Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is what happens when receptionists are the ones who decide whether or not you actually *see* a GP? (Ear infection)

416 replies

lCantHearYou · 23/10/2022 02:05

Wednesday last week- woke up with an intense pain in my left ear, and assume I’ve just jammed my ear plug in a bit too far, but over an hour later the pain is still there and I can’t hear out of that ear, so I ring the GP surgery.

The receptionist, based on no medical expertise whatsoever, asks what the problem is and unilaterally decides that all I need is a telephone appointment. The GP she’s scheduled the call with is well known in our community for not doing face to face appointments if she can help it and generally having the attitude of just wanting to get you off the phone as quickly as possible.

Later that morning, GP call. I explain that I’ve been having this very intense pain for several hours now that paracetamol isn’t really touching, my ear is ringing very loudly and all external sound is very muffled and barely audible.

She decides over the course of the 3 minute call that since I’m recovering from a cold I’m probably just a bit congested, tells me to take some Sudafed/other decongestant and paracetamol and it should right itself in a few days.

I start alternating pseudoephedrine, paracetamol and ibuprofen, but the pain wakes me in the night every night.

Thursday evening DH, the DC and I travel up to PILs house.

Friday morning, DH and I leave for a long weekend abroad (on the Eurostar, thank god we didn’t fly or I’d probably have at least one ruptured ear drum).

By Friday evening the pain and hearing loss has now spread into the right ear as well. Spend the whole weekend in pain and practically deaf, which kind of spoils things somewhat.

Monday evening, we all get home. 3:00 am I wake up in so much pain I can’t keep still, DH wakes to the sight of me sitting upright, rocking back and forth with my hands clamped over the back of my head. He calls 111 who schedule a phonecall with a Dr… who rings back 3 and a half hours later and says, sounds like an infection, I can prescribe antibiotics or you can just wait and see your own GP. I opt to see my own GP, so 111 Dr puts in notes that I need a face to face appointment.

So we’re back on the phone to the surgery, to the receptionist who’s halfway through saying “I can schedule a phonecall…” when I tell her about 111 Dr’s advice to seek a face to face appointment. Then she relents and schedules one with a different GP to the one I spoke to the week before. At the actual appointment, this GP barely needs to glance in my ears before saying it’s a severe infection, inner ears are very sore and red, lots of pus and gunk and, in her words, “looks incredibly painful”.

I’ve now been on amoxicillin and cocodamol (which I’m alternating with ibuprofen) for 5 days now. I can still barely hear a thing beyond the very loud ringing and the sound of my own pulse throbbing in my ears. All external sound is very muffled and distorted. If I wait too long between taking pain meds I fucking know about it… I’ve taken to sleeping with the cocodamol under my pillow so that when (not if) the pain wakes me in the night I don’t have to grope around on my bedside table to find them. Part of my job involves being on the phone, sometimes for hours at a time, so I have to jam my earphones right into my ears and turn the volume up full, and by the end of my shift (I work very late at night) I’m doubly exhausted from the effort of straining to hear anything.

AIBU to think that if, on that first day, the receptionist or indeed the GP had paused for a moment and thought “hmmm, intense inner ear pain, badly affected hearing, maybe get her in so we can see if there’s an infection”, then I could have started on antibiotics that day and at the very least the infection would likely have been contained to one ear and might even be starting to get better? As it is the receptionist didn’t bother, the GP didn’t bother, and instead of getting better it got considerably worse, the antibiotics are making fuck all difference and I’ve now had almost two weeks of intense pain and hearing loss for no good reason? And AIBU to be pretty pissed off about it?

Sorry for the twilight rant… I’ve just woken up feeling like the back of my skull is being squeezed. Again.

OP posts:
cc1997 · 23/10/2022 21:23

EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 13:10

"Or the patient who needs the morning after pill and they can't see a GP for a few days and it will be too late to get the Morning After Pill from the Pharmacy?"

you can get this without seeing a GP. Very important to know this.

I've bad the morning after pill from a chemist, without a GP....

DorritLittle · 23/10/2022 21:21

My Dad died being denied an appointment by a receptionist. I won't go into details but suffice to say I don't think they should triage calls.

OP I went to a walk-in clinic for a recent ear infection. I was given proper advice and treatment after years of recurring infection and being fobbed off by my GP practice. With ear infections they usually only prescribe painkillers the first day or so but then not all of them go away. I was in hospital with a ruptured ear drum as a child and can attest to it being absolute agony, whatever other posters here think it should feel like.

Reallyreallyborednow · 23/10/2022 16:57

If people are routinely trying to beat the system by booking inappropriate appointments, they should get removed from your books!

or maybe, you know, not everyone is computer savvy or know what clinical specialist they need. Some people don’t know medical terminology and might not realise the difference between obstetrics and orthopaedics. Some people don’t realise the capability of nurses now and would always automatically book with a dr as they see anyone else as inferior and not being able to prescribe, diagnose or refer. Or they simply see a convenient time and date and don’t realise they’ve booked the wrong HCP.

the system works for you because you understand how to use it. Not everyone can, particularly vulnerable people like the elderly. My mum wouldn’t have a clue, fil might, if his eyesight was good enough to read a screen. Dh is very dyslexic, not medical, and would absolutely struggle trying to navigate an online system. He does everything by phone.

Sunnyqueen · 23/10/2022 16:43

My eardrum burst after seeing the GP earlier that day. Never even thought about it, its not a big deal tbh. Plus these things develop over time, if you had seen the GP the first day there probably would have been nothing really to see so you wouldnt have got antibiotics then anyway. If you were managing to go abroad you cant have been suffering that much with it.

lljkk · 23/10/2022 16:38

24 euros to consult an English speaking online doctor in Netherlands.
I haven't tried that service, but suspect OP could have got antibiotic prescription filled quickly too, in Amsterdam.

A strategy for anyone in similar circumstances in future.
Ear infections suck. I can't blame OP for being grumpy about it.

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 23/10/2022 16:34

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 23/10/2022 16:20

@OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty Sounds like your online system isn't fit for purpose, TBH. If a doctor needs to cancel my appointment for any reason, I get a notification, not a phone call. I then rebook.

If people are routinely trying to beat the system by booking inappropriate appointments, they should get removed from your books!

@Reallyreallyborednow I don't think you understand me. People should be able to easily book appointments at a fixed time with someone who is clinically trained (not necessarily a doctor). That person can then either treat them or triage them as necessary. My solution is to get as many people booking electronically to see the right type of clinician, so the admin phone lines can be reserved for people who need more support.

Forcing all patients to dial the same number at 8am means those are the sickest will give up and not get seen, and it also disadvantages people who are at work (or travelling to work) at that time. You can't do away with a phone booking line altogether, but you can free it up for those who need it most.

I also do not believe in random callbacks. It's not compatible with modern life.

And I know my proposed system is possible and works because it's what my practice does. It's radically improved my life for the better.

Sometimes we will send texts. Sometimes we will phone. It takes an awful lot more than that to get removed from a GPs books unfortunately.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 23/10/2022 16:25

KatieB55 · 23/10/2022 16:03

Why are GPs still mostly doing phone appointments? Our surgery has patients from 3 villages & number of patients hasn't increased. You used to be able to turn up before 10am & be seen by a GP. Call at 8am for afternoon appointment with named GP. It worked well. We are getting a worse service.

Plenty of concerns can be treated remotely (although sometimes video calls are necessary rather than phone calls). There is nothing wrong with a remote first solution as long as face-to-face follow-ups are available for those needing them.

Given how many people needing an appointment are contagious, remote first is great because it's likely to reduce a doctor's odds of getting ill. And we don't want sick doctors, as otherwise, they can't work and have to cancel appointments. It's for everyone's good that doctors only see ill people in person when there's a clinical need to do so.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 23/10/2022 16:20

@OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty Sounds like your online system isn't fit for purpose, TBH. If a doctor needs to cancel my appointment for any reason, I get a notification, not a phone call. I then rebook.

If people are routinely trying to beat the system by booking inappropriate appointments, they should get removed from your books!

@Reallyreallyborednow I don't think you understand me. People should be able to easily book appointments at a fixed time with someone who is clinically trained (not necessarily a doctor). That person can then either treat them or triage them as necessary. My solution is to get as many people booking electronically to see the right type of clinician, so the admin phone lines can be reserved for people who need more support.

Forcing all patients to dial the same number at 8am means those are the sickest will give up and not get seen, and it also disadvantages people who are at work (or travelling to work) at that time. You can't do away with a phone booking line altogether, but you can free it up for those who need it most.

I also do not believe in random callbacks. It's not compatible with modern life.

And I know my proposed system is possible and works because it's what my practice does. It's radically improved my life for the better.

Reallyreallyborednow · 23/10/2022 16:19

*Why are nhs patients entitled to get good care?

We all voted in GE's and a referendum to wreck the NHS.

Go private if you want decent healthcare, thats what the UK has voted for since 2010*

not just conservative government. Blair’s labour brought in the concept of workers privatising, social enterprises and introducing private medicine through the back door.

KatieB55 · 23/10/2022 16:03

Why are GPs still mostly doing phone appointments? Our surgery has patients from 3 villages & number of patients hasn't increased. You used to be able to turn up before 10am & be seen by a GP. Call at 8am for afternoon appointment with named GP. It worked well. We are getting a worse service.

lCantHearYou · 23/10/2022 15:52

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/10/2022 15:16

Why are nhs patients entitled to get good care?

We all voted in GE's and a referendum to wreck the NHS.

Go private if you want decent healthcare, thats what the UK has voted for since 2010.

Errr- “we all” did no such thing.

51.9% of those who voted in the referendum, voted leave.

43.6% of those who voted in the 2019 general election, voted Conservative.

Personally, I voted remain and have never voted Tory in my life (and never intend to) so why do I deserve crappy NHS care?

OP posts:
walkingonsunshinekat · 23/10/2022 15:49

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 15:26

@walkingonsunshinekat 🙄 billions of our money is spent on the NHS every year.

Its not enough though, we have a massively increasing elderly population, social care has collapsed, GP numbers down pre 2019 - Cameron promised 5000 extra GP's by 2020, we got fewer.

We have consistently voted to run down the NHS, even the Health Sec said a few days ago "Nurses can leave if they want too"

Its no good moaning about it all now.

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 15:26

@walkingonsunshinekat 🙄 billions of our money is spent on the NHS every year.

KitchenSupper · 23/10/2022 15:25

Hangingoninthere88 · 23/10/2022 14:34

Eardrums 'rupture' all the time after middle ear infections (viral and bacterial). It's really nothing that dramatic or harmful as they usually heal themselves. Say whatever you need to make those naughty GPs look horrible and neglectful though...

It’s incredibly painful, and could be avoided with prompt treatment.
It can lead to inner ear infections, for which you presumably won’t be able to access treatment either.
The (hopefully temporary) hearing loss for a child learning to talk isn’t trivial either.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/10/2022 15:16

WahineToa · 23/10/2022 12:48

a pretty crumby wage actually compared to other countries half decent wage means that they owe you their blood.

Which countries?

Nobody is asking for blood. Patients are entitled to expect good care from their health service that an enormous amount of our money goes into. It’s not ‘free’, we actually pay for it. Wanting face to face appointments isn’t unreasonable. It’s basic. My GP surgery has 3 doctors all part time and the average salary is £55,000. That is an excellent wage and it’s ridiculous to suggest otherwise. GPs are paid well here. My GP started face to face months ago and gives great care. Everyone else should get the same excellent service we do here.

Why are nhs patients entitled to get good care?

We all voted in GE's and a referendum to wreck the NHS.

Go private if you want decent healthcare, thats what the UK has voted for since 2010.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 23/10/2022 15:08

111 gets it wrong too at times. My daughter rang 111 last week for her 7 year old. With symptoms of Increased thirst, urination, bed wetting, weight loss, tiredness. She was also irritable, and complaining of tummy ache.
My daughter was told, it didn’t seem that urgent and to wait until Monday and ring her gp. DD insisted she thought she needed to see a doctor TODAY.
She did see one at OOH who sent her to A&E and was sent through to Resus on admittance, diagnosed withT1 Diabetes and spent two days in critical care.

My own gp surgery has triage by receptionists, it works well, so does the e consult on line service. We always get a call back from the doctor or a face to face appt if they deem it necessary.

notasoldasiseem · 23/10/2022 15:06

OK - I'm evil; haven't read the whole thread. I just want to say that not all surgeries are the same. I rang my doctor's, asked for an appointment and was simply asked whether I wanted face-to-face. I said I did and was given an appointment a couple of weeks away. In a more urgent case I could phone on the day first thing morning or first thing afternoon and get an appointment the same day.

BlancmanegeBunny · 23/10/2022 15:04

I don't understand why you are blaming the receptionist?
Why didn't you follow it up sooner by going back to GP?

kegofcoffee · 23/10/2022 15:00

@Hangingoninthere88

Firstly, there are different levels of ruptured ear drum. Hers was pretty bad, hence ending up in A&E in the middle of the night, her completely unconsolable with blood coming out her ear. Either way if a GP had looked at her history or seen her in person it could have been avoided.

Secondly, at what point did I blame the GP. We didn't manage to actually speak to or see a doctor until A&E. We were always passed off to a call with the practice nurse or paramedic practitioner.

jtaeapa · 23/10/2022 14:59

you prob need micro suction to clear the ear out

privately

thwre are private ear clinics, specsavers or ent consultants

clearearclinic.com/

I will warn you not to go back to your gp for this and to pay to get it sorted asap. Oral antibiotics are not really targeted enough. You need the ear cleared and it looked at my someone who is not a lazy moron.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/10/2022 14:44

So what’s your solution for those who can’t or don’t want to use an online booking system?

I'd love to book online like I used to but my GP surgery doesn't have that any more. They're also stopping their partnership with Livi. They seem to want to make it harder than ever to see a doctor!

Hangingoninthere88 · 23/10/2022 14:34

kegofcoffee · 23/10/2022 14:27

I had pretty much this exact experience with my 2 year old. It ended in a ruptured ear drum and trip to A&E.

This was despite her having a history of ear injections that require antibiotics. And calling the GP or 111 for 3 days in a row.

Eardrums 'rupture' all the time after middle ear infections (viral and bacterial). It's really nothing that dramatic or harmful as they usually heal themselves. Say whatever you need to make those naughty GPs look horrible and neglectful though...

kegofcoffee · 23/10/2022 14:27

I had pretty much this exact experience with my 2 year old. It ended in a ruptured ear drum and trip to A&E.

This was despite her having a history of ear injections that require antibiotics. And calling the GP or 111 for 3 days in a row.

Reallyreallyborednow · 23/10/2022 14:12

I don't understand how anyone ever thought it was acceptable to farm out this service to receptionists. It actually feels pretty damn disrespectful to me to anyone who isn't a GP

So what’s your solution for those who can’t or don’t want to use an online booking system?

receptionists aren’t medical triage, they signpost the most appropriate service. This can be to a nurse practitioner, pharmacy, or GP with a particular specialty, phone or irl consultation. They are trained to ask a set of questions and direct appropriately, which is no different to the service 111 provide.

or are you expecting a GP or NP to man the phone lines? That feels pretty disrespectful to the years of training these HCP have done.

OldEnoughToHaveReadBunty · 23/10/2022 14:09

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 23/10/2022 13:55

Triaging is a wonderful thing. When it's done by someone with actual medical training.

If I think there's something simple wrong with me, or I need a new prescription for a pre-existing condition, I can book an appointment with a nurse practitioner or prescribing pharmacist. If it turns out what's going on with me is more complex than I thought, they know enough to recognise that and refer me to a GP or even a specialist. They're not reading from a script - they've seen things.

(The thing that I love about speaking to nurses and pharmacists is their advice is always more practical - they know all the tips for how to administer treatment in a more effective/easy way.)

I don't understand how anyone ever thought it was acceptable to farm out this service to receptionists. It actually feels pretty damn disrespectful to me to anyone who isn't a GP. There are plenty of medical professionals who aren't doctors who are very well equipped to talk to you about your health and know if it's urgent, not urgent, simple to sort out, or needs further investigation. They don't need to read from a script because they've been medically trained.

I also don't understand why so many GP practices are run like it's the stone age. Most patients can book their own appointments to suit their own schedule when you open up the booking system electronically, freeing up the phone lines for the patients who can only book over the phone. Plenty of practices still don't allow electronic booking.

I used to have a terrible doctor at a terrible practice, so I believe all of the horror stories on this thread. But I also have a wonderful practice now, so I believe most practices can be better. I feel very well looked after - and it's all on the NHS. It shouldn't be such a postcode lottery - everyone should be able to access medical care this easily.

With my current practice, I can book a video appointment by myself to see the right type of medical professional (I don't always need a doctor) at a time that suits me. I can check whether they're female (if you're feeling vulnerable, sometimes you don't want to talk to a male doctor). I can check what their background is (depending on what's wrong, sometimes it's beneficial to speak to a doctor with a clinical interest in a niche area). If I need to come in, a face-to-face appointment is then set up. All practices should be like this. Sadly, the vast majority aren't.

We had to restrict online booking at our practice due to the admin time lost each day phoning patients to rearrange appointments.

Think along the lines of booking a smear appointment because the time & date suited, but then clearly stating in the booking notes you want to discuss your back pain. Totally different clinicians, which would result in a wasted smear appointment. Likewise booking a GP appointment for a depo injection - our GPs don't do these, only practice sisters.

We are a huge practice & resorting appointments inappropriately booked was taking far too long. Obviously this will be seen as disadvantaging people who used the service successfully.

Swipe left for the next trending thread