Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that christmas is farce ?

247 replies

portocristo · 23/10/2022 11:31

Christmas seems to be a alcohol and food fest plus lots and lots of gifts and elf on the shelf etc. Just wondering if kids nowadays know or care that it's a religious occasion . I'm pretty sure that if you asked most kids about Christmas they would say its all about presents and chocolate. Am I being unreasonable in thinking this ?

OP posts:
Applesandcarrots · 24/10/2022 11:07

TheKeatingFive · 24/10/2022 10:49

Trees are Victorian, but Yule logs go way back

I believe decorated trees are German thing. They are Christian though iirc so fair enough on that one

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/10/2022 11:00

BruhWhy · 24/10/2022 10:02

We're a bunch of godless sinners and we think Christmas is the best time of the year.

Farce it up baby.

Grin
BiddyPop · 24/10/2022 10:56

But it's been very secular for years.

There are still lots of religious aspects to it for those who want to celebrate it as a Christian feast - advent preparations, carol services, Christmas Day services, the 12 Days celebrations...

There were always gifts - the 3 wise men arrived with gifts on 12th night (in the middle of march), as well as the shepherds on the night.

Candles and fire have always played a big part in it.

Even in our multidenopminational school (where the DCs learned about festivals for many faiths, but actively celebrate none - so it is a Wintersong gathering in the schoolyard on breakup day), they learned all about Christmas and the nativity story. As well as about the presents that happen in Hannukk'ah (sp?). And the importance of family to many faiths.

But there have been more non-religious aspects for many years as well. Cards go back more than 100 years, and presents go back a lot longer than that. Gathering for a big feast in the depths of winter was something that even pre-dated the Christian festival, as the solstice is just a few days before Christmas which was formerly the focus.

And there are a lot of different ways to celebrate Christmas. Some are more religious than others, but even among those who do recognise the nativity and its importance, there are different levels of celebration. For example, it is very important to Jehovah's Witnesses, but they have no presents at all. Whereas Catholics, Protestants, Methodists etc all exchange presents - but there may be a greater focus on useful items and hand/homemade items in the Protestant/Methodist communities than the Catholic communities based on their fundamental ethos.

None of the ways people celebrate are wrong. They have different priorities in their lives. They have different family or local traditions. They have different budgets to live within.

TheKeatingFive · 24/10/2022 10:49

Trees are Victorian, but Yule logs go way back

birder · 24/10/2022 10:39

To ancient people who lived by the sun and stars, the 25th of December is the first day they could tell that the darkest time had passed. DH, a Catholic who suffers with SAD, has a double celebration. I'm an Atheist, the neighbours are Muslim who celebrate the prophet Jesus, we all exchange cards and presents. Goodwill abounds.

Applesandcarrots · 24/10/2022 10:33

Bringing in greenery predates Christianity, of course. Certain plants always had a meaning and significance so people brought them in at certain times. Holy, and what's that name the one you kiss under, were always significant

Myunclesmustache · 24/10/2022 10:26

@Topgub
Decorating houses and trees (a victorian invention I believe?)

Carol singing (again victorian I think)

Really.? I know Queen Victoria had a long reign but even she doesn't predate Christianity

Myunclesmustache · 24/10/2022 10:23

@Allergictoironing These have been mentioned a number of times up thread. Yule, Saturnalia, Winter Solstice

That's interesting but I don't know anyone who celebrates any of those except a girl I knew from Shetland, where they had the Festival of Up Helly Aa. Her family celebrated Christmas as well.

Applesandcarrots · 24/10/2022 10:22

It's not even named after Christ in my language so I am allowed to celebrate it 😁

Allergictoironing · 24/10/2022 10:16

Myunclesmustache · 24/10/2022 09:59

@Topgub They celebrate the multi cultural and secular celebrations that occur at the same time as the Christian one.

Which are those?
Just curious.

These have been mentioned a number of times up thread. Yule, Saturnalia, Winter Solstice. See this History Channel link for a few more.

Topgub · 24/10/2022 10:07

@Myunclesmustache

The pagan festivals that pre date Christianity.

Decorating houses and trees (a victorian invention I believe?)

Present giving /father Christmas (linked to older traditions that predate Christianity)

Feasting

Carol singing (again victorian I think)

Its hard to separate it out completely. Lots of cultural influences are interlinked.

Most religious stories plagiarise each other. The Virgin birth myth. 3 wise men etc all exist in other religions which pre date Christianity.

Fascinating stuff

But really daft to be possessive about it.

BruhWhy · 24/10/2022 10:02

We're a bunch of godless sinners and we think Christmas is the best time of the year.

Farce it up baby.

Myunclesmustache · 24/10/2022 09:59

@Topgub They celebrate the multi cultural and secular celebrations that occur at the same time as the Christian one.

Which are those?
Just curious.

Topgub · 24/10/2022 09:57

@Marmunia1066

Yes.

And non Christians don't celebrate christmas

They celebrate the multi cultural and secular celebrations that occur at the same time as the Christian one.

Because Christians chose to align theirs with the existing festivals

If they had wanted a celebration only they could celebrate, they should have picked a different time

Marmunia1066 · 24/10/2022 09:53

Well, I'm not a Muslim so I don't celebrate Eid.

I suppose the pagans on here will claim Eid as a pagan festival too? I hope you celebrate it 😅

December 25 is the day Christians celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ.

To reiterate - Christmas isn’t a pagan holiday, but there are elements of the holiday that can be linked to paganism.

Clue is in the name - CHRISTmas.

Topgub · 24/10/2022 09:49

@UWhatNow

Except it obviously isnt just a religious festival around the birth of Christ

If Christians want to be possessive about the religious festival, thats fine. No one else celebrates that bit anyway

The other bits aren't theirs to be possessive over

BiggerBoat1 · 24/10/2022 09:36

In our house it is a lovely time. We all have time off school and work and we get to enjoy traditions we have established as a family. No, it has absolutely nothing to do with religion for us but so what? Take from this holiday what you want and what makes your family happy.

londongals · 24/10/2022 09:34

I love the time off -
The traditions
socialising with mates and family
I am not religious that means nothing at all to me

UWhatNow · 24/10/2022 09:31

Topgub · 23/10/2022 12:20

@UWhatNow

How can a festival that Christians stole and has largely become cultural with little to do with the religion, belong to Christians?

Because it just IS a religious holiday centred around the birth of Christ.

You can steal it back if you like! I’ve love two weeks off work for a fully pagan celebration but I don’t think that’s going to happen is it? You can’t undo a thousand years of cultural erosion so stop being bitter about it and chill out with a Baileys.

OperaStation · 23/10/2022 20:05

portocristo · 23/10/2022 11:37

Yes I enjoy it too just think its a bit hypocritical.

To pagans?

VestaTilley · 23/10/2022 20:03

Not in our house it’s not. We’re Christian - and it’s our second most important festival after Easter.

My three year old DS knows exactly what it’s about.

Fairislefandango · 23/10/2022 20:00

I don't think it's hypocritical at all. If you live in a country with a Christian culture, then this stuff is part of your culture whether you believe in god or not. Besides, some of the elements of how we celebrate Christmas existed in the Yule festival before it was called Christmas. It's been perfectly normal throughout human history for some bits of religious ritual and tradition to persist long after most people have stopped believing in the deity/deities. I love Christmas and I'm a staunch atheist. I expect if I went to live in a country with a different religion, I'd enjoy the traditions and festivals associated with it as well.

Caughtupinsomething · 23/10/2022 19:56

I don't think there's anything wrong with celebrating Christmas when you're not religious. We do and it's all about tradition, seeing the dc's faces light up at the magic of believing in Santa, having fun and indulging in nice food etc. Why would you care how others choose to celebrate?

DazedConfusedDone · 23/10/2022 19:55

We have been celebrating around the winter solstice long before Christianity. Traditions change over time.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/10/2022 19:52

Oh it always annoys me people saying Christmas is basically a pagan festival, as though this is some kind of argument against it.

Arguing against what?

People are pointing out that it was created to coincide with with existing pagan festivals to answer those who complain that we no longer do Christmas the "right" way, whatever they deem that to be. Could be the religious element, could be the consumerist one, whatever. The point is that even our traditional Western Christmas was a change from what was once established, indeed was designed to overtake the older traditions. So it doesn't make much sense to complain that people are doing it wrong when it's a takeover of an original anyway.