Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that transing young children is a medical scandal?

291 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 02:53

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11342541/Dr-Az-Hakeem-says-parents-claimed-kids-trans-NHS-Tavistock-transing-factory-clinic.html

"I remember saying to them, this is madness. What we're doing is madness. These are children. These are three-year-olds."
Are we seriously saying this is ok? I feel like as a society we have gone mad, allowing this to happen to young children.

AIBU to think this is child abuse? And if you disagree how do you justify three and four year olds being transed?

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 14:12

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:51

I agree.

And I would offer that advice to anyone on here.

Just because someone says something on here, doesn’t mean it’s true.

Always do your own research which is readily available on proper websites and don’t let the vipers on here try and silence you or bully you into thinking the same as them.

LMAO, you're the one asking people to DM you so you can impart your (partial and misleading) knowledge.

Posters trying to correct misinformation is not bullying or silencing FFS.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 22/10/2022 14:10

A quick health warning about DM ing posters about this topic. There are a number of transactivists who are all over Mumsnet and are very keen to engage in DMs with other posters - who then find their messages posted on twitter. So it's worth being very cautious about repeated requests for DMs.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 14:07

Don't forget quite a lot of posters here do have a scientific background despite being mums and all

‘despite being mums and all’

😁😁
You would be a good journalist.

I too am/was a scientist and a parent.
Now I am a psychologist and a parent.

Probably why I’m interested in the grey areas, rather than just the black and white areas.

landyland · 22/10/2022 14:03

It's really NOT 'lots of people'. DSDs are rare, particularly the ones that involve karyotypes outside the usual XX/XY. There have only been 500 documented cases of ovotesticular syndrome with both male and female germ lines present in the whole of human history. 500 people out of billions! It ridiculous to try and conflate DSD and being trans. They are 2 completely different things. Sex and gender identity are completely different. Phenotypical males without a Y chromosome are very rare and what they will have in most case is the SRY region of the Y chromosome translocated onto an X chromosome, by mistake. These are abnormalities and don't change the fact that the Y chromosome (with its SRY region and other associated genes) is male-determining in humans.

To really understand intersex you need to do GCSE Biology, followed by A level Biology, followed by either a degree in Molecular Biology or a medical degree. It's massively complex and does not disprove the norm. Which is that 99.99% of people have XY chromosomes in every cell and hence are functional males or XX and hence are functional females. How they feel or identify or their sexuality or their fertility is nothing to do with this base configuration.

DecayedStrumpet · 22/10/2022 14:01

Yes, carefreeme, and someone with XXY is male, XO is female.

I appreciate that you think you've done lots of reading on this but you seem to still be missing quite a lot of vital information.
Don't forget quite a lot of posters here do have a scientific background despite being mums and all, you don't need to try and talk down to us. (Especially when you're wrong)

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 14:00

I'm never even sure what the point of bringing DSDs into the conversation is. They are not, to my knowledge, even slightly over represented in those identifying as Trans.

There is nothing ambiguous in the sexual presentation of the vast, vast, vast majority of those identifying of trans.

ilovesushi · 22/10/2022 13:57

It is child abuse and complete insanity. Girls are girls, boys are boys. They can play with whatever toys they like, they can dress however they like from one day to the next but to start socially transitioning them and putting them on a pathway to unnecessary complicated experimental surgery, sterilisation and a life long need for medication and is the most horrendous form of abuse I can think of. It is like something from a dystopian science fiction horror novel!

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 13:55

This is helpful

www.nhs.uk/conditions/differences-in-sex-development/

And demonstrates that there is no real ambiguity in the sex classification of those with DSDs, even if they have chromosomal makeup that's not XX or XY.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:51

I agree.

And I would offer that advice to anyone on here.

Just because someone says something on here, doesn’t mean it’s true.

Always do your own research which is readily available on proper websites and don’t let the vipers on here try and silence you or bully you into thinking the same as them.

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 13:46

I suggest that anyone that actually wants to learn about DSDs accesses the resources available from a reputable charity and does not DM randoms on the internet for misinformation or. read ropaganda from trans activists.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:41

Down at DNA level its obvious which sex they are.

Sorry OP last point.

It is not as simple as XX or XY chromosomes unfortunately.

Lots of males have no Y chromosome and lots of people have XXY, XO etc.

If people want to DM me that’s fine and I’ll try and answer their questions as best as I can based on my previous experience and things that I have learnt as I do find these subjects very interesting but I won’t be letting posters use me to derail the thread anymore.

landyland · 22/10/2022 13:37

Sommicj misunderstanding of intersex/DSDs on display here. In the vast majority of DSDs the person is either male or female. CAIS means they are male but phenotypically female as can't respond to testosterone. Still male though. There is one extremely rare thing that can happen where genetic mosaicism means both male and female tissue can be present. In all cases this is biology, or more correctly genetics gone wrong. It's a disorder of normal human sexual development and the individuals affected are infertile and don't reproduce. It is not evidence of a third or different sex and people with DSDs are not trans because of their condition.

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 13:35

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:31

@Rainbowshit

You jumped ship quickly.

You said I was talking utter nonsense not long ago.

Now it seems you’ve had a quick read up and realised you were wrong, so are now trying to say I’m being offensive by saying that those born with both male and female sex glands are usually infertile which is true.

Make your mind up.

You have spewed offensive nonsense all across this thread for everyone to read. No wonder you're trying to change the subject now.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:33

For those who are trying to derail the thread or silence me please DM or start a new thread as OP must be getting very annoyed that we are taking up so much space.

OP I am sorry and as I’ve said I completely agree with your OP.

Hankunamatata · 22/10/2022 13:32

We need to let kids be kids. Let them wear what they want, use nickname if they want. Stop playing to gender stereotypes

Moonatics · 22/10/2022 13:31

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 12:43

People are not born "both sexes" . They might have a DSD but are still biologically male or female.

No people who are completely intersex are often given a gender by their parents or choose one themselves depending on whether they feel more male or female.
Of course if you are more one sex than the other you choose that.

Sex means male/female
Gender means a shifting constellation or something indefinable.
You appear to be conflating the two.
Intersex (psa, no one calls it that now) or dsd, disorder of sexual development, does not mean either a multiple gender or both sexes. Down at DNA level its obvious which sex they are.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:31

@Rainbowshit

You jumped ship quickly.

You said I was talking utter nonsense not long ago.

Now it seems you’ve had a quick read up and realised you were wrong, so are now trying to say I’m being offensive by saying that those born with both male and female sex glands are usually infertile which is true.

Make your mind up.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 22/10/2022 13:30

YANBU I think this is a huge scandal all pushed by an extreme very vocal minority. The whole thing has got so muddled in the pressure to be unquestionably tolerant and open minded embracing everything. Schools have also been caught up in this madness, I feel for those teachers who have tried to stand up to it only to be cancelled or called out and some sort of bigot.

Imagine if the same resources put into these clinics and treatments were children's wellbeing and mental health. I really feel we have let these kids down badly in lots of cases.

FWIW I know 3 young people at DCs schools who are transitioning- they are deeply troubled and unhappy individuals so opening the door to all this has not been a magical fix. The effects of the medication they take is horrible, I mean imagine being a teenager is hard enough and then this on top.

helpyhelperton · 22/10/2022 13:30

I find this whole 'topic' mind blowing.

I really don't know enough about it and the more I read the more I get confused.

I wish we all were just happy with our bodies and people were allowed to just present themselves in the way they feel comfortable.

My head hurts after reading this thread.

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:29

I have a question. Do you really believe that souls and brains can be racially
catagorised?

Without going into too much detail I do know of a few albino people.
2 of them were raised by white people.

All of them identify as black.

I have only ever met one black person who didn’t identify as black but that was, I believe, based on stereotypes and believing that liking X,Y,Z means he isn’t ‘black enough’.

I believe your insides (like your genes) determine your identity like race.

And no I do not believe if you have the genes of a particular race you can then transfer to a different race (I’m sure someone would have asked that question).

There is also a recognised issue with mixed race people finding it a challenge growing up because they identify as 2 races, especially if raised by a one race family.

I don’t think it’s for me to speak on behalf of an entire race of people but the majority of black people will tell you it’s not just their skin colour that makes us black.

Rainbowshit · 22/10/2022 13:22

CarefreeMe · 22/10/2022 13:05

Humans have either the mechanism to produce eggs OR to produce sperm. No one has functional mechanism to produce both.

I believe all intersex people are infertile.

There's a whole range of DSDs (less offensive term than intersex), some of which result in infertility. But many that do not. You are being incredibly offensive.

newnamethanks · 22/10/2022 13:17

YANBU. It's atrocious and Tavistock should never be allowed to pursue any more of its practices with under 18s.

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 13:14

Do you really believe that souls and brains can be racially catagorised?

or that there's such a thing as a disabled soul?

Musti · 22/10/2022 13:13

Mexicola · 22/10/2022 06:39

It’s absolutely awful and scary.

I’m a woman/female XX.

when I was a child I was a “tomboy” (I hate to use that word as it reinforces gender stereotypes).

I found the sports, hobbies and toys that boys were “allowed” to do much more interesting than the traditional feminine things thrust upon me.

I had cropped hair, wore “boys” clothes and climbed trees, had transformed toys and wrestled. All my friends were boys.

I told everyone I was a boy and my name was Junior (from Popeye!)

I didn’t want to have a penis, I am heterosexual. I just didn’t want the gender stereotypes forced upon me.

by 12/13 I had grown my hair long but I’ve always been quite masculine in my ways. (90’s ladette culture appealed to me)

I fear that if I was raised now I could end up in some kind of gender clinic and told I am trans!! It scares me what these young people are being forced on.

What mostly annoys me is I think it’s still down to stereotypes now and what society forces on children.

my son once said to me he wanted to be a girl and I asked why. He said so he could do crafts like his sister. I had no idea where that came from but course he has access to crafts at home!

it’s all down to society. Who says boys can’t wear skirts or make up etc.

scary stuff. A lot of attention seeking and in fashion. I agree with a lot of what Bob Withers says.

This.

To do such irreversible stuff to kids is absolutely unforgivable.

It also takes away their ability to reproduce and find sexual pleasure. It is sick.

Let them dress and call themselves whatever they want. But drugs and surgery should be when they’re adults after a lot of counselling and trying it.

TheKeatingFive · 22/10/2022 13:13

There are lots of journal articles but I thought considering you’re confused over it already, that they’ll be too much for you to understand.

I don't doubt your ability to unearth further nonsense, trust me 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread