Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you prefer to keep your finances private?

111 replies

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:22

For some reason I do not like talking about money. I don't like to tell anyone how much me and dh earn, even my dc. Teenage ds has asked a few times what we earn and I just say it's for me to know. I'm not keen on being asked how much I've paid for things either.

I just feel that it's private but also that it's a bit vulgar.

Dhs parents are always telling us the ins and outs of sil finances (husbands sister). How much they earn, details of what their savings and outgoings are, every detail. I am surprised that not only they know so much but that they keep relating it back to us.

OP posts:
mewkins · 23/10/2022 08:08

I think it's a good idea to talk about money with your kids and it's a bit weird to be secretive about it. At the moment there is SO much talk about cost of living that I imagine they are seeking reassurance that the family is ok.

I really don't understand not discussing politics. Again, with children it is SO important that you can all discuss what is happening before our very eyes! But also with wider family. Also, op you don't have to live by the rules you were brought up with. No one will strike you down I'd you decide on new rules or throw our rules altogether.

imnotthatkindofmum · 23/10/2022 07:55

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:22

For some reason I do not like talking about money. I don't like to tell anyone how much me and dh earn, even my dc. Teenage ds has asked a few times what we earn and I just say it's for me to know. I'm not keen on being asked how much I've paid for things either.

I just feel that it's private but also that it's a bit vulgar.

Dhs parents are always telling us the ins and outs of sil finances (husbands sister). How much they earn, details of what their savings and outgoings are, every detail. I am surprised that not only they know so much but that they keep relating it back to us.

I'm with you to an extent. Dh and I talk about money in front of the kids, they understand when times are tight (mostly these days) they understand why their grandparents have a higher disposable income than us but they also know how eye rolly I am about my sisters constant dialogue about her income.

My sister has OCD. Probably on the spectrum (not in a Mumsnet "have you thought about autism" way but actually quite likely given family history and how it presents in our family) she uses a budgeting app obsessively (not a bad thing) and kind of scripts her situation to people. I know exactly what her husband earns and her and her mortgage what she spends on shopping, her electricity bill etc etc. I never share that detail with her. Having said that I do talk about "not sure how we'll afford" "will need to get a car loan" etc etc so it's not total lockdown on money issues.

She used to work for us in a book keeping capacity so she has an idea of our income (and how it's depleted!) but I'd never actively discuss it with her.

My parents don't know what we earn. Our friends don't know what we earn. They don't need to know that. I do know what my best friend earns because she discussed it with me when she applied for the job. It's definitely not a "need to know" thing though.

ArcticSkewer · 23/10/2022 07:53

The word vulgar is a clue
It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.
Wage transparency might lead to demands for wage fairness, and then where would we be!
You can apply the same 'vulgar' rule to many things in the UK. It's a very divided and class based country

Fairislefandango · 23/10/2022 07:46

The idea that it's vulgar to discuss money or politics with family or friends is very stuffy and old-fashioned imo. And anyone who is being asked about how much they earn in a nosy, intrusive way by 'leeches' needs to stop spending time with awful people.

MintJulia · 23/10/2022 07:34

I'm with you OP. Talking about money with anyone outside the family except your boss or your financial advisor, risks sounding like either boasting or complaining.

And discussing it in specific terms with your children is risky too. By telling them you are loaded, it will get around the play ground and risk bullying, burglaries etc.

I discuss budgets with my ds(14) so he understands the pressures and the value of money but being discreet is just common sense.

Swedishmeatball · 23/10/2022 07:25

Vulgar to discuss income. But then we and all our friends (apart from doctor friends on nhs bands) are high earners in the private sector and it would be absolutely jaw dropping if anyone even intimated how much they earned. Even the Dr friends would never mention how much they earned in private practice or how much they had in their pension.

Holidays are carefully discussed - a friend, when pressed by me as I was trying to figure out if it would work for us, disclosed that their family half term holiday was £20k. I thanked her for helping me cross it off my list for next year!

We try and keep our DC vaguely aware, mostly so they understand what jobs earn what and how much they would need to earn to afford private school fees, holidays abroad, nice house etc.

OneCup · 23/10/2022 07:19

We talk about finances ( and politics) a lot at home. I think it's important to plan for the future and to educate our children.
Boasting about wages to the ' outside world' would be vulgar.
Having a transparent pay structure at work is important I think

PriOn1 · 23/10/2022 07:17

Having worked in one country where nobody discussed wages, where I twice accidentally discovered I was being paid way worse than my male counterparts, and another country, where wages are on a scale and openly discussed so I know exactly where I stand, I prefer the latter. I guess if you’re the one raking it in and great at negotiation, then you’d much prefer the former.

CrispsAreYummy · 23/10/2022 07:11

DH and I are only open with one another but that’s it. Other people ask us things like how much do you earn/how much was that holiday etc and we just say we don’t want to discuss it. My mum’s terrible for it 😂 I would be mortified to ask someone how much they earned. If they want to tell me then fine but i’m not asking 🤷‍♀️

Worthyornot · 22/10/2022 22:15

sjxoxo · 22/10/2022 22:05

It is wierd that you won’t even tell your kids about your finances. Be very careful that you aren’t so silent on it that they learn zilch about money and how to manage it. My parents were very quiet on money, never talked about it. My brother has terrible terrible debt and very bad decision making as he knows F all about how consumer money can work. Don’t make that mistake! X

I never knew what my parents earned, and don't live in debt. Hmm.
Fine to discuss budgeting, but no need to go into specifics about how much you earn.

stargirl1701 · 22/10/2022 22:12

No. I am a teacher. My salary is public knowledge. Right here: https://www.eis.org.uk/pay-and-conditions-of-service/salary-scales

I don't 'get' secrecy about finance. I'm sure it's a public sector thing.

Worthyornot · 22/10/2022 22:05

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/10/2022 21:43

It's no-one else's business what me and DP earn, anyone asking will be firmly shut down

This. It's not anyone's business. In fact it will bring more leeches to you if you earn alot.

sjxoxo · 22/10/2022 22:05

It is wierd that you won’t even tell your kids about your finances. Be very careful that you aren’t so silent on it that they learn zilch about money and how to manage it. My parents were very quiet on money, never talked about it. My brother has terrible terrible debt and very bad decision making as he knows F all about how consumer money can work. Don’t make that mistake! X

ivykaty44 · 22/10/2022 22:04

I would talk about money with adult children, but not if I thought anyone was spreading round my business

other than that it’s not talked about

Oblomov22 · 22/10/2022 22:01

I think it's good time talk about finances. We do with ds1 and ds2. It's not vulgar. You don't need to tell friends your exact salary. Most people know. Roughly. With close friends we once discussed how one mum had been on a fabulous cheap family all inclusive, and we all talked about how We'd all previously spent quite a few £k going to a previous destination and that we wouldn't now do that.

BackToWhereItAllBegan · 22/10/2022 21:51

We talk with our DS17 about our finances, salary etc. I think it's important for him to understand the general cost of living this lifestyle, how mortgages and various types of investments work and have a good grasp of the costs of insurances, utilities and other household expenses.
I NEVER discuss finances outside of the home and find it incredibly awkward when other people do bring up their salaries but that's my problem to get over, not theirs!

girlmom21 · 22/10/2022 21:47

I don't talk to family and friends about what I or DP earn or what our house costs but I have no problem with discussing what individual new items cost.

CoffeeHungry · 22/10/2022 21:47

I wish my parents were more open about the cost of living as we were growing up. It was a shock to me when I moved out and all my bills on top of rent more than doubled how much my rent was! I have teenage siblings and often I chat to them about cost of living, how much this and that costs, i take them food shopping with me often so they see how much just my weekly shop is, tell them to save what they can now and advise them to budget for the month, looking ahead, ones recently learned to drive and had a big unexpected car expense so he's learned his lesson to budget for the future in the same conversation I discussed how much he earned (in a simular field to my partner)and spoke about how much my partner earns currently and what steps it took him to get where he is and maybe he needs to look else where for more opportunities to earn more as he's on pittance working self employed for a bloke who's never gave him a pay rise and the work isant the most reliable.

luckylavender · 22/10/2022 21:45

It is vulgar to talk about money

Angelinia · 22/10/2022 21:44

I'm very open about my finances but I'm comfortable being so open - I don't think there are many benefits to being secretive and money is at risk of being a taboo subject, but I'd definitely respect other's privacy and I never pry!

Irridescantshimmmer · 22/10/2022 21:44

Finances are strictly private and confidential.

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/10/2022 21:43

It's no-one else's business what me and DP earn, anyone asking will be firmly shut down

prinnycessa · 22/10/2022 21:41

It depends - I don't discuss finances with my family at all, that's just how we are. Also, I'm mindful for various reasons, for judgment or expectations as a result.

I do with some friends. Some are more comfortable than others and vice versa. It depends on the relationship and whether our financial situations are similar. It's good to be mindful.

I do discuss salaries with colleagues as it's good to know so we can each negotiate and advocate for ourselves. As women we historically haven't done this as much and have had lower pay as a result. I think people are more open to it now so that the transparency will ensure they are fairly paid.

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:33

Yes I'm the same about politics too. Another topic at the dinner table with in laws. I was always brought up not to discuss it.

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 22/10/2022 21:32

And I’m sure secrecy around income and financial priorities is behind most of the tedious MN threads about “SIL and BIL are constantly buying new stuff and going on holiday and having work done to their house but I don’t see how this is possible unless they are committing benefit fraud and making money from drug dealing and in loads of debt because their jobs are X and Y and can’t be that well paid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread