Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that transing young children is a medical scandal?

291 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 02:53

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11342541/Dr-Az-Hakeem-says-parents-claimed-kids-trans-NHS-Tavistock-transing-factory-clinic.html

"I remember saying to them, this is madness. What we're doing is madness. These are children. These are three-year-olds."
Are we seriously saying this is ok? I feel like as a society we have gone mad, allowing this to happen to young children.

AIBU to think this is child abuse? And if you disagree how do you justify three and four year olds being transed?

OP posts:
Atmywitsend29 · 22/10/2022 10:29

Absolutely child abuse.
It's disgusting. And any doctor or health professional that does this should be struck off.

There was a mum at the school whose 4 year old boy went home for the summer holidays and came back as a girl. The mother went from posting about her darling Prince to 6 weeks later talking about her beautiful brave daughter. The school had a whole assembly about it.
The mother then started telling everyone about how she knew her son was born a girl at 6 months.

She's absolutely insane. I feel for that poor child.

TeaPleaseNoLemon · 22/10/2022 10:25

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Weemummykay · 22/10/2022 10:21

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 22/10/2022 07:11

What is happening to children is scary at the moment, I can't actually believe anyone would try to transition a 3yo!!

My daughters peer group at school consists of a non binary girl, a girls who identifies as male and very much dresses as such and uses a crazy name, a girl who says shes a boy, but acts and dresses like a girl and also has given herself a crazy name, and another who recently has started saying she is non binary but also doesnt identify as human ???

They're 13! My DD is confident in her skin, but I think the latter two in this example does show what a role peer and societal pressure plays. The crazy names are a good example, like it's fun to insist people call you a mad name rather than your much more "normal" boring name.

@MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel there is a trans girl(I think that’s the right way round) at my partners work, wants to be a girl but still dressed like a male, hair cut like a male then gets angry and plays the transphobic card when a customer asks ‘excuse me son’ do you know where I can find such and such. The only girl thing about her is the name so if you don’t know her name you wouldn’t think otherwise

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 10:20

If these children insisted they were fat, despite being slim, would the parents take them to weight watchers? I’d these children insisted they were actually adults, would they be allowed to leave school and get a job? If these children insisted they were disabled, would the parents buy them a wheelchair? Why is gender the only thing that we MUST believe a child on, even a very young one?

Standonamountain · 22/10/2022 10:16

You are 100% not being unreasonable.

I've been thinking for years that it's scary and terrifying that parents are trying to transition tiny children to be the opposite sex and insisting that it's coming from the child.

People are too scared to say anything for fear of being called transphobic.

When I think back to my own childhood I went through phases where I wanted to be a dog, then a cat. I went through a stage of wanting to be a boy, I was never into very girly things. I daydreamed about wearing boys clothes and a cap and seeing if I could trick people. I dead to think the consequences of that in todays world.

TeaPleaseNoLemon · 22/10/2022 10:15

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

TeaPleaseNoLemon · 22/10/2022 10:12

This reply has been deleted

Previously banned poster - This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

beastlyslumber · 22/10/2022 10:10

YANBU. It's child abuse and in a sane society we would never allow it.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 22/10/2022 10:07

I agree with what people are saying. However to stop this we need to actually live with no gender stereotypes. There are still regular threads on here about parents treating children differently because of their sex, about parents not wanting their boy to play with dolls or wear nail varnish etc. There was one thread a while ago from a parent who's little boy loved wearing dresses and was adamant he wanted to wear a dress to primary school which he was shortly due to start. The overwhelming response from the AIBU community was that the parent was being unreasonable and trying to be 'woke' and 'using their son to make a point', and that even if the boy had a strong preference, the parents should make him wear boys uniform so he didn't get bullied. There was another thread about parents who didnt want to tell the world if theyd had a boy or a girl, where they were branded 'ridiculous', because for some reason people think they have a right to know about someone elses genitals.

My opinion is, that children should wear and play with whatever they like. I can see why, when there is so much gendering (even at year 1, boys play football and girls play more 'feminine' games likes skipping at my kids school) that if children are told 'you can't do x because you are a boy/girl', in a kids mind it is fairly logical to jump to a conclusion that 'if I really want to do x then I must actually be a boy/girl'. If gender stereotypes were much less of a thing, and people didn't feel pressure from society to confirm to arbitrary rules based on sex, I don't think transitioning would be as much of a thing.

35965a · 22/10/2022 10:06

It’s child abuse, no doubt about it.

thesparkthatbled · 22/10/2022 10:01

There's a trans kid in my kid's school. Transitioned from a little girl to a boy when they were 4, name change, male pronouns the lot. It's so sad and absolutely ridiculous. They have an older brother who used to come to school in summer dresses etc, so it's clear to me that this is all coming from the parents. "Ooh gender is just a construct darling, you'd like to be a boy? Yes that's fine sweetie!"

I could have written @Mexicola s post, I too grew up as a tomboy, boys clothes, short hair, always thrilled when people mistook me for a boy. I also wonder what would have become of me in today's climate? Would I now be a trans gay man? That thought horrifies me, not because there's anything wrong with being a trans gay man, but that I'm perfectly happy being a straight woman. Having choices like these forced into kids for a "decision" they made when they were 4 years old is heartbreaking.

I've spoken to a family member of the kid at school and apparently the child is dreading puberty, she's 8. What I also don't understand is that everyone at school knows they are trans so they are still not accepted as one of the boys, so I don't really see the point? I thought the whole idea was so they could pretend to be a boy, in order to properly live as a boy? ie to be accepted as a boy in the way a tomboy never would be? Why not just let her be a tomboy? Why the need to change her whole identity?

Chrysanthemum5 · 22/10/2022 09:52

I think the most shocking thing in that article is the timeline where they identify every point at which someone raised serious concerns and those concerns were ignored. How many children have been physically or mentally harmed since Sue Evans first tried to raise this issue?

Concernednan456 · 22/10/2022 09:47

I was ‘a boy’. I hated anything traditionally feminine from about 3 years old . I farmed snails in the dolls house my father bought me I wore boys clothes , begged for short hair , played out on the green with the boys wrestling and stuff. I like fishing, dirt bikes and setting fire to things in the yard.
if my parents had allowed me to mutilate my body based on this and screw up my long term health , fertility and sexual function I would never have forgiven them. At about thirteen I morphed into a very pretty , very feminine, boy crazy young women who retains fairly masculine hobbies and probably would be described as a bit tomboyish but I’m 100% woman inside and out .

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 22/10/2022 09:47

I can accept the fact that in the entire country we MIGHT have a couple of children that are struggling with this issue but there is no way we need an entire department dedicated to it.
Noone under 18 should be able to have anything pumped into their body to change their gender.

FrancescaContini · 22/10/2022 09:46

Jourdain11 · 22/10/2022 09:36

I don't 100% agree on this. The kids who are quite adamant that their biological sex doesn't match their gender identity from a young age, who are consistent and persistent about that, are probably the ones who are most likely to have genuine gender dysphoria which is not parentally or societally induced. I know someone in their sixties who experienced this and it never wavered at all for them.

“Gender dysphoria” only presents in a very, very small number of boys, and usually starts around aged 4 or 5, according to Abigail Shrier. Her book Irreversible Damage is an excellent introduction for anyone wondering WTAF has been happening over the last ten years. Clue: “social contagion” is one of her key phrases.

colouringindoors · 22/10/2022 09:45

YADNBU.

In kids that young it's absolutely abusive. But I'd also say some parents (not necessarily the ones he's talking about) believe all the trans ideology.

As a parent of a teen ds who currently identifes as a girl, who's experienced massive amounts of trauma, partly as a result of their dad, I'm appalled that the gender ideology issue has overshadowed all the other issues "trans" kids present with - trauma, autism, homophobia in family, victims of sexual abuse. That's abusive, medically negligent and just fkn appalling imho.

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 09:43

So @Jourdain11 we have a few children who need help to accept they will never be the opposite sex. They should still be given therapy to accept that this means, not affirming treatment allowing them to believe they have actually changed sex.

Jourdain11 · 22/10/2022 09:36

I don't 100% agree on this. The kids who are quite adamant that their biological sex doesn't match their gender identity from a young age, who are consistent and persistent about that, are probably the ones who are most likely to have genuine gender dysphoria which is not parentally or societally induced. I know someone in their sixties who experienced this and it never wavered at all for them.

oakleaffy · 22/10/2022 09:34

As a child, I desperately wanted to be a horse.
And to fly.
and, Ironically, to be a boy, as boys had better toys and freedoms.

But it was just a phase.

To harm children by this horrific Trans Ideology is terrifying.
Change clothing, sure, but don’t mutilate bodies or use hormones and blockers on children.

No one knows the long term effects of using these powerful drugs.

SignOnTheWindow · 22/10/2022 09:32

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 05:50

It is abuse. In all of these cases, I’d think in was the parents who wanted a child of the opposite sex, or we’re looking for attention. Look at all the praise and attention helped on parents of ‘trans children’. It may be a coincidence, but since this whole debacle started, cases of munchausens by proxy have dropped significantly. You can get more attention from a trans child and if anyone asks difficult questions you can just call them a transphobe.

@Asdavaluesausage, wow - I hadn't heard the Munschausens by proxy statistic. That's interesting. Do you have a link for that?

MorningPlatypus · 22/10/2022 09:24

YANBU at all.

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 09:21

To add I think the care for genuinely trans children needs to be not “you can change sex” but “you can never change your sex, but you can present how you want and let’s try to get you to a place where you are as happy and comfortable in your body and identity as possible”

Exactly. I still do not understand how we got to the point where propagating this lie is seen as the right thing to do.

WindyHedges · 22/10/2022 09:18

YANBU

It’ll eventually be a major medical scandal. Dr Hakeem is one of the most highly qualified medicos working in this area. He is in no way transphobic. He should be listened to.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/10/2022 09:08

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 22/10/2022 07:50

I agree.
I think for very young children who are, or parents saying are, showing signs of being trans or questioning their gender there should be a open hands off approach. Those children can make decisions about surgery/hormones once they are adults and As they become older children they can lead their transition/or not themselves. I don’t think we should be affirming or denying anything. Just confirming what sec they are but letting them know that their choice in how they dress/act/present is up to them.

I think there is a very dangerous grey area between children (I presume a very small proportion) who are genuinely transgender and will go on to live as a transgender person for their whole lives and children who are, for whatever reason, not comfortable with their body or their sex for other reasons (eg they don’t fit stereo type of a girl etc). I think over focus on affirmation could harm the second group.

I think there needs to be much more exploration into why a child feels uncomfortable as their own sex before anything is done re transition. My daughter told me she wanted to be a boy. After chatting about it she said it was because she didn’t want to have a baby because it will hurt.

I agree with everything you’re saying and get how easily this sort of thing could happen. I think messages get mixed up in children and for some reason the opposite sex appears to be less frightening.

My mother discussed traumatic birth stories with other adults in front of me aged 10, which is waaay inappropriate due to what was said. My brother was also treated very differently from me and at times, I wished I was a boy.

Babasghost · 22/10/2022 09:06

Yes it's child abuse.

If you are uncomfortable with your boy playing with Barbie then you are a homophobe. You shouldn't have the right to chop of his junk and condemn him to a lifetime of drug dependency, infertility and to never experiencing orgasm.

Girls who are uncomfortable with how society sexualises them are normal. Stop chopping of their tits and plunging them into menopause before they even reach puberty.

Stop transingnthe gay away and leave autistic kids intact.
Safeguarding 101, do no harm.

Swipe left for the next trending thread