Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe that this man should not be allowed to live at Student Halls?

294 replies

Sep200024 · 23/10/2022 10:48

At Cardiff University, one of the largest Halls of Residence, housing mostly first year students, is called Talybont.

At Talybont this year, a man (Sean Hughes) who has recently been released from prison for strangling a woman, has been given a live-in safeguarding role at the Halls.

His crime was to attack and strangle a young woman, and he is currently out on license after being released from prison in May of this year.

His role at the university is to live in the Halls of Residence as a ‘life assistant’, where his role is to “support vulnerable students and manage crisis situations”.

AIBU to think that this should not be allowed? How on earth have the application and vetting procedures at Cardiff University allowed this to happen?

Newspaper article here

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IAmAReader · 27/10/2022 10:36

Ofcourseshecan · 26/10/2022 10:05

I believe that a lot of the powerful people in society and decision-makers, including those within the criminal justice system, are would- be paedophiles/rapists. They may not have carried out those acts, but they would certainly like to and sympathise greatly with perpetrators of these heinous acts.

I agree, IamaReader. Not because I think powerful people are more likely to be rapists etc, but purely because men in general seem to have a very high level of tolerance for sex offences. Presumably because of their own fantasies.

Yes I don't believe they are more likely to be sexual offenders /have peverse fantasies etc but I think they have the power to do it in a more organised way without getting caught, and doing all they can to ensure their fellow deviants who do get caught aren't punished 'excessively'.

I studied law in the noughties and I'll never forget the lecture in the criminal law module about a case where someone raped a teenager who was walking by on a hot day. The man was jailed for a very short period- around a year I think.

The sentencing judge had said, in regards to the rapist 'it could have happened to anyone' as if he was the victim or as if the act of raping someone, is something that happens to the rapist. Unbelievable.

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 26/10/2022 21:18

What the university can reply with matters not one jot.

People writing in show they are not happy with it.

XanaduKira · 26/10/2022 21:07

You'd like to think @BagpussBagpussOldFatFurryCatpuss but somehow I doubt it.

Well done for making that dad aware @nzborn - let's hope he questions them on it as I reckon prospective students / parents challenging them on it and highlighting how unacceptable it is, will be the only way to make them re-think.

BagpussBagpussOldFatFurryCatpuss · 26/10/2022 12:31

nzborn · 26/10/2022 10:25

Due to this being mentioned on Mumsnet l was able to tell a dad with his daughter who was visiting Cardiff university and staying in the same hotel as me. He was pretty shocked.

This should never have happened.
Now that it has, and the incident is being investigated I should think that their recruitment department is under intense scrutiny.

nzborn · 26/10/2022 10:25

Due to this being mentioned on Mumsnet l was able to tell a dad with his daughter who was visiting Cardiff university and staying in the same hotel as me. He was pretty shocked.

Ofcourseshecan · 26/10/2022 10:05

IAmAReader · 23/10/2022 15:58

That's awful.

I don't want to go all conspiracy theory/tin foil hat, but I believe that a lot of the powerful people in society and decision-makers, including those within the criminal justice system, are would- be paedophiles/rapists. They may not have carried out those acts, but they would certainly like to and sympathise greatly with perpetrators of these heinous acts. Their extreme compassion for sex offenders while being harsh with others suggests they have a particular slant when it comes to the former.

I believe Saville etc was the tip of the iceberg and in years to come we will hear a lot more revelations regarding high profile people and those around who turned a blind eye.

I believe that a lot of the powerful people in society and decision-makers, including those within the criminal justice system, are would- be paedophiles/rapists. They may not have carried out those acts, but they would certainly like to and sympathise greatly with perpetrators of these heinous acts.

I agree, IamaReader. Not because I think powerful people are more likely to be rapists etc, but purely because men in general seem to have a very high level of tolerance for sex offences. Presumably because of their own fantasies.

Shelefttheweb · 26/10/2022 10:00

“He disclosed his conviction so he’s been 100% honest”

Really? No one is 100% honest on job application forms or in real life. Not hiding a conviction does not make you 100% honest.

Ofcourseshecan · 26/10/2022 09:54

Discovereads · 23/10/2022 11:25

Yes. He disclosed his conviction so he’s been 100% honest and this situation isn’t really his fault imho.

He applied for the job. He wanted this situation. Whoever OKd this is an idiot. But that doesn’t make him any less guilty.

If he wanted to do good, there are hundreds of other jobs he could apply for that don’t give him access to young women who are vulnerable or in crisis.

potniatheron · 25/10/2022 10:01

I grew up in Cardiff, in an area which is now the central student area for Cardiff Uni.

On visits back to family walking round the area I can confirm that it has been taken over by aggressive pro-prostitution and TRAs. What appear to be student groups, putting up violent stickers, 'Death to all TERFs' type rhetoric, on public infrastructure such as walls, lampposts and pedestrian crossings.

Cardiff Uni seems fine with this.

So, with all that said, this does not surprise me in the slightest. It is all of a piece with the Uni and the surrounding area's collapse into misogyny and lack of safeguarding for women.

Helleofabore · 25/10/2022 08:40

EarthSight · 24/10/2022 21:48

How on earth have the application and vetting procedures at Cardiff University allowed this to happen?

a) They're idiots

b) They don't care about women

One or both of these things are true.

We can only look to Mermaids for an example of how these ‘procedures’ work.

If your organisation follows guidelines from an advisory group that is kink positive, this person’s ‘crime’ might have a different framing.

Plus we are now familiar that organisations will skip the procedure if they believe another organisation has already done it.

EarthSight · 24/10/2022 21:48

How on earth have the application and vetting procedures at Cardiff University allowed this to happen?

a) They're idiots

b) They don't care about women

One or both of these things are true.

XanaduKira · 24/10/2022 20:05

I guess that's marginally better than contacting him though @Sep200024

Sep200024 · 24/10/2022 10:42

It seems the university have now removed all details of the residence support team from their website, so now the poor students don’t have anyone to contact!

OP posts:
GCAcademic · 24/10/2022 09:56

The university can't respond to queries from third parties about specific students. We are not even allowed to confirm to a parent that their son or daughter is attending the university.

They can, however, issue a statement, but (again because of data protection) it will likely be so vague as to annoy as much as reassure students and parents.

The best thing would have been not to have got themselves into this situation in the first place. It wouldn't have been difficult to avoid giving a self-confessed strangler this job.

bare · 24/10/2022 09:43

Sep200024 · 24/10/2022 09:19

I have received a response from the university stating that they are “unable to provide information or comment further on this case”.

With this stance, current students and parents don’t even know if he is still there, never mind the details of how he was appointed and reassurance as to it not happening again.

That's interesting. I will need more than that for Cardiff to remain on the shortlist for us. Pity, as it's a really good course.

I'll drop them a line and see what response comes back. It's been one of the most popular institutions and their applications have grown a lot in the last few years - I can't believe they wouldn't try to rectify this negative publicity, especially during the application window for 2023 applicants

MonsteraDeliciosa · 24/10/2022 09:40

It wasn't them that volunteered the info in the first place, @Sep200024 , so further info may well be forthcoming from whoever the original source was... hopefully!
Let's hope the source keeps Wales Online updated with any developments.

You'd think after this exposure Cardiff uni would have to make some sort of statement to reassure students and parents.

Sep200024 · 24/10/2022 09:19

I have received a response from the university stating that they are “unable to provide information or comment further on this case”.

With this stance, current students and parents don’t even know if he is still there, never mind the details of how he was appointed and reassurance as to it not happening again.

OP posts:
MaChienEstUnDick · 24/10/2022 09:09

He's a post-grad, not a first year, and he used to be a headteacher (according to one of the other threads) so I can see how, on paper and without his conviction, he would have been selected for the role.

I attended a fantastic presentation by Fiona Druet of emilytest.co.uk a couple of years ago. Her fresher daughter died by suicide after abuse from her uni boyfriend and one of the things they are suggesting is more training for student support workers. It just makes me furiously angry that a violent abuser could be sitting in a training session nodding along to those kinds of messages.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 24/10/2022 08:40

Totally agree, @StrataZon . I have a 17 year old DD who is currently going on open days and applying to universities and this sort of thing terrifies me.

StrataZon · 24/10/2022 08:35

So as I said earlier there are two possibilities: either they never did a basic DBS check in the first place, or did do a DBS check and employed him anyway.

Both of which are equally alarming in a job which involves supporting vulnerable students.

CornishTiger · 24/10/2022 08:32

When I was doing a degree I had to do a enhanced DBS check for placements as well as suitably for the job as DBS was always going to be required. One man in his younger days had a conviction with violence and it had to go to a panel to look at. Time since offence, life since, whether he was a risk etc. At least a decade had past since the offence.

I agree that Cardiff either didn’t do the DBS or the panel that did it haven’t been robust in their decision making. Too short a period of time since the offence on this and regardless of the offender management/rehabilitation not enough time has past to indicate if ongoing risk.

Past behaviour is the best predictor of future behaviour/risk.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 24/10/2022 08:05

Just to clear up one more thing about DBS checks. There is no pass and fail.

What happens is that the DBS will issue the certificate as a statement of fact - these are the convictions/cautions which we think are relevant to the position this person is applying for. It is then up to the employer to decide whether they wish to go ahead and employ - taking into account not just the DBS check but references, interview, qualifications etc etc. It's part of the process, it's not ALL of the process.

It would be unfair for someone who was sentenced to 4 years in prison aged 18 or 19 and for whom the length of sentence is such it will never be "spent", to spend the next 35 years being a reformed character and never getting as much as a speeding ticket, to be unilaterally blocked from ever working in positions which need a DBS check.

So as I said earlier there are two possibilities: either they never did a basic DBS check in the first place, or did do a DBS check and employed him anyway.

MonsteraDeliciosa · 24/10/2022 07:19

Chrysanthemum5 · 23/10/2022 23:41

Many of us will assume this is a role like the wardens when we were at university. People you hardly saw unless you did something wrong. That's not the case - students now are given more support and these resident assistants are there running events, offering guidance, providing support etc. This is true at every university so it makes it even more important that the right people are chosen for these roles. I've worked in universities for 25 years and I've never known a 1st year get one of these roles - so appointing this man was a deliberate choice by someone

Yes indeed, @Chrysanthemum5 . It's bizarre that a first year got the job at all, never mind one that's a violent criminal.
I speculated on the site stuff thread that this guy must have had a friend who works at Cardiff uni.
That's the only explanation I can think of for this nonsensical appointment.

Chrysanthemum5 · 23/10/2022 23:41

Many of us will assume this is a role like the wardens when we were at university. People you hardly saw unless you did something wrong. That's not the case - students now are given more support and these resident assistants are there running events, offering guidance, providing support etc. This is true at every university so it makes it even more important that the right people are chosen for these roles. I've worked in universities for 25 years and I've never known a 1st year get one of these roles - so appointing this man was a deliberate choice by someone

Kanaloa · 23/10/2022 23:25

GinWithChocolate · 23/10/2022 23:23

What a lovely place Cardiff university must be for women . . .
And for vulnerable young men too.

And what role models they are providing!

I suppose they do provide real life study examples in the criminology course. You know how some creative writing courses have authors come to give talks, some science courses might have well regarded scientists come to give lectures… and at Cardiff uni they have an actual convicted strangler in your criminology seminar.

Swipe left for the next trending thread