Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you prefer to keep your finances private?

111 replies

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:22

For some reason I do not like talking about money. I don't like to tell anyone how much me and dh earn, even my dc. Teenage ds has asked a few times what we earn and I just say it's for me to know. I'm not keen on being asked how much I've paid for things either.

I just feel that it's private but also that it's a bit vulgar.

Dhs parents are always telling us the ins and outs of sil finances (husbands sister). How much they earn, details of what their savings and outgoings are, every detail. I am surprised that not only they know so much but that they keep relating it back to us.

OP posts:
MysteriousMonkey · 23/10/2022 10:11

I'm easy either way. I don't openly discuss my money but am honest if asked. I have no problem telling people how much I earn etc. What I don't like to admit to is that we are mortgage free because nearly all of my friends rent and are frustrated at not being able to get on the housing ladder so I feel it would be insensitive. Happy to admit me and DH are both on pretty near to minimum wage jobs though 😂

Swedishmeatball · 23/10/2022 10:11

Ok, I called it vulgar, would crass or poor taste be better? The main reason we don’t and our friends don’t is probably because we’re in the top 0.5% of earners in the UK. We are all in high earning professions and we’re not going to help anybody or achieve anything by comparing our enormous salaries. We talk to the DC a lot about budgeting and how many people are struggling but I’ve yet to meet anyone in our circle who tells the DC exactly how much the adults earn as we’ve heard about the kids whose parents DO tell them get into pissing contests at school (my dad earns £1.3m - well my dad had a £2m bonus).

We also don’t tell our kids how much we earn because we’re desperate to keep them motivated at school and to achieve because they are self motivated and want to earn a living - the kids who know they’ve got £millions of family money usually take their foot off the gas in my experience. Why is it when mumnsetters post their enormous salaries anonymously on threads they get told they’re showing off and/or lying? But then all of the sudden on this thread we’re supposed to be telling people in real life?

bercan · 23/10/2022 10:07

As others have said I agree the reluctance to discuss finances & label it vulgar is normally said by the privileged. If it's because they want to keep people who have less happy, who benefits from that? I'm a 2nd gen immigrant so I do find the whole class obsession, doth thy cap behaviour pretty odd.

Lionesscubmum · 23/10/2022 10:04

*My in laws love to tell
Us what my sil is earning now and blah blah blah.
Oh and the previous niece etc

I've recently set up self employed and am earning 5 x what sil and her partner earns but I never discuss it with anyone because it's nobody's business.

Fil and mil make the odd comment how we could afford to treat them to lunch and coffee now I must be earning more but I just ignore it*

I always find that whenever you do reveal the slightest thing about finances people are all over it. Either judging what you can/can't afford, what you should or shouldn't be spending you money on.

OP posts:
prisscalledwanda · 23/10/2022 09:49

bercan · 23/10/2022 09:27

@prisscalledwanda but you are talking about different things. Talking about finances doesn't have to equal boasting does it?
My parents & inlaws know the price of any property/mortgage I have. They helped us get on the ladder, same for everyone we know & all of us say we couldn't have done it without help. DH works in finance & a former colleague & friend of DHs moved into legal finance & was open about the better salaries/bonus for same work so DH followed him.

Of course not, and as long as everyone's also into it it's fine. The posts I was replying to are about the use of the word vulgar and why privileged people sometimes consider it vulgar to talk about money. Don't think it's anything to do with keeping others down. I think it's considered vulgar because it's basic good manners to steer clear of the topic unless you're sure everyone is happy with it.

DiamondAxe · 23/10/2022 09:44

Discussing interest rates etc is fine and DS has been educated about finances. But how much I actually earned, my mortgage or my savings absolutely no way. Looking at us as a couple we look like any other probably middle income nothing special couple. But in reality we had some years of making a decent amount of money investing and ended up paying our mortgage off in our mid thirties. So we have had twenty years of zero housing costs with an income that puts us in top 10% of earners. We didn’t tell a soul. I would never lend money to anyone and I would turn them down so rather than offend I just never shared the information because as soon as people know you have money they may have expectations.

Hoppinggreen · 23/10/2022 09:41

I don’t consider it anyone else’s business.
Our DC know roughly what we earn and how much money we have in our current account (seen it on the app) but nobody else does.
If anyone else was to give me detailed info on their finances I would think it was very odd and I wouldn’t be interested anyway

Mmmmdanone · 23/10/2022 09:37

My dd (18) was talking about this the other day. My ex h has started a new job and she want to know how much he's earning (so do I if I'm honest) but I said he has a right to keep it to himself, she thinks he doesn't! I think if he provides enough food etc when she sees him that's enough. Although he doesn't pay any CM for my younger dc so would be interested to find out how much it is and I know there's a way!

TheFairyCaravan · 23/10/2022 09:36

Our kids could have looked up how much DH earned when they lived at home because he was in the military and the pay scales were on line. We weren’t poor, but we weren’t rich, and they knew that. They mostly got what they wanted and knew that we saved for them.

Now DH has left the military DS1 knows how much DH earns but DS2 doesn’t. DS2 knows we’re comfortable because we’re able to help him out a bit. The only reason we’ve not told DS2 is because he’d tell DDIL and she’s got loose lips. We know how much DS1 earns because he told us, he’s also military so we could look it up if we wanted to.

DS2 and DDIL are nurses, we’ve an idea how much they earn but not a definite figure, quite frankly it’s none of my business. Again I could look it up but I don’t wish to because it doesn’t concern me.

bigshoutout · 23/10/2022 09:31

luxxlisbon · 22/10/2022 21:25

No, I don’t agree that knowing what items cost is vulgar.
Our friends openly discuss pay rises, mortgages, investment plans, childcare costs, holiday recommendations, well priced wine tips etc.
I don’t see any issues with transparency.

+1 for this. It is ok if you don’t want to share details, and no one should feel pressured to be transparent, but it is not automatically vulgar to be open about this stuff. Being braggy is vulgar (obvs?), but the older I get the more strongly I feel that being honest about money is radical and important.

logana · 23/10/2022 09:28

My old dad used to tell me 'never tell people how much you earn or how you vote'. It's stood me in good stead.

bercan · 23/10/2022 09:27

@prisscalledwanda but you are talking about different things. Talking about finances doesn't have to equal boasting does it?
My parents & inlaws know the price of any property/mortgage I have. They helped us get on the ladder, same for everyone we know & all of us say we couldn't have done it without help. DH works in finance & a former colleague & friend of DHs moved into legal finance & was open about the better salaries/bonus for same work so DH followed him.

Girasoli · 23/10/2022 09:27

I don't mind telling people, I think it's good to discuss salary/finances, especially for women.

I also discuss finances with DS1 (nearly 7, good at maths) so he doesn't get completely unrealistic ideas from YouTube!

Sciurus83 · 23/10/2022 09:26

I definitely think finances and politics should be discussed. Anyone in the public sector's payscales are public information so it's not like it's a big secret. I think it is important in the context of public sector pay freezes of over a decade that this is really understood in the context of other industries which requires others to discuss their incomes also. See also, women being paid less. Politics, well, we've had more than enough people trying to destroy the country with stupid decisions lately, as an electorate we should be discussing that and what we want for our futures. I think silence breeds ignorance around both these issues, and positive change rarely stems from ignorance.

AloysiusBear · 23/10/2022 09:26

Any financial discussions within my peer group are to lift each other up.

I told my friend my salary for my latest job. This made him realised just how underpaid he is, as a result he decided to move & got 20k more. He really, really needs that money at the moment (young family) so I'm so pleased for him.

AloysiusBear · 23/10/2022 09:23

My salary is graded and has to be approved by a committee

My salary is banded too, yet there's SO much wiggle room. conversations in the pub are often very revealing. We negotiate our pay ourselves and a lot of people do themselves no favours.

Zipps · 23/10/2022 09:17

I had some excellent advice about money when I was growing up and now we are well off. So we have shared our knowledge with our dc and talk about money pretty freely. It's neglectful not to educate your dc regards finance. I bet the super rich do. When someone talks about money I don't immediately think 'Bragging' I listen and decides if it's useful.
My clients have to share at least part of their finances with me and I barely know them.
People are so scared of talking about money, it's ridiculous.

dizzygirl1 · 23/10/2022 09:17

StaceySolomonSwash · 23/10/2022 09:01

Given some of the questions my teens came back with.... I'll stick with talking about it at home and being open.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 23/10/2022 09:06

My dad k owns what I earn because he deals with my bookwork but he's never ever made any comment about it

Robostripes · 23/10/2022 09:05

No I don’t talk about finances with my family or friends. Obviously everyone can work out from people’s jobs who is a high earner, who is a low earner etc. But I don’t know exactly how much most of my friends earn and they don’t know how much I earn, same for siblings/parents. In fact I think my parents would assume I earn less than I actually do.

the only person I am open with is my best friend - we’re in the same industry (originally met as graduates at work) and we do tell each other about pay rises and bonuses etc as it’s useful to have a benchmark for salary negotiations etc!

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 23/10/2022 09:05

My in laws love to tell
Us what my sil is earning now and blah blah blah.
Oh and the previous niece etc

I've recently set up self employed and am earning 5 x what sil and her partner earns but I never discuss it with anyone because it's nobody's business.

Fil and mil make the odd comment how we could afford to treat them to lunch and coffee now I must be earning more but I just ignore it

luxxlisbon · 23/10/2022 09:04

bercan · 23/10/2022 08:35

The word vulgar is a clue
It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.

Agree it's also largely people who earn a lot &/or come from a privilege background who think it's vulgar. I guess it makes it easier to maintain the status quo?

Totally agree with this.
Any financial discussions within my peer group are to lift each other up.
When we were all younger and starting out it was tips, ideas, tricks to save for a property. (London).
Everyone was pretty transparent (within a close friendship circle) about who had a parental contribution so it was easier to understand why people could afford something and what was reasonable if you were saving yourself.
We shared research on areas, what was a good stepping stone area in London and how to make money to progress from a small flat.
Later sharing construction costs, how a pay review went, advice and encouragement to ask a rise in-line with project work of the year etc.
A friend shared her wedding excel for example to give me an idea of what the costs are for a certain type of wedding for example.

It it all to build each other up and encourage, it is never bragging, it is never demanding to know ‘private details’ it merely comes up in conversation.
Another example is friends coming over after major construction and complimented how the work turned out, said they wanted to put similar but they didn’t know if it was realistic. I was happy to share the cost and most importantly the hidden fee cost so they could set a budget and work towards something.

To me people calling it “vulgar” is just a way to say ‘lower class’ and therefore all it says is that person thinks they are better than others because of what they discuss with their own friends.
Calling it vulgar says more about them than me imo.

Whatafustercluck · 23/10/2022 09:02

I don't discuss it with anyone except dh. We are comfortably well off. But we well remember what it's like having very little money and how we felt when wealthier relatives spoke about how much they had. We've had times when celebratory meals out for birthdays, organised by others with little thought of budgets, gave us nothing left for the month. When you're not earning much, it's hard to hear the ins and outs of others' earnings.

12yo ds knows "we have enough for everything we need and some of what we want". He also doesn't know he'll have money from us in savings when he's older, and inherit well. He does have a Go Henry account though, is given a monthly allowance and is expected to budget to afford his bus fares. It's practical experience of budgeting that prepares them for life in the real world, not knowing what their parents earn. We do talk to him about how much things cost though.

StaceySolomonSwash · 23/10/2022 09:01

dizzygirl1 · 23/10/2022 08:12

To strangers I'm quite quiet but with my teenagers I tell them. I show them my budget, where all the money goes - its an eye opener for them. I'm separated from their dad so i do it even more for them to understand why I say no or I can't afford it.
How else do our young people learn how to budget, what bills, credit cards, loans, interest ar e? They aren't taught it at school, I wasn't taught it from my parents and I went crazy with debt on 'nothing'.
My opinion anyway 🤷‍♀️

Think you'll find they are taught it in UK schools!

www.moneysavingexpert.com/news/2021/10/first-ever-financial-education-textbook-arrives-in-welsh-schools/

prisscalledwanda · 23/10/2022 08:59

bercan · 23/10/2022 08:35

The word vulgar is a clue
It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.

Agree it's also largely people who earn a lot &/or come from a privilege background who think it's vulgar. I guess it makes it easier to maintain the status quo?

Or because it's not nice to boast/ risk making other people feel bad or uncomfortable and makes you look a bit of a prat, surely? Same reason it's vulgar to talk about how gigantic your engagement ring is/ how incredibly gifted your child is at piano/ the modelling opportunity you never took up in your youth.

Talking about finances risks people feeling upset or embarrassed about having less when there is no need. And it can make those who don't want to talk about their private financial situation feeling uncomfortable. And it's often not very interesting - who on earth wants to know the detail of other peoples utility bills?!

So better not to do it unless you are very sure everyone is into it. (I don't think this means you should leave your kids clueless about finances though. That seems like a v bad idea).