Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that transing young children is a medical scandal?

291 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 02:53

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11342541/Dr-Az-Hakeem-says-parents-claimed-kids-trans-NHS-Tavistock-transing-factory-clinic.html

"I remember saying to them, this is madness. What we're doing is madness. These are children. These are three-year-olds."
Are we seriously saying this is ok? I feel like as a society we have gone mad, allowing this to happen to young children.

AIBU to think this is child abuse? And if you disagree how do you justify three and four year olds being transed?

OP posts:
Sunflower987 · 22/10/2022 12:13

Silverangels · 22/10/2022 12:00

The bit I left out was the school nurse stopping me in the corridor and (loudly) saying
’WE need to do something about A-you don’t want him to grow up gay or a peodophile’ !!!!
as if a fucking pink dress and pink shoes at the age of 5 was going to do this
(I’m still fuming all these years later)

as it is,he’s neither-he’s just a man who is living his best life
but his older brother (who was a ‘normal’ lad growing up) came out last year-he’s gay and proud
i couldn’t be more proud of either of them

That's awful.
Well done for standing your ground.

My son used to play dress up alot when he was little, he loved wearing Disney Princess dresses, I used to just let him get on with it.
My other son wanted to be a dinosaur and hated his name as he wanted to be called T-Rex.
Now they are older my boy is a 'typical' boy and my other son is a human and not a T-Rex.
No validation needed for them because like many things kids do in childhood it was just a phase.

It's absolutely bonkers what has been happening.

This whole thing is so regressive!

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 12:12

The male and female brain are different

Biologically different yes. Which comes down to sex not gender.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 12:11

How can you be born in the wrong body? The female/male brain myth has been debunked repeatedly.

The male and female brain are different.

The chemical levels are different.

The hormones are also different and these are also regulated by the brain.

The majority of sex crimes (and all other crimes) are committed by males - this isn’t just coincidence.

There are many females who wouldn’t want males in the same changing room as them but don’t mind being in the same changing room as females.
If mens’ brains were the same as females then this wouldn’t even be an issue.
Men act differently to females.

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 12:10

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 12:07

"But what do we do about those young people who feel they are the wrong gender and this persists beyond a 'phase'? "

If you read the new NHS guidelines that is allowed for. They are distinguishing between gender incoherence and dysphoria.

There needs to be an emphasis though that presenting as the opposite sex to relieve dysphoria does not mean you are actually that sex.

incongruence I meant sorry not incoherence.

AndyWarholsPiehole · 22/10/2022 12:09

If a 6 year old says I want to be the opposite sex and they are made to stay as dresses as their sex, with their name and hate it and cry themselves to sleep - what do we do then? Therapy I guess is most important here? And lots of it?

What do we do? We tell the parents to stop being regressive idiots and allow their child to dress as he or she wants to.

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 12:07

If a child displays the desire to be the opposite sex, isn't it invalidating to say that they can't be, when there are transgender people on this earth? Isn't that a lie?

No one changes sex. It's a biological impossibility. So yes it would be a lie to tell a child they can.

People can live as they choose of course and everyone should be supported in that.

Children should be reassured that it's fine to wear, present as they like, to engage in hobbies and interests they enjoy regardless of how they're 'gendered'.

Any thing further than that with regards to kids is really problematic ethically, morally, medically.

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 12:07

"But what do we do about those young people who feel they are the wrong gender and this persists beyond a 'phase'? "

If you read the new NHS guidelines that is allowed for. They are distinguishing between gender incoherence and dysphoria.

There needs to be an emphasis though that presenting as the opposite sex to relieve dysphoria does not mean you are actually that sex.

Sunflower987 · 22/10/2022 12:03

Yanbu OP.

helpyhelperton · 22/10/2022 12:02

And I wanted to be a boy when I was 4, I changed my name for a week. I also was a dog for a while.

I love being a woman and don't want to change and have felt like this since about 8.

I don't know what I would have done if I had been 'encouraged' to change or told that I could be a boy'

Isn't it better to say we can be what we want but we live our childhood in the skin we choose but aren't allowed to make any physical changes til we are 18 at least? Isn't it better to say we can transition but we have to wait?

It's really tough. If a 6 year old says I want to be the opposite sex and they are made to stay as dresses as their sex, with their name and hate it and cry themselves to sleep - what do we do then? Therapy I guess is most important here? And lots of it?

Silverangels · 22/10/2022 12:00

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 11:53

This is shocking. Well done you for standing up to the institutional bullying and harassment from the school.

The bit I left out was the school nurse stopping me in the corridor and (loudly) saying
’WE need to do something about A-you don’t want him to grow up gay or a peodophile’ !!!!
as if a fucking pink dress and pink shoes at the age of 5 was going to do this
(I’m still fuming all these years later)

as it is,he’s neither-he’s just a man who is living his best life
but his older brother (who was a ‘normal’ lad growing up) came out last year-he’s gay and proud
i couldn’t be more proud of either of them

AlisonDonut · 22/10/2022 11:58

But what do we do about those young people who feel they are the wrong gender and this persists beyond a 'phase'?

Tell them they can wear what they want but they cannot change sex?

helpyhelperton · 22/10/2022 11:55

I need help understanding this.

If a child displays the desire to be the opposite sex, isn't it invalidating to say that they can't be, when there are transgender people on this earth? Isn't that a lie?

Research has shown that the decision making part of the brain doesn't develop till we are 25. That would certainly backup the idea that children can be very easily confused, influenced and make bad decisions etc, so I completely agree that transformation should take place as late as possible. I don't know what age - I assume that procedures are taking place a puberty to improve the chance of it being successful?

But what do we do about those young people who feel they are the wrong gender and this persists beyond a 'phase'?

It's a genuine question because some of the vehemence on here frightens me, it seems very invalidating.

You really know nothing at 3, 7 and at 16! You are constantly learning but surely if you have sustained a desire to change (and I believe it's torture for some young people and their families) aren't we making it worse and isolating them but denying it's a possibility to change?

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 11:53

Silverangels · 22/10/2022 11:48

When my son was a lot smaller,he wanted to be a girl

we wanted his Willy to fall off,loved anything pink,princesses,dressing up,pushed his pram with pride and had long (ish) hair

i tell him crack on with it

until he started school-they went mental-calling me a bad mother,pushing mermaids on me,trying to put me in touch with people ‘who could help with his journey into becoming a girl’,they worried because all his mates where girls and telling me (in the next breath) that I was failing him by not forcing him to be a boy

i told them all to fuck off-this is who he was-he might grow out of it-he might not,but I would deal with it as and when it happened

school ramped up the pressure-I told them to go away

this went on all through primary-as soon as he started secondary,he grew out of it and is now a true lad (whatever that means)

he has a girlfriend,working through uni and is happy in his own skin

around this time another little lad started school (i think he was two or three years younger)

from the word go,his mother made it clear he was a girl and was to be treated like one

school bent over backwards-allowing this child to use the girls loo,calling him by his girl name and stamping any bullying out (rightly so)

I know girls where worried about a boy in their spaces-and where told to shut up and put up-this child’s mum wanted him to use the girls loo so that was that

last I heard,the poor kid was transitioning in a girl

i wonder how much was mum and how much was the little one

this brainwashing starts at a very young age

This is shocking. Well done you for standing up to the institutional bullying and harassment from the school.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 22/10/2022 11:52

YANBU. It's child abuse. The numbers alone tell us this.

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 11:50

entropynow · 22/10/2022 11:30

Suddenly MN believes the Daily Mail when it says that someone says someone says it happened 🙄 Complete with faux "how many have been harmed?" questions designed to create scandal and panic.
But no transphobia here, no siree.

Ah always the accusation of transphobia as soon as someone mentions safeguarding. Why is that I wonder?

To think that transing young children is a medical scandal?
OP posts:
Silverangels · 22/10/2022 11:48

When my son was a lot smaller,he wanted to be a girl

we wanted his Willy to fall off,loved anything pink,princesses,dressing up,pushed his pram with pride and had long (ish) hair

i tell him crack on with it

until he started school-they went mental-calling me a bad mother,pushing mermaids on me,trying to put me in touch with people ‘who could help with his journey into becoming a girl’,they worried because all his mates where girls and telling me (in the next breath) that I was failing him by not forcing him to be a boy

i told them all to fuck off-this is who he was-he might grow out of it-he might not,but I would deal with it as and when it happened

school ramped up the pressure-I told them to go away

this went on all through primary-as soon as he started secondary,he grew out of it and is now a true lad (whatever that means)

he has a girlfriend,working through uni and is happy in his own skin

around this time another little lad started school (i think he was two or three years younger)

from the word go,his mother made it clear he was a girl and was to be treated like one

school bent over backwards-allowing this child to use the girls loo,calling him by his girl name and stamping any bullying out (rightly so)

I know girls where worried about a boy in their spaces-and where told to shut up and put up-this child’s mum wanted him to use the girls loo so that was that

last I heard,the poor kid was transitioning in a girl

i wonder how much was mum and how much was the little one

this brainwashing starts at a very young age

AlisonDonut · 22/10/2022 11:42

entropynow · 22/10/2022 11:30

Suddenly MN believes the Daily Mail when it says that someone says someone says it happened 🙄 Complete with faux "how many have been harmed?" questions designed to create scandal and panic.
But no transphobia here, no siree.

So are you saying that this hasn't happened and if it had, it would be bad?

Terftrain · 22/10/2022 11:41

Scuttlingherbert · 22/10/2022 11:31

I don't think it's a scandal. It's a scandal when anyone - child or adult - isn't allowed to have the medical treatment they need.

Great. So you agree that it is a scandal that the woman who requested female only care at hospital and was refused.

Something is pushing this sinister ideology across our institutions, hmmm what could the motive for this possibly be?

AndyWarholsPiehole · 22/10/2022 11:40

Of course it's child abuse. Anyone that pushes this nonsense is either extremely stupid (wrong body people) or just doesn't care about children and probably gains something from the medicalisation and mutilation of children.

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 11:37

Scuttlingherbert · 22/10/2022 11:31

I don't think it's a scandal. It's a scandal when anyone - child or adult - isn't allowed to have the medical treatment they need.

Indeed, like autistic girls with a history of self harm and eating disorders need to have some therapy to find out why they suddenly think they are born in the wrong body you mean? And they aren't getting it and instead are being sterilised and having their breasts cut off?
I agree with you.

OP posts:
jetadore · 22/10/2022 11:36

YANBU, a massive fallout from this is in the pipeline.Just hope the internet doesn’t forget the people who pushed and supported this agenda so they get their comeuppance.

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 11:35

They’re heeeeeeerrrreeeee 😂😂😂

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 11:35

Scuttlingherbert · 22/10/2022 11:31

I don't think it's a scandal. It's a scandal when anyone - child or adult - isn't allowed to have the medical treatment they need.

You really think every single one of the 4000% rise in females being referred is really trans and needs medicalisation and surgery? Or perhaps there's something else underlying it? Perhaps as is now finally being proposed the best treatment is more focused on mental health and underlying issues.

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 11:33

I don't think it's a scandal. It's a scandal when anyone - child or adult - isn't allowed to have the medical treatment they need.

Why would you think that only affirmative approaches and pushing children down a road of medicalisation and surgery is the 'treatment they need'?

Serious question, I'd really like to hear your response.

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 11:32

entropynow · 22/10/2022 11:30

Suddenly MN believes the Daily Mail when it says that someone says someone says it happened 🙄 Complete with faux "how many have been harmed?" questions designed to create scandal and panic.
But no transphobia here, no siree.

Ha ha, where have you been? Posters on mumsnet have been trying to raise awareness of this scandal for years and years, way before the daily Mail took it up.

And GTF with the transphobia accusations, it really does not wash anymore. Everyone is waking up to this.