Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be considering giving up on goddaughter?

109 replies

Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 18:46

I have been friends with GD’s mum since we were small children. My little goddaughter is four.

I’m absolutely fed up with my friend. For a long, long time now she’s been flakey with plans. We’ll arrange something, and 9/10 she’ll cancel on the day. This year she’s cancelled because she ‘forgot’ about the plans (which we’d spoken about only the day before), because she ‘forgot she had a wedding’, and an array of other reasons. She most recently cancelled on me this week.

We arranged a night out earlier this year and I got dressed up and got a taxi to the bar, and she turned up with the car and said she could only stay for one coke because she’d had such a busy day. It was only the two of us out.

I was seeing a man and she kept forgetting his name, and forgot we’d broken up. It grates on me but I kept letting it go.

It was her daughter’s birthday party last week and so I went to the party and took a present, and gave it to GD. She took the present and put it on the floor, unopened, and DF took it away. I haven’t had any thank you or acknowledgement of it since. No idea if she liked it.

It was my birthday this week and I got a text saying ‘happy birthday’. I don’t want a present or anything, but I do think she could’ve sent a card or asked if we should arrange birthday drinks, and I always do for her.

I’m absolutely fed up. Over the years I’ve spent a fortune on her engagement, hen do, wedding, christening presents, Christmas and birthday presents for GD without fail and she can’t remember the basics of my life, if ever she bothers asking me about them or actually turning up to something we’ve arranged.

AIBU to stop buying for GD given that it is always, always me who makes any effort to see her mother, and never the other way round? It’s not the money as such, it’s just I feel like I’m being treated like a mug always turning up to parties etc that I don’t want to really go to, when I don’t get the courtesy of any effort put in my DF.

OP posts:
Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 20:40

Hullabalooza · 23/10/2022 20:37

Ok, here is what I would do:

  1. Stop trying to arrange things with friend. Wait and see if she values the friendship by attempting to arrange to see you. This will tell you a lot.
  2. Send cards through post for the next year or so, including a £10 voucher or book token.
  3. If nothing changes, scale back to cards only after 18 months or so and move on with your life.

Lots of non-religious people use the title ‘God parent’ to mean “if something happens to me, you seem sensible/trustworthy enough to raise my child”. Over time, it’s inevitable these connections have the potential to drift. You are never going to have a strong relationship with the child if you’re not a regular part of her life, and you can’t force that. I’d absolutely spend the savings money on a holiday, cut your losses and follow the above three steps before fading off into the sunset and living your life.

Ps. Your ‘friend’ sounds like a self centred dick.

Thanks, this actually sounds like a plan. We have theatre tickets next month. If she cancels that then this is what I’m going to do.

OP posts:
Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 20:39

JLQ1020 · 23/10/2022 20:35

Slightly different perspective here but do you know how your friend is feeling?
Is she coping OK? Pulling back and cancelling last minute, even forgetfulness can be symptomatic of anxiety and depression. Is she being a crap friend because she isn't actually doing OK?

She’s a crap friend, that is all there is to it. Interested only in herself. This predates her daughter, although it is getting worse. It’s the longevity of the friendship that’s kept me sticking with it. We’ve been friends since we were younger than GD.

OP posts:
Hullabalooza · 23/10/2022 20:37

Ok, here is what I would do:

  1. Stop trying to arrange things with friend. Wait and see if she values the friendship by attempting to arrange to see you. This will tell you a lot.
  2. Send cards through post for the next year or so, including a £10 voucher or book token.
  3. If nothing changes, scale back to cards only after 18 months or so and move on with your life.

Lots of non-religious people use the title ‘God parent’ to mean “if something happens to me, you seem sensible/trustworthy enough to raise my child”. Over time, it’s inevitable these connections have the potential to drift. You are never going to have a strong relationship with the child if you’re not a regular part of her life, and you can’t force that. I’d absolutely spend the savings money on a holiday, cut your losses and follow the above three steps before fading off into the sunset and living your life.

Ps. Your ‘friend’ sounds like a self centred dick.

Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 20:36

BobLemon · 23/10/2022 20:32

You sound like hard work. Do blokes spend this much energy measuring and evaluating friendships? You either like her company or you don’t. All this keeping track and measuring what you get out of it sounds exhausting.

Ooo well, if the exalted men wouldn’t behave like this then I mustn’t either.

Top tip for the future - What Would Blokes Do?

Thank you, all sorted now 😘

OP posts:
JLQ1020 · 23/10/2022 20:35

Slightly different perspective here but do you know how your friend is feeling?
Is she coping OK? Pulling back and cancelling last minute, even forgetfulness can be symptomatic of anxiety and depression. Is she being a crap friend because she isn't actually doing OK?

AllyCatTown · 23/10/2022 20:35

I’m not religious either but I’m confused why you have any attachment or duty to something you don’t believe in. If you can’t have any relationship with the mother then of course you can’t with the daughter. I’d find it weird if someone wasn’t friends with me and wanted to spend time developing a relationship with my daughter.

Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 20:34

Posted too soon!

But that is what I had hoped for - a good relationship with her when she is older. It is clearly not going to happen. Her mother is beyond self involved and it’s got to the point that she doesn’t care about anything except herself and her family and whatever affects/is of interest to them. Even when I do see her I can see her visibly losing interest when I speak.

OP posts:
Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 20:32

MrsSchadenfreude · 23/10/2022 20:28

Instead of buying birthday and Christmas presents, why don’t you put away £5 a month in a savings account or ISA for her and give it to her when she is 18 or 21? DD1 has a really nice relationship with her godmother now that she is an adult, as they like the same things and enjoy each other’s company.

I already do this with £10 a month, but I am thinking about stopping.

OP posts:
BobLemon · 23/10/2022 20:32

You sound like hard work. Do blokes spend this much energy measuring and evaluating friendships? You either like her company or you don’t. All this keeping track and measuring what you get out of it sounds exhausting.

Rhutdvhf · 23/10/2022 20:29

hardtochangename · 23/10/2022 19:55

£10 a month? That seems overly generous for a non relationship! Does your friend know about that and what will she do/say if you suddenly go on holiday with the savings, lol?
I think if you cease to have a friendship (and it does seem dead in the water) then you can ease off on the gifts etc for the god child. Not to forget them completely but the context has changed and you could have many years ahead of this. An appropriate token for a toy, book or whatever slipped in a card for birthdays and Christmas would be enough - forget all the other stuff.

No, DF doesn’t know and has never known. I always thought I’d give it to GD when she was an adult herself.

OP posts:
MrsSchadenfreude · 23/10/2022 20:28

Instead of buying birthday and Christmas presents, why don’t you put away £5 a month in a savings account or ISA for her and give it to her when she is 18 or 21? DD1 has a really nice relationship with her godmother now that she is an adult, as they like the same things and enjoy each other’s company.

kitcat15 · 23/10/2022 20:24

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/10/2022 20:19

As for the £10 a month, take the money for yourself or your nephew. Perhaps 50/50. Whatever makes you feel better. Your goddaughter won’t seek you out when she’s older even if you send cards and a present or money.

You are unlikely to ever have a relationship with the girl....I would give the money to my nephew if it was me....family first every time for me

BatshitBanshee · 23/10/2022 20:23

I'm a godmother a few times over. If I were you, I'd scale presents back to a posted card and small present - and I wouldn't be making myself available to DF anytime soon. See how long it takes her to contact you and organise something. 30 year friendship but she doesn't seem to put any effort in at all.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/10/2022 20:19

As for the £10 a month, take the money for yourself or your nephew. Perhaps 50/50. Whatever makes you feel better. Your goddaughter won’t seek you out when she’s older even if you send cards and a present or money.

ChunkyThighs24 · 23/10/2022 20:17

I have been in a similar situation.. I decided I made a commitment to the child, & continued to buy Xmas & Birthday presents, because it wasn't the child's fault my friendship with his mum had deteriorated/changed. This was several years ago but I still buy birthday & Xmas presents, with or without a thank you card, & I will until he's 18. If you step away from the friendship, it could even give your friends head a wobble. But don't exclude the child, they've not done anything wrong.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/10/2022 20:16

EmmaGrundyForPM · 23/10/2022 19:26

Sending £10 at Christmas is NOT fulfilling your duties as a Godparent. It's not about presents or money, it's about a vow to guide the child in their religious journey.

Obviously being a godparent isn’t about bunging a kid a tenner twice a year. However, my suggestion is fulfilling the obligation in the only way op is currently able. Op isn’t religious and had no intention of guiding the child on a religious journey. She is allowed to be a godparent despite not being religious. She intended made a commitment to bond with the little girl and be a guiding hand in a non religious way. The mum was happy with this at the time and so was op.

BlueWalnut · 23/10/2022 20:15

Gihi · 23/10/2022 19:56

I would stop trying to organise things with the friends. Just give it all space. She is behaving very poorly but some people just don't cope with motherhood very well and do become completely overwhelmed. Others breeze through it and remain as organised as ever. I'm an organised one until something throws me off e.g an illness and then I becomes totally overwhelmed, so I see both sides.

For the little girl, I would continue to send a card and a small present on birthdays and Christmas and I'd stop expecting a thanks for it. But I would continue until she was about 10-12yrs old and from there I would send just a card until she was 18yrs.

For a present nothing fancy.

You may find as time goes on and Mum realises you've stepped back, she comes back with a big effort.

Having read your update, I would do this. Good luck OP.

Gihi · 23/10/2022 19:56

I would stop trying to organise things with the friends. Just give it all space. She is behaving very poorly but some people just don't cope with motherhood very well and do become completely overwhelmed. Others breeze through it and remain as organised as ever. I'm an organised one until something throws me off e.g an illness and then I becomes totally overwhelmed, so I see both sides.

For the little girl, I would continue to send a card and a small present on birthdays and Christmas and I'd stop expecting a thanks for it. But I would continue until she was about 10-12yrs old and from there I would send just a card until she was 18yrs.

For a present nothing fancy.

You may find as time goes on and Mum realises you've stepped back, she comes back with a big effort.

hardtochangename · 23/10/2022 19:55

£10 a month? That seems overly generous for a non relationship! Does your friend know about that and what will she do/say if you suddenly go on holiday with the savings, lol?
I think if you cease to have a friendship (and it does seem dead in the water) then you can ease off on the gifts etc for the god child. Not to forget them completely but the context has changed and you could have many years ahead of this. An appropriate token for a toy, book or whatever slipped in a card for birthdays and Christmas would be enough - forget all the other stuff.

Axolotlquestions · 23/10/2022 19:55

I too recently gave up on a friend/goddaughter. I felt sad about it, but there's only so much effort or running you can do. I hadn't even seen the GD in a few years.

kitcat15 · 23/10/2022 19:55

PinkiOcelot · 23/10/2022 19:51

I think being a god parent means SFA these days. I would let the friendship slide along with your god parent duties - whatever they are!

This ^

PinkiOcelot · 23/10/2022 19:51

I think being a god parent means SFA these days. I would let the friendship slide along with your god parent duties - whatever they are!

caringcarer · 23/10/2022 19:51

GD Mum is not your friend. I would drop friendship but continue to send card gift to God child.

Sillystripytail · 23/10/2022 19:48

Your "friend" is taking the piss. Just stop it all, presents, saving the money for her etc.

Have a lovely holiday with the savings!

user1471457751 · 23/10/2022 19:46

I find it bizarre so many people think the OP can have a bond with this kid when the mum cancels almost every meet up. Sending a birthday card every year is fine but it's not going to develop a relationship and lead to this child being oh so keen to contact the OP when she is older. The child will just ask her mum who the card is from, shrug her shoulders and put it in the pile of all other cards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread