Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hard to see her in same way

136 replies

Perditanoy · 23/10/2022 17:02

I have a friend I've known for about a decade. Met at uni. Lots in common.

After uni we never lived close by but caught up on text every few months and saw each other periodically. She had the same boyfriend for years but was always so adamant she'd never get married or have kids. Very career-oriented, did loads of travelling and had great hobbies.

I really came to admire her stance and honesty on the marriage and kids thing as she wasn't afraid to say it wasn't for her despite the usual societal pressures. It was refreshing. She was quite clear on all her reasons for her views and we had many conversations about it. It wasn't necessarily going to be the path I took but I loved having a proudly independent female friend who wasn't pining to get married and have babies and was going to do it her way. I really looked up to her.

Then a few years ago just before lockdown, her and her partner bought a house. For legal reasons they then decided to marry given their new situation with the property (they live abroad). It was a closed door wedding and she had no fuss or even family attend. Just one witness. Fair enough. Owning property sometimes means marriage is a better option for tax/ inheritance reasons.

I saw her around this time and she was still 100% no on kids however. Her partner didn't agree though and they'd had a lot of arguments about it.

Then last year she got pregnant and has since had a kid. I found out via social media and she never let me know directly. I called to congratulate her of course but she seemed quite sheepish about it, almost embarrassed. She mentioned relatives that had trouble getting pregnant and were desperate for kids yet she hadn't been and it all happened easily.

Since then we've had occasional contact but not as much and usually about things related to hobbies. I asked a couple of baby questions but she never answered. It's fair to say we've drifted, also due to post-lockdown and living so far away. I'm OK with this as I know friendships can change but I've been reflecting on how she did a 180 on things she seemed so against all the time I knew her. Maybe I never really knew her at all?

I know people change their minds, life moves on, situations crop up so there's no judgement of her about any of this.

But for so long I saw her as the cool independent one. I put her on a pedestal and I admired her resistance to doing what is expected of every woman in society. And she was so adamant for years that that life wasn't for her. So her change of heart did come as a real shock and I guess it was hard to see her in the same way. I honestly never thought she'd change her mind as she holds very strong opinions and convictions.

Aibu to have been so shocked that she changed her mind and did what everyone else does or should I never have believed her in the first place and put her on such a pedestal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BeanieTeen · 24/10/2022 10:42

Yeah because you called her. You could have commented on social media instead of phoning her up and putting her on the spot

Missed that bit. Yeah, that is weird.
And from your stance it’s not like you actually called her to ‘congratulate’ her as you say at all OP - you’ve made it clear here that you’re not happy or excited for her. As others have said you are over invested in her life choices and the phone call seems like more of an odd check in and you are implicitly calling up to call her out on her choices. No wonder it was awkward.

Cosmos123 · 23/10/2022 22:01

Perditanoy · 23/10/2022 17:11

It wasn't so much the child free stance, it was more that she seemed to know exactly what she wanted and didn't want and wasn't afraid to say it.

I had much lower self esteem in my 20s so I was probably overly captivated by someone able to speak their mind and probably admired it more than normal.

You are over invested in someone's else life.

Could you be jealous?

everyone has the right to change their mind whenever on what ever they want.
Stop judging and interfering.
You sounds very immature and quite scary.

Charlize43 · 23/10/2022 21:47

I'm going to be very forward here and ask if your attraction to her was sexual / a crush?

Perhaps the idea that she was so vocal about not having children led you to somewhat believe she was a lesbian and maybe you had a crush on her?

I'm a lesbian, but when I was younger avoided all references to having children. When asked if I was married or had kids, I would often say that I hadn't met the right person yet (of course, the opposite is true as I had quite an active but clandestine double life).

It's only now in my 50s that I've started openly telling people that my partner is another woman, prior to that I always lived with same sex 'friends'. I also have several gay male friends who would stand in at more formal conventional functions. One, who is a distinguished academic, even proposed a marriage of convenience but I couldn't be bothered with all that and besides I always managed well by myself... you could say I am one of those 'independent' women you admire so much... but not by choice.

In a different lifetime, I would have loved being married and having a couple of kids, but sadly I never found men physically attractive. Love their minds, just not their dicks!

NeedAHoliday2021 · 23/10/2022 21:36

I said I’d never marry or have dc then I met dh and my world changed. Been married 18 years and have 3dc. I’d fine it odd if a friend had put me on a pedestal. That said bil and sil married but didn’t want dc and we understood and admired their choice but they changed their mind in lockdown - I think many people reassessed priorities.

Charlize43 · 23/10/2022 21:12

I'm not so sure what's so 'cool' about not having kids. I'm a lesbian and never had any, as have plenty of my friends.

People say dumb things when they are teenagers. I remember a girl I went to Uni with telling everyone who would listen that she was going to be famous, although she couldn't decide if she was going to be an actress or a singer. A couple of years ago, I heard from a mutual friend that she was a grandmother and had worked for the same insurance company for thirty years.

Likewise, I remember all the friends who were so insistence that they would die young and are still around today.

I'm not sure why you thought your friend was so 'cool'. She sounds very unmaternal. I wonder what type of mother she is today?

It's odd how you worshipped this woman. I don't recall anyone at Uni enthusing about having children - everyone had ambitions of one sort or another, or were too busy getting wasted.

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 21:05

Here why are you quoting me? I'm not judging.

You say "I’ve had people accuse me of lying about not wanting kids. Lying. Why? Why would I lie?"

I was accused of it too. One friend does still lie because she can't have them and prefers to say this.

when I said some might be talking nonsense, the older I get, the more I realise some people say anything at all for reasons I can't fathom. It might be that in teens and twenties, some people said it because they thought I'd like them more?

I have never accused anyone of lying, just pondering on a chat board.

BatshitBanshee · 23/10/2022 21:02

Hard to see her in the same way? God OP I'd say if she read your post she'd hardly want to see you at all now.

I'm so uncomfortable reading this - for her. You're very intense and over invested in her life and choices, so she changed her mind, she didn't have to run it by you or inform you of anything. I actually have had quite a similar timeline to your friend over the last ten years, same views and everything. I'm not going to offer explanations as to why she changed because frankly, it's none of your business. I will say that your explanation as to why you put her on a pedestal is quite weird. Stop fixating on her.

Also:

I found out via social media and she never let me know directly. I called to congratulate her of course but she seemed quite sheepish about it, almost embarrassed.

Yeah because you called her. You could have commented on social media instead of phoning her up and putting her on the spot and I'm willing to bet money that you said something along the lines of "I didn't even know you were pregnant!" in which case she probably thought because I didn't tell you. The friendship has changed and she's moved on. Just let go.

Herejustforthisone · 23/10/2022 20:57

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 19:44

No I didn't judge them.

i am god parent - not guardian - in one case and having a child was a great thing for him and his wife.

I don't think OP is judging either. It's just a bit hard if you feel that someone was maybe talking nonsense all along. But maybe I'm projecting on to OP.

This is why I feel like I need to defend myself over winding up with a child. Because people are so opinionated about women and their wombs. Fuck me.
I didn’t want children. Truly. But I wound up pregnant and decided to go with it because on paper my life was in a perfect place for a child. The only thing missing was my actual want to continue with my pregnancy. Nevertheless, I did continue with it and I’m rather good at motherhood as it goes. I love my kid but I’m not a schmaltzy, naturally maternal woman at all. I think, for me, that’s a strength.

I’ve had people accuse me of lying about not wanting kids. Lying. Why? Why would I lie?

Firstly why the fuck do people think they have a right to accuse me of that? Secondly, it transpires whatever you do with your womb as a woman, other people seem to be labouring under the misapprehension that they get to have an opinion on it and can use it against you.

I say, fuck off.

Kite22 · 23/10/2022 20:56

Totally agree with @SpidersAreShitheads at 20:53

KellyTelios · 23/10/2022 20:54

Being childfree doesn't equal to being independent and cool. Hopefully this isn't you judging people for having kids but It was an attitude you liked, she probably still has that attitude. You probably should think about what this says about you more than what it says about her. People are human, they may put decisive brave faces but maybe insecure or uncertain about things inside, maybe they may simply grow up change their minds. Maybe that decisiveness was about convincing herself. Adulthood is about greys not so much black and whites.

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/10/2022 20:53

I think there are lots of us who could relate to being strong-willed, outspoken and somewhat idealistic in our 20s.

With every decade that passes, you realise that some views you once held so vehemently maybe aren’t as clear cut as you thought. With age comes wisdom. Some things change, some things don’t - but it’s possible to appreciate nuance more easily with a bit of life experience behind you.

Shes the same person you always knew - it takes a confident woman to be strong enough to admit that her opinion has changed. She’s still showing you that she’s strong and independent by pursuing a life path that she wants. She didn’t want marriage and kids but now she does. Sounds like she’ll be an ace role model for her child.

I echo others OP, your views are a bit unusual in hero worshipping her. Were you perhaps living vicariously through her? Not trying to be unkind but might explain your misplaced disappointment in her change of heart.

BlueMongoose · 23/10/2022 20:48

People do change. And she may have been under pressure to change. I have no kids of my own, never wanted any of my own, though I don't dislike kids, I worked with them for years, and I'm fond of my young relatives. I don't see why anyone should think more or less of me for any of that. I don't try to persuade anyone to do the same, either, I expect them to make up their own minds about what's right for them and support them in whatever that is.
It's a bit unfair to put people on a pedestal for anything, we're all human, if you do it you are likely headed for disappointment, and it puts people under pressure if they begin to feel that's what you're doing.

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 23/10/2022 20:43

If you had met your friend later in life and found out she had stuck to her word, never married, no kids but she was unhappy, unsuccessful and lonely, would it be hard to see her in the same way then and would you say she’d fallen off her pedestal?
It sounds like you wanted your friend to be an example of that kind of life working out,
her life went a different way but lots of women are very happy being single and not having kids. My sister always said she wouldn’t marry or have kids, she never did and has no regrets.
Sometimes the people who talk a lot about this sort of thing and are very definite about it, it’s because they actually do want it but it scares them or they’re worried it won’t happen for them. It can be because of a bad childhood too sometimes.
I always swore I would never have kids but when I was in my late twenties, something just flipped in me like a switch. I got babies on the brain. One time I walked into a cafe and there was this really powerful smell, it was like warm, clean laundry mixed with something I can’t even describe. When I turned the corner, there was a new mums group with about ten newborns. It was the babies! I couldn’t stop staring at them. In my head I thought I still don’t want one, but it was like on a whole different level, I was compelled to. My dd is 3 now, I still don’t understand what came over me and the weirdest thing is, it’s now happening again 🙈

MrsDSalvatore · 23/10/2022 20:40

I was adamant I didnt want kids. Never felt maternal..i now have 3 year old twins which i had IVF to conceive..people change.
Its impossible to know how you are going to feel or what you are going to want 5 years down the line

kimchifix · 23/10/2022 20:39

Do you now think she was being inauthentic when she took up her stance as a fiercely independent woman? So she was duping you in some way? I don't think that's necessarily the case.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 23/10/2022 20:32

Live your life and let her live hers.

Sometimeswinning · 23/10/2022 20:28

I think you need to have a good look at your own life. At best you're judging at worst I'd be questioning your interest.

You are bu. She's not being sheepish I'm going to guess. I think it's you hearing things. Or she's really nervous speaking to you.

billy1966 · 23/10/2022 20:27

People change.
Even within a decade you can change your view.

I certainly wouldn't be surprised at that in anyone I know.

ittakes2 · 23/10/2022 20:23

My sister was so adamant when she was married in her 20s she had her tubes tied. Now in her 50s mum to a lovely teen after ivf.

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 20:22

It's just struck me that some people might be disappointed I didn't change my mind.?!

ittakes2 · 23/10/2022 20:22

Gosh you sound judgy I am sorry. People can change their minds and if doesn’t make them less of a person because of it.

gonutkin · 23/10/2022 20:21

One of my closest friends since high school has never wanted children or marriage. She's been in a couple of very long term relationships and then got into a relationship and got pregnant and had a baby before they hit a year together. She's very happy and it never crossed my mind how she never wanted children or that I never knew her. I agree it's quite odd how your viewing the whole situation and maybe your friend has picked up on that and that's why she's avoiding certain questions

Habreathmint · 23/10/2022 20:18

You sound a bit intense and insecure tbh

EIIa · 23/10/2022 20:14

She doesn’t owe you anything OP

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 23/10/2022 20:13

I never wanted to get married. Had boyfriends. Found them a bit suffocating. Met my now husband at 21 and could suddenly see building a life with someone.

Still didn't want kids though. We planned for none. Fell pregnant by accident several years after the wedding. Massive shock to both of us. Neither of us could fathom terminating though, so we accepted a baby was coming. DD is the best thing that happened to us, I'm so glad she's here.

However, if things didn't work out with DH, I wouldn't just jump into dating. I'd still rather be alone than with someone just to be with someone.

Point I'm trying to make is that she may have held those views, and to some degree still hold them, but circumstances changed for her and she's realised the joys of the things she didn't originally want, but got anyway.