Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a car when I only do very minimal driving

111 replies

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 09:39

I have a car on finance. High interest(bad credit rating). 2 years left on finance. Its affordable to me.

However, I barely drive. Back story. Late learner. Very anxious re:driving.

Bought car straight after passing, on a bit of a whim.
Plan was to drive lots. Plan never happened. My anxiety about driving has improved loads ,but I'm still a shit ,inexperienced driver! It's never really taken off.

I do drive daily but its just school run, shops etc. Appointments. Apart from big supermarket shop, nothing I couldn't do on foot/public transport.

Up to now, I suppose I like my little car and I like the fact that I have my independence if I need it,or do actually have to drive(rare).
DP has his own car and drives a lot and does all the big trips/holidays and days out.

I've just sat here thinking why am I wasting my money- car finance, petrol, insurance etc for literally 100 miles a month. Its mad isn't it? I'm thinking sensible thing is to get rid when finance is up.
I could get bloody taxis for less. Or is it wise to keep driving and have my own car as back up.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Badbadbunny · 24/02/2023 07:48

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 10:00

I actually looked into this a couple of years ago and don't cover my area of the country.

I'm an IAM observer and local group secretary. There are 180 groups all over the country (even small towns and rural areas). Some big cities have several groups. I can't think of any cities without an IAM group.

www.iamroadsmart.com/membership/local-groups

emptythelitterbox · 24/10/2022 14:12

Princedelight · 24/10/2022 13:42

@emptythelitterbox
Very true.none of my driving is associated with fun. Its always connected with a chore and added with the not wanting to drive in first place, isn't the best experience!!

Very understandable why you currently see it the way you do.

Not sure how old your DC are but maybe planning a day trip might turn out to be fun for all of you. The looking and planning together can be fun.

user1471554720 · 24/10/2022 14:04

I would keep the car in your position. Especially as you are a nervous driver, you won't improve by not having a car. In fact, borrowing dhs car when you rarely drive is even more stressful.

Also, think about if you are 70 and don't have the energy to walk/wait for buses. It is nice to have the car, especially in bad weather. You could take a drive 20 miles away once every few weeks to 'give the car a good run' even if you don't need to go to a particular place.

Also it doesn"t feel nice to have to 'book' the use of the one car. It must be very stressful when you both work. What I noticed is that public transport take ages, can be unreliable etc.

Princedelight · 24/10/2022 13:42

@emptythelitterbox
Very true.none of my driving is associated with fun. Its always connected with a chore and added with the not wanting to drive in first place, isn't the best experience!!

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 24/10/2022 11:09

I was thinking you could plan a weekend day trip with a friend who is a confident driver. Go out to the countryside. Sightsee a bit. Doing that more would help you gain some confidence and it wouldn't be associated with a chore you have to do. Right now, you haven't had any fun experiences with it.
My mum didn't learn to drive until her mid 40s. She wouldn't drive on large motorways(interstate where she lived) but she would drive everywhere else. She
always had a large sedan which fit her and us 3 kids.

My DD was a little nervous about driving until she had to go pick her grandma up across the country and drive back just the two of them. She's been confident ever since and has even driven uber eats on the weekend.
I think several small trips and a big one would give you the confidence you need.

crochetcrazy1978 · 24/10/2022 09:56

I learnt later in life and am an anxious driver. Cannot do motorways and just do local journeys. I wfh now so drive even less. When my old car gave up the ghost we decided to try and just have the one car and I hated it! It made me more isolated and I hated having to plan everything for when my husband was around so I could use the car. Picked up my new car at the weekend and pleased to have one again

Princedelight · 24/10/2022 09:08

@reigatecastle
Well yes, once car goes I won't drive again. Otherwise I may as well keep it.

I only learned in my 40s so it's only going to get harder.
I think unless some miracle happens or I'm forced into driving more somehow then I will be in this same position 2 years from now when my finance is paid.

I live in a big city and its no problem getting anywhere locally.

However, I had to car the be able to go to places non local. The reality is I'm not doing that. So the car is pretty much redundant. I have all the major ones near me. All deliver as well.

I think just having the car mithers me somewhat, reminding me that I'm hardly driving.
I can't help but think that getting rid of it would make me feel better as then I can't drive so all the worry goes!!!
I'm hardly really going to miss it!

OP posts:
reigatecastle · 24/10/2022 08:57

I think this sort of situation depends where you live. If you live somewhere with a good bus and/or train (or tram) service, and these days online shopping means can get heavy shopping delivered, it's probably not worth having a car. Especially if you have a car club nearby where you can get a car easily if you need one.

But otherwise, if it's easier and more convenient and you can afford it, it makes sense.

We run two cars and don't really need two when it's just DH and me, but it's useful when DS comes home from uni. We can afford it and one car is a hybrid, so it's ok for now. We might get rid of one when ds gets his own place though. If we had a car club in our town I'd have one car and just "borrow" a car if we needed an extra one. Sadly we don't.

It's a good point that if you get rid of it you will never drive though, and in my view it's important for women to keep their independence.

Princedelight · 24/10/2022 08:47

Well I've got to keep the car for now anyway as I don't want the hassle of getting out of the finance or the cost.

I suppose that I bought it really without as much thought as I should have.
Really sat and worked out what I wanted it for.
I guess DPs comment that it 'needs a good run out 'made me feel a bit inadequate. As most people do give their card a good run out!

Everyone that I know in RL actually use their cars a lot. Not just piddly trips to the shops. Motorways, days out, visiting relatives etc.
I don't really!

All my car trips are very short drives pretty much, ones I could do easily without a car. The only really helpful ones that I do are ferrying kids to activities when DP is unable to as they clash. Otherwise,he does them himself as he's quite involved.

In hindsight , when I passed my test I should have said to DP its not worth me having my own car. So we need a suitable car between us.
However, I suppose at the time when i passed I wasn't expecting to drive so little!!!
Now the damage is done and I've bought a car thats barely used and he has his own large manual that I can't drive anyway.

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 23/10/2022 20:56

I would keep the car .so many people say catch the bus ,user or whatever, but the freedom to go out with your dc in the holidays ,meet a friend go for a run out at we is great 👍.

Macaroni1924 · 23/10/2022 20:47

I think you are being a bit hard on yourself OP. As you say late to learn and lacking confidence yet you can and do still drive. You might not be doing hundreds of miles but you are doing it. Having the ability to drive makes things like the shopping much easier, I know you can get a bus but carting it back you need to be mindful of what you can manage.

Ive been driving for 19 years and only since I’ve had my DD who is 6 started driving on the motorway. I’m the only driver so it had to be me and when taking her to things like visiting Santa they were always by using the motorway. I hated it, every last minute. We are just back from a week away and then out again today on a trip and I drove the motorway each time. I don’t hate it now, i just don’t like it 😂 but I can do it. I like you plan my trips, check them on the maps before booking anything and if I’m 100% honest I never book anything more than 1 hours drive away as I feel that’s my limit. You have yours and have made improvements as you are already less nervous. Things will come in time and as a PP said about her friend, you never know one day you might just need to and keeping the car keeps up your practice and keeps you growing.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 20:33

Heyahun · 23/10/2022 16:20

Surely a family car you all can drive makes more sense here.

For that to happen, I'd have to get rid of my financed car
DH TO sell his and then buy an auto one and then put me on insurance. He's not going to do that. No benefit to him. He has a car. I have a car
No issue.

OP posts:
Princedelight · 23/10/2022 20:30

rookiemere · 23/10/2022 16:10

So a cautionary tale is my friend who has passed her license but lived in London until about 5 years ago when she came back here to be closer to help look after her DPs.

Except the DPs are an hour away by train. She says she wishes she could pluck up the courage to drive as would make the trip so much easier and comfortable, but she hasn't driven for so long that she can't bring herself to do it.

I don't enjoy driving- the closest I come is if I'm doing a known motorway route on my own, not in a rush. But I persevere.

What's the penalties like if you pay back the loan early or hand back the car ? That might help you make a decision.

I suspect penalty be a lot as only half way through loan

OP posts:
Heyahun · 23/10/2022 16:20

Surely a family car you all can drive makes more sense here.

Tort · 23/10/2022 16:15

I live in zone 5 and sometimes don’t drive for 2 or 3 weeks. Never drive to work or school. I just like the convenience though - often DS is invited to a party it’s hard to get to another way or we’ll want to drive to either set of grandparents. It’s fully owned cheap wee runaround though.

rookiemere · 23/10/2022 16:10

So a cautionary tale is my friend who has passed her license but lived in London until about 5 years ago when she came back here to be closer to help look after her DPs.

Except the DPs are an hour away by train. She says she wishes she could pluck up the courage to drive as would make the trip so much easier and comfortable, but she hasn't driven for so long that she can't bring herself to do it.

I don't enjoy driving- the closest I come is if I'm doing a known motorway route on my own, not in a rush. But I persevere.

What's the penalties like if you pay back the loan early or hand back the car ? That might help you make a decision.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 16:02

Badbadbunny · 23/10/2022 15:51

Exactly this. The best way to improve driving skills & reduce anxiety is to do more and more of it. If you shy away from it and do less, the OP will never get better!

God I know! Why cant it be that easy!?

OP posts:
Princedelight · 23/10/2022 16:00

sicklycolleague · 23/10/2022 15:47

OP it feels like the biggest thing here is the anxiety. Can’t you tackle that instead? A mix of solo medium distance trips (or you and a friend) driving somewhere in the countryside and some kind of talking therapy?

If you talk yourself out of journeys it won’t get better

Agree totally. But I'm trying to be realistic. Ive promised myself a million times I will do more driving. But I don't.
That's why I'm looking ahead as to when finance ends I will probably be in the same position!!!!
At least getting rid of the bloody car means no more pressure to drive when I don't like it or want to.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 23/10/2022 15:51

sicklycolleague · 23/10/2022 15:47

OP it feels like the biggest thing here is the anxiety. Can’t you tackle that instead? A mix of solo medium distance trips (or you and a friend) driving somewhere in the countryside and some kind of talking therapy?

If you talk yourself out of journeys it won’t get better

Exactly this. The best way to improve driving skills & reduce anxiety is to do more and more of it. If you shy away from it and do less, the OP will never get better!

sicklycolleague · 23/10/2022 15:47

OP it feels like the biggest thing here is the anxiety. Can’t you tackle that instead? A mix of solo medium distance trips (or you and a friend) driving somewhere in the countryside and some kind of talking therapy?

If you talk yourself out of journeys it won’t get better

orangeisthenewpuce · 23/10/2022 15:38

When I first learned to drive I used to go out and just drive around aimlessly going a bit further each time. That's how I got confident in my driving abilities.

thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 15:32

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 15:24

I live approx 5 miles from major UK city. Bus runs practically from outside my house to the city centre. Multiple train stations too.
I'm lucky.7 days a week only limited sevice is Sunday, but that's still every 30 min for most buses.
But I guess that's not why I would need a car,to get to the city centre, as I'd never drive there as too complicated.

But will you live there forever?

mondaytosunday · 23/10/2022 15:27

I don't drive every day, and due to a mix up (I have a time restricted medical license) I was actually without a license for a few weeks and managed ok. But I wouldn't give up my car because there are occasions when it's essential. Like when there is a tube or train strike I drive my daughter to school, when I visit my son I drive. While I could possibly rent a car on occasion I don't think that would be economical, as without a permit it's £25/day just to park outside my house.
To me a car means freedom, and I'm not giving that up.

Princedelight · 23/10/2022 15:24

I live approx 5 miles from major UK city. Bus runs practically from outside my house to the city centre. Multiple train stations too.
I'm lucky.7 days a week only limited sevice is Sunday, but that's still every 30 min for most buses.
But I guess that's not why I would need a car,to get to the city centre, as I'd never drive there as too complicated.

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 23/10/2022 15:20

Devoutspoken · 23/10/2022 11:42

Get rid of your car , you can do so much using alternative modes of transport

That depends entirely on where you live - not only now but on where you plan to live in the future.

Lots of rural areas have no public transport to speak of. Where I live, there's a train service (but not on Sundays or BH's, or late at night). No buses, no late night taxi, no UBER.

If you want to take your kids swimming or to the cinema, you need a car.

Swipe left for the next trending thread