Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
Naunet · 24/10/2022 08:26

Aliciaukuk · 23/10/2022 16:36

A lot of it is down to the fundemental change in the dating market since online apps were invented.

Back in the day the average guy could get an average girl from their peer group.

Now the average girl only wants a top 10% best looking man from Instagram or tinder.

Right, whereas men still just want the average woman do they? Not the porn stars or Instagram models they spend time wanking over. Remind me again, which sex it is that often tries to date someone much younger than themselves?

Watchthesunrise · 24/10/2022 08:23

I think males are born more competitive and thrill seeking than females. They learn that the thrills they want to seek are not-that-acceptable in modern societies (fighting, raids, dominance over women) so they seek the same adrenal rush through gaming. They learn, at the same time, that they'll never win at the competition of life. The women around them are more competent, smarter, more sussed. The house they want to buy is financially out of reach and always will be; the women they want to have sex with aren't interested and never will be. So they give up and get it all virtually.

Waferbiscuit · 24/10/2022 07:33

Such an interesting thread. Thank you OP for starting it.

My brother is like this - got a v good degree and worked in his 20s and 30s in v good jobs but very angry at the world and just completely dropped out. Quit work. Moved to a tiny flat. Spent all his time on the internet reading about conspiracies. Lived like a slob. That was 15 years ago and he is worse than ever.

What I am struck by is how much my parents enabled him by paying for him for the last 15 years - all living expenses, rent etc so there is no motivation for him to get back to work or improve his life. They have also tried to find jobs for him through friends.

But what I'm really struck by is the sexism inherent in their enabling. They seem to feel they can't let down the men in the family, they have to support him because he doesn't have a wife to help him- and of course is he did have a wife then he would have a clean flat (thx to her domestic labour!) and a reason to go out to work.

My parents would never support me in the same way - whether I wanted to take time off to care for children or if I just wanted to drop out. As a woman I am lesser that is clear.... and also as an adult woman I am/should be someone else's problem e.g I should be married to a man who would step in and take on any caring or support role if I was unwell.

I would suggest that the way parents enable these men or let them stall for years is driven by their sexist attitudes about the importance of their boy children, about how their little princes need more support/attention/hand holding/treated with kid gloves because they are boys.

WhatNoRaisins · 24/10/2022 06:51

There are more pitfalls for men in these situations that hinder them getting out of it I suspect. As a stuck woman I wasn't going to get into an incel movement for example, I'm far less likely to become porn addicted. Women as a group have different levels of violence so less likely to alienate people that way or get a criminal record.

Women are socialized differently to men, I always felt like I had to work, had to not cause my parents trouble, had to keep sensible hours, had to put money in a savings account. As I man I might have been less bothered about these things and more risk taking.

Also in my experience, might be generalising again here, women seem more able to maintain friendships over distance, which in my case meant I'd have at least some weekends catching up with old friends. Made me feel like I had some link to the real world rather than being in my own little world the whole time.

Lottsbiffandsmudge · 24/10/2022 06:47

This isn't necc applicable to OP but I think covid has had a big impact.
My DSs where in year 10 and 11 in first lock down and it also massively impacted their years 11 and 12. Just at the time they should have been breaking away from home they were unable to. It was so unnatural and infantalised them. They couldn't kick back against us as parents , get these part time jobs lots of posters are talking about.... etc etc
My eldest had always had more issues socially and he didn't retain his friendships through the lockdowns. He struggles with the on line nature of socialising and when physically meeting up disappeared overnight he completely withdrew. His social life was school and club based.
He is away at uni and has not made any friends. He is coping with cooking for himself etc but socially it's not great.
He is a real home body and I could see how he might end up this way if we are not careful. He has never gamed and actually doesn't enjoy on line life.
He however is a perfectionist and has MH issues.
It is a hard line to tread not to be over protective whilst knowing your son is hurting and lonely.
Having friends takes practice and involves the kind of effort and to some extent altering of one's natural personality that he just can't do.

TomPinch · 24/10/2022 06:43

I have no experience if this, but I imagine that ultimatums tend to get ignored as soon as they're said. Actually enforcing one might mean literally forcing someone out the door, leaving them to stand outside like a bewildered farm animal.

OneCup · 24/10/2022 05:58

I have a distant relative like this. Really clever and could have done so much with his life but he just stayed home and his mother couldn't find a way to get him to get a job. I recognise similar traits to what previous posters mentioned: poor social skills, no friends as such, into computers ( I have no idea about gaming and porn though)
She ended up buying him his own flat so he would leave hers but it's literally next door to hers and she goes there a lot to support him in there.
I have always wondered if an ultimatum would have done the trick. You have 6 months/a year to sort yourself out. After that, there'll be no roof over your head sort of thing. She could always have come up with am excuse like downsizing if she didn't want it to sound too brutal.

TomPinch · 24/10/2022 01:02

I think one important reason why this affects men more than women is that you're less likely to retreat to your room and stay there if you have friends. Women tend to have much better support networks than men, in general. I think there has been a lot of research into this.

It's a particularly dangerous situation if you're a young man in your early 20s as that's the time when it's easy, relatively speaking, to make friends. When you hire your 40s (speaking from experience here) it's way way harder.

This has always been the case, but the situation now is exacerbated because there is an outlet for lonely men who lack a few social niceties: cesspool Reddit communities and the like.

In my family it was actually my Dsis who got like this but the key factor is that she had no friends at all, like a lot of men, and much more unusually for women. She had crippling self doubt that took her years to get over. She did eventually manage but she lost out on so many of what could have been her best years.

As an aside my DW has a work colleague who is obsessed with an online game called Stardew Valley and lives with her parents. From what I know about it it's a game at the level of the average 10 year old. But this is a grown woman here with no other interests at all. The game provides her an alternative, safe life. So there's plenty of women too (although perhaps she's a bad example as she does have a job.)

TomPinch · 24/10/2022 00:51

Regarding a comment above, isn't it white working class boys who are the lowest achievers at school, rather than white boys?

MangyInseam · 23/10/2022 21:57

I think there are different things contributing to this, one being the extension of childhood dependence. Without that these scenarios would not so likely develop.

But the main element IMO is gaming addiction. Social issues and depression may send these boys in that direction, but much more I believe the addiction causes those things to get much worse.

Girls are less prone because they, on average, have always been less prone to withdraw in the teen years. They get into arguments with their parents, have issues with toxic mean girl groups, etc, but for the most part they are interacting with other people. Teen boys stereotypically retire to their rooms.

In the age of gaming that becomes a huge risk factor. They can game all night, watch videos about gaming, talk to people who live in other places about gaming, all without leaving their rooms.

Unfortunatly gaming addiction is extremely difficult to treat, and like other addictions usually requires total abstinance.

TheGander · 23/10/2022 20:31

Bigbadmama · 23/10/2022 17:50

@TheGander thats a sad story but thanks for sharing.
I am sorry that you are having to cope with this.

Thanks @Bigbadmama . I posted partly for OP re the perils of leaving the family home to such sons. It’s a sensitive topic of course but I think it’s actually better for them not to, as it’s only a matter of time in many cases before said home goes to rack and ruin. My brother would be better off in sheltered accommodation ( less lonely, some structure etc) which he is likely to end up in, but it’s all on me now to make that happen and realistically it’s going to take years.

Justasec321 · 23/10/2022 20:27

overtaxedunderling · 23/10/2022 16:32

I think many of these recluses are just terrified of the risk of trying and failing in the real world. Online, you can pull the plug or reset and try again.
We test the crap out of kids, SATS, mocks, GCSEs, A-Levels, degrees, professional exams, we tell them that they can claim a state pension at 65 .. 67 .. 68 ....maybe 70. Teachers, parents, MSM tell them that if they fall off the ideal career path they're doomed.
Many people will hit the buffers at some point - great GCSEs followed by disappointing A-levels for example, are their any options to recover?
In my day, 'night school' offered a way to correct a bad start, and junior jobs weren't advertised as expecting degrees.
We need ways to help someone into the world of work at 24, lessons that some of us learned doing milk- and paper-rounds are not being given.

Yes, yes, yes.

We need to let them make mistakes, let them fail a little, and let them rebuild.

Life is often presented as a zero sum game now with catastrophic consequences if one step does not go well.

That is simply not true as everyone here knows.

Media do not help with the constant hype and disaster narative. Getting them OUT, away from the house, desk, sm etc has enormous value. Part time jobs or volunteer positions really help them too. Confronting the world and figuring it out.

NeelyOHara1 · 23/10/2022 19:50

I think the roots are economic in that it has a "first world problem" feel and also conditions that only the Affluenza trope and the skewed economics that globalisation has resulted in would allow?

magma32 · 23/10/2022 19:35

I see this a lot in my community nowadays but it’s a cultural thing from what I’ve seen. When the immigrant generation first arrived the men had no choice as they were to first to arrive so had to earn and build things to bring the women and kids over . As they have prospered, where there is a lot of gender bias, the riches are for the boys and the girls as expected to earn their keep and/or get married as the priority is keeping the boys in money, and therefore responsibility is thrust upon the girls earlier whether it’s housework, looking after siblings, generally having to behave themselves both at home and school. Meanwhile little is expected from the boys, they becomes lads of leisure as parents want their boys to stay close and giving them responsibilities means they will start moving out and living away from home, so they keep them dependent financially but letting them do what they like. Like I said this is my experience but I do wonder if this happens in different ways across cultures when men are allowed to slob around so they get used to it.

cimena · 23/10/2022 19:32

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 19:27

Just "So perhaps we women should stop wringing our hands and get other, healthy men involved"

or just leave them to it. Don't fund them, don't enable them.

I agree. I can imagine it would be hard to kick your kid out but I think it’s the only way.

Mouscadoo · 23/10/2022 19:32

My partners younger brother is like this. In my eyes he seems so much younger than he actually is, which is 27. He is also a gamer with a very bad sleep pattern. He does work but can't seem to move onto the next stage of life.

I think it's a combination of being looked after too much at home by partners mother, mental health and the pressure on young men. He can afford the move out because he's able to pay huge amounts of money for gaming equipment upwards of 2 grand..

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 19:27

Just "So perhaps we women should stop wringing our hands and get other, healthy men involved"

or just leave them to it. Don't fund them, don't enable them.

bingotime · 23/10/2022 19:26

whatsthestory123 · 23/10/2022 18:01

lets be honest some men dont seem to have a purpose in life
males dont do as well in education
females can and do bring up kids alone so males not really needed
far to many drugs about especially cannabis use
no proper industry and not many apprenticehip's
rent etc so expensive and if you work for min wage its hard to afford

You sure it's true that men don't do as well in education?

AnneLovesGilbert · 23/10/2022 19:21

What’s going to happen to him when your mum dies? Is she going to leave him her house? Are they expecting you to step in and enable him as she does?

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 23/10/2022 18:46

I really do understand your angry feelings towards your brother. While I had so much empathy for my ex, he had little for me or his elderly mother. I had had to make my way in life for decades with no family support, and I got on with it.
And although he has ASD, he openly admitted to manipulating his mother and aunt, and playing them off against each other.
Guys like this will only pay attention to male opinions, even if women are saying exactly the same as healthygamergg and Jordan Peterson. So perhaps we women should stop wringing our hands and get other, healthy men involved.

Rinatinabina · 23/10/2022 18:39

overtaxedunderling · 23/10/2022 16:32

I think many of these recluses are just terrified of the risk of trying and failing in the real world. Online, you can pull the plug or reset and try again.
We test the crap out of kids, SATS, mocks, GCSEs, A-Levels, degrees, professional exams, we tell them that they can claim a state pension at 65 .. 67 .. 68 ....maybe 70. Teachers, parents, MSM tell them that if they fall off the ideal career path they're doomed.
Many people will hit the buffers at some point - great GCSEs followed by disappointing A-levels for example, are their any options to recover?
In my day, 'night school' offered a way to correct a bad start, and junior jobs weren't advertised as expecting degrees.
We need ways to help someone into the world of work at 24, lessons that some of us learned doing milk- and paper-rounds are not being given.

I think this is true, I read OP’s post and I thought he may be a perfectionist as well, he withdrew when he wasn’t as successful as his friends so rather than not be good enough he gave up altogether. The suicide threats are controlling, it’s a way of avoiding change. If he has been out of work for a while he will be even further behind his peers, the disdain is either genuine or because he needs to believe he’s above you given the mess he’s made of his life. Speaking in Japanese is just a “I might be living in my childhood bedroom and on the internet all day but I’m still better than you” because he’s doing worse than probably most people he actually knows. A sort of psychic defence mechanism.

whatsthestory123 · 23/10/2022 18:31

also you see it on here think it's wrong to take money of them for rent etc
many a life lesson learned from realising that you have to pay your way in life

tillytown · 23/10/2022 18:27

I know a lot of men like this, they were worshipped by their parents as kids, didn't do any chores, got everything handed to them whilst their sisters had to 'earn their keep'. They grew up thinking that because they were male they didn't have to do anything they didn't want to, so they don't do anything. They all still live at home, can't keep a partner, and most don't have jobs. They all blame their parents for it, but they are all in their 30s/40s, they could have learnt how to be an adult by now if they wanted too, they are just lazy.

RosieBQ · 23/10/2022 18:26

Would he be keen to try an apprenticeship? We take on apprentices where I work and I’ve seen the transformation from awkward 16yr old who needs his mum for everything into these confident, independent grown men. It gets them out of bed every morning, you can’t skive off like you can at college and you can earn a little while you learn your trade. I hope that all my children go down this route (though I won’t pressure). His MH issues obviously need dealing with as well but he definitely needs some motivation

medianewbie · 23/10/2022 18:07

Placemarking for later

Swipe left for the next trending thread