Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you prefer to keep your finances private?

111 replies

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:22

For some reason I do not like talking about money. I don't like to tell anyone how much me and dh earn, even my dc. Teenage ds has asked a few times what we earn and I just say it's for me to know. I'm not keen on being asked how much I've paid for things either.

I just feel that it's private but also that it's a bit vulgar.

Dhs parents are always telling us the ins and outs of sil finances (husbands sister). How much they earn, details of what their savings and outgoings are, every detail. I am surprised that not only they know so much but that they keep relating it back to us.

OP posts:
Lionesscubmum · 23/10/2022 08:58

Good points about discussing these things with children and budgeting etc.

Contradicting myself a bit here but I do discuss bills and house prices, saving up and the general cost of living with the teenager just not my salary, I m not actually quite sure why. I think it's because I want him to do the very best he can rather than thinking that his parents are alright doing such and such jobs. It won't be as easy for the next generation.

OP posts:
Woolandwonder · 23/10/2022 08:49

I'd say I'm not secretive but also only very open with some people. My parents know quite a bit, eg. I'm a first time buyer they know what our budget is and how much deposit we have etc. I'm not sure if they know how much we earn exactly but probably have a good idea, same with my best friend. Other people I'm more vague with although me and dp both work for the nhs so easy to know how much we earn due to banding and also we rent and people know we want to buy so have an idea that we aren't rolling in it.

Thatslife1 · 23/10/2022 08:40

100% agree!! No one needs to know x

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 23/10/2022 08:39

I talk in detail with my teenagers about what I earn, bills, investments, mortgages etc. DS1 is now in Uni and he and I discussed how he would budget and how I manage my money. He sorted out all the utilities etc for his student house in the 2nd year. Heck, I even referred him to the same energy co we use (which was the best option for them) so we each got a referral fee off our next bill.
I also talk to women in my industry about what I earn as I have had a few battles over unfair pay levels compared to male colleagues.

sandgrown · 23/10/2022 08:38

I discuss budgeting etc with my teenage DS. My adult DD is better at it than me! I work in public sector so it’s easy to see what I earn. I don’t mind discussing what things cost but I don’t discuss my finances with family and friends . When my ex lost his job I worked lots of extra hours to keep us afloat and was offended by his constant whinging to anyone who would listen how he couldn’t afford anything . I hated him discussing our private business.

bercan · 23/10/2022 08:35

The word vulgar is a clue
It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.

Agree it's also largely people who earn a lot &/or come from a privilege background who think it's vulgar. I guess it makes it easier to maintain the status quo?

flamingogold · 23/10/2022 08:35

I'm generally pretty open. My salary is graded and has to be approved by a committee so it's easy enough to say the grade if it's relevant. It's also pretty easy to tell from other advertised salaries at my employer.

dudsville · 23/10/2022 08:35

When i was a kid my Dad said never to look in a man's wallet. I grew up looking away when anyone got their purse or wallet out and never discussed money. I would have liked to understand home finances. After they divorced mum and i were exceptionally poor. She worked such long hours but i didn't understand how wages didn't equate to hours or effort and how was it possible to work 6x12hr days and not be able to buy me new trainers. It's an educational opportunity like no other.

Givenhud · 23/10/2022 08:34

I'm quite happy to talk about the nitty gritty of finances with anyone who wants to know. I literally had no clue about how to budget or save growing up (and I was more of less living alone by 16 due to parents moving abroad).

I ended up in debt as I had no idea that you should save some of your salary towards car repairs etc. I was running a car but no one thought to tell me that there will be unexpected costs that come with this. I think I started to think about money a bit more when I read a Sophie Kinsella book about a character in debt. No one ever talked about how much they earned and everyone seemed to have these City type jobs where they were competing to pay the bill so how could I ever learn? I read magazines like Red where it seemed to be normal to spend £500 on a handbag!

Now I'm thankful for social media and people who share, even anonymously how much they earn and what they do with it. We don't have any debt other than the mortgage now and thanks to those money accounts I follow, we invest for the children and ourselves, we overpay the mortgage, have well funded pensions, we have general savings and budget for things like car repairs.

I'll tell anyone who is interested what we do with our money. It's the only way people can learn.

hoowhoo · 23/10/2022 08:33

How will your kids know what a good wage is if it's not discussed? That kind of thinking enables the gender pay gap.Financial literacy is v important and a life skill.

AloysiusBear · 23/10/2022 08:33

Openness about finances generally benefits people. A culture of secrecy benefits companies.

Open people compare prices, therefore are less likely to be ripped off, they will force companies to compete on price. People who are not open will often end up as loyal customers who pay over the odds to the same business repeatedly.

Open people discuss pay with peers, find out when they are underpaid and address it. People who are private about it don't find out that their colleague bob negotiated a 5k pay rise

DontMakeMeShushYou · 23/10/2022 08:32

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 23/10/2022 08:14

This.

Absolutely this.

bercan · 23/10/2022 08:31

I don't really understand why some people are so secretive or hung up about money. I think it's good to be transparent with dc & the whole world can see what I paid for my house anyway 🤷🏻‍♀️

Darbs76 · 23/10/2022 08:27

If someone asks me I’ll tell them but none of my close friends (old school friends) have asked me but one knows I’m a higher tax rate payer as I complained to one last year about overtime putting me into the 40% and I’ve had a promotion since. I don’t know what my friends earn. My local friend knows as when I told her I was applying for a job on promotion she asked what the salary was. So yeah I don’t have any objections to talking about it but I’m rarely asked. My kids know what I earn.

MeanderingGently · 23/10/2022 08:24

It's a weird British thing that says it's "vulgar" to talk about finances/salaries, or how much the mortgage is etc. I don't understand it myself.

It was very refreshing in Norway to see that people's earnings and the amount of tax they paid is public knowledge. It's called "skatteetaten" and you can search anyone's salary, how much they earn and how much tax they've paid. I think you get 500 free searches, you can check your family, friends, neighbours and the boss if you so wish.

However, you can also see who has checked your salary, and searches do show who has checked. I like the transparency of it all (I make no secret of my own finances, there is nothing 'private' about it all). It also has the effect of ensuring everyone pays their taxes....who wants to be publicly seen as a tax dodger?!

Rabidturnip · 23/10/2022 08:22

I never discuss salary with colleagues however. For me, that is a no and always has been.

Rabidturnip · 23/10/2022 08:21

My parents were the same, very secretive. I never knew anything about what they earned ir what things cost. I think this did affect me in terms of how I handled money. They never sat down with me and gave pointers on how money should be allocated once you receive a wage. I don’t want the same for my DC. I want to show them how to manage your money properly and that includes sitting down every month and going through what goes where. I use a cash envelope system amd zero based budget and I wish I had known about it years ago.

Lopilo · 23/10/2022 08:20

If you want to be genteel and inoffensive, then you shouldn’t discuss money, politics, health, religion or sex (I’m sure there are many more). I am quite glad people don’t mind being vulgar, as I find all these topics interesting.

catbirddogchild · 23/10/2022 08:19

Money, politics and religion are not considered polite conversation are they.

HikingforScenery · 23/10/2022 08:16

luxxlisbon · 22/10/2022 21:25

No, I don’t agree that knowing what items cost is vulgar.
Our friends openly discuss pay rises, mortgages, investment plans, childcare costs, holiday recommendations, well priced wine tips etc.
I don’t see any issues with transparency.

I’ve never physically come across anyone in real life who does this. They wouldn’t be my friends, I suppose that’s why I don’t know anyone like that.

Anyone could see some people’s salaries because it’s public but the ins and outs of what you’re paying for this and that, why?
Id rather talk about something else

Reluctantadult · 23/10/2022 08:15

I think not discussing money and politics is really odd. They are the things that make the world go round, in many ways. In particular I can't understand not telling your own kids what you earn. I can't think of any situation where it would be bad for them to know that. Isn't it part of their education almost.

Woodsparrow · 23/10/2022 08:15

I'm very private about finances. My 7 yo daughter asks lots of questions, especially atm as we are moving house and I do explain things to her but each time I tell her it is information not to be told to anyone else. My mother is very nosey and I hate it

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 23/10/2022 08:14

ComtesseDeSpair · 22/10/2022 21:29

Broadly I think it’s good when people talk openly about income and money, particularly women: secrecy about pay has historically led to women being underpaid for the work they do because they don’t realise colleagues are being paid more or that their peers in other organisations receive higher pay. It’s also important for teaching young people about money management and financial planning. You can speak about income and how you spend your money without bragging about it.

This.

dizzygirl1 · 23/10/2022 08:12

To strangers I'm quite quiet but with my teenagers I tell them. I show them my budget, where all the money goes - its an eye opener for them. I'm separated from their dad so i do it even more for them to understand why I say no or I can't afford it.
How else do our young people learn how to budget, what bills, credit cards, loans, interest ar e? They aren't taught it at school, I wasn't taught it from my parents and I went crazy with debt on 'nothing'.
My opinion anyway 🤷‍♀️

AgentProvocateur · 23/10/2022 08:11

I think it’s important to talk about it with your older/adult children so they know how much it costs to maintain your lifestyle. I was shocked when I left home and had no idea how much bills etc were. It’s also good to let them know how much you save and how much you put in pensions each month.

Swipe left for the next trending thread