Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 29/10/2022 06:07

I really agree with the need to pre-socialise. Given how there is often a genetic component to these things I bet a lot of these people have parents that don't have brilliant social skills either. Good enough to meet a partner but only just, you see it all the time on here, people who's partner is their best friend and who say they don't need anyone else.

My own parents are very introverted. During my formative teenage years I can probably count on one hand how many times I saw them socialise outside of the family. I think you really benefit from seeing behaviour modelled. There came a point in my late teens when they realised I had terrible social skills but it obviously wouldn't have taken so long if we hadn't been so unsocial as a family.

My point of all that waffle is I suspect some parents will struggle to spot things going wrong and know how to help their kids with this.

Wider communities also have problems. As I've said when I was a working age adult I did not feel accepted by other adults and even felt judged. People who are already struggling with social isolation are not going to want to keep putting themselves in situations where this happens.

DatasCat · 29/10/2022 00:29

WhatNoRaisins · 27/10/2022 15:50

See I strongly suspect than many who are ND, suffer from mental illness or a combination of the two are less likely to be successful at building social networks using the methods that get recommended. You know the joining a group/volunteering stuff that's always trotted out. When you're trying all these things in good faith and it's not working out for you people lose sympathy very quickly.

I saw it all the time with service users that had complicated MH issues, there would be a list as long as your arm of all the support groups and charities that had been tried and hadn't helped or that they'd been kicked out of. There didn't seem to be anything anyone could do apart from trying more of the same in the hope of a different result.

No idea what the answer is though.

The solution to this is actually building social networks, as in, actively making communities. We randomly sort of drop these vulnerable, excluded people into equally random groups who may be anything from cliquey to utterly disengaged with each other, then expect bonds and networks to happen by magic. It doesn’t work like that!

Firstly, lonely, disengaged, depressed people are likely to need pre-socialising, just as long-term unemployed need employability skills: medication for depression and anxiety, one-to-one mentoring, progressing to small groups that they get to know and trust, then larger groups when they’re ready.

Secondly, we need to look at ourselves as communities. Community in the Western world is utterly, absolutely shit, to the point of being non-existent. In a world where many of us barely know who our neighbours are, and where neighbourhoods turn into ghost towns by day, how is it such a surprise to find that social skills are difficult to come by? We need to think about how we, collectively, can come together to prevent such isolation. These stuck young people are symptoms of much deeper problems with Western suburban living.

goldfinchonthelawn · 28/10/2022 22:45

WhatNoRaisins · 27/10/2022 15:50

See I strongly suspect than many who are ND, suffer from mental illness or a combination of the two are less likely to be successful at building social networks using the methods that get recommended. You know the joining a group/volunteering stuff that's always trotted out. When you're trying all these things in good faith and it's not working out for you people lose sympathy very quickly.

I saw it all the time with service users that had complicated MH issues, there would be a list as long as your arm of all the support groups and charities that had been tried and hadn't helped or that they'd been kicked out of. There didn't seem to be anything anyone could do apart from trying more of the same in the hope of a different result.

No idea what the answer is though.

But where this is the case, you really HAVE to step up as a parent. DS has ASD, ADHD and physical disability. He was the kid at school no one ever wanted around. It broke me to witness but I kept at it, inviting people over to play who never returned the offer (but always accepted because i made bloody sure they had a good time), making him stick with a few clubs and socities for things I knew he liked and making him at least try a few others.

Now he is at uni, has loads of friends and a girlfriend. If he comes home and hangs around I will start all over again, getting him out into the world, volunteering , playing music, going to the gym etc. ND men may need heaps more support that NT men before they can launch successfully into society,. but it can be done. I know quite a few autistic men with jobs, wives, children, good lives. It just takes longer to prep them for the world.

Swimminginthelake · 28/10/2022 22:04

It sounds like he has your parents over a barrel.. any pressure from them to change or get a job and he threatens suicide. It's emotional blackmail/ abuse. The fact he refuses to take medication is very telling...he has zero interest in getting 'better', he'd rather punish your mum instead.

PeachyPeachTrees · 28/10/2022 20:43

Same has happened to my friend's brother. Still lives at his parent's house, they are in late 70s now and still do all his meals, washing etc. The brother is 52, gaming, gambling or sleeping, never goes out, never had a career. Just a couple of jobs after finishing university. He was treated as the golden child his whole childhood, had excellent private education and everything he desired and inheritance money from grandparents. His brother is 50 and was jealous of him growing up but has been very successful in life, great career, owns house (helped by spending inheritance wisely), married with kids etc. After reading a comment on here I am wondering if being held up as the golden child and shown off to be the one who will be amazing, felt a huge pressure and just clicked out of life. Where as my friend needed to prove himself and went on to be successful.

WhatNoRaisins · 28/10/2022 18:34

goldfinchonthelawn · 28/10/2022 17:34

I'm so sorry to hear that but I genuinely don't understand what you mean. It's awful for young people whose first jobs are WFH - that make sit hard, but the rest of life is improving and opening up.

Can you not join some clubs, societies and sports teams which meet regularly just as they would on campus, and meet people that way? Allow more time for friendships to develop, but they will if you keep turning up.

Or go on under 30s adventure holidays and all hang out together and maybe contact people afterwards?

Are you still in touch with uni friends?

Things have obviously moved on now and I have a more conventional life with a house, husband, kids, friends etc. but what I remember is that nothing worked for me.

I couldn't replicate what worked at uni, the groups I tried had people from all over the county and were too spread out for me (I was bloody useless learning to drive). People turned up too sporadically or else it was a monthly thing anyway and I think to build rapport with people you need to hang out fairly frequently. Volunteering was mostly working on your own. I figured I was already spending loads of time on my own so this was the last thing I needed.

Having a base with large numbers of people your age centered around it is different to real life with a wide mix of ages, people spread out all over the place and with jobs and kids taking up time. Sometimes you can't find your people.

I've considered that I could be ND and suspect as I said before that there are subset of us who are at best less receptive to the traditional "put yourself out there" strategy that gets talked about. At worst I think for some this advice doesn't work at all.

Lemonlady22 · 28/10/2022 18:33

I’ve just watched a documentary where a young man killed his mother because she told him to get out of the house and get a job, he stabbed her in the back because ‘ how dare she expect me to get a job when I’m only playing on the computer all day, I can’t even be bothered to shower or brush my teeth, all my needs are catered for by the bank of mum and dad anyway’ crap attitude!

goldfinchonthelawn · 28/10/2022 17:34

WhatNoRaisins · 28/10/2022 06:45

I think life at school, life at university and life in the "real world" can be such different experiences that it can muddy the waters.

At university I was fine, arrived not knowing anyone but was able to make knew friends and have positive experiences. It simply didn't occur to either myself or my parents that I'd be unable to do the same thing in the real world despite trying and really wanting to. Without the structure of living on a campus and being in education I didn't have the skills.

I'm so sorry to hear that but I genuinely don't understand what you mean. It's awful for young people whose first jobs are WFH - that make sit hard, but the rest of life is improving and opening up.

Can you not join some clubs, societies and sports teams which meet regularly just as they would on campus, and meet people that way? Allow more time for friendships to develop, but they will if you keep turning up.

Or go on under 30s adventure holidays and all hang out together and maybe contact people afterwards?

Are you still in touch with uni friends?

Mindthegap725 · 28/10/2022 07:09

Yes, although adolescence can be challenging, I think the period in your early twenties between leaving full time education and establishing yourself in your first job can be very pressurised.

Up to that point, everything is theoretical in a way and you are perhaps still being financed by your parents. And you are suddenly faced in your twenties with the reality of confronting who you are and what you want to be. You need to find your first independent accommodation that you are responsible for, financially and practically, landing your first job is a big pressure, the onus is on you to establish yourself as an independent adult and extended family and friends are asking "so what's X doing now?". I think people underestimate how anxiety provoking that transition can be.

WhatNoRaisins · 28/10/2022 06:45

I think life at school, life at university and life in the "real world" can be such different experiences that it can muddy the waters.

At university I was fine, arrived not knowing anyone but was able to make knew friends and have positive experiences. It simply didn't occur to either myself or my parents that I'd be unable to do the same thing in the real world despite trying and really wanting to. Without the structure of living on a campus and being in education I didn't have the skills.

Nettie1964 · 27/10/2022 20:14

Why do parents wait until their children are 18 and then can't get them help. Were their sons completely normal and just switched? No they ignored shit behaviour from there children but find it challenging now their little prince's and princesses are adults.

DaughterofBrum · 27/10/2022 17:01

Babysitter12. Society has been feminised,eh? Sod off back to the incel boards mate

Changechangychange · 27/10/2022 16:51

TheGander · 26/10/2022 21:19

I wonder whether anyone who has had a sibling check out of active life will come on here and say “ my parents kicked him out and it was the making of him”. I suspect not, I think it’s very easy to say “ oh the parents are enabling”. It’s more complex than that, a lot of these ( mostly) men are non non neurotypical, many have a history of bullying at school and crippling social anxiety. Parents don’t toss them out mostly out of fear. Over the years, it’s true a kind of pathological caring sets in but I don’t believe that is the root of the problem, and in most cases suddenly turning it off alas won’t be enough to turn the situation around.

I think the problem starts way before you get to the “kick them out or coddle them” phase.

If somebody has been brought up being explicitly told they can’t do anything by themselves and they need their parents to do everything for them, they probably won’t have the confidence to find a job and live successfully by themselves. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Of course there will be some people whose autism or severe mental illness prevents them from ever living independently, but the majority of the people like this who I knew do not fall into that category. They often went to university and coped just fine, then moved back home and never left.

WhatNoRaisins · 27/10/2022 15:50

See I strongly suspect than many who are ND, suffer from mental illness or a combination of the two are less likely to be successful at building social networks using the methods that get recommended. You know the joining a group/volunteering stuff that's always trotted out. When you're trying all these things in good faith and it's not working out for you people lose sympathy very quickly.

I saw it all the time with service users that had complicated MH issues, there would be a list as long as your arm of all the support groups and charities that had been tried and hadn't helped or that they'd been kicked out of. There didn't seem to be anything anyone could do apart from trying more of the same in the hope of a different result.

No idea what the answer is though.

TheGander · 27/10/2022 08:36

@cinema I don’t think anyone is saying it’s ok for non neurotypical people to be socially excluded, but sadly it’s probably a risk factor. I certainly hope that with more awareness of neurodiversity and better early years support society will be more tolerant of those who can struggle with everyday interactions.

TomPinch · 27/10/2022 05:58

There's a BBC Radio 4 programme on the original hikikomori here:

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/b00b7lrg

It's from 2008 but Laurie Taylor's programmes are always worth listening to, if you like quiet academia.

An interesting point is that Japanese society doesn't have the same tolerance as, say, British society to taking a bit of time out to find yourself. The effect is that more young people (in Japan) simply withdraw and families often keep them hidden out of shame. There is no safety valve.

It would be interesting to know if this has become more of an issue in Western countries since this programme was made and whether pressure on young people has increased.

I don't recall the programme giving any indication on whether this was a male- only problem.

marktayloruk · 26/10/2022 23:30

Perhaps the boy is agoraphobic.

cimena · 26/10/2022 23:27

thing is though are we really willing to say that anyone who isn’t 100% neurotypical should be fully cared for by others?

Im the classic woman on the spectrum and maybe because of that i live a pretty normal life. I know for others it’s much more difficult but ‘oh maybe they’re not neurotypical so it’s fine actually’ seems like we’d be ruling a huge number of people effectively out of society and I’m really not sure that’s the best solution.

TheGander · 26/10/2022 21:19

I wonder whether anyone who has had a sibling check out of active life will come on here and say “ my parents kicked him out and it was the making of him”. I suspect not, I think it’s very easy to say “ oh the parents are enabling”. It’s more complex than that, a lot of these ( mostly) men are non non neurotypical, many have a history of bullying at school and crippling social anxiety. Parents don’t toss them out mostly out of fear. Over the years, it’s true a kind of pathological caring sets in but I don’t believe that is the root of the problem, and in most cases suddenly turning it off alas won’t be enough to turn the situation around.

AnorLondo · 26/10/2022 19:40

Nettie1964 · 26/10/2022 19:25

Watch dr phil it's a family problem you can help but not enable. Infantalising yr grown up children is abuse. Parents help and enable to make themselves feel better not because it help the child.

"Watch Dr. Phil" is never good advice.

Nettie1964 · 26/10/2022 19:25

Watch dr phil it's a family problem you can help but not enable. Infantalising yr grown up children is abuse. Parents help and enable to make themselves feel better not because it help the child.

sonnyday1 · 26/10/2022 19:22

This happened to a friend's son, he is smart and funny but suffered with bullying as a teenager and then decided he didn't want to go to university but wasn't forced to get a job instead and it's been downhill since, I don't believe he will ever have an independent life now, it's sad and I'm secretly frustrated with my friend as she has enabled this situation.

Nettie1964 · 26/10/2022 19:21

Sorry but yr parents are enabling him. I am sure these problems didn't start suddenly when he reached 18. He is an adult, your parents are rewarding bad behaviour. Kick him out.

magma32 · 26/10/2022 18:52

Get him involved in everyday chores so he’s in a routine, also mowing the lawn, taking bins out where he might see other people, but still within comfort of home. Then next step answering phone or making phone calls. Small steps so he has some skills he can transfer.

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/10/2022 18:23

smoothieooo · 26/10/2022 15:43

This is literally describing my son. He dropped out of school just before A levels, due to overwhelming pressure, had a weed-induced psychotic episode for which he was sectioned and has not really left the house since, other than in a 'bubble' i.e. if his dad collects him in the car. So that's 4 years of a very insular and lonely life. He's completely financially dependent on me (although I don't give him money) and is moving further and further away towards any kind of independence and I'm at a complete loss as to what to do.

He won't engage with any kind of healthcare professionals, will hide in his room for the duration if I have friends over and will never answer the door. Other than that he's a lovely, clever and funny young man and it's such a bloody waste!

Can't you work with him on a plan to get his life back? Start with easy stuff, like just going for walks around the nbeighbourhood with you, making eye contact with neighborus etc amnd then build from that to volunteering, applying for a job locally, going back to college to complete his A levels etc, starting some sort of fitness programme or goal. It won;t get any easier for any of you if you don;t make it clear that nothing will change unless he (and you too probably) are prepared to do things that make you feel a bit uncomfortable or nervous, in order to create a better life for him.