Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What was signs of asd in older girls?

113 replies

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 20:31

My daughter is 9 and I’m questioning whether I should be looking at getting her assessed for asd.

She is a lovely girl but there are a few quirks that are starting to feel a little age inappropriate.

she is extremely fussy with food and struggles to try new things.

she struggles in some situations (for eg a transport museum this weekend) where she starts crying and saying she wants to leave.

she spins a lot. She also sings all the time or dances about. She was a mad climber when she was younger and was always on her head doing headstands etc.

she doesn’t cope well when plans change. For eg if I say I’m bringing our car to school and it’s a nice day so I decide to pick her up on foot she will break down and cry in front of her friends with no embarrassment.

she has nice friendships though and she does do a lot of imaginative play on the other side of things.

she is very shy around new people but very happy and comfortable with people she knows well and family.

she doesn’t always answer to her name and seems to ignore requests (time to get out the bath etc).

she reads all the time, total book bug and can play with her toys by herself
for long periods of time.

she has weird sensory things. Like wanting to put her hand in our mouths when she’s falling asleep (we don’t allow this any more!)

she does well in school, although she is dyslexic so struggles with spelling.

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 22/10/2022 23:16

We failed to spot a lot of signs along the way, now that I know… Really obvious ones like toe-walking. She was diagnosed last year at 17. I feel so guilty. What did it was when she was trying on a ball dress and due to COVID, there weren’t too many around. I was trying to tell her what one would look like altered, and she became VERY distressed. I asked what was wrong and she said “I keep trying to tell you this, but you just don’t get it. I CAN’T visualize things. Nothing. You can describe it all you like and it just stresses me out. That part of my brain doesn’t work. I never dream. I think in words. I’ve told you this before.” Along with a heap of other cues I missed, she was verbally sophisticated for her age when she started school, a super-reader and quickly developed into a polyglot, (definitely doesn’t come from either of her parents!!!) she didn’t really click with kids her age until this year, unfortunately. She has never really liked to be touched. (I have asked her quite a few times if anything bad has happened, but she says no, thank god.) Eye contact is brief. She needs a lot of alone time. It was very difficult introducing solid and textured foods to her (but now she is a good eater). She does not like her plans to be derailed, even if she hadn’t communicated them with the rest of the universe. She has a bit of a tendency to monologue and not realise that her audience has tuned out.

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 23:12

@FlowerzInTheAttic that's very interesting about the spinning thank you.

OP posts:
schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 23:11

@FlowerzInTheAttic Sort of both. She loves graphic novels so reads the same type of books but various different series and styles. She does happily re-read books though.

OP posts:
PeppermintyPatty · 22/10/2022 23:06

Oh and my DS probably wouldn’t be picked up at school, he might have been labelled naughty for the few occasions where his mask has slipped, but by and large he loves school and the stability the routine gives him.

FlowerzInTheAttic · 22/10/2022 23:06

Does your DD read the same books again and again OP? Or are they different all the time? Just out of interest.

FlowerzInTheAttic · 22/10/2022 23:04

My 9 year old is recently diagnosed. She also spins and headstands and cartwheels frequently. I’ve been advised that when she spins (or cartwheels) in one direction, that she should then repeat it in the other direction too, as that helps with regulation - I remind her of this when I notice it.

Don’t wait for school to notice anything because they don’t seem to - even with the DC I’ve met who present is a more stereotypical and obvious way, never mind the girls who mask in school.

While we were waiting for assessment the school SENCO made it clear that she didn’t think my DD was autistic. “She is fine when she is here” type of attitude. She wasn’t fine actually, and she is autistic (and waiting for ADHD assessment now also)

PeppermintyPatty · 22/10/2022 23:03

Some of those traits sound a lot like my 8yo boy who has ASD (specifically Asperger’s). We have big issues with changing plans, transition from one activity to another, leaving the house (but just the act of leaving), various sensory needs eg hated loud/unpredictable sounds when younger, seems to need be in motion and needs physical exercise to regulate himself, loves being as close to me as possible. He’s a fairly adventurous eater but will sniff food and comment if he thinks it’s not right. He also sniffs people sometimes Grin

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 22:56

@Fink how does your daughter present if you don't mind me asking? Just looking for more clues myself thanks.

OP posts:
BlackeyedSusan · 22/10/2022 22:45

Don't rely on school to spot ASD. Some teachers know nowt. (The assessor was rather scathing of school Senco who was adamant it was not autism but had written several things on her sheet that pointed to autism. )

Fink · 22/10/2022 22:20

My dd presents differently, but I've just started the process of having her assessed for ASD and ADHD as a young teen. I just wanted to encourage you that it's not at all a scary thing, the school have been very supportive despite not initially agreeing that there was anything neurodiverse going on. I was able to give a lot of evidence and the school sent it in for referral along with some stuff they provided. Now we just have to sit and wait. It might take a long time to get through the system, but I feel that at least the school have it on their radar now. You spend the most one to one time with your daughter, if you think she should be assessed then press for it.

FarewellNoel · 22/10/2022 22:05

Could have written something similar about my 9 year old. We have asked school to assess but they are saying they don't see anything in school. At home we see:

  • Meltdowns over changes of plan or things not being how she expected them to be.
  • Hates busy and noisy places and will ask to leave but okay at sports events i.e. crowds at football or cricket.
  • Homebody - much rather be at home than out.
  • Limited imagination - struggles to think of things she'd like to do or to invent stories etc. Maths is by far her strongest subject and her writing can be clunky in comparison to her abilities in other areas.
  • Fussiness with food - unwilling to try new things.
  • Finding it hard to socialise in groups - inability to make small talk. She does have a best friend and plays football but always seems to be stood about on the edges. In group situations, without her best friend she looks awkward.
  • Complete lack of interest in clothes and fashion to the point that she finds shopping very stressful and would much rather I tell her what to wear everyday. She just about copes now to pick an outfit but hates non-uniform days etc. She prioritises comfort.
  • Unwilling to get dressed up in fancy dress for parties etc. Hates nail polish/make up but happy to wear dresses. Will happily be the only one at a party not in costume and will just shake her head/shrug her shoulders and say 'no'.
  • Phobia of characters/mascots - as a young child she'd physically shake and sob for hours if we met one. Still very wary.
  • Over reacts to being told off.
  • Anxious about school work and getting things wrong. Bit of a perfectionist at times - very small, neat handwriting.
  • If she's not given clear instructions she struggles - can be wonderful at football with the right direction but equally capable of freezing if the situation is unfamiliar or she isn't getting clear instructions.
She has got a lot better with some things and comes across as polite and confident (not worried about being left at a party etc). I think she probably 'masks' a lot and we get the outbursts when she's too tired to mask. I don't see us getting any sort of diagnosis until she presents with anxiety at high school (I think this will be almost inevitable and trying to work on coping strategies now).
schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 22:01

Yes it would be nice if people could be a bit more kind and understanding for sure.

OP posts:
soundsystem · 22/10/2022 21:53

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 21:34

@soundsystem thank you, what would have helped you as a teenager do you think?

Just knowing there was a reason for my "quirks". Having a diagnosis has really helped me to go easier on myself! With my daughter we've talked about neurodiversity generally and it seems to make sense to her that peoples brains work in different ways rather than there just being "normal" and "odd", and that wasn't really the case for me when I was younger!

BlankTimes · 22/10/2022 21:48

@ByTheGrace

ASD and ADHD are not mutually exclusive, it's perfectly possible to have both and perhaps other co-morbids too. Several traits of co-morbid conditions overlap. Many neurodiverse people don't have only one condition, but the one that is most predominant (determined by assesment) is usually called their primary diagnosis.

Mummadeze · 22/10/2022 21:43

My 13 year old DD with ASD is very anxious and shy. Can’t make a decision. Worries disproportionately about breaking rules. Worries she isn’t doing things properly. Perfectionist in the extreme. She chews things incessantly - used to be clothes, now it’s hair. She loves fidget toys. Doesn’t like loud noises. Gets really overwhelmed when people shout or things go wrong. Very empathetic, over sensitive. She also finds lots of clothes and shoes uncomfortable. She finds it hard to change clothing due to the seasons changing (eg won’t wear her coat when it gets cold, but once she has got used to it again won’t take it off when it is hot). She also has OCD, general anxiety and lots of phobias. Also picky around food (she had counselling for this at one point so it’s less extreme than it used to be). I feel bad writing down all these points as it sounds negative. Just to balance it, she is kind, loving and extremely sweet natured. She struggles with secondary school because the environment stresses her out everyday but she is intelligent and able. Good luck with the assessment.

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 21:38

Yes I am worried about her high school. She loves primary school but the high school is absolutely massive.

OP posts:
minisoksmakehardwork · 22/10/2022 21:35

Dd2's school have been pursuing an ASC diagnosis for years. She has one of social communication disorder. This year, a new questionnaire has been issued which is firm specific. Even dd2's paediatrician, who knocked her second referral back, has seen this and now is supporting evidence gathering for an ASC diagnosis.

Definitely pursue while dd is still young. It's much, much harder once they get to secondary.

littlepeas · 22/10/2022 21:35

My dd has just been diagnosed at almost 13 - it had been largely missed as it is extremely subtle and she masks a lot - but when she started secondary it very quickly became much more obvious. She has extreme anxiety around social situations and is socially awkward in a way that wasn't obvious when she was little, but became much more noticeable as she got older.

I would start the process before secondary school for sure - I think it gets much harder for girls at this stage. I know the waiting lists through NHS/CAMHS are shockingly long - no idea if it makes a difference which area you're in. We went private in the end.

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 21:34

@soundsystem thank you, what would have helped you as a teenager do you think?

OP posts:
soundsystem · 22/10/2022 21:32

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 20:48

Did anyone have any similar traits in their DDs at that age? thanks.

My DD is 8 and very, very similar. We're going through the diagnostic process now. I found the school SENCO deeply unhelpful and referred to CAMHS via the GP. Have a look at "flying under the radar" which looks at autism in girls and see if it resonates.

I'm autistic myself but wasn't diagnosed until adulthood. My teenage years would have somewhat easier with a diagnosis so very much on the side of why wouldn't you.

BadgerFace · 22/10/2022 21:28

We recently had our 9 year old DD assessed and she was diagnosed with ASD. The main things which made me seek an assessment were:

  • Meltdowns over ‘’small” problems:issues
  • difficulty with changes in plans
  • doesn’t like noisy or busy places
  • anxiety (this is newish, under a year old)
  • chews on clothes when anxious
  • Sensory issues with certain clothes
  • overly attached to teddies (for her age)
  • seems to find talking with adults easier than her peers
  • Part of a wide group of friends at school but no ‘best’ friend as most other girls on her class have or have had

Most people I’ve told (who have known her years) were surprised I was taking her to be assessed. She’s very chatty and loves people, has an amazing imagination and loves role play games - all seemingly against the ‘usual’ ASD traits. The parental questionnaire as part of the assessment has a lot of stereotypical seeming questions so I wondered if we were dealing with ‘just’ high levels of anxiety but after the speech and language therapist session with her it was very interesting in what they diagnosed her on.

As part of dealing with high anxiety pre-residential school trip at the end of last year I asked our SENCO what they thought and then went for a private assessment after she said she wouldn’t rule ASD out. But equally school had not come to us with it being as issue until I raised it so go with your gut if it doesn’t seem to be impacting anything at the moment. I’ve thought for years DD might have ASD but didn’t feel a need to do anything until the anxiety issues and intrusive thoughts started this year. I’m glad we did as a lot of girls aren’t diagnosed until the change to secondary school as they mask so well and so I’m glad we know before that transition so it can be factored in.

ByTheGrace · 22/10/2022 21:27

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 21:18

@ByTheGrace interesting re- the climbing stuff. My daughter loves climbing, a climbing club could be good. She plays football but I have noticed sometimes she gets distracted and starts cartwheeling, spinning, singing to herself at the side...

DD used to climb up bookcases, kitchen units, even got on the garage roof. I don't want to out myself, but when DD was 5, I turned my back for a few minutes and she scaled, with an audience, something that was a ridiculous height. It was then that I thought she needs to harness this, before she hurts herself. She now volunteers at her climbing club and it's a big part of her life.

Amiable · 22/10/2022 21:19

She sounds a lot like my DD who was diagnosed a year ago aged 15. Wish we had started the process sooner.

Definitely speak to your GP.

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 21:18

@ByTheGrace interesting re- the climbing stuff. My daughter loves climbing, a climbing club could be good. She plays football but I have noticed sometimes she gets distracted and starts cartwheeling, spinning, singing to herself at the side...

OP posts:
ByTheGrace · 22/10/2022 21:17

And just read your updates. We had to do a lot of work with DD on personal space, she gets it now, but it took a (long) while.