Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?

240 replies

IroningThrone · 22/10/2022 14:02

I live in a village with a large public sports/playing field - it has grass tennis courts, football pitches and such marked out. Dogs are allowed and I've always used it to give my dog a good run around (he's on a 50ft bright pink lead, not running loose. I tend to stick to the edges near the hedges so I'm not disturbing anyone!)

Walking today and just been shouted at by man setting up archery targets. They're set out so 1/3 of the field is now unusable. I'd planned to loop round the full field (as shown by the blue line- red dot is where he was setting up. Blue blob is where I entered the field!) He also wasn't shooting at the time so I'm not sure why he felt the need to shout at me that I couldn't go that way!

It's a public field with multiple access points - aibu to think that archery belongs somewhere where the access can be more controlled? A kid could quite easily run in from the side access and right across where he'd plonked himself!

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MonsteraDeliciosa · 24/10/2022 07:37

But if Greg's archers have moved indoors for winter, that must have been someone else??

SuperCamp · 24/10/2022 07:36

flamingogold · 24/10/2022 07:31

But Greg also says 'Like any sport we have seasons. We are currently indoors at Belle Vue for winter and don’t return until the end of March. And you will see more football as they enter their season.'

So there are 3 possibilities:

  1. there are a number of places with sports fields next to station road and Greg got the wrong one (there is one in my town)

  2. the archer setting up today was not one of Greg's merry gang because they have moved inside for the winter

  3. the op is either mistaken or lying about the ownership and access to the sports fields and probably the date as well.

Interesting how people default to option 3.

Well, Greg seems keen to be transparent and helpful so I am sure he and the OP can get the matter cleared up.

It does look like the same field, from some basic googling.

flamingogold · 24/10/2022 07:31

But Greg also says 'Like any sport we have seasons. We are currently indoors at Belle Vue for winter and don’t return until the end of March. And you will see more football as they enter their season.'

So there are 3 possibilities:

  1. there are a number of places with sports fields next to station road and Greg got the wrong one (there is one in my town)

  2. the archer setting up today was not one of Greg's merry gang because they have moved inside for the winter

  3. the op is either mistaken or lying about the ownership and access to the sports fields and probably the date as well.

Interesting how people default to option 3.

PuttingDownRoots · 24/10/2022 07:30

If it is actually a Private field they better either improve the signage if the local people aren't aware its private or check for Rights of Way across the field...

It seems a bit strange the OP has never seen Archery there before. Usually in Villages people seem to know Everything.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 24/10/2022 07:26

I'd guess Greg knows exactly which field the OP is talking about since there is a picture in the opening post.

Ifailed · 24/10/2022 07:24

A good example of the old adage: There's two sides to every story.

flamingogold · 24/10/2022 07:20

DaenerysTarragon · 24/10/2022 07:15

Well op, it isn’t a public field so that rather changes things doesn’t it.

Are you sure Greg is talking about the same field? It may not be anything to do with his organisation, particularly when they're inside for the winter at the Bellevue.

RoseAndRose · 24/10/2022 07:19

Yes, is it the same field?

OP describes an open space owned by the PC for the village. Update describes a field owned by a trust and leased to a sports association.

They can't both be true of one site.

DaenerysTarragon · 24/10/2022 07:15

Well op, it isn’t a public field so that rather changes things doesn’t it.

Stopsnowing · 24/10/2022 07:08

Love the informative and detailed update!

GregJP · 24/10/2022 06:58

Unfortunately we do have to stop people walking behind the targets despite signage/ropes.

Some people don’t think you’ll miss or an arrow will hurt!.

We follow guidance from our governing body known as the Rules of Shooting (RoS).

We have a buffer of 50 yards so if someone is shooting 70 yards they would need 120 yards. Which takes you to the edge of the field.

But when people see the target half way in the field they assume it’s safe and you can’t miss. Unfortunately many factors can make you miss including miss fires, equipment failures. This is why we have the buffer.

PortiasBiscuit · 24/10/2022 06:46

Was he shooting or was he setting up? Maybe he hadn’t finished setting up?
Archery clubs are incredibly safety conscious, I’m sure that if you had gone back half an hour later you would not have got anywhere near anywhere dangerous.
Also, they only shoot in one direction, at the targets, they don’t need to stop people walking behind them.

GregJP · 24/10/2022 06:39

Thanks for your input. We have been at the field two years now so I know we are still relatively new.

Like any sport we have seasons. We are currently indoors at Belle Vue for winter and don’t return until the end of March. And you will see more football as they enter their season.

From time to time you may see a handful of archers practice as they can not attend our usual club days and/or they require additional practice for competitions.

I don’t believe anyone would shout aggressively to you. They would just shout as it’s a big field and making you aware of possible danger.

If this becomes an ongoing problem we would have to consider closing the whole field, which is our right to do so. But that’s the last thing we want to do. The only time we endeavour to do this if and when we put large competitions on at our club.

When we return outdoors next year I would invite any of you to attend and have a taster session free of charge and it may make you more insightful of what we do and safety procedures or feel free to talk to archers if you’re down the field and they will happily explain.

Also to make you aware we are affiliated to and governed by ArcheryGB (AGB) in addition to holding insurance in relation to public liability.

Any Questions?.

Gregory Plews
Greatham Sports Field Secretary
Archery Club Secretary

BlackberryCat · 24/10/2022 06:01

Thanks for clearing it up, Greg. The OP said she didn’t see any signs, so perhaps it’s something you could check and make double sure that the signs are clearly visible.

garlictwist · 24/10/2022 05:59

I think it's fine. It's not all day and it's a public park. Tbh, I think dogs cause more hassle than anyone else on playing fields.

GregJP · 24/10/2022 05:53

Hello. I have just been made aware of this post by one of my members.

My Name is Greg and I am the Secretary of Heugh Bowmen Archery Club as well as the Secretary of the Sports Field.

First of all May I point out although the land remains the property of The Hospital of God, the land is leased and maintained by Greatham Sportsfield Association and thus private. Access to the public is allowed if and when we allow it. We are entitled to close of the whole field to anyone at anytime however we want to share the field space with the community and therefore do not close off all access.

Archery is permitted on the land and has safety boundaries and overshoot. Signage is placed at the gates outlining private land and warning of archery in progress. Other signs get placed at the sides of the cabins when actively shooting.

I would invite you to email me and the committee ([email protected]) and we can discuss this further or I can attend the field and show and explain our procedures.

regards

Greg

IroningThrone · 22/10/2022 22:22

Thanks for the input. I'm going to speak to the parish Council first then depending on what they say may speak to 101 as well. It's a club apparently but there was only one man there today.

OP posts:
GetOffTheRoof · 22/10/2022 16:30

@Dotjones it's absolutely a police matter. Just like someone practicing with a katana in public. These are weapons, irrespective of intent.

Using a public location without adequate means of keeping the public safe is far too risky. The methods you're describing for clearing an area of people and animals is far too simplistic when compared with the level of risk.

smileandsing · 22/10/2022 15:48

Dotjones 'shouting warnings' is far from sufficient. If someone were injured 'but I shouted a warning' would hardly constitute a reasonable defence.
OP I'd call 101 and/or the council to report your concerns. I don't know if it's a Police matter or not, but they may take an interest as it's it's causing members of the public to be concerned for their safety, and have a word with the people involved. I doubt the council will do anything tbh

Dotjones · 22/10/2022 15:38

It's not a police matter. Speak to the council to see if they allow archery on the playing field. It would only be a police matter if they were actually firing arrows without proper controls to stop people crossing the target range whilst shooting is taking place. They don't have to fence off any area, provided they control access in some manner, shouting warnings to people - and more importantly, stopping shooting if people ignore the warnings - is perfectly sufficient.

Basically, you can shoot on public land provided you do not endanger people or property. By definition, if an area is clear of people and property (however that clearance is maintained) they cannot be endangered.

IroningThrone · 22/10/2022 15:24

rwalker · 22/10/2022 15:17

I would of just given it a wide birth
tbh take a dog for a walk on a 50ft lead is ridiculous how can u be in control of a dog 50ft away tethered or not .not to mention dogs pissing and shitting on playing fields would of bother me more

And of course he's under control - he's trained to voice commands! I like him on a lead because you hear of loose dogs being stolen unfortunately. He's also not shitting on the field because he'll only go at home. And if he wees it's on the hedges and well away from the pitches!

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 22/10/2022 15:19

Even soft archery would be a bit stupid. I'd call the Police so they can have a word.

rwalker · 22/10/2022 15:17

I would of just given it a wide birth
tbh take a dog for a walk on a 50ft lead is ridiculous how can u be in control of a dog 50ft away tethered or not .not to mention dogs pissing and shitting on playing fields would of bother me more

Endeavour1971 · 22/10/2022 15:16

This is a police matter...he is breaking the law. I know someone who took a bow and arrow onto a public area to practise loading it. He was arrested and charged with endangering the public

IroningThrone · 22/10/2022 15:15

fyn · 22/10/2022 15:04

If the parish council may have given permission. If they are the landowner then can give permission for whatever they want. They don’t have to make their land open to the public all the time, they are perfectly entitled to allow users to block some of it off for use.

The field is 100% still open though. They could close and lock the gates but they're wide open. No warning signs or anything!

OP posts: