Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

dog dilemma

92 replies

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 14:25

Name changed :)

my partner and I have been together 4 years, own a house, no children but we want that in the future. Both full time jobs in industries which more often than not requires work outside the 9-5.

here goes - I love dogs, I really do - I grew up with them but my parents had a lot more time to nurture and train her.

my partner wants a dog, his parents have a dog which he loves and is very well trained (a Labrador). I’m being asked at least daily, sometimes 3 or 4 times: “can we get one?”

he knows I love animals but I don’t feel ready to commit to revolving all our plans and social lives around a puppy just yet. My partner works from home a lot, but this isn’t necessarily a guarantee in the future. Sometimes, (and I know I ABU) it makes me feel irritated being asked the same question over and over, it seems slightly unfair because it feels as though my
hand is being slightly forced (he would never just get one without me being in agreement but it makes me feel quite mean, does that make sense?)

I also feel that the type of dog is not up to me, we have a good sized house but when we have looked after his parents Labrador the house suddenly seems small with the Labrador walking into walls or doorframes etc when going into different rooms! For example, I like a certain breed of dog which is quite small - whereas my partner is on about chocolate Labrador’s.

in summary, it doesn’t feel like we have the space but more importantly I don’t feel in a place where I can commit to one, and I don’t want to have to leave work early in order to look after the dog. I want to have a dog when the time feels right, for example when we have children and they are of an age where they would
het joy from a dog. I know how much joy dogs being, being brought up with one, I just don’t feel like
now is the right time, but I’m being asked every day “please can we get one” - it makes me feel mean without even doing anything, it’s starting to upset me and make me quite anxious. I feel I have made it clear that “yes dog one day but not right now” is where I am.

just wanted to reach out really and see if anyone has ever been in this position. Thank you for reading 💐

OP posts:
Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 17:19

girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 17:18

Ask him what he'll do when his massive Labrador gets jealous of your newborn baby or frustrated with them for grabbing its tail!

Exactly! Also who needs that stress when you have a newborn? That circumstance is some
time off but it’s exhausting me just thinking about it

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 17:18

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 17:14

Just to add something else into the mix (brace yourselves) my partner says getting a dog before having children makes sense, because it’s a good test to see how we are and good practice? I had no words

Ask him what he'll do when his massive Labrador gets jealous of your newborn baby or frustrated with them for grabbing its tail!

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 17:14

Just to add something else into the mix (brace yourselves) my partner says getting a dog before having children makes sense, because it’s a good test to see how we are and good practice? I had no words

OP posts:
Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 17:11

Pipsquiggle · 23/10/2022 17:06

It sounds like you are not ready for a dog right now

It would be good to get an idea of timescales of when you think you might want DC and whether you want a dog pre or post DC - this is so your OH has an idea of realistically how long he might have to wait.

Our example
Married 12 years
Going out /living together 5 years before that.
I have always known I wanted a dog but not before DC and not until at least the youngest was at school. My DH was never that keen. I had grown up with dogs so knew the lovely dynamic they brought into the household.
We got a dog last year DC 9&6.

I was very flexible on what breed anything from a terrier size up. My DH did a lot of the research, we were thinking about a labrador but discounted it for all the same reasons as has been mentioned.

We went for an australian labradoodle. We love her so much but we have a settled home, the youngest child was able to control her and the breed suits our family set up.

When getting a dog - the timing of where you are in your life stage is key

This is such helpful and lovely advice, thank you! Researching the right dog seems so sensible, and like you I’m pretty certain I would prefer to wait until we have children at school

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 23/10/2022 17:06

It sounds like you are not ready for a dog right now

It would be good to get an idea of timescales of when you think you might want DC and whether you want a dog pre or post DC - this is so your OH has an idea of realistically how long he might have to wait.

Our example
Married 12 years
Going out /living together 5 years before that.
I have always known I wanted a dog but not before DC and not until at least the youngest was at school. My DH was never that keen. I had grown up with dogs so knew the lovely dynamic they brought into the household.
We got a dog last year DC 9&6.

I was very flexible on what breed anything from a terrier size up. My DH did a lot of the research, we were thinking about a labrador but discounted it for all the same reasons as has been mentioned.

We went for an australian labradoodle. We love her so much but we have a settled home, the youngest child was able to control her and the breed suits our family set up.

When getting a dog - the timing of where you are in your life stage is key

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 17:05

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:39

Oh my goodness!
They so aren't like 'Other' dogs...Much more like cats.

They are so quiet and good.
I really hope you get one eventually.

{Go through a breed club, and they will guide you best to the type you might like, avoiding the internet adverts entirely}

Whippet rescue has huge waiting lists {Testament to the ease of this breed}

But I'm biased.

Dog disliking mum and her visitor!

Lovely advice for when it’s the right time, thank you! See this sounds perfect, because I like cats, so seems like the perfect compromise!?

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 16:59

girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 16:27

So to reveal my dog of choice, it’s a Whippet

But you're concerned about the amount of exercise a lab needs? Grin whippets are great at destroying anything wood

Any breed of dog can be destructive if they don't get enough exercise and stimulation.

I own a beagle and they're renowned for being destructive but mine has never touched a thing as we manage his environment properly and give him plenty of exercise and mental training.

Thatskindafun · 23/10/2022 16:57

You don’t want a dog yet
and if you did want a dog you don’t want the dog your DP wants

why do you think YABU in being irritated that he keeps asking you over and over until you relent?
would you do that to him?

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:54

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:46

Yes but I didn’t say I’d get one did I, just that I like them. Is that okay?

I have a lot of 'valuable' antique wooden things at chew level and whippet hasn't touched them .. any Bored dog can chew.

Any breed needs work putting into it so it knows not to chew certain things.
Sticks and kindling are allowed, antique wood is not. {Dogs do know the difference}

dammit88 · 23/10/2022 16:52

SarahSissions · 23/10/2022 14:48

I think you need a proper chat about this to find out where his heads at rather than him just badgering you and constantly asking the question.

for me having a dog was an absolute dealbreaker, I had wanted in since I was 19 and lost my childhood boy, it took me another 12 years of waiting until I had the suitable house and lifestyle. If my partner had told me no then it would’ve been the end of our relationship. Yes I love my dogs, but I also love the lifestyle, going for a walk before work every morning and evening, training sessions etc.

you need to understand what this means to him. For some people they fancy the idea of having a dog, for others it’s a goal, for some it is a lifestyle.

I think this is a great post. It really is about why he wants a dog, because if its a lifestyle thing it would be a dealbreaker for me.

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:49

girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 16:48

@Georginathatsme and he didn't say he's getting a Labrador but you're here discussing his preferences Confused weird response tbh.

He is self confessed Labrador only

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 16:48

@Georginathatsme and he didn't say he's getting a Labrador but you're here discussing his preferences Confused weird response tbh.

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:47

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:31

Dogs are a massive commitment, and very expensive in terms of vet insurance.
Also, @Georginathatsme , would it be YOU who has to exercise said dog, and train it?
Time spent training is crucial, of the dog is to be welcomed in other people's houses.
No one wants a chaotic , noisy dog in their house.

Sister in law bought a Working breed {Insane} as her children pestered her so much.
The Working breed is manic, chaotic, pulls like a train, and is absolutely unsuited to where they live, and their lifestyle.

Not the dog's fault, but the humans, who don't bother to train the dog.

Their garden has been ruined.

All these things need bearing in mind.

As the woman, I almost guarantee it will be you doing the walking, the poop pickups, the feeding, the training.

Men who pester never fulfil their end of the bargain.

Get a dog that YOU want, when YOU are ready.

Good luck!

Thank you so much for this ❤️

OP posts:
Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:46

girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 16:27

So to reveal my dog of choice, it’s a Whippet

But you're concerned about the amount of exercise a lab needs? Grin whippets are great at destroying anything wood

Yes but I didn’t say I’d get one did I, just that I like them. Is that okay?

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:39

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:25

So to reveal my dog of choice, it’s a Whippet 😍

Oh my goodness!
They so aren't like 'Other' dogs...Much more like cats.

They are so quiet and good.
I really hope you get one eventually.

{Go through a breed club, and they will guide you best to the type you might like, avoiding the internet adverts entirely}

Whippet rescue has huge waiting lists {Testament to the ease of this breed}

But I'm biased.

Dog disliking mum and her visitor!

dog dilemma
Asdf12345 · 23/10/2022 16:34

@rookiemere we are in the uk, albeit a fairly rural area. I wouldn’t personally keep a single dog outside although many do. A pair I would be happy to keep outside (the other half insists ours stay in the house when we are out).

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:31

Dogs are a massive commitment, and very expensive in terms of vet insurance.
Also, @Georginathatsme , would it be YOU who has to exercise said dog, and train it?
Time spent training is crucial, of the dog is to be welcomed in other people's houses.
No one wants a chaotic , noisy dog in their house.

Sister in law bought a Working breed {Insane} as her children pestered her so much.
The Working breed is manic, chaotic, pulls like a train, and is absolutely unsuited to where they live, and their lifestyle.

Not the dog's fault, but the humans, who don't bother to train the dog.

Their garden has been ruined.

All these things need bearing in mind.

As the woman, I almost guarantee it will be you doing the walking, the poop pickups, the feeding, the training.

Men who pester never fulfil their end of the bargain.

Get a dog that YOU want, when YOU are ready.

Good luck!

Stickytreacle · 23/10/2022 16:30

I wouldn't get a lab, chocolate labs seem particularly prone to being more difficult to train and food obsessed in my experience. I have two large chocolate labs and I spend a fortune on food and meds, hoovering is at least a daily chore and when it's wet they get covered in mud which they get everywhere! As they age they are difficult to take anywhere, mine are 12 now and as much as I love them, they will be our last labs.
Fostering for a rescue or walking for guide dogs/hearing dogs might give him a taste of what is involved, I couldn't have lived happily without my dogs, but you need time, patience and commitment as well as stamina sometimes!

girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 16:27

So to reveal my dog of choice, it’s a Whippet

But you're concerned about the amount of exercise a lab needs? Grin whippets are great at destroying anything wood

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:26

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:21

My mum {82} dislikes dogs.
But she tolerates my Whippet as Whippet is small, non smelly, quiet, well mannered, and more like a cat. {Mum's legs in pic with Whippet}

Adorable on so many levels

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 23/10/2022 16:25

Normally in relationships you look to compromise. I’m not sure why the position on mumsnet seems to be he wants a dog, you don’t want a dog- so you don’t get a dog.

Because you don't get a pet you don't want as it's not fair on the animal. It's not about the owners.

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:25

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:21

My mum {82} dislikes dogs.
But she tolerates my Whippet as Whippet is small, non smelly, quiet, well mannered, and more like a cat. {Mum's legs in pic with Whippet}

So to reveal my dog of choice, it’s a Whippet 😍

OP posts:
StrangerOnline · 23/10/2022 16:23

Completely understand both of you…
Really miss my dogs (second one died a few months ago) but you are being very responsible.

Have you considered doing something like ‘borrow my doggy’?
Or fostering dogs - various charities need help eg/ Hearing Dogs, or old people spending time in hospital… this may help fulfil his canine need without a long-term/permanent commitment

been and done it. · 23/10/2022 16:22

Maybe you could try fostering for a bit and see how that goes?

oakleaffy · 23/10/2022 16:21

Georginathatsme · 23/10/2022 16:14

Thank you, and that’s how I feel pretty much, I think it’s one thing to pretty much insist on a dog but also the breed, just feels unfair.

My mum {82} dislikes dogs.
But she tolerates my Whippet as Whippet is small, non smelly, quiet, well mannered, and more like a cat. {Mum's legs in pic with Whippet}

dog dilemma