Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To wonder how a £36k a year education can meet DS’s needs if a £250k one can’t?

305 replies

GoneBatty · 23/10/2022 00:40

Private residential SEND college (out of area) costs £250k a year. They are saying DS’s needs are too high for them to manage.

Council are saying a £36k a year local outreach provision can meet his needs.

It’s all very fishy as SEND college at first said they felt they could meet DS’s needs so we visited, all was OK. As as soon as the council (who will have to fund it) got involved, college backtracked and said they couldn’t meet his needs.

They have given nonsensical reasons which I have mitigated numerous times. Both the college and council have told blatant lies and I’ve caught them out in two big ones!

Now we have reached Tribunal the college is suddenly full which was not an issue a few months ago so know they’re lying again as they would know numbers of students months in advance due to Tribunals and the time it take to get funding. Also most Tribunals due to take place over the summer were postponed for this age group.

AIBU to suspect the council has given the college a backhander to say they can’t meet his needs? It would cost council £750k for a 3 year program. They could have given a £100k ‘investment’ per se? Still saves a lot of money!

There is literally no other provision like this in the country. I have approached 21 other colleges, local and out of area. DS has had no proper provision for over a year and he is running out of time as age 20 - EHCP is to 25.

Do I sound nuts (I feel it)? Can this actually be possible?

OP posts:
Novum · 23/10/2022 10:42

Lizthelettuce · 23/10/2022 10:22

Well yes, they have to don’t they.

Say there is a budget of £100 and 10 pupils with SEND. There is local provision for £10 a head because that’s what the budget allows.

But then a private company pops up with superior provision for £30 a head.

Parents are going to fight for that aren't they. And yes, they can demonstrate 95% of the time that the provision is, indeed, superior. So they win the tribunal, the local authority have to pay the extra to the private company, and now the local provision is funded to the tune of £7 per head.

Then the next parent comes along, see that child A got the private provision, sees that it is superior to the local offer, and understandably fight the battle for their child and win as well.

Local provision now funded £4 a head.

The next child’s parents can’t afford a lawyer to take the LA to tribunal, so they get the £4 provision - tough shit. The LA HAVE to fight the next tribunal for THIS child. Tribunals only focus on the needs of the child under discussion. LAs have to meet the needs of ALL the children in their schools, and they know that a budget of £1 a head cannot possibly meet the needs of the rest of the children they cater for.

I don’t blame the parents. Everyone wants the best for their children. But if you want / need PUBLIC SERVICES to pay for your child’s education then you need to vote / campaign / protest for a government at local AND national levels who will PRIORITISE public services.

Local governments have to draw up their budget according to needs. If they budget at £10 a head knowing that there are bound to be children in their areas needing a much higher level of provision, they can't complain when their budget doesn't work. The economics just don't work the way you suggest.

It's not a matter of parents automatically fighting for superior provision. No parent goes into a tribunal fight just because they fancy an expensive placement. What they are fighting for is what their child actually needs, very often after years of their child falling behind because of failure to recognise their needs or provide for them properly.

Parents do NOT win tribunals because they demonstrate that what they want is superior. They win because they prove that it is able to meet their child's needs whereas the local authority offering can't.

The vast majority of SEND tribunal cases are won by parents without lawyers, so your picture of parents who can afford lawyers somehow being more privileged is seriously misleading. LAs don't HAVE to fight any tribunal - time and again they fight even when it is blatantly obvious that their decision is wrong and unlawful. If they didn't waste money defending indefensible decisions and themselves hiring lawyers, their budgets would stretch further.

pewtypie · 23/10/2022 10:42

Caroffee · 23/10/2022 10:40

Urgh. Why is the first person to post always the nastiest?

What’s nasty about it?

Caroffee · 23/10/2022 10:40

RoomOfRequirement · 23/10/2022 01:05

Of course they didn't pay them off!

Also £750,000 shouldn't ever be approved anyway. Ridiculous.

Urgh. Why is the first person to post always the nastiest?

x2boys · 23/10/2022 10:39

Lizthelettuce · 23/10/2022 10:34

Basically it’s like the health service, being drained dry by private providers.

You can’t really blame the providers because they’re fulfilling a need.

You can’t blame parents for wanting the best.

You SHOULD question why private providers were even needed in the first place.

And it would help to remember that every tribunal costs the public purse, with money taken directly from the SEND budget and the education of others. Please consider whether your child TRULY NEEDS the provision you are fighting for, and if so - campaign for political change.

Parents don't just fight for expensive provisions for their child on a whim ,they do so as they believe its the only place that can meet their childs needs ',stop trying to make parents of disabled childrren feel guilty for wanting the best for their child , I m guessing you don't have a disabled child ?

Lizthelettuce · 23/10/2022 10:39

Thatsnotmycar · 23/10/2022 10:28

Incorrect again. Parents don’t win tribunals because provision is superior. There is no right to the best education available, only one that is appropriate and reasonably required. If it was about a superior education the vast majority of appeals wouldn’t be upheld.

A lawyer isn’t required to win a Tribunal.

I think we both know that the key to a tribunal lies in the definition of ‘appropriate’ and ‘reasonable’, and a good lawyer can argue anything.

Morph22010 · 23/10/2022 10:38

Augend23 · 23/10/2022 07:16

But what the council does have an obligation to do (sharing the costs with the NHS in some cases) is provide appropriate health and social care for an individual.

For some individuals that can cost £10-£20k a week. That's a highly unusual amount but not absurd.

If someone lives in supported accomodation and has a 1-to-1 say, including waking nights, the cost of that could easily be £2k a week just in 1-to-1 staffing costs, plus the cost of the home itself - you could easily be looking at £150k a year before you look at education at all.

We don't know what this boy's needs are, and we don't know how likely it is that the college can get him to a point of living independently Vs the proposed outreach that the council is providing.

Depending on the child's needs and what staff it takes to manage his supported housing provision, the difference between current care costs and the cost of the education might not be as significant as it first appears. If it really does have the potential to ensure he can live independently it might save the system money in the long run.

I am fairly certain everyone is entitled to a personal budget for social care OP - could you ask for one, noting that you're currently happy for it to be "notional" i.e the council keeps paying but you have an awareness of cost so you can use that in the tribunal case.

Everyone is not entitled to a personal budget for social care, they are entitled to assessment. My son has an ehcp and is in socialist school but we don’t qualify for any social care

Thatsnotmycar · 23/10/2022 10:38

And it would help to remember that every tribunal costs the public purse, with money taken directly from the SEND budget and the education of others. Please consider whether your child TRULY NEEDS the provision you are fighting for, and if so - campaign for political change.

Wow! Perhaps LAs should consider this before forcing parents to appeal knowing full well they will lose the vast majority of cases and before spending large sums of money on representation to defend indefensible cases against unrepresented parents. No parent goes to tribunal unless they believe their child needs the provision. It’s hilarious you think they do.

Axahooxa · 23/10/2022 10:37

The cost of any of this is not OP’s concern- she’s not responsible for it.

she is clearly doing the very best for her son- and fighting stuff like this in this country, which has APPALLING provision for SEND in most places, is exhausting and takes its toll.

Axahooxa · 23/10/2022 10:34

(Sorry if repeating pp)
Message the National autistic society ASAP. They’ll call you. Ive had brilliant help from them.

You’re absolutely right to keep being critically minded in all this and to continue to advocate for your child.

Lizthelettuce · 23/10/2022 10:34

Basically it’s like the health service, being drained dry by private providers.

You can’t really blame the providers because they’re fulfilling a need.

You can’t blame parents for wanting the best.

You SHOULD question why private providers were even needed in the first place.

And it would help to remember that every tribunal costs the public purse, with money taken directly from the SEND budget and the education of others. Please consider whether your child TRULY NEEDS the provision you are fighting for, and if so - campaign for political change.

LaGioconda · 23/10/2022 10:34

Polkadotties · 23/10/2022 10:18

No I do not think that. The budgets are squeezed. Why should one person receive £750k worth of support when whole schools cannot provide adequate teaching assistant cover, when social carers cannot not their jobs properly as they are so stretched.

So why does the government's choice to underfund schools and social services provision mean that children with SEN and disabilities should suffer even more through lack of adequate support?

Luana1 · 23/10/2022 10:33

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 23/10/2022 10:23

Those outraged at the cost, what do you propose the council does with young people with disabilities? The costs here are typical of how much it costs to educate someone with complex needs. Are you suggesting disabled young people aren't provided with the care/education they need? What's your alternative?

I don't know what the alternative is but there are some councils across the country at risk of section 114s. The money just isn't there, and obviously £750k going on one person will leave less money for everyone else. In the OP's case the council are offering an alternative for her adult son - albeit a much less costly one, so it might not be ideal, but we as a society have got to be practical as to where public resources go so they can do the most amount of good for the most amount of people. It is tragic for individuals such as the OPs son, but that's what happens when the Tories are voted in for many consecutive years.

Thatsnotmycar · 23/10/2022 10:32

It is very difficult for local authorities and the government to decide where our money goes. You need the wisdom of Solomon. I don't envy them.

Or they could just follow the law…

Samcro · 23/10/2022 10:30

and I think that was a year

Samcro · 23/10/2022 10:29

sn college if residential is massively expensive, dds was about 200 thousand.
but the difference it made to her was worth every penny.

Xenia · 23/10/2022 10:29

It is very difficult for local authorities and the government to decide where our money goes. You need the wisdom of Solomon. I don't envy them.

Thatsnotmycar · 23/10/2022 10:28

Lizthelettuce · 23/10/2022 10:22

Well yes, they have to don’t they.

Say there is a budget of £100 and 10 pupils with SEND. There is local provision for £10 a head because that’s what the budget allows.

But then a private company pops up with superior provision for £30 a head.

Parents are going to fight for that aren't they. And yes, they can demonstrate 95% of the time that the provision is, indeed, superior. So they win the tribunal, the local authority have to pay the extra to the private company, and now the local provision is funded to the tune of £7 per head.

Then the next parent comes along, see that child A got the private provision, sees that it is superior to the local offer, and understandably fight the battle for their child and win as well.

Local provision now funded £4 a head.

The next child’s parents can’t afford a lawyer to take the LA to tribunal, so they get the £4 provision - tough shit. The LA HAVE to fight the next tribunal for THIS child. Tribunals only focus on the needs of the child under discussion. LAs have to meet the needs of ALL the children in their schools, and they know that a budget of £1 a head cannot possibly meet the needs of the rest of the children they cater for.

I don’t blame the parents. Everyone wants the best for their children. But if you want / need PUBLIC SERVICES to pay for your child’s education then you need to vote / campaign / protest for a government at local AND national levels who will PRIORITISE public services.

Incorrect again. Parents don’t win tribunals because provision is superior. There is no right to the best education available, only one that is appropriate and reasonably required. If it was about a superior education the vast majority of appeals wouldn’t be upheld.

A lawyer isn’t required to win a Tribunal.

Lizthelettuce · 23/10/2022 10:27

@Mochachocolatte I recognise this to an extent, but they have no choice, read my post above.

Mochachocolatte · 23/10/2022 10:27

@Lizthelettuce that isn't how tribunals work. They won't just grant the parents the more expensive school if the LAs offer is good enough. The reason LAs lose so many appeals is because they are trying to place children in settings that do not meet their needs.

AntlerRose · 23/10/2022 10:26

The health and care bit of an ehcp is often the expensive bit.

Spikeyball · 23/10/2022 10:24

"Why should one person receive £750k worth of support when whole schools cannot provide adequate teaching assistant cover, when social carers cannot not their jobs properly as they are so stretched."

So what do you propose to do with people with complex needs?

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 23/10/2022 10:23

Those outraged at the cost, what do you propose the council does with young people with disabilities? The costs here are typical of how much it costs to educate someone with complex needs. Are you suggesting disabled young people aren't provided with the care/education they need? What's your alternative?

Mochachocolatte · 23/10/2022 10:23

Plus an EHCP up to 25 should only be in place if a learner can make academic progress and achieve qualifications . It isnt about providing care

Fuck me. EHCP - Education, Health and Care Plan.

hiredandsqueak · 23/10/2022 10:23

I wouldn't be surprised if there have been "talks" Put in a SAR to both the college and the LA to find out what has been said. Hopefully they are more scrupulous than our LA and a school they wanted to place my daughter in though as despite two SARs, complaint to ICO, internal investigation by monitoring officer and the LA's senior legal advisor all ordering that the communication be released to me I have still never seen the communication between school and LA that determined that my academically able dd would be well placed in a school for pupils with MLD and SLD and no GCSE curricculum.

Thatsnotmycar · 23/10/2022 10:22

BounceBackBoris · 23/10/2022 09:11

Plus an EHCP up to 25 should only be in place if a learner can make academic progress and achieve qualifications . It isnt about providing care

Incorrect. Case law demonstrates obtaining qualifications isn’t a requirement for education to be provided and an EHCP to continue. Academic progress is only one part of an EHCP. And even when all further progress is only small the young person is still entitled to an education and EHCP.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.