Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is everyone aware that Mumsnet are posting your threads on Facebook?

138 replies

ImEasyLikeSundayMorning · 22/10/2022 18:46

If you knew that already then that's grand.
If you expected it and are fine with it, great!

What I feel deeply uncomfortable with is, is OP's having very specific and detailed stuff out out by MN on FB.

There seems to be little choice happening here.
Less anonymity.

I am now worried about posting on MN Inca we it's posted on fb.

AIBU!

OP posts:
KitchiHuritAngeni · 23/10/2022 17:29

french76 · 23/10/2022 02:40

Yes, it definitely stopped me from posting. I felt the Mumsnet forum is for current mums but Facebook hits a whole genre of people who could recognise/out an op. It just feels more public even though I know all of it is public. I often name change just for privacy.

So when I had my child, then my child died I should have left MN (despite all the support) because I wasn't a "current mum"?

What about the many, many people who aren't parents, should they all leave?

At least half the threads (maybe more) on here are nothing to do with parenting.

How would MN even police who is a "current mum"? What's the upper age limit your kid has to be before you leave?

SydneySage · 23/10/2022 17:16

french76 · 23/10/2022 02:40

Yes, it definitely stopped me from posting. I felt the Mumsnet forum is for current mums but Facebook hits a whole genre of people who could recognise/out an op. It just feels more public even though I know all of it is public. I often name change just for privacy.

For current mums? What's the cut off? Are we allowed to post before ttc, do we have to stop when our dc have their own? (I know that there is gransnet, but I dont like it)

Ekátn · 23/10/2022 17:02

LeMoo · 23/10/2022 14:06

I don't think people expect privacy at all. Everyone knows it's a public forum. I think many posters have an expectation of discretion and while the occasional thread is picked up by a tabloid, that's different to an algorithm flashing threads up on a much more widely used social media site.

The nature of fb, too, means that people are more likely to be identified their than they are here. And tabloids pick threads that are generally humorous or ridiculous, not ones that are sensitive. An algorithm has no such discretion.

How is someone more likely to be identified?

There’s far more people who ‘lurk’ here. You don’t need to sign in to read it. There’s far more people see each thread than reply to it.

I think mumsnet is more widely read than people like to believe.

The tabloids absolutely do pick up the sensitive ones.

The point is that it’s not private. It’s never been designed that way and their FB page has never been hidden.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/10/2022 16:27

I didn't realise it, thank you op.

It doesnt sit right so won't start threads again. I'd imagine others will be reluctant too.

CheezePleeze · 23/10/2022 16:02

undetetected · 23/10/2022 14:30

I don't like this.

Mumsnet feels more private than posting on Facebook because it's contained to those who sign up rather than being actively broadcasted and shared around.

They should definitely ask for consent, or at least notify if the post on FB/Twitter.

Yeah, not keen on the idea of airing someone's dirty laundry when you have no idea how distressing a circumstance is. 'Shoes on vs shoes off/AIBU to not do x' is fine, but not personal topics.

And it's dissuades people from posting threads, for a cheap thrill. Sure a few people might click the site to look, but it alienates the main users of the site- not a great idea.

Mumsnet feels more private than posting on Facebook because it's contained to those who sign up rather than being actively broadcasted and shared around.

Since when?

No-one needs an account to read what's written on MN??

SavingsThreads · 23/10/2022 15:58

undetetected · 23/10/2022 14:30

I don't like this.

Mumsnet feels more private than posting on Facebook because it's contained to those who sign up rather than being actively broadcasted and shared around.

They should definitely ask for consent, or at least notify if the post on FB/Twitter.

Yeah, not keen on the idea of airing someone's dirty laundry when you have no idea how distressing a circumstance is. 'Shoes on vs shoes off/AIBU to not do x' is fine, but not personal topics.

And it's dissuades people from posting threads, for a cheap thrill. Sure a few people might click the site to look, but it alienates the main users of the site- not a great idea.

But it isn't contained. Not only
Do you not have to sign up to read everything, but any member can share any post to any social media platform. Not to mention the tabloids it's regularly
Picked up in

Dotjones · 23/10/2022 14:47

People are really careless with their personal information. I read this BBC article yesterday - in the first few lines it tells us the name and age of of a young Scottish woman, the small town where she works, the bus number she catches, the fact it's often cancelled so she's left stranded, and helpful information about her having to walk along a dual carriageway sliproad to get to her stop - which effectively narrows it down to two of the seven bus stops in the town. There's also a photo of her so after a quick Google search of social media accounts you know a profile belongs to her and which animal she is obsessed with.

It's basically everything a stalker would need to locate this woman if they're willing to hang around at a bus stop for a few hours to narrow it down between the two potential stops.

undetetected · 23/10/2022 14:32

And the fact that trashy tabloids with no decent Journalists scour Mumsnet for 'news' didn't make it any better. But they're not the ones running the site.

undetetected · 23/10/2022 14:30

I don't like this.

Mumsnet feels more private than posting on Facebook because it's contained to those who sign up rather than being actively broadcasted and shared around.

They should definitely ask for consent, or at least notify if the post on FB/Twitter.

Yeah, not keen on the idea of airing someone's dirty laundry when you have no idea how distressing a circumstance is. 'Shoes on vs shoes off/AIBU to not do x' is fine, but not personal topics.

And it's dissuades people from posting threads, for a cheap thrill. Sure a few people might click the site to look, but it alienates the main users of the site- not a great idea.

JenniferBarkley · 23/10/2022 14:21

Ekátn · 23/10/2022 13:26

Some people really think MN is a private support group.

Does everyone know the Daily Mail and others uses threads all the time as well?

You shouldn’t be posting here if you expect it to remain private.

Or that a "private" FB group has genuine privacy. The MN FB page has 239K followers. Even if they made it private, there's nothing private about 200,000 people reading what you've written. Even if you can see you have no friends in the group you have no idea who the other people are, if they're fake identities or if they know you even if you haven't recognised them.

LeMoo · 23/10/2022 14:06

I don't think people expect privacy at all. Everyone knows it's a public forum. I think many posters have an expectation of discretion and while the occasional thread is picked up by a tabloid, that's different to an algorithm flashing threads up on a much more widely used social media site.

The nature of fb, too, means that people are more likely to be identified their than they are here. And tabloids pick threads that are generally humorous or ridiculous, not ones that are sensitive. An algorithm has no such discretion.

Ekátn · 23/10/2022 13:26

Some people really think MN is a private support group.

Does everyone know the Daily Mail and others uses threads all the time as well?

You shouldn’t be posting here if you expect it to remain private.

QueSyrahSyrah · 23/10/2022 13:24

I didn't know but it doesn't surprise me. It does make me more cautious about posting though.

To answer those who say FB is just as public as MN then yes of course technically you're correct, but my FB feed is full of 'you make like' suggested posts that are neither things I like nor things I follow, and often things wildly unrelated to anything I do like or follow. They're not sponsored posts either, it's just the FB Algorithm putting stuff in front of me.

Yes someone may Google a question about gardening or their pet or whatever and land here on MN, but that doesn't mean they're automatically going to stick around and start scrolling AIBU.

The problem with posts being shared on FB is that they will undoubtedly land in front of thousands of people that would never ever organically have stumbled across them. This is par for the course when MN Madness on Twitter or the tabloids do it, but it's a bit shitty when MN themselves use people's genuine and often quite serious personal issues as clickbait.

woodhill · 23/10/2022 13:21

Yes it is off putting as it is meant to be a forum for help and advice especially for mums presumably

I've found mumsnet really helpful at times but have name changed if I shared anything personal .

I try to comment on more general topics

LimeTwists · 23/10/2022 13:10

The only way to be safe on here is to not post the truth about concrete details. Don’t specify months, years, ages, sexes, type of place you work, when exactly things occurred etc etc. I never do because I might have a problem that I know won’t be seen and recognised by certain people as they aren’t on mumsnet but they may well recognise it if it appears in a paper they read or on Facebook. Sadly, people’s problems can be a source of entertainment for others who aren’t there to help, only read and giggle about over a coffee.

Backthetruckup · 23/10/2022 10:37

It's really easy to build up a pretty detailed picture of frequent posters. E.g. Bluebird1 = a 47 year old woman, living in Leeds, married with two sons aged 14 and 16 and a 7 year old German Shepherd called Bruno, works as a nurse, wears glasses and the husband is an accountant. Lots of over sharing going on. Mind you, that only applies if they're telling the truth in the first place - could be single 52 year old Brian from Wolverhampton in his underpants.

PAFMO · 23/10/2022 09:41

memoriesofamiga · 23/10/2022 00:52

This happened to me about 2 weeks ago. My thread was picked up by a national newspaper (I only found out as someone posted in the thread saying this had happened) only a few hours after I posted. And the details on the newspaper's page were wrong and exaggerated. I was only looking for some advice here.

MNHQ were very quick to respond to my message to them asking them to delete the thread. So they are aware this happens.

MN used to have a weekly collaboration with the Daily Mail. Kind of a "threads of the week" thing.
So hardly surprising that the more interesting ones still find their way there.

french76 · 23/10/2022 02:40

Yes, it definitely stopped me from posting. I felt the Mumsnet forum is for current mums but Facebook hits a whole genre of people who could recognise/out an op. It just feels more public even though I know all of it is public. I often name change just for privacy.

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 23/10/2022 01:46

XenoBitch · 22/10/2022 18:57

The Sun, Mirror, and Daily Mail also post threads from here all the time.

Exactly this too

FiveMins · 23/10/2022 01:41

butterfliedtwo · 22/10/2022 23:45

Nothing and nowhere on the Internet is private. That's rule number one. Rule number two is: the Internet is forever.

None of this should be a surprise to adults and ought to be drilled into kids and young people online.

If you're not paying, you're the product.

This X 1000.

Seriously OP I hope you don't have children who rely on you to explain this to them.

DancingInHisShirt · 23/10/2022 01:37

memoriesofamiga · 23/10/2022 00:52

This happened to me about 2 weeks ago. My thread was picked up by a national newspaper (I only found out as someone posted in the thread saying this had happened) only a few hours after I posted. And the details on the newspaper's page were wrong and exaggerated. I was only looking for some advice here.

MNHQ were very quick to respond to my message to them asking them to delete the thread. So they are aware this happens.

They’re happy that it happens. Their website is mentioned. It’s publicity for them.

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 23/10/2022 01:36

I've voted YABU as MN have never made a secret of all posts here can be shared elsewhere.

It's not a private part of the internet
They're a business
It seems some people don't realise that or if they do they need reminding.

crostina1 · 23/10/2022 01:04

For fucks sake this is my thread

memoriesofamiga · 23/10/2022 00:55

I should probably add that my thread wasn't really one that made me identifiable, I just didn't want gutter press getting anything out of it. They're scum.

memoriesofamiga · 23/10/2022 00:52

RefuseTheLies · 22/10/2022 18:54

First time it happened to me, I nearly died of shock 😆 Can’t imagine how much worse it feels to be picked up by a national newspaper

This happened to me about 2 weeks ago. My thread was picked up by a national newspaper (I only found out as someone posted in the thread saying this had happened) only a few hours after I posted. And the details on the newspaper's page were wrong and exaggerated. I was only looking for some advice here.

MNHQ were very quick to respond to my message to them asking them to delete the thread. So they are aware this happens.