Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask Headteachers and SLTs is it really that bad?

361 replies

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 19:08

Press since the start of term and now more recently has focussed on schools running out of money. Perhaps having to shorten days to cover outgoings. With more recent news of further austerity and I believe limited funding what do current HTs and members of SLTs think?

what is the solution if more money isn’t available? A lot of money is being swallowed by higher energy bills.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:59

TugboatAnnie · 23/10/2022 20:53

I wonder if the MAT CEOs would consider a cut in their salaries?

Salaries for CEOs are high, but the sums we are talking about in school budgets are higher.

In the guardian article I linked, a MAT CEO talks about how energy bills have increased by about £60,000. Say he's on the average salary for a CEO- about £150,000. Even if he halved that salary, he'd pay the energy bill increases for 1.5 schools within his trust...

To be clear, I am in no way saying CEO salaries are justified, or that MAT CEOs are a good thing, but it's not the sole solution to the problem.

Kalasbyxor · 23/10/2022 20:57

I work 0.8 but am occasionally asked last minute to step in to teach on my day off as short notice supply is hard to find in my city. Mostly, I don't put in a claim for my extra days as I know we're that skint. We've cut everything we can cut. Mixed classes and reduced TA support (I teach Y6 and have no support all week; this is the year of SATs!). Subscriptions, interventions, bought in support - all gone.
ECTs in posts where possible but little support for them as no release time available (as cover is too expensive), either for them or school based mentor.

We absolutely do not ask for parental contributions; we serve a very deprived area with a large refugee community. We're running on fumes and good will, but my lord, it's wearing thin.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:56

Navigatingnewwaters · 23/10/2022 20:50

Wow! It’s a big job in a secondary school for one person, can’t imagine how it went with teachers having to add it on as well. In the school I work at there are lots of occasions when parents think their kids have gone to school when they haven’t, if they weren’t to find out until late in the day the consequences could be disastrous

I feel like describing the situation too much might mean someone would recognise the school, but the long and the short of it is that it didn't really work, particularly if e.g. the tutor was off sick.

Luckily, there was never a really serious problem- but there definitely could have been. There absolutely would have been students who skived, and neither the school or parents knew about it. And our absence including persistent absence went up.

FluffyCat12 · 23/10/2022 20:56

I work in the finance office of a secondary school (currently a SAT but won't be long until we're swallowed up by a MAT) and for the last few weeks I've had a steady stream of emails from suppliers about their prices going up.

We rent out everything. Swimming pool, gym, minibus, auditorium etc and it's literally a drop in the ocean.

The amount of PP students is rising every year, the money is being spent on absolute basics that traditionally were supplied by parents but they just can't afford it anymore.

I'm looking to get out. I work year round but can't survive on my pay anymore,

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 20:55

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:45

I think, to be fair, more and more HTs are coming out and saying this in the national press, on twitter etc. More MAT CEOs are also speaking out too.

But it would be very difficult for a HT to go to parents and say "Sorry, because of funding your child's class won't have a TA this year" or "Because of funding, we won't have a school librarian anymore, and the library won't be open after school for revision, either". In many schools, it would make the HT unpopular with parents, and make their lives extremely difficult. It might also affect recruitment to the school.

I do think heads should be more honest with parents in general- but I also understand why they don't do it.

The national teaching/education unions are also talking about the situation- one of their key points is that any payrises for staff (including support staff who are often are on very low wages) must be fully funded- otherwise it also causes schools more problems, as they have to find money to pay these from somewhere.

I understand it’s a balance. I feel the expectations of parents and what schools are expected to provide is increasing but HTs are between a rock and a hard place.

Hugely concerned by further austerity measures. Even if a Labour government was to come in, where would they get the money?

Fundraising measures by PTAs etc and commercial enterprises (eg wraparound) will not produce enough funding.

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 23/10/2022 20:54

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:51

I agree as a teacher I am always very careful about what I say to parents and children. Heads do have a bit more freedom to speak out, though. But I also understand the reasons why they might choose not to.

I think HTs would also be wary as well.

A few years ago I remember our HT sending out a joint letter about lobbying for state funding but it got nowhere.

It sickens me the actual state of public services.

TugboatAnnie · 23/10/2022 20:53

I wonder if the MAT CEOs would consider a cut in their salaries?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:51

Believeitornot · 23/10/2022 20:49

Teachers can’t say too much otherwise they’re accused of being “political”

I agree as a teacher I am always very careful about what I say to parents and children. Heads do have a bit more freedom to speak out, though. But I also understand the reasons why they might choose not to.

Mrmoody · 23/10/2022 20:50

I'm on MAT leave but it seems the situation is pretty dire. They can't afford MAT cover for me and have written me a timetable being covered by a HLTA. I return in January but am actually pregnant again (a surprise) so they will then need to cover the summer term again. Its shocking really, my classes are being totally abandoned

Navigatingnewwaters · 23/10/2022 20:50

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:46

Yes, a secondary school.

Wow! It’s a big job in a secondary school for one person, can’t imagine how it went with teachers having to add it on as well. In the school I work at there are lots of occasions when parents think their kids have gone to school when they haven’t, if they weren’t to find out until late in the day the consequences could be disastrous

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:50

BridasShieldWall · 23/10/2022 20:44

I work in finance in a MAT and across all schools we set a balanced budget. We have a mix of mostly primary with two secondary schools. Some of our schools had a deficit budget set this year which are supported by other schools in the Trust. These are for specific reasons e..g trying to build up the school, falling numbers of pupils etc. Across the MAT we had a balanced budget with a small surplus that we use to build up a surplus to support the trust in times of need.

we have had the following changes since we set the budget

  • 5% unfounded increase in teaching salaries
  • 9% (roughly) increase in support staff so TAs, caretakers, office staff etc
  • utility increases
  • general inflation estimates

We’ve rerun the forecast and it results in a £1m deficit with no indication of whether any of this will be funded and we’re unlikely to hear soon of any changes to funding due to the chaos in the Conservative party. We’ve stripped TAs as much as we can whilst trying to maintain educational standards, we’re using our buying power to reduce costs for trust wide contracts and materials and educational resources are constantly under review. We hire out facilities where possible and have after school clubs in some schools but it depends on the demographic of each school. We’re holding firm at the moment awaiting the fall out from this but options are reviewing staffing, TAs and SLT structures, school day e.g. finish early one day or closing schools that we looking to develop. As a trust overall we were in a good position, better than a lot of schools who are in a worse position that we are.

That sounds so tough- it sounds like you were pretty healthy financially previously as well.

I agree, for the moment I think most schools are holding on (and MATs may not have approved pay increases yet) but I guess the fear is as well that things are only going to get worse- so if reserves are spent this winter, what happens next year? Or if there is an unexpected spate of staff illness in the summer term etc, when reserves might have paid for supply staff etc.

I do think this could be the nail in the coffin for some small primary schools etc, which will equally be potentially very damaging to those communities.

Believeitornot · 23/10/2022 20:49

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:45

I think, to be fair, more and more HTs are coming out and saying this in the national press, on twitter etc. More MAT CEOs are also speaking out too.

But it would be very difficult for a HT to go to parents and say "Sorry, because of funding your child's class won't have a TA this year" or "Because of funding, we won't have a school librarian anymore, and the library won't be open after school for revision, either". In many schools, it would make the HT unpopular with parents, and make their lives extremely difficult. It might also affect recruitment to the school.

I do think heads should be more honest with parents in general- but I also understand why they don't do it.

The national teaching/education unions are also talking about the situation- one of their key points is that any payrises for staff (including support staff who are often are on very low wages) must be fully funded- otherwise it also causes schools more problems, as they have to find money to pay these from somewhere.

Teachers can’t say too much otherwise they’re accused of being “political”

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:46

Navigatingnewwaters · 23/10/2022 20:44

Was that a secondary school?

Yes, a secondary school.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:45

Paris2023 · 23/10/2022 20:34

Is there an element of HTs should now inform parents of the situation as lobbying of our MPs must be done.

I think, to be fair, more and more HTs are coming out and saying this in the national press, on twitter etc. More MAT CEOs are also speaking out too.

But it would be very difficult for a HT to go to parents and say "Sorry, because of funding your child's class won't have a TA this year" or "Because of funding, we won't have a school librarian anymore, and the library won't be open after school for revision, either". In many schools, it would make the HT unpopular with parents, and make their lives extremely difficult. It might also affect recruitment to the school.

I do think heads should be more honest with parents in general- but I also understand why they don't do it.

The national teaching/education unions are also talking about the situation- one of their key points is that any payrises for staff (including support staff who are often are on very low wages) must be fully funded- otherwise it also causes schools more problems, as they have to find money to pay these from somewhere.

Navigatingnewwaters · 23/10/2022 20:44

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:40

Attendance officers are so useful, and it's a tough job. Previous school got rid of ours, and tried to get teachers to do the job, with limited success- we were expected to phone home for absences in our tutor group! Obviously, this was massively time consuming, and also happened after 3pm, so no good if, e.g. a child went missing on the way to school (I know it's an unlikely scenario, but it's part of the reason schools do these things).

I think in secondaries, unfortunately all these "back office" jobs which aren't immediately visible to parents/students will go, before student facing roles do.

Was that a secondary school?

BridasShieldWall · 23/10/2022 20:44

I work in finance in a MAT and across all schools we set a balanced budget. We have a mix of mostly primary with two secondary schools. Some of our schools had a deficit budget set this year which are supported by other schools in the Trust. These are for specific reasons e..g trying to build up the school, falling numbers of pupils etc. Across the MAT we had a balanced budget with a small surplus that we use to build up a surplus to support the trust in times of need.

we have had the following changes since we set the budget

  • 5% unfounded increase in teaching salaries
  • 9% (roughly) increase in support staff so TAs, caretakers, office staff etc
  • utility increases
  • general inflation estimates

We’ve rerun the forecast and it results in a £1m deficit with no indication of whether any of this will be funded and we’re unlikely to hear soon of any changes to funding due to the chaos in the Conservative party. We’ve stripped TAs as much as we can whilst trying to maintain educational standards, we’re using our buying power to reduce costs for trust wide contracts and materials and educational resources are constantly under review. We hire out facilities where possible and have after school clubs in some schools but it depends on the demographic of each school. We’re holding firm at the moment awaiting the fall out from this but options are reviewing staffing, TAs and SLT structures, school day e.g. finish early one day or closing schools that we looking to develop. As a trust overall we were in a good position, better than a lot of schools who are in a worse position that we are.

BounceBackBoris · 23/10/2022 20:44

caringcarer · 23/10/2022 20:08

Not HT or SMT but hiring out school Sports Hall after school and weekends. PTA have fund raising committee and put on car boot sales, car washes, Quiz Night, School Disco, Book swops, and second hand uniform sales etc. Perhaps an event every other month. Wrap around child care with breakfast club and after school club. Selling hot toast at break time for 30p a slice. I think schools have to be inventive. Government are paying subsidy on heating this winter. I am not suggesting parents/grandparents can replace T/A's but if had DBS check could do some tasks like listening to the better readers, tidying up sports equipment after PE, washing up paint pots etc. Then T/A's are freed up to concentrate on more specialised duties. I know many Grandparents, recently retired, who say they would volunteer but for only 1 morning a week.

You would loose money renting out for all of those unless the renter are prepared to pay £100 an hour which they are not.

Who will make the hot toast? How do you keep toast hot? (ie you need kitchen staff who are making lunch and not available) Who would sell the toast? Bank the money?

School discos- loose money and take a vast amount of unpaid staff time. They are a social event for children- not a Money maker.

Car washing- that's an adult only job. Shall I get the TAs to do that rather than be with children? I could stick a broom up there backsides and hire them out as cleaners as well. You need a lot of insurance to wash cars.

Book swap- wont make money

2nd hand uniforms sales- the government now expects us to sell 2nd hand uniform at little or no cost. Doesn't amex any money.

Grandparents- ok. Are they prepared to be hit, kicked, spat on? Can the calm down a distraught child? Change a nappy?

Listening to readers? It isnt 1998. No-one listens to readers. They teach reading.

Put away PE equipment and wash pots. so 5 minute jobs- how would that help?

Believeitornot · 23/10/2022 20:42

Public services do generally rely on goodwill to paper over the cracks. And we won’t have much to compare it to unless we have kids spread out over a wide range and can remember the New Labour days.

maybe as I’ve been a governor then a parent, I can see it really has degraded. Covid has kept a lot of parents out of schools so again, it’s disguised but it’s appalling. My Ds’s secondary school for example, the school building is falling apart, they use photocopies instead of proper text books, the toilets are horrific, everything is just old and tired.

The current government don’t use state services that much and it’s too centralised so those in the department for education have no clue what the front line is like.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:40

thenewaveragebear1983 · 23/10/2022 20:34

Not just teaching staff but support staff too. I have just resigned from the 2nd school in a row where I have been effectively doing 2 people’s jobs for 6 months at a time. As in, a vacant post, going unadvertised for 6 months and me doing all that job and my own as well with no end in sight. I have left because the stress was unmanageable and was making me ill. The solution? They have listed my job a band lower, so the person who gets that post will be doing the 2 jobs for even less money. It’s not as if support staff cost the earth, schools are just stripping away roles all the time and existing staff are filling the vacuum. I was attendance officer /EWO and that’s a pretty essential role but even then it was grotesquely underpaid and there was just me where there should have been 2 (at least) in a school of 1000 children.

Attendance officers are so useful, and it's a tough job. Previous school got rid of ours, and tried to get teachers to do the job, with limited success- we were expected to phone home for absences in our tutor group! Obviously, this was massively time consuming, and also happened after 3pm, so no good if, e.g. a child went missing on the way to school (I know it's an unlikely scenario, but it's part of the reason schools do these things).

I think in secondaries, unfortunately all these "back office" jobs which aren't immediately visible to parents/students will go, before student facing roles do.

vipersnest1 · 23/10/2022 20:40

Just to add another viewpoint on this (and I now know why it was done).
I've recently returned from well over six months' absence. (Not my choice and the reasons are not relevant here, suffice to say it wasn't life-threatening but is life-altering.)
I've had two meetings with HR where they have stated 'if you have another extended absence, we will have to proceed to the next stage of the absence protocol'.
The takeaway from that is that I'm an expensive employee (both UPS and have a TLR). If I 'went' they would be able to replace me with a classroom teacher, and would devolve my responsibilities to other members of staff, dressed up as a whole school contribution so they could qualify for UPS (maybe). That way they would pay absolutely nothing for several people covering the things that I do.
It was suggested to me that I consider medical retirement at one of the meetings - I can't afford and don't want that.
However, there is someone somewhere, counting the pennies. As I said, I guess I'm expensive in the grand scheme of things.
But I would like to add the rider that my school is part of a large academy trust.
I'm just a name and number.
That's all it comes down to these days.
Schools / academies / trusts are just businesses who happen to provide education.
Saying all that, there is also the huge issue of SEND funding now being portioned out to schools, rather than bids being put forward from the LEA 'pot'.
Schools are damned because whatever they do, there is always a shortfall in provision.

Navigatingnewwaters · 23/10/2022 20:39

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:28

In England, many schools are not run by the LA, but by academies/multi-academy trusts. These are generally not for profit organisations, but they take on the management of the school budgets and receive funding directly from central government. They are responsible for providing all services like HR, payroll etc to their staff as well.

Schools are not meant to have a deficit budget, so if the MAT runs out of reserves, they have to make do with what is available to the school. In general, schools aren't meant to pay staff salaries via parental donations etc either.

When people talk about schools going bust, they really mean the MAT has run out of money. In reality, what that means is the school will continue to run, but it may have no funds to e.g. pay supply staff, so if lots of teachers are unwell one day, the school would have to close (as we saw during covid).

That said, I do think things will get tight, even for LA schools in England, because as has been said, local authorities have no money either- so they won't be able to bail out schools with ever increasing costs.

Thank you for this, very helpfully explained 😊

spanieleyes · 23/10/2022 20:37

We have never had a negative budget but this year will go £30,000 in debt, the only way we can cover is to loose staff. Costs for everything are increasing exponentially and the unfunded pay rise will cripple us. When hauled before the local authority to explain the deficit, their advice was to " make savings" but they couldn't say where!

donttellmehesalive · 23/10/2022 20:36

I'm SLT and it is bad. We have held reserves by being cautious about spending but they are almost depleted. We have to ration stationery and copying. We are not replacing two teachers and will have bigger classes. We are making TAs redundant at the end of this year. Funding for SEN children does not cover their support but next year they will only be supported for the hours that we can fund. We need building work that we cannot afford to do. Our Head will teach classes for the first time in ten years. External support that we pay for will no longer be available to us. We are in a much better position than any other school in our MAT.

Invisimamma · 23/10/2022 20:34

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/10/2022 20:28

In England, many schools are not run by the LA, but by academies/multi-academy trusts. These are generally not for profit organisations, but they take on the management of the school budgets and receive funding directly from central government. They are responsible for providing all services like HR, payroll etc to their staff as well.

Schools are not meant to have a deficit budget, so if the MAT runs out of reserves, they have to make do with what is available to the school. In general, schools aren't meant to pay staff salaries via parental donations etc either.

When people talk about schools going bust, they really mean the MAT has run out of money. In reality, what that means is the school will continue to run, but it may have no funds to e.g. pay supply staff, so if lots of teachers are unwell one day, the school would have to close (as we saw during covid).

That said, I do think things will get tight, even for LA schools in England, because as has been said, local authorities have no money either- so they won't be able to bail out schools with ever increasing costs.

Thank you for this explanation. What a sorry state of affairs. In Scotland all of our schools are either run by the local authority or are independent fee paying schools, so although LAs are cash strapped I don't think we will be facing quite the same issues.

thenewaveragebear1983 · 23/10/2022 20:34

Not just teaching staff but support staff too. I have just resigned from the 2nd school in a row where I have been effectively doing 2 people’s jobs for 6 months at a time. As in, a vacant post, going unadvertised for 6 months and me doing all that job and my own as well with no end in sight. I have left because the stress was unmanageable and was making me ill. The solution? They have listed my job a band lower, so the person who gets that post will be doing the 2 jobs for even less money. It’s not as if support staff cost the earth, schools are just stripping away roles all the time and existing staff are filling the vacuum. I was attendance officer /EWO and that’s a pretty essential role but even then it was grotesquely underpaid and there was just me where there should have been 2 (at least) in a school of 1000 children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread