Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 16:56

WhatNoRaisins · 23/10/2022 16:43

As someone who went through part of my 20s in a stuck phase (wasn't violent or into drugs or porn though) what strikes me how people say these stuck people need to "get out there". How welcome do you think these stuck people are in most social circles?

During my stuck phase I didn't feel like I belonged anywhere. I remember desperately wishing for a real life way to connect with other people in the same situation. Once I was in a position to move out, relocate and rent somewhere it's like my social status changed completely. People spoke to me like an equal for the first time in my adult life.

I don't blame these people for staying in, sticking with their games and internet. I don't even know what I'd advise someone in this situation.

What changed for you?

there are absolutely places who would welcome someone - soup kitchens, food banks, churches just for a start.

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 23/10/2022 16:54

Mum has had to give up her fulfilling career to look after him.

She didn't "have to". A grown man can take care of himself. She's enabling his lifestyle.

No sympathy for these useless men or their enabler parents.

EL8888 · 23/10/2022 16:52

Elieza · 23/10/2022 14:12

He spoke to you in Japanese so none of you could understand. Wtf.

Go on here and see if you can get a translation if ‘you’re a lazy bastard whose making our lives harder because you’re pathetic. Fuck off and get a job you prick’ into Japanese and shout it at him in Japanese lol.

Your mum needs counselling as she is enabling his behaviour.

This. He is an arrogant obnoxious prick

He’s an overgrown toddler e.g. threatening suicide when internet is withdrawn. Disappearing when he gets his own accommodation AKA sulking / flouncing

Way too much enabling. He actually needs firm boundaries. Or your parents will in effect be held hostage by him forever

Mollymalone123 · 23/10/2022 16:48

I know two and both are gamers and contribute nothing g to the household.literally stay awake gaming til 4am and never looked for work apart from a Saturday job in their teens and he gave that up.mum has found him a job that is v v part time and he is always late to that.he is pandered to and was never told off as a child-whereas her daughters are independent and work full time and left home ages ago.You cannot say anything negative about her son -he’s 28!

my son is nt and disabled but he has volunteered and lives independently with our support.We could have said live r we it’s us forever but he needed to leave the nest and try first.Itherwise when we’re gone he’s have no clue how to live independently and isn’t disabled enough to have a cater or live in a group home

WhatNoRaisins · 23/10/2022 16:43

As someone who went through part of my 20s in a stuck phase (wasn't violent or into drugs or porn though) what strikes me how people say these stuck people need to "get out there". How welcome do you think these stuck people are in most social circles?

During my stuck phase I didn't feel like I belonged anywhere. I remember desperately wishing for a real life way to connect with other people in the same situation. Once I was in a position to move out, relocate and rent somewhere it's like my social status changed completely. People spoke to me like an equal for the first time in my adult life.

I don't blame these people for staying in, sticking with their games and internet. I don't even know what I'd advise someone in this situation.

JudyGemstone · 23/10/2022 16:41

OP, you mention your mothers role and how she’s had to give up work - but where is your father in this? Fathers are traditionally the role models that young men are meant to identify with and learn from. Fromma psychoanalytic perspective, the phenomenon of the ‘puer aeternus’ is linked with the absence of the male:

Unseelie · 23/10/2022 16:38

Our education system encourages children to spend way too much time on their own, and at computers, instead of focusing on teamwork. For example it’s well known that the human brain has evolved to do its best problem-solving in teams, but we force children to study solo and they’re assessed on solo work.

For their free time - more computers, of course!

Then we end up with adults who don’t know how to get out in the world and their instinct is to hide behind a computer, alone. Schools need many more teamwork opportunities, like in the army and scouts. They learn and study as a group.

And I am alone on my phone and my child is in a different room on tv and upstairs DH is working alone on a laptop.

Sigh.

Aliciaukuk · 23/10/2022 16:36

A lot of it is down to the fundemental change in the dating market since online apps were invented.

Back in the day the average guy could get an average girl from their peer group.

Now the average girl only wants a top 10% best looking man from Instagram or tinder.

overtaxedunderling · 23/10/2022 16:32

I think many of these recluses are just terrified of the risk of trying and failing in the real world. Online, you can pull the plug or reset and try again.
We test the crap out of kids, SATS, mocks, GCSEs, A-Levels, degrees, professional exams, we tell them that they can claim a state pension at 65 .. 67 .. 68 ....maybe 70. Teachers, parents, MSM tell them that if they fall off the ideal career path they're doomed.
Many people will hit the buffers at some point - great GCSEs followed by disappointing A-levels for example, are their any options to recover?
In my day, 'night school' offered a way to correct a bad start, and junior jobs weren't advertised as expecting degrees.
We need ways to help someone into the world of work at 24, lessons that some of us learned doing milk- and paper-rounds are not being given.

cimena · 23/10/2022 16:28

WeAreTheHeroes · 23/10/2022 15:00

@cimena I think that is a tiny step away from blaming women for making men's lives harder. It's like the incel movement - far easier to blame someone else than make an effort to change things yourself.

I don’t think it’s blaming women to recognise that we’ve taken huge steps forward in the past 40 years or so in terms of being able to participate in areas that used to be massively male dominated. Imagine studying the gender pay gap in the 80s!

I don’t think there’s any point in pretending that this doesn’t come at the expense of some men. Not everyone can earn above the average wage or get a job they’re fulfilled by and the competition for those jobs, if you’re a man, has basically doubled. It also complicates finding a partner - if women don’t need you to provide for them then you might have to find another way of appealing to them that’s less straightforward than putting a paycheque on the table.

For women, all of this is great and I think long term a fairer society is a better one. BUT making society fairer means some people will lose a bit of what they had, and that’s understandably a threatening feeling. I think white women voted for trump for that reason - they can see that they’re starting to have to cede some ground to people of colour and that means a loss of power for them, so they voted to protect their own interests.

Totally agree about the shuttering of workforces that sustained a community being a huge tragedy - especially for men who tend not to be as well trained in making and maintaining relationships outside the house.

Firstshoes · 23/10/2022 16:25

CatinaStorm · 23/10/2022 15:46

Could she do some voluntary work? Maybe with you alongside - at a food bank or clothing bank, or visiting a care home to read to old people.

My autistic DS met a fantastic group of friends by volunteering at a soup kitchen when he was 19.

Thanks for your reply. I'm so glad your DS made friends. We have spoken about voluntary work. She wasn't keen at first because she wants to have money like her sibling but I think we will look at it again.

RoseslnTheHospital · 23/10/2022 16:22

"White males" are not the most underperforming group in schools. This is just not true. Poverty is an important factor, poor white boys don't do as well as their peers, but other ethnic groups are also in the same position. It's not about being white and male, it's how poverty and ethnicity intersects. Eg children from the traveller community massively underachieve, girls as well as boys.

And white males are not "vilified". Children with SEN aren't "playing a card", for goodness sake. They have actual recognised barriers to learning. It's not a "play".

CatinaStorm · 23/10/2022 16:15

JamSandle · 23/10/2022 13:15

I also think boys need to be pushed to grow up in a way that girls don't. Perhaps this is how we are socialised and I know it isn't universally true, but women seem to want to grow up. Boys seem to need to be encouraged. A bit like Peter Pan. I read something yesterday about men passing skills to boys and boys learning 'man to boy' - i wonder if something in this old approach is missing?

I think both your posts are really interesting. A lot more boys are reared without father figures than before. Most teachers are female. So they don't really get such clear role models as women do.

And I do agree about demonising men. They end up feeling quite lost. I have foudn myself saying to my young adult sons: well you can play the gay card and you can play the SEN card so you don't get villified for being white males but have a minority niche that makes them acceptable. It's so unfair and unhealthy. White males are the most underperforming of all sectors at school in UK these days and have been for some time. .

ByTheGrace · 23/10/2022 16:13

I was a bit like this. I hadn't been well and didn't achieve the giddy academic heights of which I was deemed capable. I had awful anxiety, didn't feel I was capable of anything (not helped by a hyper critical dad). I was a computer nerd, but there wasn't the internet then, I read a lot.
What helped was a job centre advisor, I was on benefits, they talked me into trying a basic job in a hotel, phoned up for me and everything. I could work a couple of hours and top up with benefits. It was the launchpad I needed, soon I picked up more hours and then a different job. It's a pity job centres are no longer this type of place and benefits are no longer flexible.

I've also got a male relative in a similar position, he's ND, hasn't coped since leaving school, there just doesn't seem to be any support.

HMSSophia · 23/10/2022 16:13

Watching

RedToothBrush · 23/10/2022 16:12

Its 100% gaming and internet.

And parents too chicken shit to say no when they are teenagers.

Justasec321 · 23/10/2022 16:10

This is heartbreaking. I have seen quite a bit of it in my friend group with the boys/young adults. My nephew is sadly this way too. I know one girls. Two elements are consistent with all of them.
They had every possible problem consistently removed by their parents from a young age in order to facilliate study.
All of them had fairly unresricted gaming/easy access to internet from a young age.
They never had teens jobs or any responsibility apart from good exam results.

I read recently that Angela Langsbury moved her family lock, stock, and barrel to Ireland in order to get them away from LA and their drug use. That sacrifice saved her children from life long addiction. And even though she could afford it it was costly at the time for her carreer.

Clearly not everyone can do that but the spirit of it is interesting. There is addiction in the mix here, and without tacking the addiction the other larger issues will not get fixed.

Disconect wifi from the home would be a start no? For an alcoholic there would be an alcohol free home. The theraphy friend sounds really smart to get the baby steps in place.
Night into day is really bad, My nephew has a pallor that is deathly. He must not have a grain of Vit D in his body.
This whole thing is a rotten seris of circles with bad leading to worse.
Really stong tough love would be my course of action and many private tears.

Good luck to your mum.

CatinaStorm · 23/10/2022 16:00

fUNNYfACE36 · 23/10/2022 12:58

I literally have only ever come across one person like this in my entire life

I remember when we moved into our new house I discovered that every other family in the street (all much older than us) had some sort of male social drop out living at home with mummy and daddy, ranging in age from mid-twenties to late thirties. One was not neurotypical, another was an ex-heroin addict, a third had split up with his partner and come home, a fourth had had a breakdown. The only ones who didn't were the young family next door, and then they invited a lost young male relative to live with them as he couldn't hack life either and he;s been with them ever since. There was one in every house. That was fifteen years ago and I remember thinking - is this some weird new phenomenon that men never leave home?

Amiagrinchh · 23/10/2022 15:57

JamSandle · 23/10/2022 13:15

I also think boys need to be pushed to grow up in a way that girls don't. Perhaps this is how we are socialised and I know it isn't universally true, but women seem to want to grow up. Boys seem to need to be encouraged. A bit like Peter Pan. I read something yesterday about men passing skills to boys and boys learning 'man to boy' - i wonder if something in this old approach is missing?

Completely agree. I am in my early 30s and since I was 18 I was ready to leave home and did just that. Came home after uni whilst job hunting then as soon as a job moved straight out.

When I was single a few years ago lot of men around my age have seemed very content living at home with their parents with no signs of wanting to move out.

My DP is/was never not at all like this however he has his first child at 19 and his second at 20 so had to move out and take responsibility for his now ex and children I.e. he had that ‘push’.

ThatGirlInACountrySong · 23/10/2022 15:57

Joes a good time to wean off gaming/internet addiction

Electric costs

CatinaStorm · 23/10/2022 15:46

Firstshoes · 23/10/2022 15:43

My dd 19 is like this. She is diagnosed autistic. Doesn't leave her bedroom most of the time and games all day. She did well at school and sixth form but made no friends so has noone to go out with. She would like to go out if she had friends. We've looked for groups locally she could join but with no luck. She's been for a couple of interviews but is very quiet and didn't get the jobs. She struggles in certain environments which narrows down which jobs she can apply for. She also gets very tired so doesn't want early starts etc. Her brother is 16 and got a part time job straight away and has a good social life and doesn't game. They were both raised the same. I worry about her so much!

Could she do some voluntary work? Maybe with you alongside - at a food bank or clothing bank, or visiting a care home to read to old people.

My autistic DS met a fantastic group of friends by volunteering at a soup kitchen when he was 19.

CatinaStorm · 23/10/2022 15:44

Here's a link about internet addiction

AutumnCrow · 23/10/2022 15:44

I think what posters are saying about cannabis use and gaming being risk factors for 'Hikikomori Syndrome' (so to speak) is really interesting.

Looks like being male is also a risk factor. But why, that's the question? And how do we separate out all the cultural / environmental variables from those that relate to male puberty and adolescence, and neurodiversity? Huge job of work.

Firstshoes · 23/10/2022 15:43

My dd 19 is like this. She is diagnosed autistic. Doesn't leave her bedroom most of the time and games all day. She did well at school and sixth form but made no friends so has noone to go out with. She would like to go out if she had friends. We've looked for groups locally she could join but with no luck. She's been for a couple of interviews but is very quiet and didn't get the jobs. She struggles in certain environments which narrows down which jobs she can apply for. She also gets very tired so doesn't want early starts etc. Her brother is 16 and got a part time job straight away and has a good social life and doesn't game. They were both raised the same. I worry about her so much!

Liorae · 23/10/2022 15:42

PinkFrogss · 23/10/2022 13:13

I suppose another layer to the question, is what about the ones who’s parents aren’t able to support them? It definitely seems like there is a layer of parental enablement to the point of encouragement with many of these men. And it almost always seems to be men…

The one's whose parents can't support them get up off their arse and get a job. The reason it's mostly men who live like this is that parents rarely molly coddle the daughters as they do the sons. Stop enabling it, they will be forced to be productive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread