Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
icelolly12 · 24/10/2022 12:33

I haver a friend whose brother is one of these- he lives with his widowed mother who is lonely and has no real desire for him to leave - it's a weird co-dependancy. He is in his late twenties and has never had a girlfriend and has no friends despite living in the town he grew up in. His life is sleep, eat, online gaming in the early hours. He won't even leave the house to claim benefits and is essentially a financial leech on his mother who seems to see it as a small price to pay for her darling son to stay with her (even though he never seems to leave his bedroom and keeps strange hours so not exactly good company!).

In his case from what I can see it's largely due to sheer laziness and the fact everything is done for him. Why he doesn't have the desire to shape his own life I can't imagine. Both of his sisters are fully independent, partners and careers and live full and interesting lives. Neither are particularly close to their Mother, whereas the son is the apple of her eye- go figure.

RedToothBrush · 24/10/2022 12:15

WonderingWanda · 24/10/2022 09:24

Sorry, posted too soon.

What I mean is that unlimited screen time, allowing teenagers their phones in their rooms at night, not insisting that their 12 y o still comes for a walk on the weekend, not facilitating clubs and sport, not encouraging their sons to organise social events from a younger age. Not turning off the WiFi, confiscation, remote controls etc when rules are broken. Not making them do chores not making sure homework is done first etc These are just some examples. Teens are just huge toddlers and need just as much parenting but so many parents are burnt out by modern life and just leave them to parent themselves. I have lots of gcse age students whose parents say 'what can I do, he just games all the time', they have no stomach for being the bad guy and stopping the gaming.

I know parents in my son's class like this.

My son is year 3. The kids are still almost all 7 years old.

Its something else.

WhatNoRaisins · 24/10/2022 12:11

I agree with the parenting teens. I think some people assume that people will just develop good life habits like housework by a socially acceptable age without having to do anything. Many don't, many need to be actively taught things, made to do them with consequences, have the value of them reinforced.

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 24/10/2022 12:10

Yes I agree. My late father was one, I think, and he was born in the 1930s. He made a late bid for self-actualisation in his 40s by marrying my mother, who had a mental health diagnosis. That wasn't an enormously functional setup either.

scaredoff · 24/10/2022 12:08

I think what’s changed is 1) pre welfare state you had to work unless your family could support you, now you can get by on benefits 2) you can now withdraw into a virtual world. I find all this Metaverse stuff and talk of “augmented” human beings deeply sinister.

I don't think (1) really applies because if you look at people's accounts of relatives like this, they're almost always living in their parents' homes and being fed and very basically supported by those parents. It may be that benefits top that up but with stricter criteria now and the fact that people tend to go on for years or decades living like this, they're not going to be the main ongoing factor. They certainly won't be enough for a hikikomori to rent somewhere on their own, not least because of the difficulty of finding a landlord who will accept long term unemployed tenants.

What may be a factor is that home ownership is much more widespread now than it was up until the mid-20th century. When most people rented, they wouldn't have had a spare room in which to accommodate an economically unproductive adult son. Now they buy a family-size home and pay it off with a mortgage while the children are growing up; the rooms are then there to be used so rather than downsizing, they go on letting them be used.

TheGander · 24/10/2022 11:36

I guess what I am trying to say is there probably always have been socially
withdrawn, low functioning men but the possibility of living without work, and the advent of the internet has made it more widespread and more acute now.

TheGander · 24/10/2022 11:30

Interesting re gaming. My brother (53) was not and isn’t into gaming. Books have always been his thing. If you look at family trees, you will often find in the past ( pre and post WW2) men who didn’t marry, maybe lived with a married relative and held down a simple job. Maybe some of them would be Hikkikimori today. I think what’s changed is 1) pre welfare state you had to work unless your family could support you, now you can get by on benefits 2) you can now withdraw into a virtual world. I find all this Metaverse stuff and talk of “augmented” human beings deeply sinister.

LeningradSymphony · 24/10/2022 10:28

I suspect he won't take medication because then there'd be the expectation he will see some improvement and start getting better. He doesn't want to because his life is set up exactly how he wants it right now.

And of course, it will continue for as long as your parents enable him. He's figured out threats of suicide are a very handy way of getting everyone to back off and leave him be/go along with his wishes.

Your parents could do with some proper education in mental health and suicide imo, including learning that threats of suicide are often a means of manipulation and that nobody can 'cause' someone to end their lives via reasonable actions, nor can anyone prevent someone who's determined from ending their life if they've made their mind up.

Ultimately it's not really your problem so I'd back off and let it play out however it's going to. Your mum probably enjoys on some level being useful and needed and still caring for her baby, perhaps gets something from the drama of it all, who knows. If they don't call the police when he becomes violent then they're partly responsible for the next time. It sounds quite embarrassing tbh, like he's an overgrown toddler.

scaredoff · 24/10/2022 10:14

TomPinch · 24/10/2022 06:43

I have no experience if this, but I imagine that ultimatums tend to get ignored as soon as they're said. Actually enforcing one might mean literally forcing someone out the door, leaving them to stand outside like a bewildered farm animal.

I think that touches on one of the key psychological aspects of this, which is the effect of timescale upon cause-and-effect relationships, and how easy it is to just ignore those the operate over a longer timescale and only react to the immediate ones. Psychologists call this "time discounting" - it's why we can spend all morning earnestly planning how we're going to lose weight and then eat half a chocolate cake and a tub of ice cream with lunch.

If you literally took a hikikomori youngster and locked them out of the house without a key, they probably would do something about finding somewhere safe and warm to sleep, they wouldn't just curl up on the side of the road and die. That's not really the point though. People can carry on for a surprising amoung of time living dysfunctional desperate lives from moment to moment - like some addicts for example. What they need is to learn to exert control and creativity over longer timescale issues. Not can I get lunch now, but do I have a job which means I'm going to be able to support my need to eat into the mid-future without relying on others. To do that they need self confidence and something to value, but it's also true that they probably need to be pushed.

I think what I'd tend to do, rather than suddenly one day just locking them outside, is set some things in motion to facilitate a move towards independent living. If money allows, take out a rental on a flat and pay the rent for the first three months, making it clear it's up to them after that. Support with job applications etc. in that time. Have a deadline, but with a process in place to lead up to it so it can become part of a larger picture way of seeing the world.

Myunclesmustache · 24/10/2022 10:05

@WonderingWanda What I mean is that unlimited screen time, allowing teenagers their phones in their rooms at night, not insisting that their 12 y o still comes for a walk on the weekend, not facilitating clubs and sport, not encouraging their sons to organise social events from a younger age. Not turning off the WiFi, confiscation, remote controls etc when rules are broken. Not making them do chores not making sure homework is done first etc These are just some examples. Teens are just huge toddlers and need just as much parenting but so many parents are burnt out by modern life and just leave them to parent themselves. I have lots of gcse age students whose parents say 'what can I do, he just games all the time', they have no stomach for being the bad guy and stopping the gaming.

This ^ is an excellent summation of the problem

Upsidedownagain · 24/10/2022 09:42

My dd had just left college when the pandemic started. She had poor GCSEs, had done two college courses she disliked and had no idea what she wanted to do. She had a few friends but isn't as good socially as most women are.

She was staying in bed all day, interacting online. She did get into gaming for a while but for her it was a way to make friends, as much as it was about the gaming. She became very close to an older girl and they met up frequently in real life. She supported dd to get a job - dd hated it (with good reason actually, it sounded awful) and it didn't last but it was her first taste of employment.

Due to the pandemic we didn't push her to get another job for a while. She stayed in her room mostly but we knew she was interacting socially online and 18 months ago met a boyfriend that way who she is still with - he doesn't live near us so that got her out travelling to see him.

She has since had several short term jobs and is now in one that looks like it could last a while. The job hunting experience got her over her nerves about being rejected. I no longer worry she will spend her life in her room at our house.

I have nephews though who could turn into men who do nothing. Two have jobs though have mostly had to work at home in the last couple of years and still live with mum and dad in their mid twenties, no girl or boy friends etc. One still at uni who has no friends, always been painfully shy and games a lot. He did go to meet some online friend irl recently though, so maybe there is hope......

WonderingWanda · 24/10/2022 09:24

Sorry, posted too soon.

What I mean is that unlimited screen time, allowing teenagers their phones in their rooms at night, not insisting that their 12 y o still comes for a walk on the weekend, not facilitating clubs and sport, not encouraging their sons to organise social events from a younger age. Not turning off the WiFi, confiscation, remote controls etc when rules are broken. Not making them do chores not making sure homework is done first etc These are just some examples. Teens are just huge toddlers and need just as much parenting but so many parents are burnt out by modern life and just leave them to parent themselves. I have lots of gcse age students whose parents say 'what can I do, he just games all the time', they have no stomach for being the bad guy and stopping the gaming.

WonderingWanda · 24/10/2022 09:19

Parents enable this in their teenage sons and by the time they are 20 it's too late the habits are ingrained.

NicolaSixSix · 24/10/2022 09:15

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 14:51

@RedHelenB she gave up her job because of his suicide threats.

There have been various diagnosis' over the years. The latest suggestion was that he had a type of non-psychotic schizophrenia, but I'm not sure where they are with that.

‘non-psychotic schizophrenia’ doesn’t exist. The criteria requires different psychosis symptoms to be present, and for some time.

what did the psychiatrist say? @Bunny890

Myunclesmustache · 24/10/2022 09:15

Some statistics here - delamere.com/blog/gaming-addiction-report-2022

RedToothBrush · 24/10/2022 09:02

GenjiMain · 24/10/2022 08:56

I agree re the pitfalls. I used to play a lot of online games (namely WoW, DotA, and Overwatch), and the one thing I’ve noticed is that the more serious you are about the game and the better you get, the more misogynistic the environment becomes. I’ve been in groups trying to chase rating (these are people that are online for maybe 15 hours a day) and their discord servers are rife with porn, incel ideology, and more porn. It was what turned me off high rated gaming in the first place.

Hell yes. This.

Proudcareworker3 · 24/10/2022 09:00

My nephew in early 20s is like this, doesn't have a job, living at home with mum and nobody barely sees him as he's shut in his room gaming. Family have tried to help and he did have a job for a short amount of time.

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 24/10/2022 09:00

I think a lot of these young men dislike the fact that women are now thoroughly educated.
It is as if they then say, "if I can't win, then I don't want to play the game". So they opt out of education.

GenjiMain · 24/10/2022 08:56

WhatNoRaisins · 24/10/2022 06:51

There are more pitfalls for men in these situations that hinder them getting out of it I suspect. As a stuck woman I wasn't going to get into an incel movement for example, I'm far less likely to become porn addicted. Women as a group have different levels of violence so less likely to alienate people that way or get a criminal record.

Women are socialized differently to men, I always felt like I had to work, had to not cause my parents trouble, had to keep sensible hours, had to put money in a savings account. As I man I might have been less bothered about these things and more risk taking.

Also in my experience, might be generalising again here, women seem more able to maintain friendships over distance, which in my case meant I'd have at least some weekends catching up with old friends. Made me feel like I had some link to the real world rather than being in my own little world the whole time.

I agree re the pitfalls. I used to play a lot of online games (namely WoW, DotA, and Overwatch), and the one thing I’ve noticed is that the more serious you are about the game and the better you get, the more misogynistic the environment becomes. I’ve been in groups trying to chase rating (these are people that are online for maybe 15 hours a day) and their discord servers are rife with porn, incel ideology, and more porn. It was what turned me off high rated gaming in the first place.

Cuppasoupmonster · 24/10/2022 08:53

Fairislefandango · 24/10/2022 08:41

Our education system encourages children to spend way too much time on their own, and at computers, instead of focusing on teamwork. For example it’s well known that the human brain has evolved to do its best problem-solving in teams, but we force children to study solo and they’re assessed on solo work.

I don't think that's true at all (except during lockdown, when it was unavoidable). Kids spend all day in classes full of 30 people. They interact with other students and with teachers, do group and pair work etc. I've been a teacher in a wide variety of different schools for many years. I haven't seen any forcing children to study solo!

Plus any 30 something year old men now wouldn’t have had the emphasis on IT when they were at school in the 90s/early 2000s

WhatNoRaisins · 24/10/2022 08:51

It makes sense that if you if you aren't getting much out of the real world and you are out of gaming that's where you'll spend most of your free time.

RedToothBrush · 24/10/2022 08:50

TomPinch · 24/10/2022 00:51

Regarding a comment above, isn't it white working class boys who are the lowest achievers at school, rather than white boys?

White working class boys find it harder to hide in bedrooms into adulthood because they can't afford to.

The white working class boys are more likely to cocklodge with the first woman who will have them.

Mummy's boys locked in bedrooms are much more of a privileged middle class issue.

Fairislefandango · 24/10/2022 08:48

So much of it is down to the internet, gaming and porn. So much less effort and lower-stakes to get your entertainment, social interaction, information etc from the comfort and 'safety' of your bedroom, behind a screen where you can pretend that you are whatever virtual version of yourself that you fantasise about being.

Any number of even pretty minor adverse life occurrences, disappointments, problems, MH issues etc can make that virtual life look more appealing than the real one.

Fairislefandango · 24/10/2022 08:41

Our education system encourages children to spend way too much time on their own, and at computers, instead of focusing on teamwork. For example it’s well known that the human brain has evolved to do its best problem-solving in teams, but we force children to study solo and they’re assessed on solo work.

I don't think that's true at all (except during lockdown, when it was unavoidable). Kids spend all day in classes full of 30 people. They interact with other students and with teachers, do group and pair work etc. I've been a teacher in a wide variety of different schools for many years. I haven't seen any forcing children to study solo!

Tumbleweed101 · 24/10/2022 08:33

My son has traits of this. He does work but could find something with more hours. He does a lot of gaming. He doesn’t live with me but is living with family. I think part of the problem is it’s so expensive for young people to move into a place of their own now. He doesn’t want to house share and he can’t get housing support for anything except
a house share so sees no motivation to move from family. Private rentals are far to high for those on younger rate min wage as a single person.