Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask Headteachers and SLTs is it really that bad?

361 replies

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 19:08

Press since the start of term and now more recently has focussed on schools running out of money. Perhaps having to shorten days to cover outgoings. With more recent news of further austerity and I believe limited funding what do current HTs and members of SLTs think?

what is the solution if more money isn’t available? A lot of money is being swallowed by higher energy bills.

OP posts:
twinkletoesimnot · 23/10/2022 20:34

I'm a primary teacher in a very small school.
We have a TA mornings only across KS2, and 2 in our Reception/1/2 class. I assume these will be first to be made redundant, although it may be that a teacher has to go instead.

At the end of this financial year we are predicting that we will be just over 30k in deficit. This is solely due to energy and unfunded staff pay rises.

I found this out when I handed in some receipts for things I have bought for my class this half term. Nothing much, paint, a book, cooking ingredients, it came to £58.
HT said that all of ks2 classroom budget is now spent. That means until April, no new glue, books, pencils, no cooking etc.

Our trip can't happen unless we get enough 'voluntary' contributions.

Schools are not allowed to run at a deficit, although this has been waived as long as it has been clawed back at the d Ed me if the current 3 year budget - but how the hell can that happen?

In theory we could manage with 1 teacher across both KS2 classes, but it would be virtually impossible in practise. 32 pupils from Y3 - Y6, with 4 SEND children.
Not to mention the 5 subjects my colleague and I lead across our small federation. Neither one of us would want that job.

I think small schools will close.

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 20:34

Is there an element of HTs should now inform parents of the situation as lobbying of our MPs must be done.

OP posts:
ohfook · 23/10/2022 20:33

@FatAgainItsLettuceTime there's a school in Brixton which in the past the head made very profitable but they had a pool they could hire out.

I've just googled to try and find the name and actually it also looks like that arrangement ended with a bit of controversy and money being funnelled in the wrong direction!

TwitTw00 · 23/10/2022 20:28

After school clubs are also closing around me rather than generating extra income, as many more parents are WFH and so can have primary-aged children entertaining themselves for an hour or two even if they're working. Incidentally, in a small school staying open for ASC, clubs etc inevitably falls to teachers fairly often - as soon as the ASC member of staff is off sick, there is no one else to ask unless the head or classroom teachers step in.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:28

Invisimamma · 23/10/2022 20:23

This thread has really opened my eyes. This is such an awful situation.amomgst everything else that is going on just now. Naively I did not realise schools covered their own energy bills, I thought this would be covered by the council/LA.

I'm in Scotland though, perhaps things work differently up here? I have never heard of it being possible for a school to go 'bust' (except private schools).

In England, many schools are not run by the LA, but by academies/multi-academy trusts. These are generally not for profit organisations, but they take on the management of the school budgets and receive funding directly from central government. They are responsible for providing all services like HR, payroll etc to their staff as well.

Schools are not meant to have a deficit budget, so if the MAT runs out of reserves, they have to make do with what is available to the school. In general, schools aren't meant to pay staff salaries via parental donations etc either.

When people talk about schools going bust, they really mean the MAT has run out of money. In reality, what that means is the school will continue to run, but it may have no funds to e.g. pay supply staff, so if lots of teachers are unwell one day, the school would have to close (as we saw during covid).

That said, I do think things will get tight, even for LA schools in England, because as has been said, local authorities have no money either- so they won't be able to bail out schools with ever increasing costs.

AntlerRose · 23/10/2022 20:28

I am actually hearbroken by how bad school finance are. I've worked in my lovely school for a decade and we have had to make cut after cut. We are already in deficit and the surplus runs out this financial year.

We have a breakfast club, afterschool club, hire out the rooms, have an amazing PTA, parents contribute, we have volunteers.

The quality of education is suffering and the sen provision is no way near as good as we know it was just a few years ago.

TwitTw00 · 23/10/2022 20:26

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 23/10/2022 19:50

It's shockingly crap that schools are as underfunded as they are by the gift but I don't see that changing any time soon given we are currently stuck with the Tories.

So, is there any way to generate an income? Could space be leased out during school holidays for events? Could computer rooms be used in evenings/weekends to deliver computer based testing in partnership with organisations like Pearson, prometric, Reed.. who deliver things like the driving theory tests. Could the hall be leased outside of hours for after school/sports providers?

Haven't know a (primary) school that's had a computer room for years - they've all been turned into classrooms. The technology that schools do have if so poor there's no way it would work for online tests.

Same with suggestions to cut general TAs. Haven't had a general TA in the last 6 or 7 years. All TAs are assigned to children with an EHCP and thus the school is fulfilling a legal obligation - it is breaking the law not to provide these.

Invisimamma · 23/10/2022 20:23

This thread has really opened my eyes. This is such an awful situation.amomgst everything else that is going on just now. Naively I did not realise schools covered their own energy bills, I thought this would be covered by the council/LA.

I'm in Scotland though, perhaps things work differently up here? I have never heard of it being possible for a school to go 'bust' (except private schools).

HollyGoLoudly1 · 23/10/2022 20:21

Not a SLT but a teacher. It's really bad. Morale wasn't great after covid and is going downhill. Basics like printer ink are becoming unaffordable never mind salaries. I've never seen our HT or SLT look so stressed. I predict an exodus at management level because they literally can't run the school on the budget we have and it will only get worse.

Dorisbonson · 23/10/2022 20:17

On a slightly different note it's the same now in most council's. Many have a big budget deficit often related to social care care costs, in the past government has bailed council's out. It may not be the same this year. There is a lot of pain to come.

LunaLoveFood · 23/10/2022 20:16

My school no longer has class TA's, only 1:1s.
Our budget is already spent for this year (or earmarked to be spent) and that's without utilities cost rising. It is dire.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:15

FWIW, I think most schools won't make redundancies in terms of teaching staff unless they e.g. stop running a course or maybe close their sixth form as it's no longer viable.

What will happen is that staff may leave, and be replaced by either someone on fewer hours, or someone cheaper e.g. an ECT replacing someone on UPS. Support staff will not be replaced and some may be made redundant. This will have a knock on impact on teacher workloads, and/or make communicating with the school more difficult.

It may be that some teaching staff who leave aren't replaced, if the school can get around it by making class sizes bigger etc.

In primary, I think the biggest cost saving will be TAs, and you may find some classes are covered by TAs on a regular basis, rather than using supply, or qualified teachers to e.g. cover PPA. And again, recruiting cheaper staff, rather than more experienced.

Hercisback · 23/10/2022 20:14

A fundraiser every other month isn't going to fill the budget hole ffs. Such a naive post.

Cookiecrisps · 23/10/2022 20:12

These measures will directly negatively impact the children. I think 90% of schools saying they will go bust next year is unprecedented. State schools weren’t in a great place before Covid due to sustained inadequate funding but they are certainly in an even worse place now especially when extortionate energy bills are added on and a pay rise the government refuse to fund. People should be questioning the government and holding them to account. Children deserve so much better.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:12

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 20:09

Our local primary has been invited to a MAT they’re the last school in the area not in a MAT. They would be the only Primary school in the MAT.

Will this larger entity save money? Pool resources?

The MAT will take any reserves your school has, take x% of their budget for centralised resources and then not be allowed to post a deficit budget.

It used to be centralised services were provided by LAs- which was more efficient. I am not sure multiple MATs covering the same area can now be considered efficient.

It really depends on the MAT as to whether the school will feel better or worse off, but my experience in two different schools was that it made the schools feel worse off in the long run, even if the MAT was initially able to secure funding for individual projects.

funtycucker · 23/10/2022 20:11

caringcarer · 23/10/2022 20:08

Not HT or SMT but hiring out school Sports Hall after school and weekends. PTA have fund raising committee and put on car boot sales, car washes, Quiz Night, School Disco, Book swops, and second hand uniform sales etc. Perhaps an event every other month. Wrap around child care with breakfast club and after school club. Selling hot toast at break time for 30p a slice. I think schools have to be inventive. Government are paying subsidy on heating this winter. I am not suggesting parents/grandparents can replace T/A's but if had DBS check could do some tasks like listening to the better readers, tidying up sports equipment after PE, washing up paint pots etc. Then T/A's are freed up to concentrate on more specialised duties. I know many Grandparents, recently retired, who say they would volunteer but for only 1 morning a week.

Wraparound childcare would incur staffing costs though as you can't expect people to staff it for free

MrsWombat · 23/10/2022 20:11

We had a large surplus and were in a good position. We've been told how much our school/trust will now be in deficit, and yes it is a similar number to what has been reported elsewhere. We've been told there will be no redundancies, or reduced hours but there will also be no non-essential spending. We are looking at outside funding for various things.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:09

I do also think energy bills are getting to the point where hiring out individual rooms in the main school building (which would then have to be lit, heated, etc) would actually make a loss. Remember, schools aren't covered by the price cap, and although some help has been promised this winter, it won't cover the full bill increase.

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 20:09

Our local primary has been invited to a MAT they’re the last school in the area not in a MAT. They would be the only Primary school in the MAT.

Will this larger entity save money? Pool resources?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 23/10/2022 20:08

Not HT or SMT but hiring out school Sports Hall after school and weekends. PTA have fund raising committee and put on car boot sales, car washes, Quiz Night, School Disco, Book swops, and second hand uniform sales etc. Perhaps an event every other month. Wrap around child care with breakfast club and after school club. Selling hot toast at break time for 30p a slice. I think schools have to be inventive. Government are paying subsidy on heating this winter. I am not suggesting parents/grandparents can replace T/A's but if had DBS check could do some tasks like listening to the better readers, tidying up sports equipment after PE, washing up paint pots etc. Then T/A's are freed up to concentrate on more specialised duties. I know many Grandparents, recently retired, who say they would volunteer but for only 1 morning a week.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:07

In terms of leasing things out, the school I work for has an astroturf pitch which is leased out to junior football teams etc in the evenings. The sports hall is also used for sporting events already. I think a lot of schools already do this!

Any adult who comes into the school building whilst students are still present (bearing in mind we run after school clubs/revision etc) has to be escorted at all times unless they have a DBS check, so the times and facilities we can rent out are limited. There are often students on site until about 5pm, using the library and other facilities for revision, so letting people use facilities within the main school building is tricky.

If we wanted to rent out classrooms etc to make extra money during the week, it would mean potentially kicking students out of the building earlier- at a time when many of them are struggling!

The energy hikes schools are facing are absolutely massive- I have seen several heads and academy CEOs talking about costs increasing to 3-4x the previous winter.

The unfunded payrises are also a real issue. Academies could, theoretically, not give these to staff, but in reality, that will lead to staff leaving for other schools, and of course, a loss of goodwill among staff.

Every member of teaching staff is teaching a full timetable, some part time staff have had their hours cut. SLT and middle leadership are teaching more, which means they don't have time to carry out their other duties. TAs who leave aren't replaced- we have the bare minimum needed to cover ECHPs.

I genuinely don't know what the next step is, in terms of cutting costs. Do we lose members of staff like the librarian?

Last year, in a previous school, I was a union rep, and I was told the school had spent the majority of its reserves on agency supply staff (who were needed due to covid and general staff shortages). The school had also paid money to a local building firm to do essential work, and the firm then went bust, leaving the school in a very difficult position.

Farcry66 · 23/10/2022 20:07

It's awful. My school have restructured to save money, which means I am now doing the job of 3 people because we can't afford to replace roles when people leave. I ordered reams of lined paper on Friday, they were £4.25 each, last time I ordered some, in June, they were £2.50 - when you look at the costs of utilities and resources, we're broke, and that's before you factor in staff costs that are set to rise in the next month as pay awards are approved.

We have a swimming pool, even with hiring it out we are making a £250 loss a DAY on it! Unless something happens soon with funding for education, we, and our kids in a very deprived area, are screwed!

Hercisback · 23/10/2022 20:07

Example from my school. UPN was 180, four years ago it went up to 240. We hired NO extra teachers.

Hercisback · 23/10/2022 20:06

The situation is awful.

Teachers, support staff and leadership teams have papered over the cracks for so so long. It's all unraveling before our eyes while parents are still somewhat in the dark.