Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is what happens when receptionists are the ones who decide whether or not you actually *see* a GP? (Ear infection)

416 replies

lCantHearYou · 23/10/2022 02:05

Wednesday last week- woke up with an intense pain in my left ear, and assume I’ve just jammed my ear plug in a bit too far, but over an hour later the pain is still there and I can’t hear out of that ear, so I ring the GP surgery.

The receptionist, based on no medical expertise whatsoever, asks what the problem is and unilaterally decides that all I need is a telephone appointment. The GP she’s scheduled the call with is well known in our community for not doing face to face appointments if she can help it and generally having the attitude of just wanting to get you off the phone as quickly as possible.

Later that morning, GP call. I explain that I’ve been having this very intense pain for several hours now that paracetamol isn’t really touching, my ear is ringing very loudly and all external sound is very muffled and barely audible.

She decides over the course of the 3 minute call that since I’m recovering from a cold I’m probably just a bit congested, tells me to take some Sudafed/other decongestant and paracetamol and it should right itself in a few days.

I start alternating pseudoephedrine, paracetamol and ibuprofen, but the pain wakes me in the night every night.

Thursday evening DH, the DC and I travel up to PILs house.

Friday morning, DH and I leave for a long weekend abroad (on the Eurostar, thank god we didn’t fly or I’d probably have at least one ruptured ear drum).

By Friday evening the pain and hearing loss has now spread into the right ear as well. Spend the whole weekend in pain and practically deaf, which kind of spoils things somewhat.

Monday evening, we all get home. 3:00 am I wake up in so much pain I can’t keep still, DH wakes to the sight of me sitting upright, rocking back and forth with my hands clamped over the back of my head. He calls 111 who schedule a phonecall with a Dr… who rings back 3 and a half hours later and says, sounds like an infection, I can prescribe antibiotics or you can just wait and see your own GP. I opt to see my own GP, so 111 Dr puts in notes that I need a face to face appointment.

So we’re back on the phone to the surgery, to the receptionist who’s halfway through saying “I can schedule a phonecall…” when I tell her about 111 Dr’s advice to seek a face to face appointment. Then she relents and schedules one with a different GP to the one I spoke to the week before. At the actual appointment, this GP barely needs to glance in my ears before saying it’s a severe infection, inner ears are very sore and red, lots of pus and gunk and, in her words, “looks incredibly painful”.

I’ve now been on amoxicillin and cocodamol (which I’m alternating with ibuprofen) for 5 days now. I can still barely hear a thing beyond the very loud ringing and the sound of my own pulse throbbing in my ears. All external sound is very muffled and distorted. If I wait too long between taking pain meds I fucking know about it… I’ve taken to sleeping with the cocodamol under my pillow so that when (not if) the pain wakes me in the night I don’t have to grope around on my bedside table to find them. Part of my job involves being on the phone, sometimes for hours at a time, so I have to jam my earphones right into my ears and turn the volume up full, and by the end of my shift (I work very late at night) I’m doubly exhausted from the effort of straining to hear anything.

AIBU to think that if, on that first day, the receptionist or indeed the GP had paused for a moment and thought “hmmm, intense inner ear pain, badly affected hearing, maybe get her in so we can see if there’s an infection”, then I could have started on antibiotics that day and at the very least the infection would likely have been contained to one ear and might even be starting to get better? As it is the receptionist didn’t bother, the GP didn’t bother, and instead of getting better it got considerably worse, the antibiotics are making fuck all difference and I’ve now had almost two weeks of intense pain and hearing loss for no good reason? And AIBU to be pretty pissed off about it?

Sorry for the twilight rant… I’ve just woken up feeling like the back of my skull is being squeezed. Again.

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 23/10/2022 10:51

Unseelie · 23/10/2022 09:53

I’d put in a formal complaint.

Why GP aren’t doing zoom calls (as private doctors are) so that they can physically see the symptoms beats me.

You can't look in the ear, listen to the chest etc

zoom calls need to be f2f appointments.

blame the GP here though, not the receptionist. last time I bumped into an admin person from my surgery, she was furious about GPs not seeing patients in person.

Whattheduck · 23/10/2022 10:47

Please don’t blame the receptionist
I work in a gp surgery and we are given telephone appointments and face to face appointments if the patient has a telephone call and the doctor decides that they need to be seen then they will be that day
We are asked to triage the patient and put in the appointment the problem so then the doctor decides with the telephone call appointments who is more likely to need to be seen face to face then they prioritize those calls so they can be seen ASAP if need be
If the doctor chooses not to see someone that’s their decision nothing to do with the receptionist
It’s always the receptionists that get the blame but at the end of the day we are only following the instructions of the partners and management we don’t make the rules

Belatedeyebrows · 23/10/2022 10:44

What a drama.
Should have got antibiotics from the doctor rather than wait.

siyanasaysrelax · 23/10/2022 10:36

FernlovingNodosaur · 23/10/2022 10:32

waterSpider Spot on. They, GP's should do the job to the best of their abilities, just like other workers much lower down on the pay and social scale are expected too, and that includes seeing the patient in the flesh to make the best possible diagnosis. Even so called mundane illnesses like ear infections can become life threatening.

At the end of the day doctors in this case GP's are simply people like everyone else and are just luckier to have a better IQ than the average person in the street. GP's themselves have decided to become doctors, they could use their inherited
skills and get a good job somewhere else, an option and privileged quite a few other workers don't have. They, themselves choose to take Hippocratic oath and with that decision comes the responsibility to their patients wellbeing and actually doing their basic job and not fobbing patients off via their receptionist.

As to the NHS GP shortages some one mentioned, oddly that very rarely happens in the private sector. I can get to speak to a doctor today with BUPA and see a consultant (very often a senior NHS consultant at that) normally within two weeks yet the situation for patient and doctor is exactly the same, apart from more money being involved.

and why do you think that is the case in the private sector @FernlovingNodosaur ? (by the way, the private consultants you see are also NHS consultants)

Walkaround · 23/10/2022 10:34

How completely ridiculous to blame the receptionist when you spoke to the GP. If the GP didn’t appear to feel the need to see you face to face, then why the hell do you think the receptionist should have forced the GP to see you face to face?! The receptionist will just be expected to follow a protocol given to them by the GP. You appear to want a receptionist to pretend to be a doctor themselves and go against protocol when they deem it medically necessary.

FernlovingNodosaur · 23/10/2022 10:32

waterSpider Spot on. They, GP's should do the job to the best of their abilities, just like other workers much lower down on the pay and social scale are expected too, and that includes seeing the patient in the flesh to make the best possible diagnosis. Even so called mundane illnesses like ear infections can become life threatening.

At the end of the day doctors in this case GP's are simply people like everyone else and are just luckier to have a better IQ than the average person in the street. GP's themselves have decided to become doctors, they could use their inherited
skills and get a good job somewhere else, an option and privileged quite a few other workers don't have. They, themselves choose to take Hippocratic oath and with that decision comes the responsibility to their patients wellbeing and actually doing their basic job and not fobbing patients off via their receptionist.

As to the NHS GP shortages some one mentioned, oddly that very rarely happens in the private sector. I can get to speak to a doctor today with BUPA and see a consultant (very often a senior NHS consultant at that) normally within two weeks yet the situation for patient and doctor is exactly the same, apart from more money being involved.

Livelovebehappy · 23/10/2022 10:32

I moved to my home 3 years ago and had to move GPS. I haven’t seen the inside of the surgery in that time, although I’ve had four telephone appointments for different issues. It’s literally like trying to get into a prison. There are signs all over the surgery door telling patients under no circumstances can they cross the threshold without a pre arranged appointment. You have to ring a door bell to speak with the receptionist. God knows what your punishment would be for breaking the rule. The GP surgeries appear to have enjoyed the process during lockdown so much that they’re continuing it, at the expense of patient safety, because they’re probably wfh and not having to mix with the plebs.

cptartapp · 23/10/2022 10:32

All other NHS services haven't routinely gone back to f2f. Our health visiting run baby clinics, physio and dietetic services off the top of my head.
GP's are as entitled as any other profession to work pt, particularly considering the nature of their job. Enforcing 'full time' working would result in a mass exodus and even more mistakes than there are now.
After working over twenty years in primary care I have never been so busy. Not just our own work, but picking up that from secondary care whose clinics such as those for phlebotomy or wound care have no capacity. We even get sent patients for treatment from employers with no occupational health service. 'See your GP' cop out.

Reallyreallyborednow · 23/10/2022 10:30

Everything you've described above can be explained by a staffing crisis not a staffing 'unwillingness to pull their weight'

IME it’s one leading to the other.

i used to work in a department with 22 staff.

one left, no funding for replacement, staff closed the gap and the sept ran on 21 staff.

another left. No funding to replace. Staff closed the gap, increased their workload and the dept ran on 20 staff.

bear in mind this is shift work so the fewer people the worse the working pattern, and the harder it becomes to take al/ml/sl.

then another member of staff left. No funding to replace. Now the staff start to burn out, can’t take a/l and still provide a full service.

i left when we got to 12 -yes that’s twelve- staff. The shifts were not maintainable, there was no one to cover leave, everyone was burned out. Not so much “not pulling their weight”, but each person pulling two peoples weight so yes, they did get annoyed and snippy when asked to take on yet another task.

my maternity ward “fully staffed” was 4 m/w to a 32 bed ward. With one usually off with sections etc.

the govt needs to stop throwing money in the general NHS direction which then gets spent on new it systems, committees to plan how to better run the nhs, and management to come up with those plans.

start with using that money to get more staff. Once units are staffed properly they’ll find a lot of these issues disappear.

Peanut61 · 23/10/2022 10:27

Urgh I did a post the other day about this.

im ok about phone appointments in very obvious cases.

however… when it comes to ear infections, kids or anything like that… we need to have face to face.

Im sorry, it just isn’t working like it should be and like it was before covid.

I went to my Gp last week with a kid after a dumb phone appointment and it was shut… I kid you not. It was empty as they had shut for “training” something they frequently do.

last few times I’ve been it’s been empty in waiting room. It’s almost like an intense reluctance to see people in person.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 23/10/2022 10:24

There have been LOADS of examples like this over the past 2 years @lCantHearYou I am really sorry you're suffering. Hope you feel well soon. Flowers

DEFINITELY a really stern email/letter to the practice manager though. Unfortunately, whilst there are some good GPs/HCPs out there, there are some who CBA to do much and should really not be in the job they're in. The covid/lockdown thing made some of them complacent and a bit slack. NOT ALL, before anyone starts! Just some.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/10/2022 10:19

SierraSapphire · 23/10/2022 06:59

This. Receptionists are only carrying out the instructions of the partners, but are often working in a hostile environment with little control over how things are run for not much more than minimum wage. It's interesting how they seem to come in for more stick and have a reputation of being obstructive more than the GPs who design the system.

It would help if the receptionist actually listened to what the patient tells them though. I went to A&E with a Bartholins cyst as I couldn't get through to my GP (I tried minor injuries first but they sent me to A&E before I'm accused of wasting NHS time). The next day the pain was worse so, rather than go back to A&E I managed to get through to my GP. I explained exactly what had happened and what was wrong but the appointment notes said 'some kind of cyst'. What's the point of telling them if they don't listen?!

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 23/10/2022 10:19

VeronicaFranklin · 23/10/2022 10:08

So in my opinion (which I'm entitled to, as you are yours)

They are not pulling their weight because:

  1. They are the only NHS service to not to have gone back to face to face appointments as routine. Resulting in incorrect triaging (as above) more misdiagnoses and more need for follow up or multiple appointments for same issues.
  2. My surgery closes everyday 1 hour over lunch time and every Thursday half day for 'training'. The hospital I work at, often do 12 hour shifts with less than 15 min break or sometimes none at all.
  3. Many of the patients sat in A&E are there because they were unable to access a routine healthcare appointment at their GP surgery, GPs working partime and taking bank shifts at private hospitals...
  4. My personal experience of my GP and Drs surgery over the last 18 months has been appalling. Including incorrect prescribing of medication, not reviewing my medical file prior to prescribing, not triaging my 2 week old baby appropriately ending in a hospital stay. When I questioned this, they tried to blame my midwife/health visitor anyone but themselves. Ultimately I challenged it and they eventually admitted fault.

Appreciate this is not all GP's so my blanket description was maybe a little unfair but I imagine there is not one person in my locality who hasn't queued number 80+ in a call for an hour trying to get an appointment only to then be told all appointment gone for the day.

Sadly NHS GP's will become a thing of the past and very much life NHS dentists most end up going private. The hospitals will be overrun and the NHS will collapse.

Happy Sunday!

  1. My last 2 specialist appointments were zoom calls

  2. Secondary care services are horrendously delayed. My dd has been waiting over a year to see a specialist and had to fight tooth and nail with the hosptital receptionists just to get her on this waiting list

  3. All doctors do training. It's an essential part of their job. Hospital doctors will take regular time out to do this as well you just don't see it

  4. Everything you've described above can be explained by a staffing crisis not a staffing 'unwillingness to pull their weight'

People that spout such nonsense have no idea what it does to GP's morale to hear it. It's really deflating when you're video calling your own child for the umpteenth time that week to say goodnight because you've not been able to tuck them in, or you're looking at your triage list literally in tears because you know you actually won't be able to see all these patients before midnight tonight and you're trying to decide which are safest to 'cut corners' with. None of this is GPs fault it's the people who fund all of this, by which I mean the government and the public, both of whom seem to want 5 star treatment but seem allergic to the tax that is needed to pay for it.

KrisAkabusi · 23/10/2022 10:18

I'm surprised the op is getting so much stick here. Surely if you have ear pain someone needs to actually look in it?

No. If the pain has just started, they'll tell you to wait as it might clear up itself. If it continues to develop, they can prescribe antibiotics. Which 111 offered, but for some bizarre reason, which she hasn't come back to explain, the OP refused. If she had taken those when first prescribed, things could be very different now.

Southwig22 · 23/10/2022 10:16

It sounds like a horrible experience and it does sound like you've suffered in pain for longer than you needed to.

Telephone appointments for issues where you clearly need to be assessed face to face are simply a further waste of NHS resources, so a really poor economy from the GP surgeries perspective.

That said, the majority of people who have earache, sore throats etc for a couple of hours don't need antibiotics and the conditions are self-limiting; if a GP gave everyone antibiotics in that situation we'd all be in a much worse position with resistance. The GP definitely should have given you advice on what to do if it gets worse, so you could have sought treatment sooner when it was clear it wasn't resolving itself.

Prescottdanni123 · 23/10/2022 10:15

@Tanfastic

But it is not the receptionist's fault if the doctors are encouraging phone consultations.

Holidayexpert · 23/10/2022 10:10

I have less and less faith in the NHS, and think it’s not fit for purpose. Embarrassed that people in the uk think it’s the best in the world. All of my friends bar none from European countries who live here think it’s shit!!

Sick to death of GP’s not doing f2f appointments because they can’t be arsed!
The whole system needs to be overhauled! Embarrassing that people were clapping a couple of years ago!

VeronicaFranklin · 23/10/2022 10:08

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 23/10/2022 09:20

What do you regard as 'pulling their weight' then? How many extra patients do you expect them to see? How much of their life do you think they should spend in their surgery? How much of their own physical and mental health should they sacrifice? I'd love for the people that seem so sure that the NHS is only failing because of 'lazy GPs' to actually quantify this.... Maybe GPs should provide video evidence of what they actually do and how many extra hours they do and how under pressure not to cause serious harm to somebody they actually are. I guarantee it still wouldn't be enough...

So in my opinion (which I'm entitled to, as you are yours)

They are not pulling their weight because:

  1. They are the only NHS service to not to have gone back to face to face appointments as routine. Resulting in incorrect triaging (as above) more misdiagnoses and more need for follow up or multiple appointments for same issues.
  2. My surgery closes everyday 1 hour over lunch time and every Thursday half day for 'training'. The hospital I work at, often do 12 hour shifts with less than 15 min break or sometimes none at all.
  3. Many of the patients sat in A&E are there because they were unable to access a routine healthcare appointment at their GP surgery, GPs working partime and taking bank shifts at private hospitals...
  4. My personal experience of my GP and Drs surgery over the last 18 months has been appalling. Including incorrect prescribing of medication, not reviewing my medical file prior to prescribing, not triaging my 2 week old baby appropriately ending in a hospital stay. When I questioned this, they tried to blame my midwife/health visitor anyone but themselves. Ultimately I challenged it and they eventually admitted fault.

Appreciate this is not all GP's so my blanket description was maybe a little unfair but I imagine there is not one person in my locality who hasn't queued number 80+ in a call for an hour trying to get an appointment only to then be told all appointment gone for the day.

Sadly NHS GP's will become a thing of the past and very much life NHS dentists most end up going private. The hospitals will be overrun and the NHS will collapse.

Happy Sunday!

BlueDiamondGlow · 23/10/2022 10:06

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 23/10/2022 06:28

When you'd had ear pain for a few hours, you probably didn't need antibiotics, and seeing the GP in person that day wouldn't have changed that. Most ear infections will get better in days without antibiotics, most will be viral.

You got worse, at that point seeing a doctor in person was worthwhile. You phoned up and this happened.

I agree with this. I think your GP might have been right at the time. You could have called back when it didn't get better?

Our GP only does phone consultations in first instance but will see you if necessary.

IWishICouldDance · 23/10/2022 10:01

Like my son it could have just been the tail end of a cold and cleared up itself without antibiotics.

IWishICouldDance · 23/10/2022 10:01

You rang the doctors after having an earache for an hour? It does sound rather ott. My 4 year old had an earache that woke him in the night last week, he was awake in our bed crying on off all night and it was still there that morning so he took the day off. There was gunk too. I said if he still had it the day after I'd ring the doctors. As it happens the earache was gone by the next night and the gunk cleared up a day or so later. Granted you clearly needed help in the end, but if

NotNiceButNecessary · 23/10/2022 10:00

THE major problem in the NHS is lack of staff. Sky ran this report recently saying that the number of people needed NOW is the equivalent of the city of Newcastle.

news.sky.com/story/amp/workforce-the-size-of-newcastle-needed-to-ease-gridlocked-health-and-care-system-12725940

The trouble is Britain’s social snobbery and political ideology has been allowed to get in the way of dire practical needs. No one can train into a system that requires huge lifelong debts: working people need part time work and regular hours to fit in with families. Work has to pay.

Hollyhead · 23/10/2022 09:59

Why did you let yourself get fobbed off? I certainly wouldn’t have given them the convenient excuse of telling them I was recovering from a cold. It’s almost like you went along with it to prove a point even though you knew you had a more serious problem.

Tanfastic · 23/10/2022 09:59

I'm surprised the op is getting so much stick here. Surely if you have ear pain someone needs to actually look in it?

In the height of covid I had something similar and receptionist said straight away I needed a face to face as doctor would need to look in my ear(s). how can they tell what is going on inside someone's ear without looking in it? What if the patient isn't very good at describing their symptoms over the phone?

Hangingoninthere88 · 23/10/2022 09:59

Swimmum1206 · 23/10/2022 09:48

Similar experience last week with DS who's 16. Over the summer he was extremely tired and weak (beyond normal for a teenager). As he is 16 he made an appointment with the GP and went alone. They sent him for blood tests after a 2 minute appointment. He had to phone for the results and was told all normal.

The tiredness and weakness has continued, to the extent he can't race ( he's a swimmer) and it's affecting every aspect of his life. He's also become dizzy and faint when he stands up.

Our surgery only does same day appointments. So on Friday I was at the surgery and requested an appointment for him. The receptionist offered him 11.00. When I said he was at school, could he have an afternoon appointment, she said as he was able to go to school, it's not an emergency, so he couldn't have an appointment!

After a lot of argument, he eventually got an appointment for after school.

The GP was great this time, but it turns out, he may have a heart condition and will have to go through a whole series of tests! If we had listened to the receptionist, this would have continued even longer.

It seems like you can't be working or at school to need an appointment at the doctors!

This was an entirely reasonable response from the receptionist. You were offered an emergency appointment and refused on the basis that you couldn't be arsed to remove your son from school which he wouldn't have been at btw if it was a genuine emergency...

Swipe left for the next trending thread