Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is what happens when receptionists are the ones who decide whether or not you actually *see* a GP? (Ear infection)

416 replies

lCantHearYou · 23/10/2022 02:05

Wednesday last week- woke up with an intense pain in my left ear, and assume I’ve just jammed my ear plug in a bit too far, but over an hour later the pain is still there and I can’t hear out of that ear, so I ring the GP surgery.

The receptionist, based on no medical expertise whatsoever, asks what the problem is and unilaterally decides that all I need is a telephone appointment. The GP she’s scheduled the call with is well known in our community for not doing face to face appointments if she can help it and generally having the attitude of just wanting to get you off the phone as quickly as possible.

Later that morning, GP call. I explain that I’ve been having this very intense pain for several hours now that paracetamol isn’t really touching, my ear is ringing very loudly and all external sound is very muffled and barely audible.

She decides over the course of the 3 minute call that since I’m recovering from a cold I’m probably just a bit congested, tells me to take some Sudafed/other decongestant and paracetamol and it should right itself in a few days.

I start alternating pseudoephedrine, paracetamol and ibuprofen, but the pain wakes me in the night every night.

Thursday evening DH, the DC and I travel up to PILs house.

Friday morning, DH and I leave for a long weekend abroad (on the Eurostar, thank god we didn’t fly or I’d probably have at least one ruptured ear drum).

By Friday evening the pain and hearing loss has now spread into the right ear as well. Spend the whole weekend in pain and practically deaf, which kind of spoils things somewhat.

Monday evening, we all get home. 3:00 am I wake up in so much pain I can’t keep still, DH wakes to the sight of me sitting upright, rocking back and forth with my hands clamped over the back of my head. He calls 111 who schedule a phonecall with a Dr… who rings back 3 and a half hours later and says, sounds like an infection, I can prescribe antibiotics or you can just wait and see your own GP. I opt to see my own GP, so 111 Dr puts in notes that I need a face to face appointment.

So we’re back on the phone to the surgery, to the receptionist who’s halfway through saying “I can schedule a phonecall…” when I tell her about 111 Dr’s advice to seek a face to face appointment. Then she relents and schedules one with a different GP to the one I spoke to the week before. At the actual appointment, this GP barely needs to glance in my ears before saying it’s a severe infection, inner ears are very sore and red, lots of pus and gunk and, in her words, “looks incredibly painful”.

I’ve now been on amoxicillin and cocodamol (which I’m alternating with ibuprofen) for 5 days now. I can still barely hear a thing beyond the very loud ringing and the sound of my own pulse throbbing in my ears. All external sound is very muffled and distorted. If I wait too long between taking pain meds I fucking know about it… I’ve taken to sleeping with the cocodamol under my pillow so that when (not if) the pain wakes me in the night I don’t have to grope around on my bedside table to find them. Part of my job involves being on the phone, sometimes for hours at a time, so I have to jam my earphones right into my ears and turn the volume up full, and by the end of my shift (I work very late at night) I’m doubly exhausted from the effort of straining to hear anything.

AIBU to think that if, on that first day, the receptionist or indeed the GP had paused for a moment and thought “hmmm, intense inner ear pain, badly affected hearing, maybe get her in so we can see if there’s an infection”, then I could have started on antibiotics that day and at the very least the infection would likely have been contained to one ear and might even be starting to get better? As it is the receptionist didn’t bother, the GP didn’t bother, and instead of getting better it got considerably worse, the antibiotics are making fuck all difference and I’ve now had almost two weeks of intense pain and hearing loss for no good reason? And AIBU to be pretty pissed off about it?

Sorry for the twilight rant… I’ve just woken up feeling like the back of my skull is being squeezed. Again.

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/10/2022 14:07

TroysMammy · 23/10/2022 13:57

They do though and can give more information to the Receptionist without being prompted. You could just say a gynae problem and elaborate to the GP.

When I went to the local walk in centre I was expected to give details of my Bartholins cyst to the receptionist in front of all the other patients. Because I know that's how they work I typed it in my phone and just handed it to her which she was fine with. However, the nurse who was triaging everyone in the waiting area wasn't and kept asking questions that I wasn't happy about answering so that everyone could hear. She also had the cheek to say my heart rate was very fast and to calm down! Er that would be because I'm in a lot of pain and you're asking me personal questions in a room full of people!

There needs to be more thought about patients confidentiality and dignity.

TroysMammy · 23/10/2022 13:57

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 13:28

If people feel comfortable ringing up and discussing their medical issue with a receptionist and do it that way, great. But a 78 year old woman doesn’t want to ring up and discuss vaginal pain with a receptionist. So she should be able to just ask for an appointment with her regular doctor.

They do though and can give more information to the Receptionist without being prompted. You could just say a gynae problem and elaborate to the GP.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 23/10/2022 13:55

Triaging is a wonderful thing. When it's done by someone with actual medical training.

If I think there's something simple wrong with me, or I need a new prescription for a pre-existing condition, I can book an appointment with a nurse practitioner or prescribing pharmacist. If it turns out what's going on with me is more complex than I thought, they know enough to recognise that and refer me to a GP or even a specialist. They're not reading from a script - they've seen things.

(The thing that I love about speaking to nurses and pharmacists is their advice is always more practical - they know all the tips for how to administer treatment in a more effective/easy way.)

I don't understand how anyone ever thought it was acceptable to farm out this service to receptionists. It actually feels pretty damn disrespectful to me to anyone who isn't a GP. There are plenty of medical professionals who aren't doctors who are very well equipped to talk to you about your health and know if it's urgent, not urgent, simple to sort out, or needs further investigation. They don't need to read from a script because they've been medically trained.

I also don't understand why so many GP practices are run like it's the stone age. Most patients can book their own appointments to suit their own schedule when you open up the booking system electronically, freeing up the phone lines for the patients who can only book over the phone. Plenty of practices still don't allow electronic booking.

I used to have a terrible doctor at a terrible practice, so I believe all of the horror stories on this thread. But I also have a wonderful practice now, so I believe most practices can be better. I feel very well looked after - and it's all on the NHS. It shouldn't be such a postcode lottery - everyone should be able to access medical care this easily.

With my current practice, I can book a video appointment by myself to see the right type of medical professional (I don't always need a doctor) at a time that suits me. I can check whether they're female (if you're feeling vulnerable, sometimes you don't want to talk to a male doctor). I can check what their background is (depending on what's wrong, sometimes it's beneficial to speak to a doctor with a clinical interest in a niche area). If I need to come in, a face-to-face appointment is then set up. All practices should be like this. Sadly, the vast majority aren't.

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 13:28

If people feel comfortable ringing up and discussing their medical issue with a receptionist and do it that way, great. But a 78 year old woman doesn’t want to ring up and discuss vaginal pain with a receptionist. So she should be able to just ask for an appointment with her regular doctor.

Soontobe60 · 23/10/2022 13:23

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 12:42

Of course you should tell the receptionist why you need an appointment.

No. they’re not your doctor. This puts people off making appointments.

“Hi, I need an appointment to see the GP. I’m not sure if a phone appointment will do”
”Can I ask what it’s for?”
”I’ve previously had a mole removed and have another similar one that I’d like the GP to have a look at.”
”I’ll book you in for a phone appointment and send you a link to send the GP a photo before your appointment”
”thanks, that’s great”

GP checks the photo, phones me back and refers me to dermatology. Job done.

Soontobe60 · 23/10/2022 13:17

TroysMammy · 23/10/2022 13:06

@cc1997 thank you.

@WahineToa so if someone rings the surgery and doesn't tell the Receptionist they have chest pain and has to wait for a call back from the GP, in the first instance a telephone call, and they have a heart attack, whose fault is it then?

Or the patient who doesn't want to continue with a pregnancy and they can self refer to a clinic which is what the GP will tell them to do.

Or the patient who needs the morning after pill and they can't see a GP for a few days and it will be too late to get the Morning After Pill from the Pharmacy?

Or the person who's elderly relative has fallen and now in pain with an injured arm?

Fine, don't tell the lowly Receptionist who honestly is so busy your ailment doesn't register as they are taking the next call and who hasn't time to care if you have a chest infection, urine infection, worms or athletes foot but does care that you are signposted to the correct place whether that's GP, Minor Injuries, Dentist, A&E or Pharmacy.

Just in case you need it in the future:
www.nhs.uk/conditions/contraception/where-can-i-get-emergency-contraception/

Soontobe60 · 23/10/2022 13:16

KweenieBeanz · 23/10/2022 06:20

Don't you think it's quite a waste of the doctors time to be doubling up like that???

If they'd seen all the patients f2f first time rather than over the phone they wouldn't have needed to repeat half the appointments again with those who need seeing f2f.

How do people not see that this telephone triage is just doubling up the work?! No wonder people can't get an appointment.

I’ve not seen a GP face to face since the start of Covid. In that time, I’ve had a referral to dermatology, one to a consultant about a knee issue, 1 lot of antibiotics for a urine infection, an urgent ultrasound scan and a referral to a muscular skeletal therapist.
IME, phone consultations work very well most of the time.

Reallyreallyborednow · 23/10/2022 13:14

No. they’re not your doctor. This puts people off making appointments

so you want to discuss menopause and HRT.

you refuse to tell the receptionist this. They book you in with the first available GP who’s specialty is elderly care or diabetes.

you attend the appt, to be told that this GP doesn’t know much about HRT, and you need to book in with Dr smith, who has had specialised training and is much better placed to help.

so now you’ve taken up two appointments, when the receptionist could have booked you in with dr smith straight away.

if everyone does this then the GP’s workload immediately doubles.

NicolaSixSix · 23/10/2022 13:12

dudsville · 23/10/2022 03:03

It's crazy that we have to be so well informed about NICE guidance before we even try to book, so that we can explain to them what stage we're at with the progression of our illness, an illness in which we have no formal training.

tell your kids to study medicine as after the next 2 years of tory government they’ll only be able to see a doctor if they are one

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 13:10

"Or the patient who needs the morning after pill and they can't see a GP for a few days and it will be too late to get the Morning After Pill from the Pharmacy?"

you can get this without seeing a GP. Very important to know this.

TroysMammy · 23/10/2022 13:06

@cc1997 thank you.

@WahineToa so if someone rings the surgery and doesn't tell the Receptionist they have chest pain and has to wait for a call back from the GP, in the first instance a telephone call, and they have a heart attack, whose fault is it then?

Or the patient who doesn't want to continue with a pregnancy and they can self refer to a clinic which is what the GP will tell them to do.

Or the patient who needs the morning after pill and they can't see a GP for a few days and it will be too late to get the Morning After Pill from the Pharmacy?

Or the person who's elderly relative has fallen and now in pain with an injured arm?

Fine, don't tell the lowly Receptionist who honestly is so busy your ailment doesn't register as they are taking the next call and who hasn't time to care if you have a chest infection, urine infection, worms or athletes foot but does care that you are signposted to the correct place whether that's GP, Minor Injuries, Dentist, A&E or Pharmacy.

shedwithivy · 23/10/2022 13:06

ivykaty44 · 23/10/2022 04:24

It’s the doctor that should have decided to see you face to face to examine you, not the receptionist- they are following instructions

I’ve had more than one telephone appointment that’s lead to a face to face appointment later the same day

YABU

Agree that receptionist is not to blame here, doctor should have seen you from what you described here

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 13:00

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 23/10/2022 12:50

Pneumonia wants A&E surely?

nah. Had it twice. In those days they gave antibiotics but I don't think they do now.

other posters - do not take medical advice from me!

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 23/10/2022 12:50

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 11:56

I don't suppose that includes walking pneumonia? Unlikely, I know!

Pneumonia wants A&E surely?

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 12:48

a pretty crumby wage actually compared to other countries half decent wage means that they owe you their blood.

Which countries?

Nobody is asking for blood. Patients are entitled to expect good care from their health service that an enormous amount of our money goes into. It’s not ‘free’, we actually pay for it. Wanting face to face appointments isn’t unreasonable. It’s basic. My GP surgery has 3 doctors all part time and the average salary is £55,000. That is an excellent wage and it’s ridiculous to suggest otherwise. GPs are paid well here. My GP started face to face months ago and gives great care. Everyone else should get the same excellent service we do here.

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 12:44

This is true in theory

Yes it is. Thank you for agreeing with me.

I don’t think you know what gaslighting is.

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 12:42

Of course you should tell the receptionist why you need an appointment.

No. they’re not your doctor. This puts people off making appointments.

bakebeans · 23/10/2022 12:31

YABU. I've gone for this as The GP can overrule a receptionist. It's not her fault. She did what she could. On that initial call, the GP with all his medical expertise could at that point asked for you to come down even the day after to another member of staff. Even the practice nurse or advanced practitioner could have had a look at your ears and send a swab off for analysis. Not acceptable.

FernlovingNodosaur · 23/10/2022 12:24

Cheeseandcrackers86 I and I guess many others would not mind paying more if they actually did their job correctly and saw their patients in the flesh. As for the pound of flesh analogy. Other workers who refused to do a vital part of their job would be given their P45's and the door.

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 23/10/2022 12:10

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 11:27

then of course somebody has to decide and prioritise! I can't believe that this needs spelling out to even the sinplest of brains tbh

Not the receptionist. The receptionist has no medical training to make those decisions. It’s also ridiculous to suggest that phone calls save time. They don’t. The GP should see everyone face to face now. There is no excuse. My GP saw me this March face to face to discuss HRT, check my nose as I had pain and to book me in for a specialist for a long standing neck lump ( US within just 6 weeks ). I’m in a busy area too.
If you’re going to throw insults about me having a simple brain, you should take the time to check your spelling or it loses its impact.

Please don't backtrack on your words. This is gaslighting at it's worst. Your very clear suggestion that nobody should deny you an appointment. This is true in theory but in reality there's human beings that are required to meet your's and lots of other people's needs. The fact is that people just want GP's blood and think paying them a pretty crumby wage actually compared to other countries half decent wage means that they owe you their blood. It's pathetically entitled and no wonder there aren't enough people willing to do it

KitchenSupper · 23/10/2022 12:10

IWishICouldDance · 23/10/2022 10:01

You rang the doctors after having an earache for an hour? It does sound rather ott. My 4 year old had an earache that woke him in the night last week, he was awake in our bed crying on off all night and it was still there that morning so he took the day off. There was gunk too. I said if he still had it the day after I'd ring the doctors. As it happens the earache was gone by the next night and the gunk cleared up a day or so later. Granted you clearly needed help in the end, but if

If an earache disappears very quickly it often mean that the eardrum has perforated.

FernlovingNodosaur · 23/10/2022 12:09

BorgQueen For what it's worth. I recently changed surgeries. (Because I couldn't even get though to NHS surgery, let alone make an appointment! And just to clarify they are still not allowing people to go in to the surgery in person either before any asks why I didn't just roll up and ask for an appointment ) And that was only allowed because it was my old surgery and my partner was still registered there.
Guess what? It's no better! I still can't see a NHS GP in person and even phone appointments have a wait of several weeks. I just consider myself very lucky to have BUPA on the highest cover level. Partners work perk, but many others are not that fortunate and at the end of the day my family are still paying for a service that you can't access.

Rlt8990 · 23/10/2022 12:02

Actually going to defend the receptionist here and say that she might have got you a same day appintment when she could have said they are full and emergencys only? In my surgery once f2f is full it is down ti telephone triage for emergencies/ things that can't wait. If you said you had an ongoing issue she may not have given you an appointment at all and told you to try another day. It's not down to her whether the GP brings you in, this was poor treatment by the GP but not by the receptionist

KitchenSupper · 23/10/2022 11:59

Suzi888 · 23/10/2022 02:57

Happened to me, only the infection was so severe the two week course of antibiotics did bugger all. The drops the G.P prescribed were not to be used with a ruptured ear drum. The bone at the back of my ear swelled (mastoid bone, I think) and I went to A&E. Ended up in hospital 5 nights on IV antibiotics and Oramorph.

Hospital consultant advised on antibiotic ear drops should be used. Oral ones take too long/won’t always work.

When I had mastoiditis it was in a country with a functional healthcare system. Within 15 minutes of noticing the swelling I saw a GP (in the surgery there is one walk-in GP always available for urgent appointments that don’t warrant A&E; it’s not abused since you can easily get an appointment with your normal doctor). Even though it is a life threatening condition it could be treated for a minimal sum at home as I could see a doctor so fast.
Compare that with the cost of the 5 day hospital stay with IV medication. It’s more expensive for the system to work this way.

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 11:56

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 23/10/2022 11:29

Actually, Pharmacists can prescribe antibiotics on their own say so for various conditions. UTIs to name the most common one.

I don't suppose that includes walking pneumonia? Unlikely, I know!