Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a car when I only do very minimal driving

111 replies

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 09:39

I have a car on finance. High interest(bad credit rating). 2 years left on finance. Its affordable to me.

However, I barely drive. Back story. Late learner. Very anxious re:driving.

Bought car straight after passing, on a bit of a whim.
Plan was to drive lots. Plan never happened. My anxiety about driving has improved loads ,but I'm still a shit ,inexperienced driver! It's never really taken off.

I do drive daily but its just school run, shops etc. Appointments. Apart from big supermarket shop, nothing I couldn't do on foot/public transport.

Up to now, I suppose I like my little car and I like the fact that I have my independence if I need it,or do actually have to drive(rare).
DP has his own car and drives a lot and does all the big trips/holidays and days out.

I've just sat here thinking why am I wasting my money- car finance, petrol, insurance etc for literally 100 miles a month. Its mad isn't it? I'm thinking sensible thing is to get rid when finance is up.
I could get bloody taxis for less. Or is it wise to keep driving and have my own car as back up.

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 11:40

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:31

@thelobsterquadrille
I absolutely agree. If I give up the car it will be it. Full stop. No point to give up to buy another in the future, or hope DP will one day get a smaller auto.
But it will help my anxiety as no car will equal not being able to drive. So no pressure. No overthinking.

After all the work you've put in to pass your theory, do lessons and pass your test, it would be such a shame to give it all up now.

There are places you can get lessons (like as a week course or as normal) for nervous drivers - it may be worth investing so that long-term, driving doesn't cause you so much anxiety.

You may not need a car much now but you never know what the future holds and I think you'll regret giving up your independence.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/10/2022 11:40

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:36

I've not heard of that. Is it like rental?
I work for the NHS
But funny you should say that, as I often think when I get parcels like from Asos etc that must be very good practice!!!

I think they call it car sharing but is like rental. You book on an app for as little as two hours. Cars have a home parking spot you collect from /return them to. Quite handy for parking as there were reserved spots for car club cars in the town centre. There’s a fuel card inside and they are cleaned weekly by the company. I used to live a short walk away so could easily collect a car. I found it brilliant tbh much cheaper than car ownership you just need to be organised.

nannybeach · 23/10/2022 11:38

I did the High Performance course after the Advanced. Wasn't something I had thought about, but that was motorway driving. I don't enjoy driving,we live on the outskirts of a village,2 roads from a one way system. I did get a bus a few times,had to get off because of motion sickness. My car is going this week (15 years old diesel estate) I've had her 10 years,am gifting her to my oldest DS. We cannot afford to run 2 cars. I have a lot of friends my age 70ish,who never learned to drive. Oldest DD living and working in London,lot of people 20s don't bother to learn.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:31

@thelobsterquadrille
I absolutely agree. If I give up the car it will be it. Full stop. No point to give up to buy another in the future, or hope DP will one day get a smaller auto.
But it will help my anxiety as no car will equal not being able to drive. So no pressure. No overthinking.

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 11:25

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:22

I have thought about refresher lessons. Maybe then I'd start enjoying it. Hard to enjoy something you dread or worry about.
I suppose I just think that there's so much that I don't know!!!!!

I just think if you gave up your car, you'd never go back to driving and that would make your anxiety even worse if, in an emergency, you had no choice.

I was a really nervous learner and I hated driving when I first got my license, but I live rurally so had no choice but to stick with it. I wouldn't say I love driving but I feel pretty confident driving daily (it's part of my job) and my life would be very restricted if I'd give up my car.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:22

thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 11:19

When your contract runs out, why not replace it with a cheap, but safe runaround and put some of the money you save towards refresher lessons?

I have thought about refresher lessons. Maybe then I'd start enjoying it. Hard to enjoy something you dread or worry about.
I suppose I just think that there's so much that I don't know!!!!!

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 11:19

When your contract runs out, why not replace it with a cheap, but safe runaround and put some of the money you save towards refresher lessons?

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:17

@rookiemere
This is very true.
I put off driving for so long as I was so unsure, but then I guess I thought how great it would be to 'do stuff'.
Reality is I actually do fuck all.
My car has been somewhat useful in the time I've had it.
I can afford it but I'm 100% not getting out of it what I'd hoped and it's not value for money at all. If I add up useage V cost.

OP posts:
Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:12

Irritatedmum · 23/10/2022 11:00

My mum was terrified of driving and so was I. So I’d say keep driving to set an example to your children as well as all the other benefits. Please consider working on your anxiety though - treat it like any other phobia, do gradual exposure. Reward yourself for the driving you already feel comfortable doing, choose the next thing you want to be able to do and work on making yourself comfortable with that.

Thank you.
I live in a very busy area.
Unfamiliar places are very, very daunting.
It's always busy. Even my fucking Street is busy. So many aggressive drivers. Its so intimidating.

Even on my short journey, there seem to be a bloody issue every day
I sick of drivers right up behind me when I'm doing the speed limit or above!!
DP is very experienced so not fazed.
Bu me it just makes me feel even more unsure.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 23/10/2022 11:11

A large contingent of mumsnet is obsessed by women being able to drive and car ownership. It's not essential as long as you accept that you may well have to spend money on taxis sometimes which will still be cheaper than car ownership.

However that said, I'd keep the car for now unless it's causing financial hardship. It's very handy when DCs are young for ferrying around. We have two cars and hardly use them now that DH wfh all the time and I only go in ( by bus) one or two days a week. But I'm not overly fond of driving and I know if we went down to one, I'd get out of the way of it, plus my DPs are elderly and live an hour away so it's good to know we both have cars should any emergencies arise.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 11:05

@ArialAnna
Absolutely no chance of this happening.
Hes generally very supportive of my driving (only due to the odd time it helps him ferry one of Dc) but he wouldn't get rid of car and swap.

Actually before the car he has now, he did have an auto(just after I passed) and I asked to go on insurance to practice etc. He said it was too expensive and was very vague and unhelpful. He denies this now and says he was happy for me to go on insurance and all I needed to do was ring up sort it (not true).
So it put me off.
Then not long after the car packed up and he got the 7 seater manual and i got my car.

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 23/10/2022 11:02

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 09:59

Think can take dogs on trains.
Another issue with me is, I too live in a city and everything is very accessible.
Plus I'm so used to walking or getting public transport, that it feels very lazy driving a short distance!!

That's because it IS lazy driving a short distance. Much better for your health to walk. And your bank balance. And the environment. And for congestion on the roads. Sounds like you don't actually need a car at all. You just feel you should have one.

Irritatedmum · 23/10/2022 11:00

My mum was terrified of driving and so was I. So I’d say keep driving to set an example to your children as well as all the other benefits. Please consider working on your anxiety though - treat it like any other phobia, do gradual exposure. Reward yourself for the driving you already feel comfortable doing, choose the next thing you want to be able to do and work on making yourself comfortable with that.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:59

If I had to drive(and there is the odd occasion I've had to) then I'd do it.
But its not enjoyable at all.
It takes up way too much headspace.

I get all about pushing yourself and all that. But why do something that stresses you.
In all honesty, I think I started to late in life to benefit/enjoy/ become any good at it.

OP posts:
ArialAnna · 23/10/2022 10:59

Sorry OP, just seen the update - could you trade in both cars for a family automatic?

ArialAnna · 23/10/2022 10:56

I would get rid of the extra car and walk day to day, but practise doing stints in your DH's car on holidays and trips, so you don't lose the skills. Much better for the environmemt and air quality. Tbh, I find longer drives much more relaxing anyway - short trips round town with the parking when you are in a rush for school etc are much more stressful. I hate driving locally and am amazed by how many people do it! Locally I walk / cycle everywhere. I have a cargo bike to take the kids to nursery & school (we could actually walk it, but I appreciate the extra time back!) Could that be an option for you OP as your younger kid dawdles? But I do drive on holiday / longer trips, so I don't forget how to do it.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:56

TeaAndStrumpets · 23/10/2022 10:45

OP my best friend lost her husband a few years ago. They always used his massive car (manual) which she couldn't drive, so for their frequent long journeys she relied on him. She had a little automatic which she only used around town.

After he died she was thankful she had kept her little car, she quickly gained confidence because she now had to do all the long trips solo.

Sorry to be morbid, but at the very least you should BOTH be able to drive the family car.

Not morbid. I totally get this.
I suppose I don't drive because I don't have to. DP needs his car as he drives everywhere and some of the dC activities are in another county.
I won't ever be able to drive his car though, even if I wanted to as I'd have to take another test as his his manual. And there is absolutely zero chance of me doing that!!!!

OP posts:
BattenburgDonkey · 23/10/2022 10:50

If you’ve got it for another 2 years and you drive it daily you might become more confident yet OP. I’d try driving it a little more and make the most out of it, and eventually up to driving DHs car.

TeaAndStrumpets · 23/10/2022 10:45

OP my best friend lost her husband a few years ago. They always used his massive car (manual) which she couldn't drive, so for their frequent long journeys she relied on him. She had a little automatic which she only used around town.

After he died she was thankful she had kept her little car, she quickly gained confidence because she now had to do all the long trips solo.

Sorry to be morbid, but at the very least you should BOTH be able to drive the family car.

maddening · 23/10/2022 10:44

It all depends on where you live I guess, for me taxis are expensive where I live and there is sweet fa in the way of public transport. Eg ds school is 1hr 15 mins walk, or 1 hour on a bus (1 in to the town from our village to get another to the village where his high school is) whereas it is a 9 min drive (he walks the last mile).

Plus there is no transport on a Sunday. I want to be able to see friends and family even if dh has gone hiking etc. So it really works to have 2 cars for us compared to someone in a different position with better public transport.

Ilikewinter · 23/10/2022 10:43

Similar situation, I go into the office twice a week. DH perm WFH. We could very easily go to 1 car as we only go out in DH at the weekends and on holiday etc BUT theres no way I'd give up my independence and share a car....plus we couldnt decide on a joint car, DH has an estate which is good for the dog, mines a hatchback and I dont want to drive a big estate car!. So here we are paying out for 2 lots of everything 😂

Darbs76 · 23/10/2022 10:38

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:25

Extra activities are a bit awkward as they both do separate activities on the weekend.
DP is quite involved , but sometimes they clash so we take one child each.

So that suits DP ,as it means that I can 'help out', as logistically he can't do both. However, he insists on driving whenever he can(suspect he doesn't trust me!).

Before I had the car, these activities were awkward and involved multiple planning or asking other parents or family to drop one DC,which I hated ,as I do not like relying on people.
And before I had my car, I never asked for lifts and hated people feeling sorry for me.
But having said all of that, is it still worth having a car just to possibly need to take DC to a sporting event once a fortnight?

It would have been really difficult for my son’s football without a car. I’m an experienced driver though, passed at 17 and 1 month (grew up in north wales were transport is rubbish) and I regularly do motorway driving plus overseas. I only got experienced with more driving. I was so nervous at first. My mum gave up driving as she too was a nervous driver and regrets it hugely. Keep the car

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:37

alwayslearning789 · 23/10/2022 10:35

You are not a Sunday Morning driver... you a a Mum driver😊

Big difference when it comes to the ferrying the kids, managing household shopping, emergencies, etc!

Ha ha. Definitely mum driver. But not the kind of driver I hoped I'd be.

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 23/10/2022 10:36

It sounds like a small inexpensive car to run. I'd just try to pay it off early and keep it. The prices on cars have gone up so much. Your DC may want to learn on it or their activities may change and you'd need it more.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:36

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/10/2022 10:25

Do you have a city car club? I belonged to one in Edinburgh before I moved out to the sticks. £120 membership for the year and then a reasonable hourly rate to use the car. Brilliant for doing Ikea/ visiting awkwardly situated relatives etc.

D|riving does get better with practice I was a shit driver and it all clicked in eventually. What do you do for as living? Could you get a job delivering packages P/T just to give you lots of practice.

I've not heard of that. Is it like rental?
I work for the NHS
But funny you should say that, as I often think when I get parcels like from Asos etc that must be very good practice!!!

OP posts: