Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
Hmm1234 · 24/10/2022 21:10

Girl/women can be like this too. Sometimes it takes an extremely bad situation for the person to realise they want better in life

Elfrazzle · 24/10/2022 21:01

Some interesting points from pp:

Older males in past times living with relative and having simple jobs - I know many as my father was an engineer and the club's/hobbies he went to attracted these types. They tended to remain single, living with relative or in council flats. Some were hoarders. Most were socially awkward. Had the internet and gaming existed I'm sure they would have been similar to modern day failure to launch. Many would have undiagnosed asd I imagine.

Comments about the much needed transition stage in the teens gradually taking on responsibilty- totally agree. My kids are younger but I work with teens and I can see this. I can see it in younger kids too. Some have unlimited access to screens with very little parental supervision. Adult free / risk taking play with other kids is limited. We seem to baby/spoonfeed teenagers and make the goal passing exams/ getting to university rather than growing intelligent/ critical/ motivated adults and wander why they struggle in the ever harsher/ more competitive world of work.

notmyrealmoniker · 24/10/2022 20:40

He sounds to have a mental health issue. Somehow help need to be obtained, though I know its difficult.

Hottubby · 24/10/2022 20:38

I know a female like this. Worked for a short time in her early twenties, now in her 40s and totally financially enabled by her parents to have withdrawn from society. They have bought her a house, pay all bills etc. I don’t think she has been outside for more that 20 years other than doctors appointments. Seems to sleep a lot all day, no idea what else she does with her time.

VerveClique · 24/10/2022 20:38

This has happened to someone we know. Absolutely heartbreaking so placemarking also.

He wanted to get into a fairly selective and reputable occupation (think police) as various other family members had chosen that path. Tried and tried, and got in on about the third attempt. Did no other paid work as a young man however as he was 'holding out' for his 'destiny' (enabled by family). Majorly messed up though - several serious disciplinary issues later he was out.

He has spent the last 10+ years living with his mother on and off and basically terrorising her. He has picked up serious mental health issues and a serious drug habit along the way. He has worked for and lived with various other family members who have genuinely 'helped him out' and messed up every single time.

He is back living with his mother. She won't give him a timescale to move out as 'what would he do'? She should have done it years and years ago - and probably he can't function independently now anyway. Interestingly no gaming apparently involved.

BUT - and here's the but - she won't let him rent somewhere (dead money), flat share (ditto), move anywhere (how would he cope?), do any sort of menial work (he was in the Police! He wouldn't want to stack shelves or push trolleys! It'd hardly be worth his while by the time he's paid to travel to work!). He's actually very amenable to 'bumbling on' with a very low standard of living - doesn't care for new clothes, any nice things at all, hardly even personal hygiene - and has basically become (pathologically?) avoidant of life.

Complete 'failure to launch' and he is in the process of taking his mother down with him who is a nervous wreck - as he often comes in drunk / high / aggressive. I can't see him ever getting into a relationship as he has so much baggage. So sad.

EmmaH2022 · 24/10/2022 20:29

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 15:15

@kittenkerfuffle thank you so much for the YouTube recommendation. I'm watching some of the videos now and they seem to address our situation.

Sorry if I have missed the name but I can't seem to see the name for the channel on this thread?

marktayloruk · 24/10/2022 20:22

Thought there was nonstop pressure on.Japanese kids growing up. I was a bit like that at one time.

BeeAFreeBird · 24/10/2022 20:20

This is such an important issue. Is part of the answer in the wider problem description. Your mum has left her job to look after an adult son at home. Is there perhaps an issue with dependency?

Anecdotally, I noticed from my dating that men who weren’t raised as boys to be reasonably self sufficient were always the ones who had unreasonable expectations. Basically, they were looking for someone to continue mothering them - doing their washing and cooking - rather than a partner. I do wonder if young men would fare better transitioning through to adulthood if we invested more in developing their life skills during adolescence.

With his increasingly violent behaviour, social media has been devastating for the behaviour of young men.

I don’t know what to suggest other than it really matters who we surround ourselves with. If any relatable positive role models are available to him to show him a different path that might be a step forward. Perhaps there’s a local men’s group he could join? Lots of them are springing up although some are dodgy so it needs a bit of due diligence first.

Good luck with it. I’m rooting for him!

Buteverythingsfine · 24/10/2022 20:19

It is not true that young men have no value. We need cleaners, carers, shop workers and admin staff. These can be men too. Lots of men from non-British origin backgrounds work in these jobs, but a lot of people think they are too good for them. Women, young girls, tend to see these type of things as jobs they can do, even if they don't like them, and they offer social opportunities, camaraderie, some type of life. Lots of young men have the inexplicable view these jobs aren't for them or they are too good for them, and that's perpetuated by their parents who financially support them instead of encouraging them to go into some great areas of work (they may not be high paying but there are a lot of social benefits as well as satisfaction in working for money out of the home).

It must be very upsetting not to be at the top of the social tree all the time, and do less status oriented jobs, but by and large women have had to suck that up.

mathanxiety · 24/10/2022 20:19

The brother in this case probably hasn't had hundreds of interviews.

When he is not withdrawn he is violent. There is no mention of any meaningful contribution to the running of the home.

The fact that the mother has felt it necessary to give up her job to take care of him is a strong indication that yes, he has been treated like a child by her for many years, with nothing expected of him and no consequences imposed for behaviour that frankly sounds completely unacceptable.

If a young man has had hundreds of interviews but no offers, has he learned why? Has he approached interview #87 with the same preparation and the same manner as Interview #3?

DaughterofZion · 24/10/2022 20:16

Crimeismymiddlename · 24/10/2022 19:16

This is a parenting fail. Lots of faffing about worrying about mental health and young men feeling sidelined by society but these young men are choosing to be sidelined, enabled by parents who fund the unhealthy existence.
I employ a lot of young people and in the last ten years I have noticed a growing trend of capable young men who don’t want to excel, move up the ladder or even want full time positions or extra hours and don’t need them due to parents subsidising them. They lead such sad, boring safe and lonely lives and it worries me for the future.

Exactly this!
lots of excuses of MH and ND and all sorts of crap
the problem with modern society and this generation is excuses for every laziness and entitlement.

these men are just lazy plus a huge part is parenting fail.
if this child was never encouraged to be responsible and hardworking, he won’t suddenly have that skill after turning 18.

SunneRising · 24/10/2022 20:12

Please stop blaming the parents. If your kid doesn't get a job - after literally hundreds of interviews - and there are no flats or studios - and no easy transport - what can you do? Society despises young men, they have no value - families don't need men any more, the workplace doesn't need them - so what are you supposed to do?? It's really, really hard.

FahadMalik · 24/10/2022 20:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sleepysophie · 24/10/2022 20:09

I know what you mean. I think as a teenager you cam write it off as adolescence and needing more sleep but my 18 yo used to spend all day sleeping and all night watching TV, gaming or on Social Media.
This began in lockdown when he was doing his GCSEs. Luckily his work ethics before this meant he got decent grades for GCSEs without doing them. Then A levels - he just managed to scrape through with the minimum required to get into his University of choice.
I was happy to take him down to the Uni (3 hours drive from us) as I believed "this would be the making of him" but now I spend most of my waking hours afraid he's sat in his Halls, not going into lectures and drowning in mental health issues. I message him regularly but you just don't know. It's awful.

Sammy900 · 24/10/2022 20:09

I haven't rtft but reading this reminds me of teenage mental health worries a that stage of life such as eating disorders, addictions, withdrawing from society...like a more internalised depressive response,..in a way if they are locked in their bedrooms they are not developing, changing, learning new skills and continue to be heavily parented by those around them.

Agnsch79 · 24/10/2022 20:08

This is common problem with young male and female but why??There reason is usually how they were treated to this point .What you expect from young person when nothing was expected from him/her for many many years .It was acceptable for your mother to do everything for your bro and now suddenly she want him to know about life.Sorry mate the problem is within family.If doing nothing was alright few years ago why suddenly you and your family have a issue with this??Just because you can navigate trough life easier does not mean your brother will do the same.Now is the process of teaching him how to live a life ,which was missed by your mother.So she is at fault.Usually parent damage their children,do every for them when they are small and the minute they turn 18 the same parents expect everything from that child.Sorry but it is not working this way.And don’t forget that your brother will always be your brother successful or not.But how we measure succes is individual thing.Some people are happy with nothing but some are unhappy with everything.And one more very important thing ,people in mental institutions are there not because of their neighbours, bosses,teachers ,friends but because of their own family .Your bro is a human and he has a feelings.

FahadMalik · 24/10/2022 20:08

Hello "" *("Hello", I apologise in I have no other word in relation towards English. Me (a man) saying hello towards a sister/woman is a big unkind).I write as a Man (Born);

I am 24 years old. I do not watch xxx content. When I was 12 years old my mother took me to a Unisex barbers. The only people there were women and the manager was also a woman. I saw a mazagine and opened it then I saw a xxx image and put it down immediately.

After that I was roped into the content. 7 Years ago I stopped. Nothing of the xxx content is of interest in scientfical and studies wise.
And of course I have no interest all of it makes me physically sick. I do not hold female hands or friends. I do not fetize women. I call out men 24/7 for misogyny. I am a Muslim. I dislike girlfriend and boyfirnd terms and find them revolting. I do not dream about women. I do not think about women. I do not follow women on social media.

My issues are cognitive and coordinate related. Not every single man who has issues should be compaed with women.
I do notunderstand why you are talking about men and relationships. When I was 15 years old I had a degreade in memory, cognitive abilities. I wrote out words and sentences on paper and did this for 4 pages each side and questioned myself without cheat and could never remember the sentence or word and Tried this with people. My maths capabities dropped severely.

My issues were not “trigger” themed they were functional issues. Hence why I have had trouble working and left University.
There is no issue such as role models. Insufficiency. Is the core problem amongst men. If we wish to talk about pshycolgy of men.
Men believe they are the pinicale of humanity. I said to a man whilst playing basketball that I do not play with women as I view women as supiror religiously and logically.

He could not take it. He had to fight nonstop about the topic. These men say that they support women but when I say this he cannot handle it. My views and such are not your common men.

Men must have modesty.

Women are not objects. Women are not Animals.
I can answer you not matter what.

Kind Regards
Fahad Malik

Date:24/10/2022

FahadMalik · 24/10/2022 20:04

Hello "" *("Hello", I apologise in I have no other word in relation towards English. Me (a man) saying hello towards a sister/woman is a big unkind).I write as a Man (Born);

I am 24 years old. I do not watch xxx content. When I was 12 years old my mother took me to a Unisex barbers. The only people there were women and the manager was also a woman. I saw a mazagine and opened it then I saw a xxx image and put it down immediately.

After that I was roped into the content. 7 Years ago I stopped. Nothing of the xxx content is of interest in scientfical and studies wise.
And of course I have no interest all of it makes me physically sick. I do not hold female hands or friends. I do not fetize women. I call out men 24/7 for misogyny. I am a Muslim. I dislike girlfriend and boyfirnd terms and find them revolting. I do not dream about women. I do not think about women. I do not follow women on social media.
My issues are cognitive and coordinate related. Not every single man who has issues should be compaed with women.

I do notunderstand why you are talking about men and relationships. When I was 15 years old I had a degreade in memory, cognitive abilities. I wrote out words and sentences on paper and did this for 4 pages each side and questioned myself without cheat and could never remember the sentence or word and Tried this with people. My maths capabities dropped severely.

My issues were not “trigger” themed they were functional issues. Hence why I have had trouble working and left University.
There is no issue such as role models. Insufficiency. Is the core problem amongst men. If we wish to talk about pshycolgy of men.

Men believe they are the pinicale of humanity. I said to a man whilst playing basketball that I do not play with women as I view women as supiror religiously and logically. He could not take it. He had to fight nonstop about the topic. These men say that they support women but when I say this he cannot handle it. My views and such are not your common men.

If you wish for an answer for men to fix their disgusting appearance. Men must have modesty.
Women are not objects. Women are not Animals.
I can answer you not matter what.

Kind Regards
Fahad Malik

Date:24/10/2022

MidnightsFoodbowl · 24/10/2022 20:03

My son is diagnosed autistic, and I could see him ending up like this without careful management, so many of the suggestions here have been helpful!
He suffered during Covid, lost track of friends, but was always a gamer, and I could see how easily it could become 'everything'.
He already has a couple of out-of-house hobbies, one physical, one social; and I've pushed him into volunteering at a local charity shop (he's also applying for paid work, but with no success yet) - he's 16, and I agree, there don't seem to be the same opportunities for 'Saturday jobs' that there were when I was young.

thetimehascomesaidthewalrus · 24/10/2022 19:55

Placemarking here in case DS turns out like this. I really hope he won't. Thankfully he has started at uni now, but it was very concerning post-A levels seeing him give up too easily on finding holiday work, staying in bed most of the day then gaming for most of the rest of it. It is up to the parents to take a tough line of course, but this can be easier said than done.

An interesting and important thread.

FahadMalik · 24/10/2022 19:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Arou · 24/10/2022 19:52

I think that the problem may start even earlier. I suspect the prime age for kids becoming functioning, contributing members of the community is the years from about 13 to 16.

Absolutey agree with this as someone who was desperate for independence and my own life at 15 and became increasingly disaffected and ‘gem as I realised how many hoops to jump through and roadblocks there are to actually becoming independent (and being born without parents who can help). I’m doing okay now but it’s taken a time to get there and having a partner who can shore up my income.

The housing situation makes you feel so hopeless when you see how you really need two incomes or 5 additional years of education (and a couple of entry level jobs as stepping stones) to be able to earn a sustainable wage to even afford to live in a shit place alone. I don’t blame a lot of youths for feeling the way they do.

WhatNoRaisins · 24/10/2022 19:46

Trainfromredhill · 24/10/2022 19:20

@WhatNoRaisins
Agree it's a problem. We can't all get better jobs due to skill level and the simple fact that someone has to do the worst paid jobs.Not every person in this situation can turn of the games console, go outside and create a better life for themselves

i agree with this, but equally nor should they sit at home living off universal credit which I, and many others, fund. If they can’t better themselves either because they can’t be arsed or simply because they don’t have the skills or intellect then I’m afraid there is a moral obligation to contribute to society as they are able. If we all decided we wanted to sit at home (or make up MH issues to enable us to do so) then society would collapse.

I suppose that raises the whole question of why we go out to work, I've always thought most people do so because it gets them what they want, ie. finances the life they want. Is that the case for most people?

I know some have vocations or go into something because they want to make a difference but is wanting to contribute to society a common motivation? I don't know if this has been studied or what most people think.

Actually during my own stuck phase I think what motivated me to go out and work was that I knew I'd be sneered at even more as an unemployed person living with my parents.

JamSandle · 24/10/2022 19:34

Yespresh · 24/10/2022 19:31

My 28 year old son has recently been diagnosed with severe ADHD. It presents itself very differently to the traditional symptoms. Since his diagnosis his life has changed massively. He is on meds, back to work, lost 6 stone, practicing self care and even dating again.

Previous symptoms were a lack of control with spending, gambling, over eating, no self control, lack of self care. He is extremely intelligent but was unable to channel this unless it was for something he loved like gaming. Unable to concentrate on books or furthering his education.

I suspect a lot of this. A lot of the younger boys/men that fit the category of failing to launch have been neurodivergent and overwhelmed at having to function 'normally', especially when they haven't been diagnosed.

Yespresh · 24/10/2022 19:32

I also think my son has high functioning autism but refuses a diagnosis.