Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young men who get stuck doing nothing...

411 replies

Bunny890 · 23/10/2022 12:28

My younger brother is living at home with my parents and I know several other young men who also get 'stuck' at home - endlessly online, alienate friends, not able to even look for employment or engage with healthcare. I realise that there is a mental health element to this, but I can't help but feel frustrated - Mu

OP posts:
GenjiMain · 23/10/2022 18:05

I’ve watched several of my classmates from Uni fall into this pattern. One thing many of them have in common is the misogyny and the online company they keep.

We have discord/Reddit groups for our school, and in some specific ones such as the CS ones and the gaming ones, not leaving the house is often glorified and seen as something to strive towards because ‘society is full of toxic people’. There’s also the idea I’ve seen many express that the world is biased against men, and that men are often seen as disposable because ‘women can create an only fans account and become millionaires’ and that if you get a job in FAANG ‘don’t marry because she’s just in it for the money’.

Spend long enough in these communities and that level of isolation you’re talking about is the norm, not the exception.

whatsthestory123 · 23/10/2022 18:01

lets be honest some men dont seem to have a purpose in life
males dont do as well in education
females can and do bring up kids alone so males not really needed
far to many drugs about especially cannabis use
no proper industry and not many apprenticehip's
rent etc so expensive and if you work for min wage its hard to afford

ladygindiva · 23/10/2022 17:57

I think this phenomenon shows why my mum told me and my brother when we turned 18 we either completed college and went to uni, got a job and paid board or left home. She was utterly right to do so.

dubyalass · 23/10/2022 17:57

Thanks @JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves . It's all a huge shame because he's also a really lovely bloke and I really enjoy his company, he's got nice mates who are very fond of him. He's kind and thoughtful, although I wouldn't say he's generous - I have had to have words in the past to get him to pay his way. I think he would be an asset to any company because he's bright, hard working and conscientious (he's the only one of his team who wasn't furloughed at the start of Covid) but there's this mental block that he's just not willing to resolve. And with the inheritance, and a roof over his head, he doesn't have to try.

JudgeJ · 23/10/2022 17:54

Gwenhwyfar · 23/10/2022 14:13

Forced labour is not the answer.

Hardly forced labour but as long as we allow situations like those described here, sponging off parents, the state, etc what's the solution? It would get them off their arses and doing something and maybe motivate them to grow up. Having read threads on this site about how a 'child' is not an adult until 25 and they have to be babied until then is anyone surprised that they don't want to leave the womb?

EL8888 · 23/10/2022 17:52

JudgeJ · 23/10/2022 17:43

Totally agree, instead of coming up with the usual pseudo psychiatric reasons, let's just say that many of these young men are bone idle and by allowing them to fester in their room all day rather than looking for work their parents are partly to blame, get a job, contribute to the household or leave. There are jobs out there, they're not high paying jobs maybe but they're better than nothing.

All of this. None of them seem to work, study or volunteer. Then have misguided beliefs about their abilities, despite having no real work experience or qualifications but think NMW is beneath them

Professionally l have encountered someone like this. Mum is querying what lm going to do about it?!?!?! I have no control over what he does or doesn’t do. He has no motivation. She babies him massively so he probably thinks he doesn’t need to try. E.g. for an appointment 2 miles away she asked about taking annual leave so she could drive him there and / or wait with him. Im like nah, how about if he makes his own way to the appointment? For clarity this guy is late 20’s, no physical impediment. Lives on a frequent bus route, not too far from a train station or god forbid could walk

Bigbadmama · 23/10/2022 17:50

@TheGander thats a sad story but thanks for sharing.
I am sorry that you are having to cope with this.

Travelpodge · 23/10/2022 17:49

Sorry they bought him a flat in his late 30s then upgraded it to a house.

Travelpodge · 23/10/2022 17:49

My brother is the same, OP, and he's 46 now. Lived at home with my parents until they bought him a flat in his late 40s. A few years ago they then upgraded this to a house. He has never paid rent, will never pay a mortgage and never has to worry about bills as they pay him an allowance every month. He has a business for show that brings in nothing and my parents pretend to family that he is self sufficient.

I've been independent since leaving Uni and lived in a succession of horrible rented houses in my 20s that I paid for with my own modest wages. These days DH and I both work f/t and have 2 dependents and our own home.

Incidentally, my parents have more than enough money to also make me mortgage free in the same way they have my brother but have never offered to.

I am no contact with the lot of them now. My workshy brother and my hideous, enabling parents. He is their golden boy and always has been and they will continue to maintain this sham until they die, he inherits their enormous wealth and pisses it all away.

Which will serve the lot of them right.

JudgeJ · 23/10/2022 17:43

MrsMorrisey · 23/10/2022 13:25

I'm gonna get slammed for this but I think that gaming has a huge part to play in this.
They immerse themselves in a world that is extreme and not real to the point they cannot deal with anything in real life.
Parents need to aware of this and not allow it to get to a point where their child cannot function in real life.

Totally agree, instead of coming up with the usual pseudo psychiatric reasons, let's just say that many of these young men are bone idle and by allowing them to fester in their room all day rather than looking for work their parents are partly to blame, get a job, contribute to the household or leave. There are jobs out there, they're not high paying jobs maybe but they're better than nothing.

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 23/10/2022 17:42

dubyalass · 23/10/2022 17:39

This, sadly, is my brother (aged 43) although he's not a gamer, doesn't take drugs. He does have depression. A few years ago our mum died and he finally moved out to retrain. It took a while for him to find a job and when he did, it wasn't what he wanted but he needed to start earning. And then Covid hit, his MH took a nosedive, he got signed off sick and it all went to shit. He eventually quit, moved back in with my dad and has been there ever since.

He does lots around the house and garden, helps friends with DIY etc but he just won't apply for jobs. I think he is scared of rejection having been unemployed for so long, and having to explain why in interviews. However, he's also essentially just pleasing himself, doing whatever he wants with his day, and I get a bit resentful because I work full time, am 100% responsible for my rent and bills etc while he lives at home and doesn't contribute financially.

I have spoken to my dad about it many times; he's tried to get my brother to look for jobs but my brother can be very manipulative - he will become tearful when dad speaks to him about jobs, but not with me. It is complicated by dad giving us some early inheritance - I am using it to buy a house but my brother seems to be living off his. It means he has no incentive to change.

I have asked them both what happens when dad dies. Hopefully a way off but he's late 70s so we need to be realistic. I have told dad that I don't want to be joint executor with my brother because if he refuses to sell the house once dad's gone, where does that leave me? I actually want my dad to get proper legal advice on this but he's so passive. The other issue I've raised is what happens if dad becomes unwell and needs care? That will fall to my brother if he stays at home. That might be the push he needs to move out. I don't really know what to do.

Yes, the inheritance will be a factor.
My ex completely wasted his inheritance from his father, and used it to avoid working.
He could have bought himself a flat.
It's very difficult. I feel for you. X

ByTheGrace · 23/10/2022 17:42

Unfortunately, bullying is so rife in schools that teamwork is painful for those being bullied (if their bullies are in the same team group!), so they just withdraw more and soon gain start to hate working in groups.

Absolutely. One of mine has struggled, fortunately she has things outside of school. But she hates anything teamwork related now, the girls at school are vicious and allowed to get away with it. School is an awful environment for many.

dubyalass · 23/10/2022 17:42

FWIW I think my parents have created this situation. I've always been pretty independent and I can't abide being unemployed - I will take any NMW job just to have money coming in, or have done volunteering when working wasn't an option. But my brother seems unwilling to consider jobs that he thinks are beneath him.

RoachTheHorse · 23/10/2022 17:40

My brother is a big man child. He's perfectly capable of being independent but at home, and he lives with mum, it's like he's permanently 17.

He does work, and at work he's very competent and good at his job.

dubyalass · 23/10/2022 17:39

This, sadly, is my brother (aged 43) although he's not a gamer, doesn't take drugs. He does have depression. A few years ago our mum died and he finally moved out to retrain. It took a while for him to find a job and when he did, it wasn't what he wanted but he needed to start earning. And then Covid hit, his MH took a nosedive, he got signed off sick and it all went to shit. He eventually quit, moved back in with my dad and has been there ever since.

He does lots around the house and garden, helps friends with DIY etc but he just won't apply for jobs. I think he is scared of rejection having been unemployed for so long, and having to explain why in interviews. However, he's also essentially just pleasing himself, doing whatever he wants with his day, and I get a bit resentful because I work full time, am 100% responsible for my rent and bills etc while he lives at home and doesn't contribute financially.

I have spoken to my dad about it many times; he's tried to get my brother to look for jobs but my brother can be very manipulative - he will become tearful when dad speaks to him about jobs, but not with me. It is complicated by dad giving us some early inheritance - I am using it to buy a house but my brother seems to be living off his. It means he has no incentive to change.

I have asked them both what happens when dad dies. Hopefully a way off but he's late 70s so we need to be realistic. I have told dad that I don't want to be joint executor with my brother because if he refuses to sell the house once dad's gone, where does that leave me? I actually want my dad to get proper legal advice on this but he's so passive. The other issue I've raised is what happens if dad becomes unwell and needs care? That will fall to my brother if he stays at home. That might be the push he needs to move out. I don't really know what to do.

JustYouWaitTillHeLeaves · 23/10/2022 17:35

I've an ex like this. 48 and living with Mum.
I think there were several early causal factors:

  • ASD (actual diagnosis 10 years ago)
  • Dad left the family when Ex was in his teens, and Mum kept Ex as replacement husband
  • Ex went away to uni, and got a screenwriting job after, but had a breakdown (arts/media is tough), and Mum was only too happy to let him come home
  • Dad was emotionally abusive, sensing weakness in his son, and Ex didn't have a proper father figure therefore
  • Neither parent seems to have insisted that Ex learn any adult life skills
PaisleyP · 23/10/2022 17:32

My dads kind of like this it's like a stunted growth type thing I dunno how to explain it. He does go out to the gym etc and will happily go and meet his brother or whatever for drinks. But 99% of the time he's indoors on his phone, if it's not the phone it's the laptop, if it's not that it's a game. He doesn't really do much else. Drinks way to much always sat down. Doesn't do any housework. My mum does it. Erm just about does school runs if he's asked.

When he was younger he spent majority of his life in the pub or out with mates. Doesn't see any friends now though through choice.
He Was treated for depression a whilst back and we do think he's also Autistic. Doubt it's related but it's defo a possibility.

Since going back through our family tree and as people are having kids and they are getting diagnosed. We've found so many of them on dads side who would meet criteria for diagnosing too.

Weepachu · 23/10/2022 17:31

Online gaming, porn and the fact the powers that be have made it so one man can no longer support a wife and few kids on his wage.

Caroffee · 23/10/2022 17:28

Aliciaukuk · 23/10/2022 16:36

A lot of it is down to the fundemental change in the dating market since online apps were invented.

Back in the day the average guy could get an average girl from their peer group.

Now the average girl only wants a top 10% best looking man from Instagram or tinder.

This is Incel thinking.

scaredoff · 23/10/2022 17:24

I know a lad like this. In his case it's definitely his parents' fault. He avoided everything growing up and his mum's response was always to just let him do (or not do) whatever he wanted. His dad tried to change things a few times but basically got overruled by her.

Dropped out of school. No quals. Never had a job. Looks now like he never will.

Nice enough bloke, not violent or anything. But no life to speak of. None.

TheGander · 23/10/2022 17:17

My brother is like this OP, he is now 53 and I am 55, our parents are dead. He never left home except for one year to go to university, had a breakdown and came home. It’s too complex to sum up in a few lines but these are my thoughts:
Changed country at age 15
Bullied relentlessly at school back in england
possibly on the autistic spectrum
Dad was either over involved and enmeshed with my brother, or absent ( off working abroad)
Dad had a huge fear of the stigma of mental illness and did not accept psychiatric involvement, diagnosis etc so blocking therapy ( expect for prayer). To be fair, he did have involvement with psychiatrists and from what I could see most of that was useless
Mum was a gentle soul who was just starting to stick up for herself when she died suddenly at 54- brother was verbally and physically abusive towards her at times, while being childishly dependent physically and emotionally.
Brother has never had a job or a girlfriend expect for one or two flings. For sex he uses porn and prostitutes. He has a platonic lady friend who like him has mental health issues.
He inherited the home from Dad and is totally unsuited to home ownership- the place in is a frightful state, he can manage to use a cooker and a washing machine but little else. When things break he has no idea how to fix them or which trade to contact. Because of the state of the house most trades won’t set foot in there. He is now dependent on me for help and advice and intervention when things don’t work. It is quite a burden.
He was sectioned a month or so ago and they want to discharge him, I’ve told him the home isn’t safe. The heating has packed up, the place is hoarded, I could go on. I am taking 2 weeks’ unpaid leave to try and sort the place out, there is no help practical or financial from anywhere, it’s down to me.
My advice would be for your parents to think very carefully about how they make their wills. Any inheritance beyond about £20000 will cause a loss of benefits. A trust might be a possibility where money is ringfenced for him and benefits not affected. They need to start teaching him life skills now eg house maintenance, or consider not leaving a home to him, in which case I presume he would be entitled to some kind of sheltered housing. If he inherits the home ( as a PP said in the case of some farmers’ sons in Ireland) there is a real risk the home will end up in a state of terminal disrepair.

WhatNoRaisins · 23/10/2022 17:10

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 16:56

What changed for you?

there are absolutely places who would welcome someone - soup kitchens, food banks, churches just for a start.

Literally what changed was me and my partner were eventually in a position to pool resources and he was offered a job in a different part of the country. Luckily I met at partner at university as my stuck lifestyle wasn't really conducive to dating.

I'm not sure that there was a soup kitchen near me, thought they were more of a city thing. I don't think food banks were so prevalent back then and I did try church, it wasn't great, people didn't really know what to do with me, I was too old to be categorised with their teenaged children but I wasn't one of them if that makes sense.

sjxoxo · 23/10/2022 17:09

I have had this convo with my DH and Dad multiple times - my brother is a bit like this op and also my parents have several friends who also have sons exactly like this, some better some worse. It seems to me to be a modern phenomenon of young men not being able to ‘launch’ into adult life. I do think my parents are quite ‘helicopter’ parents but then it’s only one child who is like this. It’s very sad xox

Jewel7 · 23/10/2022 16:59

Look into asd. Could he be undiagnosed? I can think of a few men older than me who probably fitted into what you are describing. Looking back now I would say they had asd traits.

Badbadbunny · 23/10/2022 16:57

Unseelie · 23/10/2022 16:38

Our education system encourages children to spend way too much time on their own, and at computers, instead of focusing on teamwork. For example it’s well known that the human brain has evolved to do its best problem-solving in teams, but we force children to study solo and they’re assessed on solo work.

For their free time - more computers, of course!

Then we end up with adults who don’t know how to get out in the world and their instinct is to hide behind a computer, alone. Schools need many more teamwork opportunities, like in the army and scouts. They learn and study as a group.

And I am alone on my phone and my child is in a different room on tv and upstairs DH is working alone on a laptop.

Sigh.

Unfortunately, bullying is so rife in schools that teamwork is painful for those being bullied (if their bullies are in the same team group!), so they just withdraw more and soon gain start to hate working in groups. Likewise on the sports fields - often only "team" sports are available, so again, those prone to bullying (i.e. those not particularly good at hockey, football or whatever due to weight, strength, or co-ordination) just get bullied for it by the ones who are good at sport who feel they're being let down on the pitch! No easy answers, but forcing team activities without dealing with bullying isn't the answer!