Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 13:57

@Nina9870 I'm so pleased for you and your family that it worked out. We've been down this route and I worry that he is too far gone. He becomes angry at any suggestions as they are l 'below' him and show what little we think of him...

OP posts:
Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 13:55

Lots of interesting questions.

We had as similar upbringings as most siblings had. He wasn't babied, and our parents did expect a degree of independence and pitching in (although after this I expect much more of my DC). He had a nice childhood, an expensive education and has a degree from a very good university. He did struggle at his first job. The first sign he wasn't doing well as well as his school friends he literally gave up.

I suggested Jordan Peterson to him and massively got into it myself - trying to model how positive changes can happen. But he will barely speak to me.

Posters who suggest kicking him out - it isn't that simple. We've tried council accomodation and he just disappears and comes back home. We are all terrified as he has threatened suicide in the past. It's not worth the stress. That's why Mum gave up her career as she is so worried about him taking his own life.

Definitely not drugs. He has seen a psychiatrist but refuses to take any medication.

Some part of me feels like there is a misogynistic streak to this. I can feel like he is purposefully ruining his life as a way to punish my Mum for working, or for girls not going out with him. Despite doing nothing he does act like we are all below him. There have been periods when he has only spoken to us in Japanese knowing none of us understand... Sometimes the looks he gives me are of disgust (I'm a very normal looking women in my 30s...)

OP posts:
Elieza · 23/10/2022 13:54

Unless your mum can man/woman up enough to make changes he won’t change.

TimeforZeroes · 23/10/2022 13:51

I think the gulf between women as portrayed in porn (basically coerced automats) and real human beings comes as a shock to boys who’ve grown up literally physiologically conditioning themselves to respond to choking/ violence etc.

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 23/10/2022 13:49

What would happen if you turned the internet off?

Or limited it ( you can do this per device, put it on a timer)

Who is paying for this as benefits for a regular person usually mean going out to sign on at the job centre and be actively seeking work?

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/10/2022 13:48

I think kids are more anxious because parenting has become over involved. The university/a-level threads on here baffle me. My parents probably couldn’t have told you which a-levels I was even doing. A lot of parents seem to be unable to accept the fact their kid isn’t bright or just average, and try to push them towards a ‘good university’ anyway, ‘because we’re middle class and that’s what happens’. And the huge angst when their kid gets only fair grades and then misses this ‘big offer’ they’ve been offered based on the parents persuading the teachers to predict them grades they were never going to get.

Parents also seem unable to let their kids grow up. The number of hysterical threads from an upset parent who has going out their son/daughter is having sex at 16-17 is laughable. As are the threads where the 18 year old came home drunk ‘so we had a chat about alcoholism and choking on your own vomit’.

Nina9870 · 23/10/2022 13:45

This was my brother. We’ve had the exact same upbringing/ parents. I went to uni, got a good job, got married and have two children (I realise not everyone wants to do these things, but I’m just illustrating a point)
my brother has no qualifications and was in my parents extension gaming all day, the room was disgusting.
I couldn’t understand why my parents were essentially allowing this to happen- he was wasting his life. Everyone was treading on eggshells with him and he became really socially awkward. On the rare occasions he would join us for family events it was painful to watch him talk to cousins/ aunts/ uncles. It really was a horrendous time, and it went on for a good ten years.
Anyway, I saw a few jobs that he might like and spoke to him. He expressed interest and I applied for one for him. He got the job and I can’t begin to describe the change in him. He has confidence, hardly games, has a girlfriend.
It was bloody heartbreaking and frustrating seeing him waste his life away. However, I do agree this seems to be a problem solely young men have. I can’t get my head around it. I love my parents dearly but can’t help think they enabled his behaviour. He was never pushed to find a job or move out- he was essentially a child.

TwentysixV · 23/10/2022 13:44

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/10/2022 13:29

I’m sure if their enablers stopped providing food and cut the internet connection off they would find a way out of their rooms.

Men (and people in general) have hugely extended youths now - 20s are basically seen as an extension of your teens, for ‘having fun’ and doing what you want. Some people will use those years usefully and build a career and life. Others will just sit about playing computer games, not doing much and living at home.

The problem is that responsibility is a good driver, if you have to work to pay for your food and roof over your head, then you have no choice and you just do it. If parents are offering these things for free there’s no incentive. And too much is excused through ‘mental health’.

I would just kick him out.

It’s definitely not as simple as “just kick them out”. That would almost definitely lead to suicide in a lot of cases unfortunately

BorisIsaSpider · 23/10/2022 13:43

National Service, doesnt have to be military. Get the young unemployable out in the community doing stuff.

Octomore · 23/10/2022 13:43

Octomore · 23/10/2022 13:41

It would be useful to understand why your mum had to give up her job. What care does he need? Is it a physical disability? Or serious mental health issues?

If it's neither of these (and by serious mental health issues I mean suicidal, or unsafe to be left alone), then your mum is actively choosing to enable him.

ShhDoNotTell · 23/10/2022 13:42

Often it’s because they have zero meaning or possibility of meaning to their life. I genuinely think Jordan Peterson is one of the very few people trying to tackle this.

Octomore · 23/10/2022 13:41

It would be useful to understand why your mum had to give up her job. What care does he need? Is it a physical disability? Or serious mental health issues?

Upsidedownagain · 23/10/2022 13:40

The ones I know of are all somewhere on the ASD spectrum, which is not to say that is the only cause. I do think that many young people are extremely anxious these days, whether that's just because society recognises it more or it's an effect of modern life, internet access, social media or whatever.

I think parenting comes into it in the sense that once it has taken hold, it's very hard to overcome the comfort of just opting out, and facing the world becomes entirely overwhelming. I doubt it relates to earlier parenting but maybe to parents who cosset their teen / young adult and hope it will get better eventually.

My DC have gone through periods of anxiety and depression - I always encourage them to get out and do things, however small, and support them to overcome self doubts, and it has definitely paid off. (They are girls though, not boys).

I think the fact your mother has given up her job is actually a very bad sign. She is over invested in her son and his life to the detriment of her own, and that does say 'enabler' to me. I could understand if he was suicidal, but you don't mention that.

mondaytosunday · 23/10/2022 13:39

The only person I've heard of like this had bad mental health issues. It was awful, his mum took care of him and his two sisters tried their best to get him therapy and once to get doctors to see him when he had an injury that got very badly infected. Such a worry for the parents.

mansviewpoint · 23/10/2022 13:38

He is hiding from his insecurities and fears. ''Men' see it as a weakness and what they really need is a kick up the arse.
It's all bottled up inside him, and the only emotion which comes out is anger. He won't seek help, because he's not even aware of the problem. He just wants to hide away.

Oddly, I'd say the best way to help, is for him to be forced to take any old job, if he refuses, he gets kicked out of the house. He doesn't mean to be angry, he doesn't mean to mis-understand, it's just that he doesn't know which way to turn.
If he is autistic (properly, not just 'on the spectrum') then that's different, but I'd suggest he's got a cushy life, and so why change it...

Having a job really does help with both Mental Health and getting you back into society. A Part time job shelf stacking in your local asda / B&Q etc... would probably do wonders for him, (in the long term). Your mum should try to push him a bit into just doing 10 hrs a week or whatever the minimum is.

Elfrazzle · 23/10/2022 13:34

My brothers( now 40yo) friendship group was like this back in the 1990s. They seemed to have no ambition or motivation about them. They were content in picking up dole money for weed and staying in their room gaming.

They eventually got fairly entry level jobs and most moved out. They weren't in the popular group, didn't have girlfriends/ weren't sporty. Their friends were in similar situation so they were reinforcing it as a norm. They were also socially awkward and still are as 40yos.

I agree with the poster who said about the passing on of skills from older men and projects like doing up cars. Cars are now more complicated with electrics. They are not the sort of cars you could tinker with like back in the 70s/ 80s.

I imagine it's quite hard to find your place in society.

Interestingly my cousin ( female 30yo) is the only female I can think of like this. Still living with parents, inconsistent employment. She is open about her mental health issues. I've never heard men in this situation openly talk about their mental health.

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/10/2022 13:33

Yettoconfirm567 · 23/10/2022 13:31

This is probably not going to be a popular view but I also think that the balance of power, if that is the right term, has swung somewhat from parents towards their DC of late. Once upon a time parents were firmly in control of the household. Nowadays we parent in a more collaborative way, which in many ways can be a very good thing, but it can end up where the DC being a bit entitled or living in a way where they take from their parents but are not expected to give back. I am not judging anyone here as I have a tendency to give my DC far more leeway than I was allowed and it's a very tricky balance to maintain.

I agree. You see it on here all the time, parents taking their 7 year old’s opinions seriously and placing far too much values on their whims and what they think. I don’t think my parents listened to a single word I said until I left home, I had very little choice in life (wasn’t allowed to choose own clothes, was never asked my opinion on anything, was just told what was going to happen). I wouldn’t endorse that necessarily but the ‘modern’ approach is worse in my view. It actually makes kids more anxious by making them feel like they hold more responsibility than they should.

cimena · 23/10/2022 13:33

JamSandle · 23/10/2022 13:14

Also and this may be an unpopular thought...there has been a modern wave of demonising young men, particularly white men. It started from a place where it made sense but seems to have just become about bashing males and boys and there needs. Perhaps this is causing many to pull back and head into echo chambers.

I have a different angle on this - I don’t think it’s ‘demonising’ but I do think the playing field has shifted and white men have a slightly higher barrier to the traditional idea of ‘success’. We’re not too far along from the era when women weren’t expected to take ‘serious’ careers or be the breadwinner - a job, sure, but not one that threatens mens traditional spheres. I’m only 40 but I remember men being ‘head of the household’ was still quite a real thing when I was young.

It’s good that things are balancing out in this way, but power is not infinite and so more power for women does mean less for men and I wonder if there’s a feeling of lostness in a generation of white men who will likely have to try a lot harder than their dads did.

Yettoconfirm567 · 23/10/2022 13:31

This is probably not going to be a popular view but I also think that the balance of power, if that is the right term, has swung somewhat from parents towards their DC of late. Once upon a time parents were firmly in control of the household. Nowadays we parent in a more collaborative way, which in many ways can be a very good thing, but it can end up where the DC being a bit entitled or living in a way where they take from their parents but are not expected to give back. I am not judging anyone here as I have a tendency to give my DC far more leeway than I was allowed and it's a very tricky balance to maintain.

Isitsixoclockalready · 23/10/2022 13:29

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

I watched a documentary on that situation in Japan where apparently it's a bit of a phenomenon.

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/10/2022 13:29

I’m sure if their enablers stopped providing food and cut the internet connection off they would find a way out of their rooms.

Men (and people in general) have hugely extended youths now - 20s are basically seen as an extension of your teens, for ‘having fun’ and doing what you want. Some people will use those years usefully and build a career and life. Others will just sit about playing computer games, not doing much and living at home.

The problem is that responsibility is a good driver, if you have to work to pay for your food and roof over your head, then you have no choice and you just do it. If parents are offering these things for free there’s no incentive. And too much is excused through ‘mental health’.

I would just kick him out.

JamSandle · 23/10/2022 13:28

There are links to porn addiction making real life sex and relationships less appealing. There are school counsellors dealing with this at a younge age. I think a huge reason men wanted to grow up is for sex and women. But those things are accessible online and thus the need to grow up diminished.

TimeforZeroes · 23/10/2022 13:27

Gaming, social media and pornography alienating people from real relationships. It’s endemic everywhere I think but does seem to affect men more.

DonnaBanana · 23/10/2022 13:26

It’s called “failure to launch”. While a minority of people are truly hermitic, it’s usually because someone hasn’t been pushed to fend for themselves.

MrsMorrisey · 23/10/2022 13:25

I'm gonna get slammed for this but I think that gaming has a huge part to play in this.
They immerse themselves in a world that is extreme and not real to the point they cannot deal with anything in real life.
Parents need to aware of this and not allow it to get to a point where their child cannot function in real life.