Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“What caused it?”

66 replies

Borisisabanana · 23/10/2022 18:39

My child was born with a physical issue/impairment. He needs surgery and it will still never be 100% fixed. MIL asked me today “what caused it?”

AIBU to think this is fucking rude?

i just feel it implies a degree of blame on my part as he’s just a baby so must have been in utero, and has had me worried sick googling causes (some of which are very concerning indeed but none of which the doctor has mentioned).

or am I just being sensitive? I can’t imagine seeing someone with an impairment or disability and asking their mother what caused it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThreeLocusts · 23/10/2022 22:27

Hi OP, seems to me the issue here is how not what - yes a grandmother may well want to know about the causes of dc's condition, but no, she is not entitled to be rude and accusatory about it.

My paternal grandparents developed a habit of constructing accusatory narratives targeting my mother whenever I or my sister had any problems. It can happen.

The main problem though was that my dad didn't shut them down. Hope your dh is in your corner.

TiredButOk · 23/10/2022 21:52

Aww. I feel for you OP. I wouldn't over think it. She's likely just curious. I don't think it was rude unless she was saying it in a way that implied wrong doing on your part. It sounds like you are worried now that something you did caused it, which I very much doubt. Maybe have a discussion with the docs about causality. It will make you feel better, empower you, and then you won't mind such questions in future 💐

cc1997 · 23/10/2022 21:48

She didn't say "what did you do wrong to cause it?" She said "what caused it?" I don't think this is unreasonable of her to ask you. I'd be curious as a close family member probably. At least she asked you rather than googling like some people have suggested! I wouldn't be offended personally, I'd appreciate someone asking instead of speculating.

Mysonsmother · 23/10/2022 21:03

Borisisabanana · 23/10/2022 20:45

Thanks for the input everyone - appreciate the opinions. I am sure I am just being over sensitive as I’m upset and will try to accept her comment in a positive/interested nature and I’m sure I will feel better when I know more about the medical situation/am
not so afraid/know exactly what the parameters are.

going to step off the thread now. Thanks again.

Sending you every best wish and a virtual hug.

lljkk · 23/10/2022 20:49

Do you blame yourself for his impairment, OP?
Coz the natural answer would be "I don't know" rather than be sure your MIL is accusing you of something.

You're stuck with this woman for life by virtue of having her grandchild. This is just my opinion you can ignore. I'm sure that if you always respond as though you know she could only have said something with the best of intentions, then you will have a better relationship. That doesn't mean you trust or like her, it just means that you can always hold your head up high that you have done nothing wrong in the relationship and any issues she has are her issues, entirely not yours. Her opinions don't have to weigh heavy on you.

Borisisabanana · 23/10/2022 20:45

Thanks for the input everyone - appreciate the opinions. I am sure I am just being over sensitive as I’m upset and will try to accept her comment in a positive/interested nature and I’m sure I will feel better when I know more about the medical situation/am
not so afraid/know exactly what the parameters are.

going to step off the thread now. Thanks again.

OP posts:
InTrussWeTruss · 23/10/2022 20:45

I don't think it implies blame whatsoever unless there's a back story. Of course as his grandmother she would want to know. I think you are being sensitive and reading things into a simple sentence but I can understand that this is hard for you and that kqxbe you worry that others are blaming you even if they aren't.

Pixiedust1234 · 23/10/2022 20:35

Its a perfectly normal and valid question especially if there was a thought it might be genetic.

As for saying she should have googled...surely its better to ask the person who has spoken to medical specialists about this specific child and get the relevant facts rather than maybes.

Be grateful shes actually interested in her grandchild.

Mysonsmother · 23/10/2022 20:33

I’ve NC for this as I’m a MiL.
The fact that she asked you and not your DH directly demonstrates she believes your relationship with her has improved.
Trust her.
She’s as upset and confused by what has happened as you are.
She is in no way attributing blame to you. There is no indication that she is doing this. Don’t project into her.
The baby has not only inherited your DNA but her son’s and hers.
She is most likely more aware of her family medical history than you are. She could help you to understand the situation more fully if you open up to her.
Do you want to know the cause? Yes. She does too for the same reasons as you.
There’s nothing to read into what she asked.
Try not to think of her as insensitive. Perhaps you are overly sensitive to her.
Accept her as an experienced mother who is looking out for you and the family you have made with her son.

FergusSingsTheBIues · 23/10/2022 20:30

How are you going to cope when your child asks? Some things have to be dealt with relatively openly.

My sons autistic and I didn’t get offended when we used to sit and chat about the causes. But you know the tone and the context.

CheezePleeze · 23/10/2022 20:24

I think it's a perfectly valid question for her to ask OP.

nokidshere · 23/10/2022 20:21

It’s completely tone deaf. What was the op supposed to respond? “The cause? Oh yes it was because I drank too much/have bad genes/ played too much sport”. It implies something happened to make it happen.

One of my 5 sisters was diagnosed with a genetic problem a couple of years back, we all received letters from the genetics department. The first thing we did was a group zoom and asked her what her consultant said about what caused it (and how we all got to our 60's without it being detected before). There's no implication that the first sister who was diagnosed had done anything wrong. It's a basic question about how it happened to us. When I was telling my DH, my sons and MIL the first question from all of them was "what caused that"

The relationship is context here. It's not tone deaf to discuss family issues with family. Maybe insensitive given that OP hadn't processed it yet and doesn't always get on with MIL.

TeaPleaseNoLemon · 23/10/2022 20:21

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

iklboo · 23/10/2022 20:19

I wonder if she thought something went wrong at the hospital rather than something you did?

Cheeeeislifenow · 23/10/2022 20:19

@FatCatSkinnyRat so sorry for your little boys illness.
I think people often ask this question as it is such sad and upsetting news that something awful happens unfairly , especially when it's children that as humans we need to find a way to make sense of it by asking for a cause

Spidey66 · 23/10/2022 20:17

A cousin of mine has 2 kids with cystic fibrosis. My aunt (grandmother to the children) believed it was caused by my cousins wife having rubella in pregnancy.

I've no idea why she hadn't been properly informed that that's not how a child gets CF, but I do think that a grandparent would want to know.

FatCatSkinnyRat · 23/10/2022 20:15

Hi OP, I think YANBU. I get you. I knew what this topic was about from just seeing the title in the thread list!

My son had Non-Hodgkins Lymphoma a few years ago. It was the number one question absolutely every one asked - "did they say what caused it?". Not "I hope he is OK" or "how are you getting on?" or even "how can I help?".

To me, the subtext was "How can I do something you did/didn't do so my family doesn't end up like yours?"

In hindsight this is perhaps slightly unreasonable. But it went along with the why me, why my lovely boy, feelings I had at the time.

My PIL didn't even contact us when my son was sick as they are crap and live a fair distance away but I did hear that they mentioned to a family member that "we don't have cancer on our side of the family" which is also a bit shit.

BiscuitLover3678 · 23/10/2022 20:11

Also let’s please try and be sensitive to the op who is clearly going through an awful time. Of ten it’s the manner in how these things are asked too.

BiscuitLover3678 · 23/10/2022 20:09

It’s completely tone deaf. What was the op supposed to respond? “The cause? Oh yes it was because I drank too much/have bad genes/ played too much sport”. It implies something happened to make it happen.

A more sensitive way would be to say “do you know why it’s happened?” But tbh even that can feel nosy and upsetting.
The baby is clearly young and it’s an incredibly emotional time anyway so she should have been much more sensitive.

surreygirl1987 · 23/10/2022 20:09

I can entirely understand why you feel that way. I think I would feel the same too. But I also understand why she asked. When my oldest son had health issues as a baby, I was desperate to know if there was a 'cause'. I was desperate to know anything! She's not a stranger - she's a family member who is very emotionally invested. However, she could have perhaps phrased her question more sensitively. I doubt she intended you to feel any element of blame whatsoever but I can fully understand why you took it that way and feel defensive. I don't think anyone is being unreasonable in this situation though- it's just tough for everyone. I really hope things work out okay.

DoubleBuggyDriver · 23/10/2022 20:08

I really don’t see the problem.

My son is 6 months and when he was 2 months old we found out he had a rare genetic disorder. We often had questions like
’how did he get it’ as it wasn’t passed on from his dad or I. I don’t see the issue in asking a question as I’m sure you’d be more educated on the topic seeing as it’s impacting your child.

The answer could simply be, ‘it was completely random’ and that’s it. I don’t feel like she’s implicating you did something wrong but obviously tone and stuff is a factor. You’re entitled to feel how you feel

DesMoulinsRouge · 23/10/2022 20:05

I think you are overreacting a little and she was a little insensitive.
You are stressed, understandably, and it's really got to you.
I think it's normal to ask whether it is something genetic or just one of those things. Probably she could have worded it better.
Hope that your baby is OK and that you get some reassurance from the consultant.

drpet49 · 23/10/2022 20:01

BattenburgDonkey · 23/10/2022 18:44

I think it’s far stranger than your own mother hasn’t asked to be honest. Guessing you aren’t close to her?

I agree.

HotCoffee22 · 23/10/2022 19:59

I have a profoundly disabled family member and everyone wants to know how it happened. I think it’s natural.

DeadbeatYoda · 23/10/2022 19:57

I mean as the mother of a child with a genetic condiction ( me) I think you should be careful...