Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that transing young children is a medical scandal?

291 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 02:53

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11342541/Dr-Az-Hakeem-says-parents-claimed-kids-trans-NHS-Tavistock-transing-factory-clinic.html

"I remember saying to them, this is madness. What we're doing is madness. These are children. These are three-year-olds."
Are we seriously saying this is ok? I feel like as a society we have gone mad, allowing this to happen to young children.

AIBU to think this is child abuse? And if you disagree how do you justify three and four year olds being transed?

OP posts:
Terftrain · 22/10/2022 09:04

Yes of course it’s a scandal but we’re up against a very rich (and insidious) lobby group who make a fortune out of putting children on a medical pathway for the rest of their lives.

social contagion driven by big tech companies and any adults affirming this are doing harm to that child.

AnaJeff · 22/10/2022 08:55

Absolute madness. This should not be happening until they are old enough to make an informed decision eg 21 and even then, they should pay for it themselves. This is not something the NHS should be funding imo

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 08:55

what @Moonatics said. The parents are the ones influencing this. I hope they’ve explained to their son that when he gets older he will be expected to use male facilities and spaces.

glamourousindierockandroll · 22/10/2022 08:54

A close friend of mine, who is gay, has told me that if someone could have told him as a child that he could change to being a girl he'd have done it. He loved dressing up, dolls, play kitchens, clip clopping about in mum's high heels etc.

He's a very happy man, firmly GC, and is rather horrified at what could have been if he was growing up now rather than in the 90s/00s.

Moonatics · 22/10/2022 08:51

UmbilicusProfundus · 22/10/2022 06:50

is there actual evidence that cases of Munchausen’s by proxy is dropping?

I am gender critical like most of MN and think the affirmative rather than critical approach of gender clinics is a scandal.

However the only trans kid I know has been dressing/identifying as a girl since they were a toddler, is now a tween and has never changed. It’s not a phase. And I know it’s not an agenda pushed by their parents. It’s the old-fashioned kind of transgenderism which has long existed before the current cult.

I am more concerned about the societal influences which are driving up trans identification in adolescents. Teens have always tried to find their tribe. But usually this is not associated with such life changing and potentially harmful choices.

I have to just say, toddlers do not buy clothes. If a toddler is trans its because the parents did the transing.

AutumnCrow · 22/10/2022 08:35

Meanings of words have no meanings in Butlerian ideology, lest we forget.

UmbilicusProfundus · 22/10/2022 08:25

Word salad is actually a clinical term which you are using incorrectly

AutumnCrow · 22/10/2022 08:21

‘Trans child’ = word salad
’Transgender’ = word salad
’Gender identity’ = word salad
’Attention seeking parent’ = valid concept

Toseland · 22/10/2022 08:15

YANBU but this is being heavily promoted by schools, nurseries, councils, the police, many companies and the political parties especially Labour and the Greens - i've never seen anything like it. I don't believe in 'trans', or 'trans' children. The only 'trans' people i've ever met in 50 years are older males who are sexually aroused by dressing as women and breaking boundaries like accessing women's spaces. How can Eddie Izzard become a girl just by saying so but children need drugs and surgeries?

Haudyourwheesht · 22/10/2022 08:13

Then = them

Haudyourwheesht · 22/10/2022 08:09

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 22/10/2022 07:52

To add I think the care for genuinely trans children needs to be not “you can change sex” but “you can never change your sex, but you can present how you want and let’s try to get you to a place where you are as happy and comfortable in your body and identity as possible”. People can’t change sex and I worry that pretending that is possible is harmful as it sets very high expectations.

I completely agree with this. Telling kids the truth that you can't change sex is going to lead to then taking advice and support from elsewhere and goodness knows where that will lead.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 22/10/2022 08:09

@Asdavaluesausage very good points. I agree.

Clymene · 22/10/2022 08:08

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 22/10/2022 07:52

To add I think the care for genuinely trans children needs to be not “you can change sex” but “you can never change your sex, but you can present how you want and let’s try to get you to a place where you are as happy and comfortable in your body and identity as possible”. People can’t change sex and I worry that pretending that is possible is harmful as it sets very high expectations.

I think terms such as 'genuinely trans children' are problematic. Old studies show that 80% of children who have gender identity issues desist as adults if they're left alone. Given the exponential rise in kids being referred in the last couple of years and the tip from boys to girls through social contagion, I'd expect that number to be even higher now.

So I think we need to move away from that term altogether. Not liking your breasts because you hate being ogled by men is not dysphoria, it's a perfectly normal reaction to being treated as a sex object by men.

UmbilicusProfundus · 22/10/2022 08:06

I totally agree with you @Whowhatwherewhenwhynow . There is complexity and nuance around this issue, which I think people like JKR also acknowledge, but is sometimes not appreciated on this site.

VaddaABeetch · 22/10/2022 08:05

SuziecGreen of mermaids took her child to Thailand for castration.

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 08:00

@Whowhatwherewhenwhynow i do kind of agree but I think, without using sexist harmful stereotypes, how would a child ‘show signs of being trans’? How would a very young child, unless they are fed ‘only boys can do that, only girls can do that’. Know that they were not their biological sex?

social transition is also harmful, as it is not neutral. How many children would be brave enough to say ‘I got it wrong I’m not trans’ in this current climate? They’ll have had attention, praise and unqualified affirmation. Look at the abuse detransitioners get from the trans community. Would any child willingly go through that?

WifeMotherWorker · 22/10/2022 07:56

YANBU - it’s child abuse, the whole situation is scandalous!!

WeAreOnTheRoadToNowhere · 22/10/2022 07:55

Of course it's parent driven. The toddler might have like feminine clothes but telling them that means they must be a girl is coming from the parents. We should be telling children they can wear or play with whatever they want but they will always be the sex they were born. And that should be fine. We are creating unhealthy children
It blows my mind that a mother who took her child abroad for FGM would be arrested but a mother can irreversibly stunt development with puberty blockers and have the genitals operated on and is a hero
I dare not use the C word which it is or I'll likely be deleted

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 22/10/2022 07:52

To add I think the care for genuinely trans children needs to be not “you can change sex” but “you can never change your sex, but you can present how you want and let’s try to get you to a place where you are as happy and comfortable in your body and identity as possible”. People can’t change sex and I worry that pretending that is possible is harmful as it sets very high expectations.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 22/10/2022 07:50

I agree.
I think for very young children who are, or parents saying are, showing signs of being trans or questioning their gender there should be a open hands off approach. Those children can make decisions about surgery/hormones once they are adults and As they become older children they can lead their transition/or not themselves. I don’t think we should be affirming or denying anything. Just confirming what sec they are but letting them know that their choice in how they dress/act/present is up to them.

I think there is a very dangerous grey area between children (I presume a very small proportion) who are genuinely transgender and will go on to live as a transgender person for their whole lives and children who are, for whatever reason, not comfortable with their body or their sex for other reasons (eg they don’t fit stereo type of a girl etc). I think over focus on affirmation could harm the second group.

I think there needs to be much more exploration into why a child feels uncomfortable as their own sex before anything is done re transition. My daughter told me she wanted to be a boy. After chatting about it she said it was because she didn’t want to have a baby because it will hurt.

Asdavaluesausage · 22/10/2022 07:50

I think one of the problems In allowing social transition for very young children is that this may work in a fashion in primary schools, but when these children hit secondary school, there will be problems. Are schools supposed to,allow mixed sex changing and PE, or do they have to enforce single sex changing, which would possibly be upsetting for these children, especially if they have been told by everyone that they truly have become the opposite sex.
Surely It would be kinder when presented with a child who says they are the opposite sex is to correct them gently. A lot of this gender dysphoria at that age is based on stereotypes, so as a society, if we get rid of gendered stereotypes, surely this will only benefit children. if a girl says she is a boy because she likes certain toys or activities, then that says more about society than about that child.

UmbilicusProfundus · 22/10/2022 07:50

Thanks very much for that link @Clymene I also wondered why this doctor had worked in the sevice for so long if he was critical, but seems like he is actually a hero in the field!

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 07:49

VestaTilley · 22/10/2022 07:44

Yanbu- it’s the new munchausens.

It should be illegal to prescribe puberty blockers or tell a child they’re born in the wrong body, or any of the other crap these snake oil salesmen pedal.

My big fear now is just how much Labour don’t understand this. They’re bound to get in now, and will introduce self ID in all but name.

This is terrifying - as is Scotland with Sturgeon and Green Party Harvie pushing it at children too.
What can we do? Starmer appeared at a Pink News conference recently - he's pushing it to the max.

It's children ffs!!!!

OP posts:
Ragingoverlife · 22/10/2022 07:46

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · 22/10/2022 04:46

YA-definitely-NBU!

And I honestly don't think anyone can actually rationalise transitioning 3/4 Yr olds, or even any children under the age of about 15yo imo.

It is 100% abuse. When one of mine was about 8 he still spent a fair bit of his life insisting he was a dog. I didn't put a collar on him, feed him Chappy and let him shit in the back yard FFS.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

AlisonDonut · 22/10/2022 07:45

RFPO77 · 22/10/2022 07:24

This doctor is trying to cover his arse. I mean he's right of course but he worked there for 12 years so he obviously didn't have a problem with it at the time, he's only spoken up now Tavi is being investigated and closed.

He left in 2012 just as this started to ramp up.