Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What was signs of asd in older girls?

113 replies

schoolissues1234 · 22/10/2022 20:31

My daughter is 9 and I’m questioning whether I should be looking at getting her assessed for asd.

She is a lovely girl but there are a few quirks that are starting to feel a little age inappropriate.

she is extremely fussy with food and struggles to try new things.

she struggles in some situations (for eg a transport museum this weekend) where she starts crying and saying she wants to leave.

she spins a lot. She also sings all the time or dances about. She was a mad climber when she was younger and was always on her head doing headstands etc.

she doesn’t cope well when plans change. For eg if I say I’m bringing our car to school and it’s a nice day so I decide to pick her up on foot she will break down and cry in front of her friends with no embarrassment.

she has nice friendships though and she does do a lot of imaginative play on the other side of things.

she is very shy around new people but very happy and comfortable with people she knows well and family.

she doesn’t always answer to her name and seems to ignore requests (time to get out the bath etc).

she reads all the time, total book bug and can play with her toys by herself
for long periods of time.

she has weird sensory things. Like wanting to put her hand in our mouths when she’s falling asleep (we don’t allow this any more!)

she does well in school, although she is dyslexic so struggles with spelling.

OP posts:
Cats1234567 · 24/10/2022 23:06

waterrat · 24/10/2022 20:51

I cant recommend more highly seeking a diagnosis. The children i know who were diagnoses young seem to be more at ease with being autistic than those who were diagnosed as teens.

I think because some children find their little path and routinr at school and have learnt how to fit in and maybe are at same scholl from 3 or 4 ..it just isnt apparent at school until they head off at 11 and then all the shit hits the fan.

And that’s exactly what happened with my daughter, she was always autistic just not obvious and it was brushed off as quirks and we were actually told that she would grow out of it, but then she started high school and suddenly she couldn’t cope anymore..

yes I agree with getting assessments done as soon as possible.

Cats1234567 · 24/10/2022 23:00

schoolissues1234 · 24/10/2022 20:34

Do higher functioning teens on the autistic spectrum manage things like friendships and relationships?

Well in my daughters case no not really, she doesn’t really have friends and she is very socially awkward. She tries to fit in But finds it exhausting, so she prefers her own company. Sometimes she is lonely though and doesn’t understand why other kids don’t want to hang out with her.

MywobblyBottom · 24/10/2022 22:29

We’ve just had a (private) diagnosis for DD 7, who had many similar behaviours. She also masks at school. She has been diagnosed with ASD with a PDA profile. It’s early days, but we’re glad we pursued a diagnosis.

buttons123456 · 24/10/2022 22:26

@schoolissues1234 yes!
My dd is at uni and making some friends albeit very slowly and cautiously. She has a very close long term friend too

ihatethecold · 24/10/2022 21:03

MakeItRain · 22/10/2022 21:04

As a teacher I've taught many girls on the autistic spectrum. It can be harder to spot/diagnose in girls because they can be experts at masking or copying others' behaviour to fit in.

All the things you mention can be signs of autism. Mostly girls will present with various social difficulties/ needing routines/ becoming absorbed in books and characters is very common as a way to shut out the busy real world and become absorbed in a much more appealling one/ sensory issues around noise, taste, touch. I've come across spinning and singing too.

Diagnosis takes years these days so definitely speak to your senco or your GP and ask to get the ball rolling if that's what you want to do. The positive about a diagnosis is it gives you/your child/ the people around you an understanding of the difficulties associated with autism and ways to support.

A good book on the subject is "Women and girls with autism spectrum disorder" by Sarah Hendrickx.

Would this book be good for someone wondering if they have ADD?

waterrat · 24/10/2022 21:03

@BetterCallMe dont feel guilty ...partly its the harsh one size fits all system thst induces autistic meltdowns and anxiety. I would never bave known my dd was autistic but my husband has it in the family and was more aware.

I would have just thought her quirky anxious and a mad stickler for rules !

waterrat · 24/10/2022 20:57

Dm me if you want oP.

As others have said....a key thing i think with my dd is the subtle failure to follow normal social cues particularly with conversation. She is either silent and doesnt respond out of nerves or she just talks far too much particularly to adults. She cant stand being interrupted and will scream if wr try to talk before she is finished. She will tell never ending stories of no relevance to others or overly detailed in a way thst is quite funny sometimes but is just off kilter to how pther 8 or 9 year olds act.

Anon778833 · 24/10/2022 20:55

From what you say, it does sound like she should be assessed. The thing is that only a proper assessment will tell you. And girls present very differently from boys and even from each other. I’m autistic - I was diagnosed at 37. It would have made my life much better to know earlier.

waterrat · 24/10/2022 20:51

I cant recommend more highly seeking a diagnosis. The children i know who were diagnoses young seem to be more at ease with being autistic than those who were diagnosed as teens.

I think because some children find their little path and routinr at school and have learnt how to fit in and maybe are at same scholl from 3 or 4 ..it just isnt apparent at school until they head off at 11 and then all the shit hits the fan.

waterrat · 24/10/2022 20:48

Please dont ever rely on a teacher to spot or understand signs of autism in girls unless it is their specialism

If you can afford it get a diagnsisis privately we waited 2 years including a year for initial assessment and then paid for our child and it was a few months then we have now got thr diagnosis

My daughter is 8 and very like you described your daughter including spinning dancing talking to herself. Yes lots of imaginative play but struggles to join in groups. Okay playing one to one but really struggles with new social situations

Because she is happy once in a settled routinr and Because she is socially very anxious she appeared fairly wel behaved at school. Lockdown then us moving house made her autism a lot clearer which was sad as she struggled but did mean she is now getting the help she needs

schoolissues1234 · 24/10/2022 20:34

Do higher functioning teens on the autistic spectrum manage things like friendships and relationships?

OP posts:
Cats1234567 · 24/10/2022 15:06

Toomanysquishmallows · 24/10/2022 08:30

I don’t want to derail , but I have a 13 year old daughter who was diagnosed at two , although a lot of what is mentioned here is familiar regarding terrible sleep and anxiety.The I question is , if autism in girls become seen as a separate condition to autism in boys , what happens to girls like mine , who got an early diagnosis because of obvious traits ? Would she get diagnosed with “ boys autism “?

I think I might be able to help to answer your question as I have family members of both boys and girls on the spectrum. I don’t believe that they have separate conditions. ASD is the same in everyone who has it, it’s just that it effects everyone slightly differently, I think with some of the girls, but not always, from a young age they try to fit in and so therefore ‘mask’ by copying others and study of others behaviour/mannerisms. This is seen more in the high functioning type of ASD, which my daughter has and at least 2 boys in my family. The lower functioning type of ASD (non verbal, no eye contact) would be more obvious autism. I know of another girl with this type of autism, she does not give me eye contact but is social to a certain extent. So I think it depends on the individual person really how their autism effects them.

Fink · 24/10/2022 12:20

Toomanysquishmallows · 24/10/2022 08:30

I don’t want to derail , but I have a 13 year old daughter who was diagnosed at two , although a lot of what is mentioned here is familiar regarding terrible sleep and anxiety.The I question is , if autism in girls become seen as a separate condition to autism in boys , what happens to girls like mine , who got an early diagnosis because of obvious traits ? Would she get diagnosed with “ boys autism “?

I'm not a medical expert, but I assume that if they were to do this, they wouldn't call it boys' autism and girls' autism, they would call it autism/ASD and something completely different. And boys would be more likely to have ASD but not exlusively so, and girls would be more likely to have the other thing, but not exclusively so. A bit like how women can be colourblind, but much more rarely than men.

Toomanysquishmallows · 24/10/2022 08:30

I don’t want to derail , but I have a 13 year old daughter who was diagnosed at two , although a lot of what is mentioned here is familiar regarding terrible sleep and anxiety.The I question is , if autism in girls become seen as a separate condition to autism in boys , what happens to girls like mine , who got an early diagnosis because of obvious traits ? Would she get diagnosed with “ boys autism “?

miffmufferedmoof · 24/10/2022 07:55

@Paddingtonthebear it varies by area, but where I am you can ask either your school or your GP to refer

Cats1234567 · 23/10/2022 16:19

Forgot to add, my daughter gets also obsessed with things, is very literal, has difficulty understanding emotions, and finds it difficult expressing her needs to others, she acts very young for her age and is easily swayed by others. She sings and talks constant throughout the day, spins, paces, and sometimes rocks back and forth when sitting down. I have also had people not believing me that she is autistic as she gives eye contact and can be sociable (although that’s on her own terms) but she is a masker, so sometimes in girls it’s not always obvious…

Cats1234567 · 23/10/2022 16:07

Your daughter sounds very similar to mine, yes definitely get her assessed.

my daughter is diagnosed with high functioning Autism and ADHD.

Winter789Mermaid · 23/10/2022 15:51

Someone asked up thread about referral forms you look on your LA website for child services and a referral it’s all online in my local education authority.
www.ipsea.org.uk has good information

buttons123456 · 23/10/2022 14:02

@Paddingtonthebear it's incredibly difficult but you ask for a referral via your gp . I skipped all that and paid for one for dd ( around £3k) because camhs are useless unless you are the child of a druggie or alcoholic family and at risk ( yes they admitted that to me ) ..

Dd wasn't but needed help so I paid for it 🙄🤷‍♀️

schoolissues1234 · 23/10/2022 09:55

Thank you all.

OP posts:
CoolBeanie · 23/10/2022 09:42

One I’ve thought of, which can make it harder for school to understand and pick up when it presents this way… is my DD can be “overly expressive” and sometimes have slightly exaggerated social responses. Her voice isn’t monotone and she is very enthusiastic and animated when talking.

She smiles a LOT, and seems happy even when she isn’t. In fact, there can be a correlation between how “okay” she seems after something upsetting happens and how upset she really is. There is a certain type of smile that I describe as “a stage school smile”
and it’s a cover up one that I have come to recognise, but it certainly isn’t something that people who don’t know her would see, and it contributed to school thinking she was “fine” when she really really wasn’t.

The bigger the smile and the more emphatic “I’m FINE, I understand” (about something like not being invited to a party sleepover) the more concerned I am, and it usually comes out later in a meltdown. I don’t think she is deliberately lying about her feelings other, but it takes her a while to feel or to even recognise her emotions, as well as partly wanting to cover up socially.

Re: the not being able to feel feelings -for example on a Sunday evening before school she would often be awake really late with a headache and nausea. She would say it had nothing to do with school (and I think she really believed this) but that she was ill. Soon as we took her out of school this stopped.

Back to the masking and social skills - my DD doesn’t come across as shy, and she will talk to anyone. Seems really confident. But actually, that is a little bit unusual in itself, and as she has become older (she is 9) I notice it more, as older DC don’t usually start conversations with shop assistants and strangers, so it stands out more than it did when she was a younger child. She also keeps talking even if the person isn’t being especially responsive.

She also uses stock phrases “So, how was your day today?”/“Any plans for the weekend?”.

Recently I could hear her chattering away to the receptionist, when I had a quick hair appointment, and DD asked her “So, are you doing anything after work tonight?” and it made me smile. It’s hard to explain but if you listen carefully it’s possible to pick up the social phrases she has stored, that sound a little bit adult.

This was picked up in during the ASD assessment. Also, there are a few parts for it when the clinician makes small talk and talks about plans they have. I heard my DD exclaim “That’s amazing!!” when the clinician talked about her plans for the weekend. But later on DD responses again with “That’s amazing!” or “How amazing!” , “Amazing!” in the same tone of voice in response to the clinician sharing information about herself

it was exactly the same each time.

This was picked up on. They also noticed that when my DD exclaimed “I’m so excited!” a couple of times, her facial expression didn’t
change or show excitement to match what she was seeing.

So, the masking side of things is really subtle and took experienced clinicians - who know a lot about masking and autism in girls - to recognise. Some traits of DDs are stereotypically autistic, but the social communication side was harder to see.

School insisted “She has loads of friends” but this wasn’t as true as it seems. She has acquaintances but can’t seem to form many close friendships, or she forms them and then loses them, and is desperate for a “best friend”. School weren’t seeing that though, they saw her with other children in the playground and took that and face value. She is actually also more comfortable and confident with adults than with her peers.

We saw the extreme meltdowns and the loneliness and fear and anxiety at home but she usually holds it together in public. So girls can be harder to recognise.

ScottishInSwitzerland · 23/10/2022 09:34

I would agree with others to kick off the diagnosis process if possible. Our experience was that ASD became more obvious as our daughter got older.

ASD definitely can present very differently in girls. For example my daughter is exceptionally passive at school and for a long time they thought of her as a ‘nice, sweet, quiet girl’ (of course she is lovely and sweet but she wasn’t being passive because of that but rather because she was overwhelmed and retreating into herself).

Paddingtonthebear · 23/10/2022 09:27

How do you go about getting a screening?

Thehonestbadger · 23/10/2022 09:20

I’ve done endless reading on the differences between boy ASD presentation and girls.
My eldest (DS) is ASD and my youngest (DD) isn’t as far as we can tell but she’s only small still (16m) so I’m really alert to it presenting.

with my DS it is very obvious. He’s non verbal, somewhat low functioning and has a lot of the very clear signs.

Girls often don’t. Girls are much more likely to pass as ‘normal’ till later in life. They are more likely to hit milestones like talking, imaginative play and socialisation but just seem a bit ‘off’. Maybe struggle emotionally or sensory and fixate on certain things.
With what you’re describing id push getting her screened you have nothing to lose whilst she has everything to gain x

Paddingtonthebear · 23/10/2022 09:17

This is really interesting. I have a 10yr old DD with a few strange quirks and I’m not sure whether there’s something “there” or not.