Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you prefer to keep your finances private?

111 replies

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:22

For some reason I do not like talking about money. I don't like to tell anyone how much me and dh earn, even my dc. Teenage ds has asked a few times what we earn and I just say it's for me to know. I'm not keen on being asked how much I've paid for things either.

I just feel that it's private but also that it's a bit vulgar.

Dhs parents are always telling us the ins and outs of sil finances (husbands sister). How much they earn, details of what their savings and outgoings are, every detail. I am surprised that not only they know so much but that they keep relating it back to us.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 23/10/2022 20:11

I really think it is a taboo that doesn't serve women well. I work in the City and the opaqueness of the salary and bonus structure has time and again been found to disadvantage women.

I can fully understand a taboo against bragging, which really is vulgar in my mind, but total secrecy allows for unfair practices to happen. I earn multiples of what my siblings earn so obviously I don't mention my income to them because there is no need to do so but I will make sure my female colleagues are being treated fairly (I have fought some pretty tough battles over my pay and I want others to benefit from that too).

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/10/2022 19:58

ExpectMore · 23/10/2022 19:11

It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.

Designed implies a conscious decision by someone. Tell me, who sat down and made this decision, how did they implement it, and how is it maintained....?

Personally, I think you might believes there's a conspiracy that doesn't exist....

It’s a well studied area of anthropology and sociology, the rules and etiquette around talking about money in different societies and how they change across socioeconomic groups and cultures. In the UK and the US it’s long been observed that people who think of themselves as upper-middle and middle class are more likely to have a taboo around discussing their finances, and to use terms like “vulgar” - literally meaning “of the common / low class people” to reinforce and emphasise the taboo, that “people like us” don’t do it. Something doesn’t have to be decided by a designated committee and have standing spoken rules to be a system.

Its also well observed that people from lower socioeconomic backgrounds are broadly less circumspect about disclosing specifics about their income, rent, or expenditures, and to feel far less so than people from higher socioeconomic backgrounds that their earned income says something about their personal worth or value - hence feeling more comfortable to discuss their financial challenges and celebrate having found a good bargain or been thrifty.

emptythelitterbox · 23/10/2022 19:45

Lionesscubmum · 23/10/2022 10:04

*My in laws love to tell
Us what my sil is earning now and blah blah blah.
Oh and the previous niece etc

I've recently set up self employed and am earning 5 x what sil and her partner earns but I never discuss it with anyone because it's nobody's business.

Fil and mil make the odd comment how we could afford to treat them to lunch and coffee now I must be earning more but I just ignore it*

I always find that whenever you do reveal the slightest thing about finances people are all over it. Either judging what you can/can't afford, what you should or shouldn't be spending you money on.

This is exactly why I'm very careful who I share with.
People get very petty, gossipy, and jealous.

emptythelitterbox · 23/10/2022 19:43

I talk about it but use discretion about it.
I avoid it with gossipy people.
With the kids, it's more about financial education rather than exactly what I make.

MrsTumblebee · 23/10/2022 19:21

catbirddogchild · 23/10/2022 08:19

Money, politics and religion are not considered polite conversation are they.

when I was younger it was sex, religion and politics.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 23/10/2022 19:12

prinnycessa · 22/10/2022 21:41

It depends - I don't discuss finances with my family at all, that's just how we are. Also, I'm mindful for various reasons, for judgment or expectations as a result.

I do with some friends. Some are more comfortable than others and vice versa. It depends on the relationship and whether our financial situations are similar. It's good to be mindful.

I do discuss salaries with colleagues as it's good to know so we can each negotiate and advocate for ourselves. As women we historically haven't done this as much and have had lower pay as a result. I think people are more open to it now so that the transparency will ensure they are fairly paid.

This....

ExpectMore · 23/10/2022 19:11

ArcticSkewer · 23/10/2022 07:53

The word vulgar is a clue
It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.
Wage transparency might lead to demands for wage fairness, and then where would we be!
You can apply the same 'vulgar' rule to many things in the UK. It's a very divided and class based country

It's a system designed to keep the lower classes in their place.

Designed implies a conscious decision by someone. Tell me, who sat down and made this decision, how did they implement it, and how is it maintained....?

Personally, I think you might believes there's a conspiracy that doesn't exist....

ExpectMore · 23/10/2022 19:09

Lionesscubmum · 22/10/2022 21:22

For some reason I do not like talking about money. I don't like to tell anyone how much me and dh earn, even my dc. Teenage ds has asked a few times what we earn and I just say it's for me to know. I'm not keen on being asked how much I've paid for things either.

I just feel that it's private but also that it's a bit vulgar.

Dhs parents are always telling us the ins and outs of sil finances (husbands sister). How much they earn, details of what their savings and outgoings are, every detail. I am surprised that not only they know so much but that they keep relating it back to us.

What's the issue with telling people &/or people knowing? I ask from a place of curiosity as I've never understood the opaqueness around finances in this country.

TheChosenTwo · 23/10/2022 14:33

Money and politics are big topics of conversation around our dinner table! Not the specifics of what we earn but our older dc have a rough idea of what we earn and an understanding of why what we do and where we holiday etc varies from one year to the next.
In wider situations, I work somewhere with a totally transparent payscale which I think is brilliant, everyone doing a certain job earns exactly the same money all the way up to the top.
Dh and I wouldn’t sit and discuss our earnings in a group of people. It’s not that it’s a secret, it’s just not the done thing with any of our friends/family, not a topic that comes up. Different to someone asking how much your jumper was or something more trivial!

Snoredoeurve · 23/10/2022 14:09

Liorae · 23/10/2022 11:08

Sad that earning so much that a treat of coffee is beyond your means.

Point proven that is best to keep quiet.
Other people dont get to spend your money

Liorae · 23/10/2022 11:08

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 23/10/2022 09:05

My in laws love to tell
Us what my sil is earning now and blah blah blah.
Oh and the previous niece etc

I've recently set up self employed and am earning 5 x what sil and her partner earns but I never discuss it with anyone because it's nobody's business.

Fil and mil make the odd comment how we could afford to treat them to lunch and coffee now I must be earning more but I just ignore it

Sad that earning so much that a treat of coffee is beyond your means.

Snoredoeurve · 23/10/2022 10:57

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 22/10/2022 21:43

It's no-one else's business what me and DP earn, anyone asking will be firmly shut down

Same.
People either gossip or ask you for money in an entitled way.

gogohmm · 23/10/2022 10:53

Interestingly my kids (adults) know what their parents (exh exactly and me roughly) earn as his is published online and they know I don't pay income tax (clue) but dsd has no idea at all about her dad - she has been worrying about energy costs and whether we need to cut back on things at home (she's an adult but lives with us) but he earns enough to hit 45p tax! Her parents never discussed money with her, to the extent I've been teaching her about compound interest, loans, how pensions work etc. my biological kids are so much more financially savvy

gogohmm · 23/10/2022 10:48

I think it's useful to broadly know where people close to you are with their finances when organising events etc - eg I knew I earned over double my db so offered to pay far more on a joint gift to my parents

Lionesscubmum · 23/10/2022 10:46

@CadburyCrunchy sorry I didn't write that I was quoting a previous poster but it didn't go in bold for some reason.

OP posts:
mewkins · 23/10/2022 10:46

dudsville · 23/10/2022 08:35

When i was a kid my Dad said never to look in a man's wallet. I grew up looking away when anyone got their purse or wallet out and never discussed money. I would have liked to understand home finances. After they divorced mum and i were exceptionally poor. She worked such long hours but i didn't understand how wages didn't equate to hours or effort and how was it possible to work 6x12hr days and not be able to buy me new trainers. It's an educational opportunity like no other.

It worked out well for him then! Just not so much for you and your mum.

bercan · 23/10/2022 10:44

The only ones in the whole world that know what I earn are me, and the taxman. Not my DH, not my children, not my family, not my friends. Nobody can even make a guess. I like it that way, I’m in control.

Do you not have. mortgage?

CadburyCrunchy · 23/10/2022 10:36

@Lionesscubmum if you've set yourself up as self employed and have a Ltd company then your PIL's and SIL can satisfy their nosiness as they'll be able to see for themselves that you're earning 5 times your SIL's salary as that information is publicly available to anyone on companies house website!

IncompleteSenten · 23/10/2022 10:33

Re my children.
They are adults now. They know how much the bills are. They don't need to know how much we earn in order to understand what it costs to run a house. They can do addition.

IncompleteSenten · 23/10/2022 10:31

I only tell those who need to know.

Eg HMRC when I do my annual sa tax return.

It's nobody else's business what our household income is.

woff45 · 23/10/2022 10:29

I'm very open with my kids about finances when they ask, why on Earth would you not want your own son to know? How are you going to teach them about finances, budgeting and the value of money being so guarded about your own? And we absolutely talk a lot about politics too. Very important in my opinion.

HorribleHerstory · 23/10/2022 10:24

The only ones in the whole world that know what I earn are me, and the taxman. Not my DH, not my children, not my family, not my friends. Nobody can even make a guess. I like it that way, I’m in control.

I teach my DC about money using example earnings and example outgoings..

Mynoodlesareoodles · 23/10/2022 10:19

DC is quite young, so i only talk about basics - that I work, earn money, pay taxes to pay for services. That we have sufficient money, but need to budget and we can't have everything we want. I will absolutely talk to her more when she's older about earnings, pensions, savings, mortgages, debt etc. And to ensure she is financially independent and never vulnerable to being reliant on someone else.

I don't talk about money much with friends, but don't mind at all when asked and will happily share my experiences if I think it may help.

bercan · 23/10/2022 10:16

Why is it when mumnsetters post their enormous salaries anonymously on threads they get told they’re showing off and/or lying?

statistically that aren't many woman earning 7 figures (unfortunately) & people lie about all sorts on here all the time. I don't think it's a reach to believe that some are truthful, some aren't.

DH works for a law firm, partners earn about 2m on average. Very common in top firms but not representative of everyone in law by any stretch.

bercan · 23/10/2022 10:11

One thing I find interesting on MNs is that you often read posts that say "we never discuss money, none of our friends would know how fortunate/comfortable we are, etc" If you never discuss it, how do you know your friends also haven't paid off their mortgage, had investments come good or received an inheritance? 😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread