Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is what happens when receptionists are the ones who decide whether or not you actually *see* a GP? (Ear infection)

416 replies

lCantHearYou · 23/10/2022 02:05

Wednesday last week- woke up with an intense pain in my left ear, and assume I’ve just jammed my ear plug in a bit too far, but over an hour later the pain is still there and I can’t hear out of that ear, so I ring the GP surgery.

The receptionist, based on no medical expertise whatsoever, asks what the problem is and unilaterally decides that all I need is a telephone appointment. The GP she’s scheduled the call with is well known in our community for not doing face to face appointments if she can help it and generally having the attitude of just wanting to get you off the phone as quickly as possible.

Later that morning, GP call. I explain that I’ve been having this very intense pain for several hours now that paracetamol isn’t really touching, my ear is ringing very loudly and all external sound is very muffled and barely audible.

She decides over the course of the 3 minute call that since I’m recovering from a cold I’m probably just a bit congested, tells me to take some Sudafed/other decongestant and paracetamol and it should right itself in a few days.

I start alternating pseudoephedrine, paracetamol and ibuprofen, but the pain wakes me in the night every night.

Thursday evening DH, the DC and I travel up to PILs house.

Friday morning, DH and I leave for a long weekend abroad (on the Eurostar, thank god we didn’t fly or I’d probably have at least one ruptured ear drum).

By Friday evening the pain and hearing loss has now spread into the right ear as well. Spend the whole weekend in pain and practically deaf, which kind of spoils things somewhat.

Monday evening, we all get home. 3:00 am I wake up in so much pain I can’t keep still, DH wakes to the sight of me sitting upright, rocking back and forth with my hands clamped over the back of my head. He calls 111 who schedule a phonecall with a Dr… who rings back 3 and a half hours later and says, sounds like an infection, I can prescribe antibiotics or you can just wait and see your own GP. I opt to see my own GP, so 111 Dr puts in notes that I need a face to face appointment.

So we’re back on the phone to the surgery, to the receptionist who’s halfway through saying “I can schedule a phonecall…” when I tell her about 111 Dr’s advice to seek a face to face appointment. Then she relents and schedules one with a different GP to the one I spoke to the week before. At the actual appointment, this GP barely needs to glance in my ears before saying it’s a severe infection, inner ears are very sore and red, lots of pus and gunk and, in her words, “looks incredibly painful”.

I’ve now been on amoxicillin and cocodamol (which I’m alternating with ibuprofen) for 5 days now. I can still barely hear a thing beyond the very loud ringing and the sound of my own pulse throbbing in my ears. All external sound is very muffled and distorted. If I wait too long between taking pain meds I fucking know about it… I’ve taken to sleeping with the cocodamol under my pillow so that when (not if) the pain wakes me in the night I don’t have to grope around on my bedside table to find them. Part of my job involves being on the phone, sometimes for hours at a time, so I have to jam my earphones right into my ears and turn the volume up full, and by the end of my shift (I work very late at night) I’m doubly exhausted from the effort of straining to hear anything.

AIBU to think that if, on that first day, the receptionist or indeed the GP had paused for a moment and thought “hmmm, intense inner ear pain, badly affected hearing, maybe get her in so we can see if there’s an infection”, then I could have started on antibiotics that day and at the very least the infection would likely have been contained to one ear and might even be starting to get better? As it is the receptionist didn’t bother, the GP didn’t bother, and instead of getting better it got considerably worse, the antibiotics are making fuck all difference and I’ve now had almost two weeks of intense pain and hearing loss for no good reason? And AIBU to be pretty pissed off about it?

Sorry for the twilight rant… I’ve just woken up feeling like the back of my skull is being squeezed. Again.

OP posts:
NotQuiteHere · 23/10/2022 09:31

Have you noticed how we are now very well used to telephone appointments? Ten years ago they were only scheduled as a privilege for the people who could not come to the surgery, now it is the norm.

Mummyoflittledragon · 23/10/2022 09:31

ICanReadYourMind · 23/10/2022 04:16

Sounds awful. I have epilepsy and have had seizures in the past due to ear infections as the body temperature rises and this is one of my triggers. Anyway, I called the surgery as I felt the pain of a perforated ear drum and the brown stuff was pouring out of my ear. I asked the receptionist if I could have an appointment and she said no. I explained that my neurologist had told me that if I got another ear infection I should get treatment straight away to hopefully prevent a seizure. I explained this all to the receptionist.

No prizes for guessing that I had a seizure within 24 hours. I was absolutely fuming although a part of me was a little smug when I called the receptionist to tell her and to re-ask for an appointment. She probably thought it was ‘rather convenient’ but I know it was true and that’s all that matters.

Did you complain to the practice manager? Next time, go to a pharmacy and get a note from them stating you need an urgent appointment. They cannot force the doctor’s surgery to give you an appointment but it would be going against medical advice not to. Or call 111.

I think you should have been more persistent and got an appointment on Friday if it worsened. Definitely should have take the antibiotics from the out of hours GP.

fortheloveofflowers · 23/10/2022 09:31

Oral antibiotics are not that good for outer ear infections. First line is usually ear drops with steroid and antibiotic. This may be why yours is not doing anything.

A swab needs to be taken and I’d be prescribing you some cipro and steroid drops until it comes back.

Duttercup · 23/10/2022 09:30

@Cheeseandcrackers86 I'm sure GPs are nice and work hard, but they are damaging themselves and their own cause with their utter refusal to go back to face-to-face appointments.

feministqueen · 23/10/2022 09:30

Thatskindafun · 23/10/2022 03:12

Yes I agree it’s crazy that someone with no medical training effectively ’triages’ you. I also find at my drs they are quite overzealous and treat you as though you are definitely a time waster stealing from the nhs.

but I do think your whole situation was made worse by you not dealing with it properly
you couldve been more insistent on the phone call
And its not the receptionists fault the gp is lazy
after being up all night wednesday I don’t know why you wouldn’t call back Thursday, knowing you are about to go away for the weekend
and why when a gp offered to prescribe you antibiotics you didn’t just take them, but instead opted to wait, allowing the infection to continue

and there’s no way if I wasn’t sleeping and the pain was as bad as you describe, I’d be going into the weekend without speaking to the gp again on the Friday

i know that all sounds harsh and genuinely ear ache is so bad so I’m really sorry to hear you’re having a lousy time! But in this case I don’t think it’s the receptionists fault at all.

This^

KikiniBamalamm · 23/10/2022 09:29

My mum wanted a face to face for a weird bit of skin that started bleeding. GP would only do phone.

Based on the over the phone description my Mum gave GP decided it was nothing to worry about.

It kept bleeding and somehow my Dad managed to get her seen privately through his work health care and guess what… it’s skin cancer. She’s going to have it removed shortly and luckily it hasn’t spread.

I understand perhaps my Mum didn’t describe it well but that shouldn’t be in her, she should’ve been seen!

BooksAndHooks · 23/10/2022 09:27

In all fairness even if they had diagnosed an infection the first day, the current guidelines are they don’t prescribe antibiotics straightaway. Most ear infections clear up in the same amount of time they would with antibiotics.

m I would have called back again before I travelled if I were going away or if it had got worse.

SydneySage · 23/10/2022 09:26

Part of my job involves being on the phone, sometimes for hours at a time, so I have to jam my earphones right into my ears and turn the volume up full, and by the end of my shift (I work very late at night) I’m doubly exhausted from the effort of straining to hear anything

obviously you haven't had a good experience, but seriously why didn't you go off sick? Are you cleaning or replacing your headphones at the end of each use? If not,you are making it worse.

Secondly you have to jam my earphones right into my ears and turn the volume up full that really can't be good for you

TroysMammy · 23/10/2022 09:26

Sorry you are unwell but it's not the Receptionists fault, they do not triage. They merely take messages to pass into the GP. The GP triage and do what they want to do.

siyanasaysrelax · 23/10/2022 09:26

I know the answer to the workforce problem!

pay them less! That’ll work!!

committees.parliament.uk/committee/81/health-and-social-care-committee/news/172310/persistent-understaffing-of-nhs-a-serious-risk-to-patient-safety-warn-mps/

WimbyAce · 23/10/2022 09:24

Our surgery also offers us an online system where you can write down your problem and then the gp will determine a phone call or in person appt. I had a mental health problem recently and they were very good at getting me seen and helped fairly quickly so it's not all bad.

siyanasaysrelax · 23/10/2022 09:23

waterSpider · 23/10/2022 09:17

We pay GPs shedloads of money, but the 'cult' of the NHS stops people making criticisms because we should be grateful. Latest data from NHS Digital shows that GPs contracted to the NHS earning an average of £142,000, and that's after their practice expenses.

England
The estimated average income before tax of GPs in either a General Medical Services or a Primary Medical Services practice was:
£111,900 for combined (contractor and salaried) GPs
£142,000 for contractor GPs
digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/gp-earnings-and-expenses-estimates/2020-21

And yet there is a massive shortage and GPs are leaving in droves?

how do those salaries compare to what GPs get on the continent, Canada or the Antipodes?

in addition, why do you think GPs should not be remunerated on a par with eg company directors/lawyers?

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 23/10/2022 09:22

waterSpider · 23/10/2022 09:17

We pay GPs shedloads of money, but the 'cult' of the NHS stops people making criticisms because we should be grateful. Latest data from NHS Digital shows that GPs contracted to the NHS earning an average of £142,000, and that's after their practice expenses.

England
The estimated average income before tax of GPs in either a General Medical Services or a Primary Medical Services practice was:
£111,900 for combined (contractor and salaried) GPs
£142,000 for contractor GPs
digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/gp-earnings-and-expenses-estimates/2020-21

So about the same amount per year we'll be paying Truss for the rest of her career for screwing up the country for 40 days.... what's your point exactly?

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 23/10/2022 09:20

VeronicaFranklin · 23/10/2022 09:15

As much as GP receptionists get bad rep, they are trained to triage people using set criteria and that is what the receptionist will have done, hence she scheduled a phone call with a dr.

I personally don't see that this falls on the receptionist she did her job, it comes down to the fact GP's are not pulling their weight to support the failing NHS and hence people with mild conditions are ending up in A&E because GPs are not triaging, conducting F2F apts etc, the whole system is failing, it's only a matter of time before it's fully privatised it cannot continue as it is.

I agree your GP should have seen you F2F, it's all a massive farce.

I've found kicking off (which I dislike doing) helps, a little. Sometimes they'll just try getting away with fobbing you off. You have to stand your ground, demand better care...as sad as that is.

I recently had some terrible maternity care from my GP (not prescribing correct medication, no F2F etc) and I complained, they jumped all over it. Now if I ever call...I seem to be offered a F2F appointment.

Sad times.

What do you regard as 'pulling their weight' then? How many extra patients do you expect them to see? How much of their life do you think they should spend in their surgery? How much of their own physical and mental health should they sacrifice? I'd love for the people that seem so sure that the NHS is only failing because of 'lazy GPs' to actually quantify this.... Maybe GPs should provide video evidence of what they actually do and how many extra hours they do and how under pressure not to cause serious harm to somebody they actually are. I guarantee it still wouldn't be enough...

WimbyAce · 23/10/2022 09:20

I would have phoned them again tbh if it was that bad. I am not sure why you didn't do this if you were going away on a trip.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 23/10/2022 09:20

But why didn’t you take the antibiotics from 111? You’ve not had the best experience but you’ve also made it harder for yourself too

MolkosTeenageAngst · 23/10/2022 09:19

You should have sought help on Friday/ over the weekend when it got worse. It’s not the GP’s fault that you were in France and had to wait until Monday.

Wearing earphones in your ear at top volume won’t be helping. Get some over the ear headphones or take time off work sick to recover, surely it’s common sense that if you have an ear infection the last thing you should be doing is putting anything into the ear until it’s healed.

waterSpider · 23/10/2022 09:17

We pay GPs shedloads of money, but the 'cult' of the NHS stops people making criticisms because we should be grateful. Latest data from NHS Digital shows that GPs contracted to the NHS earning an average of £142,000, and that's after their practice expenses.

England
The estimated average income before tax of GPs in either a General Medical Services or a Primary Medical Services practice was:
£111,900 for combined (contractor and salaried) GPs
£142,000 for contractor GPs
digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/gp-earnings-and-expenses-estimates/2020-21

88milesanhour · 23/10/2022 09:16

tunthebloodyalarmoff · 23/10/2022 08:51

Our doctors always put you in for a phone call sometimes it with a nurse. The receptionist is so rude and horrible they just do anything to avoid seeing you. GPs just arnt doing much atall which puts more pressure on the hospitals they get paid shit loads for doing not much. How can they diagnose properly on the phone it's ridiculous. I hope you get well soon

I would never be so utterly arrogant as to say that somebody who's job I've never done or even shadowed is 'not doing much' It's this kind of attitude that's causing doctors to leave in their drones. It's honestly like being in an abusive relationship. They will never be good enough to keep this failing system and they will be gaslighted to believe it's their fault when it does fail

siyanasaysrelax · 23/10/2022 09:16

What’s the solution guys?

if GPs are lazy and being paid too much why is there such a shortage? (I’m not a GP btw).

VeronicaFranklin · 23/10/2022 09:15

As much as GP receptionists get bad rep, they are trained to triage people using set criteria and that is what the receptionist will have done, hence she scheduled a phone call with a dr.

I personally don't see that this falls on the receptionist she did her job, it comes down to the fact GP's are not pulling their weight to support the failing NHS and hence people with mild conditions are ending up in A&E because GPs are not triaging, conducting F2F apts etc, the whole system is failing, it's only a matter of time before it's fully privatised it cannot continue as it is.

I agree your GP should have seen you F2F, it's all a massive farce.

I've found kicking off (which I dislike doing) helps, a little. Sometimes they'll just try getting away with fobbing you off. You have to stand your ground, demand better care...as sad as that is.

I recently had some terrible maternity care from my GP (not prescribing correct medication, no F2F etc) and I complained, they jumped all over it. Now if I ever call...I seem to be offered a F2F appointment.

Sad times.

Cantthinkofanewnameatm · 23/10/2022 09:05

GP service in this country isn’t fit for purpose. This level of service would be unacceptable in any other country I’ve lived in ( Europe, ME and Africa, comes to something when I say I witnessed better, faster medical care in a developing African country than England)
I ended up in A&E as a GP ( who’d never met me) instructed me to take the wrong level of medication. When my complaint was “ investigated” ( read whitewashed) she blamed the receptionist for not giving her the correct information, even tho I had during the phone call. I wouldn’t stand for this shit show from a vet, my dog gets better health care than I do.

CluelessAtClothing · 23/10/2022 09:03

I voted YABU as you did several things wrong, 1 accept telephone appointment in the first place, 2 wait so long and go on holiday etc when clearly still ill and in pain, continue to wait til your husband had to call 111, decline anti biotics from the 111 doctor and go to see the GP again?? What was the point in that. Also not go and get checked up again when it's clearly not improving. You have to stand up for yourself these days and you failed to do any of that. No ones fault but your own sorry.

WeAreTheHeroes · 23/10/2022 09:02

@cosmiccosmos - the balance of power is with the doctors though so if there are limited appointments it doesn't matter how many times reception staff complain, it's not going to change things.

OP I would have started the conversation telling the receptionist the 111 Dr had said I needed a face to face appointment. No pussyfooting around.

FixTheBone · 23/10/2022 09:01

PinkPrettyAndPointed · 23/10/2022 02:15

Honestly, how anyone can actually support the NHS is beyond me. It's an utter disgrace. Not being able to see your GP face to face?!

I couldn't believe that I could only visit one doctors surgery, that I had to register with and get approved.

Honestly, the alternative isn't the US system.

Hope you feel better soon OP, that is just shit service 💐

Not sure anyone is defending then NHS as it is today, after almost 13 years of systematic programmes to defund and impose top down management culture....

I suspect people are supporting the idea of what it could be, appropriately resourced and managed.

And before anybody parrots the 'how much money do you want to throw at it' maybe do some research and see that we spend comparatively little compared to our gdp per capita. Furthermore, nobody has ever managed to explain to me how any other system makes the total cost less? It just moves expense around so that instead of everyone paying based on their means, everyone pays a bit less and the shortfall is shifted to service users, which is disproportionately people who can't afford any Co pay type options, so the bill gets picked up by the state anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread