Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
TomPinch · 25/10/2022 18:19

Yes I don't think being a SAHM is in any way equivalent. But I'm pretty sure no one has suggested that.

marktayloruk · 25/10/2022 17:36

I'm 63 and was rather like that as a teenager- no friends . My main interests were boxing and films - I later made the possible mistake of political activism.

Octomore · 25/10/2022 16:43

I agree - it's pure misogyny to say that being a SAHM is the equivalent.

If a SAHM was gaming all day, neglecting to feed or care for her children, refusing to engage with the world, and expecting to be waited on by those around her, that might be a fair comparison. But I've never met a SAHM like that.

magma32 · 25/10/2022 16:40

How can anyone say the equivalent is a sahm? I don’t know any sahm that sit infront of the tv all day or are gaming, usually they’re doing the childcare and housework cooking etc so the man can go to work uninterrupted and not fork out nursery fees.
I haven’t come across any female equivalents as sahm.
Now I would love to see these male slobs do the equivalent labour but they can’t even bring themselves to leave their rooms nevermind raise kids or cook for someone else.
Just because a woman doesn’t want to do paid employment doesn’t mean she’s doing fuck all to contribute in other ways.
The true equivalent is a woman who is behaving the same way, stuck in her room not helping with anything around the house etc.

luxxlisbon · 25/10/2022 13:40

It happens to both sexes, how equal the split is debatable but it’s not a problem exclusively for men.
Women who don’t want to do anything with their lives often find men to support them so it’s less visible. It’s much more obvious when a man withdraws from society as they often still live with parents.

I think the mental pressures and stimulation in society has changed so much over a generation or two and imo lots of parenting and schooling, in part, doesn’t equip children with the emotional tools they need in life.

In my experience a personality trait more commonly found in boys is to completely throw in the towel when they fail, or when they are afraid of failing and this manifests in them retreating.

Weepachu · 25/10/2022 13:37

A PP mentioned the lack of Saturday jobs for teens. It’s because these jobs are are now taken by fully grown adults who are happy to live 15 to a house. Hence wages can stay low.
Same thing happened with fast food jobs in the US with people from south of the border.

So parents need to find other, constructive ways to occupy their teens instead of falling into gaming.

JamSandle · 25/10/2022 13:30

WhatNoRaisins · 25/10/2022 13:04

It's actually one of the more nuanced threads I've seen on this, often it's all just a load of slagging off.

Back to the thread, what do people think, if we didn't have as much of a "virtual" world of gaming and social media would some of these people try harder to build real social lives? Or is it the other way round and they'd still have the problem of social rejection and would just withdraw to different things?

I'm leaning towards the latter a bit but I imagine the former has exacerbated things a lot.

I think you'd still have people avoiding real life but it would manifest differently.

WhatNoRaisins · 25/10/2022 13:04

It's actually one of the more nuanced threads I've seen on this, often it's all just a load of slagging off.

Back to the thread, what do people think, if we didn't have as much of a "virtual" world of gaming and social media would some of these people try harder to build real social lives? Or is it the other way round and they'd still have the problem of social rejection and would just withdraw to different things?

I'm leaning towards the latter a bit but I imagine the former has exacerbated things a lot.

cimena · 25/10/2022 12:54

getting the sense that this thread has come to the attention of the manosphere.

A sensitive bunch

BigFatLiar · 25/10/2022 12:35

I think increasingly they're living online in a virtual world becoming detached from reality. Without their pc/phone and Internet they're lost. Why go out and make proper friends and have a real life when you can have a virtual life doing whatever you want with no effort or consequences.

EmmaH2022 · 25/10/2022 12:19

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 24/10/2022 23:50

For the previous poster who asked what the helpful YouTube channel was, it's 'healthygamergg'. Seems to be a Harvard-educated psychiatrist who started the channel because he felt he could reach young gamers better via that method than via conventional psychiatric practice.

Thank you.

amispeakingintongues · 25/10/2022 12:19

MumofaRecoveringManBaby · 24/10/2022 22:05

We have had this with one of our sons. Lockdown completely exacerbated it. He spent all of this time gaming as there was nothing else to do, his room was disgusting and he was belligerent and rude to the rest of us. He dropped out of uni as It was all virtual so he didn't see the point in us spending the money (and it meant he couldn't stay up all night gaming with his "Friends"). He had endless political and social opinions that ultimately always seemed to be excuses why he couldn't do anything else.

In the end, we pulled the rug out from under him. It sounds brutal but I decided that I had to treat the suicide threats as just that, threats, because he refused treatment and refused to see a counselor as he "didn't see the point". We were lucky that we could financially take a hit so we found him a flat, paid the deposit and the first 4 months rent. Told him if he wanted to go back to Uni, we'd keep paying the full rent. If he didn't (and he didn't), he needed to find a job or alternative and we would only help financially if he was actively trying to stand on his own two feet.

He's now what I privately think of as a work in progress. He has a full time job and, although he doesn't earn enough to fully cover the rent, as long as he keeps at it, we happily make the difference. He stands taller, he laughs more, he's clean(!), he socializes outside of the gaming world again. He comes home for dinner once a week (that's all on him, I would not be offended in the slightest if he didn't). I am so incredibly proud of him and, although he still has a way to go before he's a fully independent adult, he is 10000% closer to it now than he was a year ago.

And yes, I blame myself for him ending up there in the first place and I cannot remember how many nights I lay awake terrified that one day, he'd prove his threats weren't just manipulation but true. I love that kid with all of my heart, even when he was an absolute arsehole. I do think the gaming community has a part to play as there is this huge global community of particularly young men who feel exactly the same as my son did and they, I dunno, egg each other on is the wrong phrase. Maybe just validate each other that their lives are not their faults and the whole world is against them improving them. And then that just becomes their truth.

Well, THAT was quite a ramble!

I applaud your bravery and parenting…genuinely happy to hear a good outcome to such a common problem in society!

EmmaH2022 · 25/10/2022 12:19

bluesapphire48 · 25/10/2022 00:19

Maybe having a pet might help. A lot of people with emotional problems show improvement when they have a dog or other animal to bond with.

Just a suggestion...

Lordy, do not get a pet for someone who is violent.

User135644 · 25/10/2022 12:17

TomPinch · 25/10/2022 09:27

To be honest, I think for every neckbearded unemployed gamer, there is an unemployed or underemployed young woman sitting in front of the television, filling in her time in an equally useless but more socially acceptable way.

Women who stay at home aren't nearly as stigmatised as men who do so, meaning they aren't regarded as a problem and are therefore ignored. It's anecdotal, but most of the stay-at-home-do-nothings I'm aware of are female.

Women always have the only fans options though, even just sitting at home.

amispeakingintongues · 25/10/2022 12:12

TimeforZeroes · 23/10/2022 13:27

Gaming, social media and pornography alienating people from real relationships. It’s endemic everywhere I think but does seem to affect men more.

This

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 25/10/2022 11:13

Thinking about the phenomenon of getting 'stuck', I guess many of us have experienced that at some point when we allow action to be thwarted by fear.
When I was very young though, the desire for independence propelled me.

TomPinch · 25/10/2022 09:27

To be honest, I think for every neckbearded unemployed gamer, there is an unemployed or underemployed young woman sitting in front of the television, filling in her time in an equally useless but more socially acceptable way.

Women who stay at home aren't nearly as stigmatised as men who do so, meaning they aren't regarded as a problem and are therefore ignored. It's anecdotal, but most of the stay-at-home-do-nothings I'm aware of are female.

BerriesOnTop · 25/10/2022 09:17

ChagSameachDoreen · 23/10/2022 15:12

Hikikomori are a phenomenon exclusive and unique to Japan and its postwar society. They can't be compared to men like the OP is taking about. Completely different context.

Exactly. This is a really different social phenomena then what is happening in the West.
Its not uncommon in Japan to have kids in school that don’t talk to ANYONE not even trusted adults. I find there’s at least a couple in every grade level. You just don’t see this in the West

TomPinch · 25/10/2022 09:17

marktayloruk · 24/10/2022 20:22

Thought there was nonstop pressure on.Japanese kids growing up. I was a bit like that at one time.

I think this is a point well worth exploring. Lots of comments on this thread conclude, without evidence, that it's because boys are indulged. But the very country where this all started is one that pushes boys and men very hard indeed.

In my experience people are more likely to get like this because they get overwhelmed by pressure. This is their way of opting out.

Vicky48 · 25/10/2022 08:53

My eldest son is like this - somewhat. He is ADHD and on the autistic spectrum, so social interaction is hard for him. Thankfully though, he is not into gaming only social media, which means he will come outside, as he can access that on his phone anywhere. The problem is we can't afford to support him any more, he needs to get a job but he very reluctant as he thinks he is crap at everything ! Also his CV shows he has no experience and no degree, as he failed that, so he can't go for jobs he is perfectly capable of as he has not got the qualifications. If your social skills are lacking it seems the world of work does not want you!

askmenow · 25/10/2022 08:44

I have a brother like this, the youngest of 5. My parents were getting on a bit and basically didn't encourage him out of the house. When my sis was off school leaving age, of similar disposition, staying in her room all day, unwilling to interact with family, left school without any real ambition to work or study, my mum dragged her off to the local college to enrol her in further education.
Sis developed a life with social interaction and purpose.
But by the time bro was of school leaving age, mum was that much older and tired. Bro is 15 years younger than sis. Now both parents have passed, bro's basically a hermit, socially inept, living in a rental flat on benefits and a little side hustle to pass time. And he has a dispositon to violence when challenged. So sad.

PasstheginImgoingin · 25/10/2022 08:17

Boys are educated by everything they see around them. As are girls. Role models for boys are frequently violent and male violence against women is so prevalent. Boys are 'expected' to be aggressive as a sign of their masculinity and their frustrations are expressed aggressively. Boys are also serviced by the women in their lives, those role models are still very active. He's at home becoming violent because he knows he can. Stop looking after him for a start, yes call the police - you would if he was a stranger. He has to grow up and no one can do that for him and he really does need to know he can't throw his weight around. He's in a difficult place but so is anyone in his orbit. Expect him to participate in the work of the household, hide his toys.

Rosejasmine · 25/10/2022 07:52

Has your brother ever been assessed for autism?

WhatNoRaisins · 25/10/2022 07:21

Thinking about this overnight I remembered a comment on a different thread about how parents need to give kids a route out of behaving badly. I think as a wider society we need to try and leave people in these lifestyles routes out of it.

Obviously it's hard to deal with a lot of the behaviour or to be judgemental of it second hand. The problem is the more the person feels the judgement the more they are going to withdraw back into the lifestyle. No one wants to be around people that make them feel like an outsider even if unintentionally.

Not everyone is going to have working out of the situation as a realistic prospect. It used to be normal for people to continue to live with parents while working, these people were still regarded as respectable members of society. It's like the living with parents is becoming normal again but society can't stop judging these people.

Elfblossom · 25/10/2022 04:45

OP you sound very bitter towards your brother, unfortunately that won't help the situation at all, in fact it will only make it worse.

I notice you mention your Mum a few times - what about Dad?

Your parents must take some responsibility for the situation. At some point your brother was a teen, a child and I'm guessing that he was given a game console and then NOT given boundaries for ir...

I have a 14 year old son, his xbox is not in his room, its downstairs in a communal room and I've always put rules in place about how long he games for before taking a break and he's never been allowed to play games that are PEGI rated above his age - not Fortnite til he was over 12 and definitely no COD, GTA (ever hopefully) unlike many of his peers who have consoles in bedrooms & are up till all hours.

I get so sick of 'oh well, what can you do' parenting - YOU'RE the parent! It's literally your job to parent and that includes setting boundaries and good examples.

Secondly, I suspect that your brother is possibly neurodivergent and almost certainly has unaddressed mental health needs and the more you threaten and bully him, the more he'll be backed into a corner.

You it seems, are not suffering as your brother is and as tough as it is, if you want the situation to be different, it's you that's going to have to change first.

You're going to have to try and see the world through your brothers eyes, understand how he feels and try and work in a different way.

You catch more flies with honey than vinegar ... remember that.