Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask for money off house? Wwyd?

33 replies

moveblues · 22/10/2022 09:16

We are buying a house and paying 500k for it. The level 3 survey came back to say this needed a new roof (“life expired”) because the property is around 90 years old. We got a roofer to look at it who reckons it just needs a few replacement tiles, some other minor bits and bobs and a new flat roof. Circa £5-7k.
Drain survey also states £1.5k of work.
Now, I think it’s worth asking for this money off. We are already having to get new windows (circa 12k) to bring up to date and while the property isn’t the most expensive that’s sold on that road, it certainly isn’t the cheapest and isn’t in the best condition. Needs quite a bit of renovating which we will need to pay for in addition to these unforeseen works.

Husband is thinking we should not ask for the money off.
He has a point; one link in the chain has a mortgage expiry in the next 3-4 weeks. We do want to complete.
If it fell through we aren’t sure we would get it again (either in terms of offer on ours and prices ??increasing where we are buying relative to where we are selling?)
Vendor is lovely but temperamental

WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clymene · 23/10/2022 09:14

You're choosing to get new windows, you don't have to. The house has been priced with its current windows. And that roofing estimate is extortionate, assuming that the majority of the roof isn't flat. I've just had a load of cracked and missing tiles replaced, including bonnets down two sides and repointing around 3 chimneys and paid under a grand.

And drains is maintenance.

I'd tell you to sod off at this stage if I were the vendor.

moveblues · 23/10/2022 09:04

Hmm yes part of the problem is that the valuation isn't back yet but we probably only have the window in which that's being processed to revise our offer (without causing delays given our deadline)

OP posts:
Elphame · 22/10/2022 18:07

Antaboo · 22/10/2022 12:49

I've only lived in houses of a similar age, every survey we've had said it would be prudent to budget for a replacement roof in the short term (or similar wording), in 35+ years not one of the 4 houses have needed to be replaced - more often than not it's a surveyor covering their backside with bullshit.
If I was the seller I'd want quite strong proof that the roof was in need of imminent work before reducing - more than a disclaimer from a surveyor.

Indeed -my survey report said exactly that too. We asked a local builder to take a look. He said it was fine

20 years later we've just had to have a small bit of work done on part of the roof.

I'd be wanting cast iron proof and quotes before I'd be prepared to reduce the price.

Motheratlast123 · 22/10/2022 13:01

*down valued by the valuation

Motheratlast123 · 22/10/2022 13:00

Today, it is another person in the chain whose mortgage is elapsing soon. Tomorrow, if this chain falls over and you have to start over, it could be you. Unless the house is under valuation, I would tread carefully.

Antaboo · 22/10/2022 12:49

I've only lived in houses of a similar age, every survey we've had said it would be prudent to budget for a replacement roof in the short term (or similar wording), in 35+ years not one of the 4 houses have needed to be replaced - more often than not it's a surveyor covering their backside with bullshit.
If I was the seller I'd want quite strong proof that the roof was in need of imminent work before reducing - more than a disclaimer from a surveyor.

Vikinga · 22/10/2022 12:20

I wouldn't risk it for that. Having said that, when I was debating between two houses, the seller of the house I bought dropped the price by £5k without me even asking her. They have plenty of money and couldn't be bothered with the hassle of more time selling the property.

I guess you could ask and see what they say.

moveblues · 22/10/2022 12:15

I don't think it'll change the ltv and it won't change the interest rate; seller isn't purchasing; my own biggest concern is how long it could take for our mortgage co to revise the mortgage.

OP posts:
Reallybadidea · 22/10/2022 11:49

We asked for a reduction in a very similar situation recently following survey. We didn't get the full amount we asked for but we did get some. They're unlikely to cancel the sale at this stage just because you asked the question.

I would just double check with your mortgage broker that it won't affect your LTV or lead them to change your interest rate. Also how long to send a new mortgage offer out.

It's totally reasonable to renegotiate following a survey, you can't necessarily tell what repairs need doing during a 30 minute viewing. And most people don't have the expertise - that's why you get a survey!

Snugglemonkey · 22/10/2022 11:48

JustOrderADoor · 22/10/2022 11:08

He has a point; one link in the chain has a mortgage expiry in the next 3-4 weeks. We do want to complete

You'd be a bit of a cow to do this to them, it may totally fuck up their ability to buy the house/any house & will ceryainly
increase their cost of the mortgage IF they can get one.

If it fell through we aren’t sure we would get it again (either in terms of offer on ours and prices ??increasing where we are buying relative to where we are selling?)

How much do you want to move?? £8k on £500k house isn't much to risk losing it & the opportunity to move.

Vendor is lovely but temperamental

Again are you prepared to lose it over £8k on a house you know needs renovation?

As another poster said, look at the cost of replacing the roof. It might be best just to bite the bullet & do that first, properly. There's only so much you can patch before it becomes uneconomical & a risk of flooding. I'd do that before windows (there a lot you can do reasonably cheaply to insulate them for this winter) or if you can afford it after the roof so the worst windows. There's not generally a huge saving getting all of them done aa opposed to half now & half later on.

get the drainage checked by a second reputable company & see where that comes in the order of importance. Again I'd see that as more important than windows, but if it can be left until spring without further issues I'd do that

I agree with this. It is really shit of you to risk those people being actually unable to buy a home. It is foolish to risk your own move. It is reasonable upkeep and not enough money to create all the chaos (much of which would be for others to bear).

moveblues · 22/10/2022 11:45

If we got the money off it would directly free cash up (otherwise being used as deposit) for the work

OP posts:
CharlotteRose90 · 22/10/2022 11:43

I’d be asking for a reduction. Sellers are jacking the prices up currently on properties that aren’t worth it. My brothers just done the same thing for a roof and chimney and got £10k off. Might not sound a lot but it’s the principle.

moveblues · 22/10/2022 11:42

The vendors aren't doing an onward purchase and our mortgage is ok (fixed, porting). We haven't had the valuation back yet - should be next week

OP posts:
Boredsoentertainme · 22/10/2022 11:22

I never understand posts like this, you’re not buying a new build for gods sake .

Motheratlast123 · 22/10/2022 11:20

At what price was the house valued in your valuation?

JustOrderADoor · 22/10/2022 11:08

He has a point; one link in the chain has a mortgage expiry in the next 3-4 weeks. We do want to complete

You'd be a bit of a cow to do this to them, it may totally fuck up their ability to buy the house/any house & will ceryainly
increase their cost of the mortgage IF they can get one.

If it fell through we aren’t sure we would get it again (either in terms of offer on ours and prices ??increasing where we are buying relative to where we are selling?)

How much do you want to move?? £8k on £500k house isn't much to risk losing it & the opportunity to move.

Vendor is lovely but temperamental

Again are you prepared to lose it over £8k on a house you know needs renovation?

As another poster said, look at the cost of replacing the roof. It might be best just to bite the bullet & do that first, properly. There's only so much you can patch before it becomes uneconomical & a risk of flooding. I'd do that before windows (there a lot you can do reasonably cheaply to insulate them for this winter) or if you can afford it after the roof so the worst windows. There's not generally a huge saving getting all of them done aa opposed to half now & half later on.

get the drainage checked by a second reputable company & see where that comes in the order of importance. Again I'd see that as more important than windows, but if it can be left until spring without further issues I'd do that

Readaboutyourself · 22/10/2022 11:02

Thatiswild · 22/10/2022 10:40

We did this, ended up with £1k off the price and then taking about 4-6 weeks to change the mortgage amount it was a right pain and stress for nothing really. I wouldn’t bother again!

Same. They had to rush the mortgage offer through. Not worth the stress!

Aworldofmyown · 22/10/2022 11:00

Ask. They may decline and then you decide what to do.

mumda · 22/10/2022 10:59

The big expenses like windows and the roof are important to consider. I'd be interested in energy costs right now and what improvements can be made.

mumda · 22/10/2022 10:57

Is it your money you're spending?

All houses need maintenance and upkeep. If you needed to spend money replastering after you rip wallpaper off would you have enough money to do that work?

The big expenses like wi

Calmdown14 · 22/10/2022 10:56

Do you have a decent fixed rate mortgage offer? Will you need to reapply if the value changes?

It's a very small amount in the scale of a 500k house.

Could be worth it but if this fall's through and your new mortgage rate is much higher you might regret it.

If I'd secured a decent mortgage and this house was hard to find I wouldn't risk it. If I was a cash buyer and there are a decent number of properties that would suit my requirements then I'd ask

KalaniM · 22/10/2022 10:55

No, don’t bother. The things you say need doing are fairly standard minor things, not particularly unexpected. Not worth potentially sullying the transaction imho.

Bluevelvetsofa · 22/10/2022 10:50

It depends whether the prospect of money off is sufficient to jeopardise the whole chain and if it isn’t accepted, risk pissing of everyone in that chain, as well as losing the house.

Thatiswild · 22/10/2022 10:40

We did this, ended up with £1k off the price and then taking about 4-6 weeks to change the mortgage amount it was a right pain and stress for nothing really. I wouldn’t bother again!

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 22/10/2022 10:37

Things like a roof are visible and so it's condition should have been taken into account when the house was originally valued.

I think if the roof is 90 years old you risk throwing money away over the next few years by patching it up and perhaps in 10 years time a roofer will say it is beyond economic repair and you will have to replace it. I would find out the cost of a new roof and consider doing it sooner.