Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?

240 replies

IroningThrone · 22/10/2022 14:02

I live in a village with a large public sports/playing field - it has grass tennis courts, football pitches and such marked out. Dogs are allowed and I've always used it to give my dog a good run around (he's on a 50ft bright pink lead, not running loose. I tend to stick to the edges near the hedges so I'm not disturbing anyone!)

Walking today and just been shouted at by man setting up archery targets. They're set out so 1/3 of the field is now unusable. I'd planned to loop round the full field (as shown by the blue line- red dot is where he was setting up. Blue blob is where I entered the field!) He also wasn't shooting at the time so I'm not sure why he felt the need to shout at me that I couldn't go that way!

It's a public field with multiple access points - aibu to think that archery belongs somewhere where the access can be more controlled? A kid could quite easily run in from the side access and right across where he'd plonked himself!

To think archery has no place on a public playing field?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CaptainThe95thRifles · 25/10/2022 14:56

maddening · 25/10/2022 09:08

Shouting warnings and signs seem inadequate - what about hearing impaired, visually impaired and people unable to read or understand english

The person walking into the shooting line doesn't have to hear or understand the command.

When people are shooting, there should be a marshal present who is watching the area. This may be two people, swapping between ends, so each shoots while the other watches. When the marshal sees a potential risk, their job is to shout - "hold" or "fast", usually - and then try to clear the area. The archers do not shoot because the "hold" command applies to them - they will remove arrows from their string and wait until the range is safe.

You'd have to be bloody fast to run across the range and get into the way of an arrow between the point of no return, and the arrow hitting the target. This is particularly true in the UK as bow hunting is illegal - an archer would be culpable if a pigeon flew across in front of the targets and was hit by an arrow. Thus, we all take adequate precautions to make sure there's no risk of anyone or anything getting in the way.

girlmom21 · 25/10/2022 14:49

IroningThrone · 25/10/2022 14:45

When I clicked on the link it loaded a blank page. I explained that!

So you assumed the man doing archery was behaving dangerously rather than that the link just didn't work and try to google the club instead. Makes sense.

IroningThrone · 25/10/2022 14:45

When I clicked on the link it loaded a blank page. I explained that!

OP posts:
GregJP · 25/10/2022 14:33

thelobsterquadrille · 25/10/2022 14:08

I don’t know why everyone is having such a go at the OP

Because she went to the effort of looking the field up on Google Maps, saw it said "Archery Club", deliberately blocked it out, and then came online to complain about a man using an Archery Club field to...do archery Hmm

Surely most people would look the field up, go "Oh! I didn't realise there was an Archery Club there" and either leave it, or look up the club on Facebook/Google?

Exactly my point.

I wouldn’t even be aware of this if a member of my club didn’t make me aware of it.

I felt I had to come on to discuss this and like everything often has two sides. I’m not saying we are perfect and of course we have all learnt lessons but getting the correct information out there is very important.

GregJP · 25/10/2022 14:31

IroningThrone · 25/10/2022 14:08

Why the sarcasm? I simply said what I've seen in the past. Of course I'm aware that it exists. I don't think that was ever in doubt. That particular field was part of a private estate down south though. I don't think I've every seen it done on a space where people can just walk in (which is why I started this thread - it's outside my sphere of experience!)

Yes my bad on the sarcasm. But just the whole thing that developed came around from you after you screenshot the field on google maps and then blocking our Club out and then creating a debate when really you googling it answered your debate. So can you see how this has all exploded?.

thelobsterquadrille · 25/10/2022 14:08

I don’t know why everyone is having such a go at the OP

Because she went to the effort of looking the field up on Google Maps, saw it said "Archery Club", deliberately blocked it out, and then came online to complain about a man using an Archery Club field to...do archery Hmm

Surely most people would look the field up, go "Oh! I didn't realise there was an Archery Club there" and either leave it, or look up the club on Facebook/Google?

IroningThrone · 25/10/2022 14:08

Why the sarcasm? I simply said what I've seen in the past. Of course I'm aware that it exists. I don't think that was ever in doubt. That particular field was part of a private estate down south though. I don't think I've every seen it done on a space where people can just walk in (which is why I started this thread - it's outside my sphere of experience!)

OP posts:
GregJP · 25/10/2022 13:51

IroningThrone · 25/10/2022 12:22

I've seen it physically fenced off before with ropes. (Different location!)

So you are aware Archery exists and on a big open spaced field?.

Also just out of curiosity did you think the archer lugged an approximate target 3ft X 5ft and 2-3 stone on his back?. To an open space?. If not you may have observed he retrieved a target out of a ginormous shipping container which sadly isn’t even movable by the worlds strongest man. at just over 30 TON we had to use a Hiab.

IroningThrone · 25/10/2022 12:22

I've seen it physically fenced off before with ropes. (Different location!)

OP posts:
Ekátn · 25/10/2022 10:18

maddening · 25/10/2022 09:08

Shouting warnings and signs seem inadequate - what about hearing impaired, visually impaired and people unable to read or understand english

So what’s the alternative?

Backthetruckup · 25/10/2022 10:17

Man uses archery field for archery, hold the front page!

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 25/10/2022 09:58

@GregJP
Your organisation is to be commended for trying to be community spirited and allowing public access to this privately owned field.
Sadly, with the attitudes shown by some on this thread, I think you probably need to protect your own interests and close the field to the public.

GregJP · 25/10/2022 09:13

maddening · 25/10/2022 09:08

Shouting warnings and signs seem inadequate - what about hearing impaired, visually impaired and people unable to read or understand english

For those who don’t read signs or actually look do you think we should have a full time guard at the gate?. With the main gate closed there is still a small cut through to the children’s play area. We have people who shout loud, also a megaphone and whistles,

maddening · 25/10/2022 09:08

Shouting warnings and signs seem inadequate - what about hearing impaired, visually impaired and people unable to read or understand english

GregJP · 25/10/2022 08:59

JobSeekingMissile · 25/10/2022 08:50

@GregJP i work with the general public and as a whole they never fail to surprise with their ingenuity for the stupid / ridiculous mishaps. Great believer in belt and braces to protect one's self.
my local pub has 2 sets of clear hazard signs "mind the steps" & "caution steps" complete with images, they have paint on the steps to make them stand out, and they are well lit and you would not believe the number of people stumbling in - usually accompanied by a sniggering friend that did read the signs 😣

It’s unfortunate as when we moved to the field we notified the parish as well as advertised in the village shop to make people aware we were there and if anyone would like to join. We had a few respond. But in the last few months new builds have popped up so those obviously haven’t seen anything,

JobSeekingMissile · 25/10/2022 08:50

GregJP · 25/10/2022 08:29

Thank you for your input. But to point out there is adequate space/distance before an archer can see a member of public walk on the range so shooting alone is not an issue. I have shot alone but would prefer to shoot with someone as it’s a social sport as much as a competitive one.

One side exceeds 80 yards and the other 50 - 60 yards. so there is plenty of time to observe some one approaching either side of the target. Access directly behind is neigh on impossible as there is a big tree line/over growth with a beck immediately behind it. But thank you all for your advice and suggestions.

@GregJP i work with the general public and as a whole they never fail to surprise with their ingenuity for the stupid / ridiculous mishaps. Great believer in belt and braces to protect one's self.
my local pub has 2 sets of clear hazard signs "mind the steps" & "caution steps" complete with images, they have paint on the steps to make them stand out, and they are well lit and you would not believe the number of people stumbling in - usually accompanied by a sniggering friend that did read the signs 😣

GregJP · 25/10/2022 08:29

JobSeekingMissile · 25/10/2022 08:15

@GregJP I think @IroningThrone has done you a favour here.

You admit there are issues with people walking behind the targets - they could easily approach outside the archer's line of vision until it was too late. In the instance of injury (or worse) and the injured party having entered the field by a known access point - gap in hedge - with no signage then you could have been in hot water legally.
if you can't block the entry points immediately then you either need signage or to stop lone archers until it's resolved. At least a group of you are able to be more vigilant than one person.
From a legal stand point you need to make sure you are well covered here for your sake, so maybe some positives will come out if it for the club, and maybe you will get new people looking in to
archery 🏹 it is a great sport and you'd be surprised who may have a natural aptitude for it, it's not always the stereotypical sporty person 😬

Thank you for your input. But to point out there is adequate space/distance before an archer can see a member of public walk on the range so shooting alone is not an issue. I have shot alone but would prefer to shoot with someone as it’s a social sport as much as a competitive one.

One side exceeds 80 yards and the other 50 - 60 yards. so there is plenty of time to observe some one approaching either side of the target. Access directly behind is neigh on impossible as there is a big tree line/over growth with a beck immediately behind it. But thank you all for your advice and suggestions.

Ekátn · 25/10/2022 08:22

When the op took the photo and blacked out ‘archery club’ she knew exactly what she was doing. She could have just hidden then name.

Surely, when she looked at the field and saw ‘archery club’ her response would have been ‘oh, it’s an archery club’ and actually looked into it.

No one can control people making gaps in the hedge. If op is so fussed about signage and the proper way to do things, she should enter via the entrance. Not via a gap in the hedge.

if people are making gaps in the hedge it would be impossible to have signage to accommodate this consistently. And things like this are why these sorts of things end up being closed to the public.

The problem here really is that Op believed the field was something it’s not them moaned publicly without even looking into it.

JobSeekingMissile · 25/10/2022 08:15

@GregJP I think @IroningThrone has done you a favour here.

You admit there are issues with people walking behind the targets - they could easily approach outside the archer's line of vision until it was too late. In the instance of injury (or worse) and the injured party having entered the field by a known access point - gap in hedge - with no signage then you could have been in hot water legally.
if you can't block the entry points immediately then you either need signage or to stop lone archers until it's resolved. At least a group of you are able to be more vigilant than one person.
From a legal stand point you need to make sure you are well covered here for your sake, so maybe some positives will come out if it for the club, and maybe you will get new people looking in to
archery 🏹 it is a great sport and you'd be surprised who may have a natural aptitude for it, it's not always the stereotypical sporty person 😬

GregJP · 25/10/2022 07:05

SpringersLoveSofas · 25/10/2022 06:47

Feels like both sides have been a bit selective with the truth tbh.

We hear a lot about the great signage at the entrances and only later do we find out there are gaps in the hedge that are

A) known about to the club
And
B) acknowledged that they do need signage which hasn't yet been erected yet.

Half a dozen of one and six of the other, to me.

No, signage was erected multiple times by myself and has been taken down by some unknown individuals. Sadly I don’t live in the village and cannot always attend the field. So nothing selective here. Sadly kids and adults mistreat the privilege of the sports field and damage fences/gates/play area and unfortunately we are limited with volunteers so repairs don’t get done immediately,

SpringersLoveSofas · 25/10/2022 06:47

Feels like both sides have been a bit selective with the truth tbh.

We hear a lot about the great signage at the entrances and only later do we find out there are gaps in the hedge that are

A) known about to the club
And
B) acknowledged that they do need signage which hasn't yet been erected yet.

Half a dozen of one and six of the other, to me.

QuebecBagnet · 25/10/2022 06:47

And she gave a plausible explanation of why, for privacy reasons. Though I do agree it would have been better if she’d mentioned that maybe she had reason to believe the club had permission to be there. But like I said earlier even with permission the OP would still be wondering about safety rules. I just get a bit fed up with MN pile ons. Some people have been really daft, sending her PMs demanding she returns to the thread, whooping with delight about her being “caught out”. No need for it.

girlmom21 · 25/10/2022 06:43

QuebecBagnet · 25/10/2022 06:39

I don’t know why everyone is having such a go at the OP……the mob needs to stand down a bit!

OK so we have established that the club own/rent the field and have every right to be there. But from my understanding of Greg’s posts he agrees with the OP that there are some known/well used gaps in the hedge where there’s no warning signs. Great that Greg says this is going to be rectified. But I think most people would agree if they walked into what they thought was a community field (and had been a community field until recently ) with no warning signs and you came out into the target area of an archery club you might be wondering if that was ok or not.

But most people would then see it on Google maps and go "oh, there's actually an archery club" not scribble the name of the archery club out so that they can post the map online and complain.

QuebecBagnet · 25/10/2022 06:39

I don’t know why everyone is having such a go at the OP……the mob needs to stand down a bit!

OK so we have established that the club own/rent the field and have every right to be there. But from my understanding of Greg’s posts he agrees with the OP that there are some known/well used gaps in the hedge where there’s no warning signs. Great that Greg says this is going to be rectified. But I think most people would agree if they walked into what they thought was a community field (and had been a community field until recently ) with no warning signs and you came out into the target area of an archery club you might be wondering if that was ok or not.

girlmom21 · 25/10/2022 06:23

PuttingDownRoots · 24/10/2022 22:25

To be fair to the OP... the Archery club nly moved there last year. Before that it appears it was a Community Playing fields.

I wish there was an Archery Club near where I lived. The closest is Paintball....

The OP moved there more recently than the club did