf impairment services, all but gone. EAL services, all but gone. Gypsy/Roma services, all but gone. Schools are expected to deliver this specialist support with no training and then get slammed when it's not good. And all we think of is doing our best for the child at the end of it all.

These 5% unfunded payrises turned our healthy budget into a deficit one by April 2023.

And yet we still go on, as we still try to do the very best for our pupils with the meagre amount we've got. Our own mental health takes a battering trying to sort it, hence so many leadership positions unfilled.

I can only see things turning around under a Labour government. The Tories have shown what they think of state schools by their actions. But they're alright, as they can afford private schools for their offspring.

I genuinely think that private schools should be scrapped. If those in power had to put their own children into the state system, we'd see marked improvement and increased funding overnight. But that's another conversation...

BridetoBee · 24/10/2022 08:45

@Givenuptotally Reception classes are supposedly maxed at 30 but once schools start shutting, your LA can direct you to take a few children each over so they don’t have to fund the lost school. We’ve had a few years of 33,32 and 31

SchoolOfGoodAndEvil · 24/10/2022 08:39

AntlerRose · 24/10/2022 08:28

The problem with TAs and admin staff being cut is it doesnt actually save that much money to cut one as they dont earn much. You have to massively reduce them to save money. Thats how you go from one TA in every class, to a floating TA, mornings only for a year group.

That is exactly what has happened in our school re: TAs.

It’s with a very heavy heart this has happened. Everybody, including SLT and Governors, knows this has had a huge negative impact on our children, particularly our pupils with SEND and those with anxiety and MH issues.

We have also completely cut our mentoring programme in the past year. Our school counsellor is down from 5 to 2 days a week. We used to have non-teaching heads of year, but it is now a poorly paid additional responsibility for a group of very overstretched teachers.

We are clawing in services from a stretched and chaotic childrens services, but it isn’t a pretty picture. I’ve just been told we have lost our one day a week CAMHS practitioner as they’ve closed their schools service and our Safer schools police officer, as they have staffing issues.

This isn’t a recent thing. The services that support schools have been decimated over the past 10 years or so, and schools have been chronically underfunded, yet post lockdown there has never been a higher expectation on schools to support children’s whole well-being and mental health alongside providing a quality education. The shit is just really hitting the fan now.

Bluebellysmell · 24/10/2022 08:39

Think of it this way,
-a schools budget is probably around 90% staff costs;
-the payrises (which are well below inflation and have been for years) are about 5% for teachers, 7-8% for TAs, so say staffing increases an average of 6%

  • if the school previously had a budget of £1million a year, (primary school of 300+ kids) staffing was about £900k;
  • that unfunded rise costs the school an extra £54k ;
  • that's roughly the salary of 2.5 TAs (full time), 1.7 NQTs or 1 SLT, when you include employers tax and employers pension the school also has to pay;
-they don't just need to find this money this year, but in all future years;
  • many schools can't drop a teacher due to minimum ratios so inorder to balance they will need to cut TAs;
  • because staffing is such a high percentage of costs, savings elsewhere, or fundraising will barelyscratch the surface.

And moving to aMAT won't get the school extra funds, that's not how it works, the budget gets given to the MAT to allocate rather than directly to the school.

Schools are fucked unless those rises are funded.

Expect government and media to spin this as "greedy teachers wanting more" though.

AntlerRose · 24/10/2022 08:28

Givenuptotally · 24/10/2022 07:47

Reception classes are topped out at 30.

if there is no money to pay teachers, what are schools going to do?

The problem with TAs and admin staff being cut is it doesnt actually save that much money to cut one as they dont earn much. You have to massively reduce them to save money. Thats how you go from one TA in every class, to a floating TA, mornings only for a year group.

SchoolOfGoodAndEvil · 24/10/2022 08:22

Our Head’s PA does so much! She has an important HR function, does the website and newsletter and parent communications as well as all the meeting minutes, diary coordination, admin for SLT. She’s genuinely needed. I don’t think in any other sector the idea that the Head of an organisation would be able to do without a PA would even be mooted.

The pastoral support in our school has been cut to the bare bones, which is my biggest worry at the moment. It keeps me awake at night. It’s an absolute needs must, though, or we’ll have to start cutting teaching staff.

Strictly1 · 24/10/2022 08:19

I think money being ring fenced also causes misinformation. In the summer we had money left in our sporting grant which we can usually carry forward. We were told we couldn’t - and if not spent by 31/8 - it would be clawed back. We bought equipment with it. For those looking in - they must question why we bought that if we have no money.

ThanksItHasPockets · 24/10/2022 08:16

juggleit · 24/10/2022 00:23

Our new head has advertised for a new PA position. parents were a bit perplexed. I dunno I suppose if the monies available??

You think the school has money to burn because the headteacher has a PA? That person will cover multiple areas of responsibility in the office: from experience the HT PA usually also provides admin support to the rest of SLT, office management, absence and cover co-ordination, HR admin and sometimes reprographics.

Strictly1 · 24/10/2022 08:06

I’m a primary HT - it is bad to the point I don’t know how we will cope but know there are other schools worse off as we had saved some money for building work which we will now use to get us through this year and next. After that I haven’t a clue.
The demands in schools are increasing with no increase in capacity. It is going to break but sadly it will be the people in school who break first.
Im finding expectations from parents are increasing and we are honestly trying our best but don’t have the resources or support from beyond school. I am not a mental health nurse, doctor or housing officer. I really do want the best for the children in our care - but we are now expected to be the answer for everything. If the number of staff reduce, as they will have to, those left will be stretched to breaking. The media and politicians telling parents we are lazy and if not happy phone Ofsted etc are not helping. In the last two years when trying to recruit - I’ve really struggled. I can’t get middays for love or money so I do that too. It’s not sustainable.
Ramble over - apologies for typos - I’m on my phone.
The bottom line is our children deserve more but school staff have no more to give and a lack of funds will just exacerbate the situation.

Hercisback · 24/10/2022 07:52

@juggleit Most heads do have a PA. Usually the role will include other non PA duties but having someone deal with the "admin" so the head can actually be a head makes much more financial sense than the alternative.

noblegiraffe · 24/10/2022 07:52

if there is no money to pay teachers, what are schools going to do?

In primary, they are getting much lower paid TAs to teach classes instead.

In secondary, cut courses, increase class sizes.

This has already been happening.

toomuchlaundry · 24/10/2022 07:49

@Givenuptotally that is the question most schools are asking

Givenuptotally · 24/10/2022 07:47

Reception classes are topped out at 30.

if there is no money to pay teachers, what are schools going to do?

DanglingMod · 24/10/2022 07:47

In England, class size is capped at 30 only until the end of year 2. Class sizes are consistently much higher than that in ks2 and secondary. We have more children than chairs in many of our lessons and it's a good things TAs are leaving in their droves, because no one can get down the gaps between tables to support children anyway.

Relocatiorelocation · 24/10/2022 07:42

Im reading this thread in horrified fascination.
I genuinely believed that class sizes were topped at 30 in law, hence so much angst around appeals etc. Is that not the case, can schools be forced to have class sizes of 35 or even 40?

SausageinaBun · 24/10/2022 00:32

I'm a governor of a primary school. The last few years have seen our finances improve due to growing pupil numbers (to nearly PAN in every year) and the minimum funding guarantee. Some of the things that other schools are losing were previously only a dream for us. In my time with the school, there's never been a TA in each class or year.

The biggest issue at the moment is TA recruitment. Our TAs are primarily 1:1, with some capacity used for small group interventions. When we can't recruit TAs, the ones we have are spread even thinner.

The other issue is high levels of SEND. We are proudly an inclusive school, but I can see why, financially, some other schools don't make an effort to be welcoming to all families.

juggleit · 24/10/2022 00:23

Our new head has advertised for a new PA position. parents were a bit perplexed. I dunno I suppose if the monies available??

Givenuptotally · 24/10/2022 00:03

caringcarer · 23/10/2022 21:59

@BounceBackBoris, and yet secondary school I worked at rented out school hall to people teaching sports clubs, eg football club, cricket club and made a profit also to Weight watchers group one evening a group and Pilates another evening. Not sure why you'd think groups would not pay. Most Weight Watchers groups rent out Sports Halls in evenings. Secondary children cook own toast. Each form group rotates duty in break times, again this worked very well at my old school. A couple of Sixth Formers' supervised and brought bread and spread each day. Hand Car washes work and no one is expecting teachers or T/A to do any extra work. The whole point is PTA organise and volunteer. Parents pay to get cars cleaned because they know their children will benefit. Used to make £500-£600 once a year on a Saturday morning at my old school. You seem determined to be negative and not want any suggestions to work. My old PTA used to contribute about £2k a term. Some fund raisers like book swaps would take place on Parents Evenings and parents just brought a book or bought a book and paid £1 per book. Dropped money into a bucket. Often made £70 and no staff effort. PTA took any books away at end of Parents Evenings. Uniform sale in School Hall week week before school started in September. Also on Parents Evening too. Did not make a lot of money but people donated items for free and parents bought for 50p or £1 per item. Parents did use it, especially for PE kits. Perhaps you would prefer your school to run out of funds?

With all due respect, £2K is probably not enough to cover the cost of an NQT salary plus on-costs for a month. It's a drop in a very dry ocean.

And the risk assessments involving children and toasters....

IncessantNameChanger · 24/10/2022 00:01

Governor. Yes it's very bad. It's not just energy or a recent thing, it's staff of sick, unable to recruit TAs as well. So much is in a fine balance