Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?

240 replies

IroningThrone · 22/10/2022 14:02

I live in a village with a large public sports/playing field - it has grass tennis courts, football pitches and such marked out. Dogs are allowed and I've always used it to give my dog a good run around (he's on a 50ft bright pink lead, not running loose. I tend to stick to the edges near the hedges so I'm not disturbing anyone!)

Walking today and just been shouted at by man setting up archery targets. They're set out so 1/3 of the field is now unusable. I'd planned to loop round the full field (as shown by the blue line- red dot is where he was setting up. Blue blob is where I entered the field!) He also wasn't shooting at the time so I'm not sure why he felt the need to shout at me that I couldn't go that way!

It's a public field with multiple access points - aibu to think that archery belongs somewhere where the access can be more controlled? A kid could quite easily run in from the side access and right across where he'd plonked himself!

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
girlfriend44 · 24/10/2022 17:01

knew a man who was hitting a golf ball in the park once so dangerous. I did mention it of course.

BMW6 · 24/10/2022 17:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JorisBonson · 24/10/2022 16:58

Absolutely fucking batshit.

StrangerOnline · 24/10/2022 16:42

GregJP · 24/10/2022 15:39

Before this all started I sent a private message but no response.

And another example here of @GregJP being courteous and neighbourly, doing the right thing.

I agree with PP - you are a great ambassador for your club and sport… thank you for restoring my faith in human nature, your patience on this thread has been exemplary

thestarvingcaterpillar · 24/10/2022 16:39

What a simply marvellous thread!! Nothing constructive to add but I do love Mumsnet!

RoseAndRose · 24/10/2022 16:38

It does sound as though it would be advisable for @GregJP to print off this thread and discuss it with the club's insurers as a concrete example, and then take whatever steps they recommend.

It looks as though OP might just have lost the village the general use of the field.

GregJP · 24/10/2022 16:34

girlmom21 · 24/10/2022 16:32

Can someone sue if they're hurt on private land that's clearly signposted without permission to be there?

As far as I’m aware you can still attempt to sue but if measures/risk assessments and signage is in place they would still find it hard to win a claim. We have our own insurers who identify risks and should a member lose an arrow we have to report that.

girlmom21 · 24/10/2022 16:32

BlodynGwyn · 24/10/2022 16:25

Greg, you need to stop dog walkers from using your field. You might be setting yourself for a law suit if you don't stop people such as the OP. We own a lot of land and have to tell people to leave a few times, especially on the land that borders a town. We actually call the town marshal and sees them off. We don't want someone getting hurt and suing us.

Can someone sue if they're hurt on private land that's clearly signposted without permission to be there?

RoseAndRose · 24/10/2022 16:29

rwalker · 24/10/2022 16:22

So common sense would tell you to keep off the ACHERY CLUB filed then

If OP reported the Archery Club, the upshot would be no more public access to the grounds it leases, other than by specific hire (eg the football club which uses it at set times)

BlodynGwyn · 24/10/2022 16:25

Greg, you need to stop dog walkers from using your field. You might be setting yourself for a law suit if you don't stop people such as the OP. We own a lot of land and have to tell people to leave a few times, especially on the land that borders a town. We actually call the town marshal and sees them off. We don't want someone getting hurt and suing us.

rwalker · 24/10/2022 16:22

Rainbowshit · 24/10/2022 13:15

Bet an arrow in your or your child's eye would have bothered you a damn sight more.

OP, you need to report this it's so dangerous.

So common sense would tell you to keep off the ACHERY CLUB filed then

picklemewalnuts · 24/10/2022 16:22

@GregJP sorry, I tried to clarify, I wasn't suggesting you had. OP may not have understood this is an established club with a better right to be there than she has, just because the name is on the map though. In your case that is clearly what it means.

Mind, I'm well aware I see the best in people to the point of gullibility.

I've too often been unfairly suspected of bad behaviour, perhaps!

SuperCamp · 24/10/2022 16:12

The quality of my tech is so low that I can't see that is says Archery Club. I bet the OP only wanted to try and anonymise the location. I mean, you would hardly try and make mischief for an archery club or its members by anonymising the club, would you? I am assuming that the OP was simply a bit taken aback to see arrows about to fly, and decided to seek opinions on whether this is OK on publicly accessible land.

thelobsterquadrille · 24/10/2022 15:55

picklemewalnuts · 24/10/2022 15:28

In my experience most people make assumptions about publicly accessible land in their area.

OP most likely thinks land that's publicly accessible is the same as public land, that it's owned by the parish council because the parish council owned the playing fields at the last village she lived.

Anyone can add a label to a map, Google are notorious for letting you claim addresses! A neighbour's home is labelled something like 'Smith Palace'.

Obviously I'm not suggesting you have done that, Greg, just that a name on a map wouldn't necessarily indicate to OP that it's an actual established archery club and not owned by the council.
As for the sign, I managed to fault to see the 'no dogs' sign on my local field, despite looking for it, until it was pointed out to me. Turns out I don't look up very far!

It's harsh to assume OP is being disingenuous. What would the point be?

It's not harsh at all.

OP is complaining about someone playing archery on a field.
She's then gone to the trouble of looking up the field, found that it says "Local Archery Club", blacked it out, and posted the photo to try and argue that people shouldn't be practising archery there.

It's dodgy at best.

GregJP · 24/10/2022 15:47

picklemewalnuts · 24/10/2022 15:28

In my experience most people make assumptions about publicly accessible land in their area.

OP most likely thinks land that's publicly accessible is the same as public land, that it's owned by the parish council because the parish council owned the playing fields at the last village she lived.

Anyone can add a label to a map, Google are notorious for letting you claim addresses! A neighbour's home is labelled something like 'Smith Palace'.

Obviously I'm not suggesting you have done that, Greg, just that a name on a map wouldn't necessarily indicate to OP that it's an actual established archery club and not owned by the council.
As for the sign, I managed to fault to see the 'no dogs' sign on my local field, despite looking for it, until it was pointed out to me. Turns out I don't look up very far!

It's harsh to assume OP is being disingenuous. What would the point be?

Re claiming a place from google you’re right but I haven’t claimed the place after said discussion. And the OP clearly knows this by blacking out the name. We listed it on Google as we were previously elsewhere and it helps visiting archers find our club when travelling to competitions. We also use what3words

GregJP · 24/10/2022 15:46

What delightful morning/afternoon events I’ve had to deal with. I really do hope the OP returns. Everyone is entitled an opinion but facts will decide the outcome of this matter.

GregJP · 24/10/2022 15:39

BMW6 · 24/10/2022 14:51

I have sent OP a message asking them to come back to this thread to explain themselves. 🤔

Before this all started I sent a private message but no response.

picklemewalnuts · 24/10/2022 15:28

In my experience most people make assumptions about publicly accessible land in their area.

OP most likely thinks land that's publicly accessible is the same as public land, that it's owned by the parish council because the parish council owned the playing fields at the last village she lived.

Anyone can add a label to a map, Google are notorious for letting you claim addresses! A neighbour's home is labelled something like 'Smith Palace'.

Obviously I'm not suggesting you have done that, Greg, just that a name on a map wouldn't necessarily indicate to OP that it's an actual established archery club and not owned by the council.
As for the sign, I managed to fault to see the 'no dogs' sign on my local field, despite looking for it, until it was pointed out to me. Turns out I don't look up very far!

It's harsh to assume OP is being disingenuous. What would the point be?

thelobsterquadrille · 24/10/2022 15:26

IaltagDhubh · 24/10/2022 13:56

Giving Op the benefit of the doubt, I’d assume that blacking out the club name was for her own privacy. Plenty of places have a Station Road, so that wouldn’t be outing. Basically Greg, you’ve outed the op rather dramatically, which is somewhat against MN etiquette even if it wasn’t your intention! Can’t blame her for not coming back really.

Personally, I’d suggest that the field should be closed any time arrows are flying around. Kids and dogs don’t read signs. Plenty of adults don’t bother to either.

Greg hasn't outed anyone.

OP has been decidedly underhand in her posting. She can clearly read, so she knew she was blocking out "Archery Club" when she did it. She could have just blacked out it's name if she was worried about being identified.

As it is, she blacked out the existence of the archery club then came on to complain about people playing archery Hmm

Augend23 · 24/10/2022 15:23

ShirleywasaLady · 24/10/2022 15:19

But she was literally blacking out the words 'archery club' to come on and complain that she didn't think people should be doing archery there? Are you telling me that you think she looked it up on google maps, though 'I'd better block out the name to anonymise it' and at no point thought 'oh, wait, it says 'archery club' - that might be important...'?

And as for outing her - anyone who lives there would recognise the field from the google maps image (and probably the dog walker with the bright pink 50ft lead). If she wanted to stay anonymous, she could have hand drawn a diagram....

Also you could black out the top bit without blacking out the part that said archery club...

ShirleywasaLady · 24/10/2022 15:19

IaltagDhubh · 24/10/2022 15:05

Well yes, she could have googled and answered her own question rather than posting here, but I doubt she was intending anything underhand but blacking out the club name, as you seem to be implying.

If you get to decide who is allowed to use the field, then that’s up to you, but personally, I’d not want random people walking about if I was firing arrows. People, in general, are quite stupid, and always keen to blame someone else if something goes wrong. You don’t need to close the field all the time, only when the archery club is using it. Again though, you’re implying that it would be op’s fault if you decided to stop all dog walkers from using the field, which seems a bit unfair to me, especially since you’ve just outed her to your entire village.

But she was literally blacking out the words 'archery club' to come on and complain that she didn't think people should be doing archery there? Are you telling me that you think she looked it up on google maps, though 'I'd better block out the name to anonymise it' and at no point thought 'oh, wait, it says 'archery club' - that might be important...'?

And as for outing her - anyone who lives there would recognise the field from the google maps image (and probably the dog walker with the bright pink 50ft lead). If she wanted to stay anonymous, she could have hand drawn a diagram....

SuperCamp · 24/10/2022 15:16

With the dog. On the pink lead.

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?
IaltagDhubh · 24/10/2022 15:05

GregJP · 24/10/2022 14:27

Ok so I’ve responded to this thread after a member highlighted it to me. To make people aware of facts. The OP described the sports field but was making it clear archery shouldn’t be there then said OP googled and found said Club at which time they screenshot and blacked out said Club for privacy or other reasons. My point is they blacked it out which clearly stated Archery so at that point she could have investigated or not even posted as clearly it was labelled. Guess I’m in the wrong?. And all dog walkers will be refused entry because of this one person?.

Well yes, she could have googled and answered her own question rather than posting here, but I doubt she was intending anything underhand but blacking out the club name, as you seem to be implying.

If you get to decide who is allowed to use the field, then that’s up to you, but personally, I’d not want random people walking about if I was firing arrows. People, in general, are quite stupid, and always keen to blame someone else if something goes wrong. You don’t need to close the field all the time, only when the archery club is using it. Again though, you’re implying that it would be op’s fault if you decided to stop all dog walkers from using the field, which seems a bit unfair to me, especially since you’ve just outed her to your entire village.

BMW6 · 24/10/2022 14:51

I have sent OP a message asking them to come back to this thread to explain themselves. 🤔

BMW6 · 24/10/2022 14:46

I agree GregJP

OP surely read Archery Club as she was blacking it out !

Will She/he have the courtesy to come back here to explain themselves? 🤔

Swipe left for the next trending thread