Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that transing young children is a medical scandal?

291 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 22/10/2022 02:53

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11342541/Dr-Az-Hakeem-says-parents-claimed-kids-trans-NHS-Tavistock-transing-factory-clinic.html

"I remember saying to them, this is madness. What we're doing is madness. These are children. These are three-year-olds."
Are we seriously saying this is ok? I feel like as a society we have gone mad, allowing this to happen to young children.

AIBU to think this is child abuse? And if you disagree how do you justify three and four year olds being transed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WandaWomblesaurus · 29/10/2022 20:21

SamTamit · 29/10/2022 19:44

You can always rely on the Daily Mail to publish accurate and insightful articles

Which points are inaccurate?
And what insights do you have an issue with?

OP posts:
Asdavaluesausage · 29/10/2022 19:46

SamTamit · 29/10/2022 19:44

You can always rely on the Daily Mail to publish accurate and insightful articles

Well quite. Unlike the guardian which didn’t publish anything on this scandal….

SamTamit · 29/10/2022 19:44

You can always rely on the Daily Mail to publish accurate and insightful articles

FrancescaContini · 29/10/2022 07:35

Dr Bell has made a very scathing comment in today’s Telegraph on the SNP - there’s a thread going on it. He is definitely in a position to comment.

WandaWomblesaurus · 27/10/2022 20:57

How many children will be harmed by the SNP before then I wonder.

OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/10/2022 23:05

I know that's a rhetorical question but I think the Cass Review may answer it, when Dr Cass finishes her investigation.

FrancescaContini · 23/10/2022 22:04

@PurgatoryOfPotholes That blog - I could hardly bear to skim read it. What a tortuous pile of self absorbed steaming bullshit. How does this individual function in the real world?

FrancescaContini · 23/10/2022 22:00

ResisterRex · 23/10/2022 12:47

Looks like direct contact with toddlers from this:

twitter.com/cheesycuban/status/1584082381874421760?s=46&t=BziyNG6ZgvrmHOLryNQOOw

Certainly looks like this person has been in schools with "Educate and Celebrate"

This is terrifying.

nilsmousehammer · 23/10/2022 19:28

It's always the same isn't it? In all of this and in all of the stuff on the relationships board that ends with women in refuges.

They said 'no' and their boundary, their feelings, their choice, was seen as their opening point in a negotiation with a salesman bent on his sale.

'I'm homosexual' - well let me talk you out of that (so this male gets what they want; what you want/need/feel isn't relevant, you role is how the male wishes to use you)

'I want single sex spaces' - rinse and repeat

'I don't have a gender identity' - rinse and repeat

'I think children need standard safeguarding with no special exceptions' - rinse and repeat.

What's the common factor here for women?

The male. And the male's view of them as a resource that they have entitlement to. And their feelings/choices/needs being framed as unwanted boundaries and negative behaviour.

Largely because they stand in the way of the male getting exactly what they want.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/10/2022 18:40

I presume the onus here will be on convincing the women to put the effort into maintaining these relationships at the behest of their now-transwoman husband who wants to have their cake and eat it, and to stay in these relationships whether they want to or not?

That's the impression I'm getting. Other references cited:

  • Aramburu Alegria, C. (2010). Relationship challenges and relationship maintenance activates following disclosure of transsexualism. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 17, 909–916.
  • Aramburu Alegria, C. (2013). Relational and sexual fluidity in females partnered with male to female transsexual persons. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 20, 142–149.
SidewaysOtter · 23/10/2022 18:28

Silence from Stonewall, GIRES, Gendered Intelligence, Global Butterflies or the organisations involved (Gendered Intelligence, Mermaids etc)…Which inevitably raises the question about why? Why won't they say this is wrong?

I suspect, knowing someone who seems to have a similar mindset, that every proclivity is labelled as a kink, as queerness, as a natural expression of their true selves, and all of this is not only A-OK in the name of inclusivity, diversity and breaking down boundaries barriers, but it’s to be actively encouraged.

As such, it doesn’t matter what a DBS or social media check would throw up, it’s all fine.

It's actually on how adult women can preserve their relationships with adult males pursuing transition.

I presume the onus here will be on convincing the women to put the effort into maintaining these relationships at the behest of their now-transwoman husband who wants to have their cake and eat it, and to stay in these relationships whether they want to or not?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/10/2022 17:54

Some highlights from the references

  • Brown, N. R. (2009). ‘I'm in transition too’: Sexual identity renegotiation in sexual minority women's relationships with transsexual men. International Journal of Sexual Health, 21, 61–77.
And

Joslin-Roher, E., & Wheeler, D.P. (2009). Partners in transition: The transition experiences of lesbian, bisexual and queer identified partners of transgendered men. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Social Services, 21, 30–48.

Language has really shifted since 2009. Telling same-sex attracted women that they should be open to sexual relationships with "transgendered men" sounds so much more absurd, doesn't it?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/10/2022 17:34

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2022 17:20

While we're asking genderfuck elf rhetorical questions, when did they graduate as a doctor?

Okay. that's thrown up new questions for me. I don't know when they would have had their viva, but they submitted their thesis in 2016, and they would have been working on it when they got their job as a trainee clinical psychologist at the tavistock, the year before that. I'd presumed their thesis would be in the care of adolescents with gender dysphoria. It's actually on how adult women can preserve their relationships with adult males pursuing transition. So, transwidows?

Full thing is behind a paywall, naturally, but the abstract is public access. As are the references used.

ABSTRACT
> Historically trans people have often wrongly been advised that the gender role transition process would result in the breakdown of their relationships, and couples have often been provided with little support through this process. This paper presents an in-depth narrative analysis of the accounts of six cisgender women who have been partnered with trans individuals. It focuses on the support that non-trans partners accessed while their partner progressed through their gender transition. Support was deemed important by all participants in relation to their aim of remaining together with their partners. In terms of whom they accessed support from, participants spoke about interactions with other people in similar situations, with professional therapists, with the Gender Identity Clinics (GICs), and with their partners. In regard to therapy, some reported that their partner's transition was a topic they did not need to discuss. Many reported they had to take an “educator” role in therapy, suggesting that more training for therapists is required. Those who attended GICs with their partner were ambivalent about whether they would have utilised support there if it had been available there, stating that locally situated support was preferable. The paper draws out the clinical implications in relation to these areas.

nilsmousehammer · 23/10/2022 17:22

And if people are now identifying as elves can they get the ears on the NHS?

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2022 17:20

While we're asking genderfuck elf rhetorical questions, when did they graduate as a doctor?

Over7billiongendersbut2sexes · 23/10/2022 16:06

I stand for spaces that are ‘opt in’, where power is placed in the individual and one gets to decide for themselves whether they belong, or even if they wish to belong at all. Spaces that are set up to be welcoming and supportive, inclusive and based on self-defined and self-constructed identities. Spaces that have the power to be healing, affirming and nurturing. Those are spaces of which I am proud to belong.

Well that's all well and good but to create these spaces which affirm some people, you have to force others to stay in them. That's what's happening with women's spaces. Like most women, I have nothing in common with a TW. But if all the women left those spaces, leaving all the trans-identifying males in them, those males would feel maligned. Men who want to believe they are like women are desperately trying to prevent women from saying that they don't identify as women, they just are women. Because to face the truth removes the ability for them to deceive themselves that they belong with the women. This is horribly individualised thinking.

TheKeatingFive · 23/10/2022 14:49

I stand for spaces that are ‘opt in’, where power is placed in the individual and one gets to decide for themselves whether they belong, or even if they wish to belong at all

Well that all sounds lovely.

But not for an acquaintance of mine, who suffered a violent rape and now struggles with the presence of men generally. If men are 'opting in' to her intimate spaces, that triggers panic attacks in her. Meaning she has no choice but 'opt out'.

She'd love to belong to regular day to day society, but under suggestions like yours, she wouldn't be able to.

Is she just collateral damage in your lovely plan?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 23/10/2022 14:03

it's noticable how that sexual background turns up again. And again. And again.

Interesting that all the charities determined to "educate" our children about sex and sexuality are completely silent about safeguarding breaches. As each safeguarding scandal is uncovered (paedophiles, porn obsessions, flashing, inappropriate online content for children and worse) not one organisation ever speaks out.

Silence from Stonewall, GIRES, Gendered Intelligence, Global Butterflies or the organisations involved (Gendered Intelligence, Mermaids etc). No reassurance that safeguarding is a priority, no assurance that all their staff have credible enhanced DBS checks, no standards / boundaries about personal behaviour required from those working directly with children.

Which inevitably raises the question about why? Why won't they say this is wrong? What would be revealed about their staff / representatives / trustees if someone looked?

Why are they unable / unwilling to prioritise safeguarding children despite being so keen on talking to children about sex and sexuality? Because this is the connection between the emergence of all these little "trans" children and fragile mentally unwell teenage girls wanting to change sex:

Cynical self invested adults / groups with an agenda and no boundaries.

nilsmousehammer · 23/10/2022 13:46

Who gets to decide who belongs and who doesn’t? Who performs their gender ‘well enough’ to be granted permission to enter?

Yes that would all be lovely in theory if it went both ways. But it doesn't. I'm sure the writer would feel they very definitely get to decide that females who say they don't have a gender don't get to belong. That females who need privacy, or single sex spaces for their own inclusion and access needs to be recognised too, don't belong and shouldn't be granted permission to enter.

Which makes it not values based, but a lot of specious wankery. Indulgence in self important consideration of the wonder of them, that doesn't work once it leaves their head and what they want and expect the world and people around them to provide. The writer is only arguing and throwing words around to destroy other people's boundaries preventing them doing exactly what they want and to justify to the writerself that they can ignore the voice of their conscience. Which they have or they wouldn't need to wang on arguing with it like this.

And then you have to root it in the evidence, increasing daily, of these views coming alongside a lack of awareness and capacity for appropriate boundaries and behaviour towards others, such as involving non consenting others. Shouting about inclusion and kindness while excluding in exceptionally unkind and cruel and uncaring terms. It's all about The Wonder of Me. All the time. With a hell of lot of sexual appropriacy all mixed up in it. And yes, it's noticable how that sexual background turns up again. And again. And again.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 23/10/2022 13:44

Do these people have no concept of what living in society actually entails?
Let alone taking any responsibility for ensuring that children are able to grow safely in society without falling into the clutches of adults seeking to sexualise them, engage them in age inappropriate behaviour and worse.

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2022 13:44

(My point is that yes, some spaces/situations exclude people. This is why I can't volunteer at a primary school without a DBS check. The power isn't placed in me as an individual, and I don't get to decide if I can 'belong' in any space I fancy occupying, because we have this thing called safeguarding. I would have expected a health care professional working with children/young people to understand this pretty thoroughly, tbh).

ArabellaScott · 23/10/2022 13:41

I stand for spaces that are ‘opt in’, where power is placed in the individual and one gets to decide for themselves whether they belong, or even if they wish to belong at all

Well, that's lovely. But what about the other people sharing spaces with you, Mx genderqueer elf?

Do these people have no concept of what living in society actually entails?

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 23/10/2022 13:35

If you look at the background of some of the adults that the government (via the Women & Equalities Committee, the DfE and others) have "consulted with" in recent years, it makes for uncomfortable reading.

This applies to some of the clinical staff at the NHS clinic, too. Over the last couple of days, I've followed up some things I've seen previously mentioned, and it's cast some light on the performance of the Tavistock. One clinical psychologist, who has worked at the Tavistock since 2015 and is still there, used to be one of the organisers of a tantra group where they (they use the pronouns they- I'm not trying to obscure their sex, which is clearly female) described themselves in their potted biography as a genderqueer elf and political pervert.

They also blogged about their experience of a sexuality festival under their professional name. They are themselves trans, and I hope they always remain happy with their own personal decision to transition. However, are they able to maintain professional distance when considering the longterm interests of female children and female teens referred to the clinic?

blog about festival

LGBTQ people are born rebels, explorers and pioneers. Coming Out is an act of self-affirmation in defiance of HUGE homophobia in the world, and five decades of law reform and changing attitudes in some places has not changed that. Coming Out is an act of rebellion against the norms of the world that shows the authentic drive within to be Who We Are is stronger than the idiocy and prejudice that exists around homo, bi and trans-sexuality.

For a number of years I have been vocal about my feelings against gender specific spaces. Not spaces such as women only refuges, but single sex workshops or held spaces that are specifically designed to explore, develop or discover one’s masculinity or femininity in an exclusive and essentialist manner. However, more recently I have come to think that it is not so much the spaces specifically that I am against, but the way in which these spaces are set up.

I have attended a variety of sexuality/Tantra festivals over the years, which more often than not have some kind of ‘men only’ and ‘women only’ sessions throughout the programme. I never wished to attend the women’s only sessions, yet I felt ambivalent around my presence in the men only spaces. Even in the more heteronormative workshops there tended to be some controversy and much discussion about these spaces; particularly how men and women were defined. Were the spaces about exploring sex, bodies, gender, identity, stereotypes, expression or something else? If the purpose was to explore identity, and not sex, then could a woman who wished to explore her masculinity attend the man’s space? The answer was always no. These were spaces created by excluding others, by those in power deciding if a person was allowed to attend, telling people they were not welcome based on criteria that has been set by a culture of oppression.

As the women connected with mother earth and the men growled and stamped around the room, those of us ‘gender rejects’ sat in the smoking cabin and criticised the way the spaces had been set up. At the same time part of me wanted to be ‘one of the boys’ and be allowed into the club of masculinity. I wanted that part of me to be validated by the process of simply being allowed into the room. Yet at the same time I did not want to be part of a club that excluded people like me.

As testosterone has now taken hold of my body my membership of this club is often assumed. I am positioned as a man by most new people I meet and thus given membership through their perception. I therefore no longer have to ask ‘are trans guys allowed in this space?’ but simply turn up. Yet I still feel ambivalent about my presence in men only spaces and the aspects of my old self, and my politics, that I may be betraying if I enter.

During the summer I attended the Queer Spirit festival, a festival for queer people to celebrate sexuality, spiritually, ritual and communities. When reading the program, I noticed that there was a session for ‘masculine identified people’. This was in stark contrast to the spaces I had come into contact with before. An ‘opt in’ space, where the individual can decide for themselves whether they wish to be part of such a space rather than the larger group excluding those who they feel do not meet some culturally oppressive criteria.

I felt myself being drawn to the session, despite the blurb about it being rather vague and I couldn’t really tell what it was about. My next question to myself was as to whether I was really ‘man enough’ to attend. I do not think of myself as a man, though I often enjoy being called a boy. I strongly connect with the term genderqueer and on occasions I will refer to myself as trans masculine, thus I decided that I was indeed ‘man enough’, or possibly ‘masculine enough’ to attend.
I entered the session and quietly sat down. Just before the session began two younger faces peeked around the door, “Can we come in?” one asked in a soft unbroken voice.
A variety of versions of “If you identify as a man you are welcome here” answered back. “We are both trans guys” the unbroken voice replied. “Then yes, come on in”. The two young men entered the space and joined the circle.

It turned out that the session involved a variety of exercises looking at touch and consent, some similar to ones that I had done before. [bold mine] Out of a total of 18 participants, four of us were trans which seemed to make no difference to any of the cis men there. The workshop ended with a discussion about how the group had found the session. As the young man with the unbroken voice said how important it had been for him to be welcomed into such a space I felt tears well up in my eyes. Now several years into my physical transition I can look back and remember how important it was for me to find role models, both cis and trans men, who connected with a kind of masculinity that I found myself drawn to, yet opportunities of this kind had felt few and far between. In hearing how important the space had been for that young man I felt proud that I had been there with him. I felt grateful to the other men who had also been there, who had made the session a welcoming space for all of us to be in together.

As I reflect on my position about gender specific spaces I believe that it has changed over time. It is not so much the existence of them that I stand against, but rather how they are set up and who gets to dictate group membership. Who gets to decide who belongs and who doesn’t? Who performs their gender ‘well enough’ to be granted permission to enter? Who defines how these ideas of gender are constructed? It is the power in this exclusivity that I stand against; a power that exists in day to day culture which is harmful and oppressive to all of us, irrespective of our gender. Instead, I stand for spaces that are ‘opt in’, where power is placed in the individual and one gets to decide for themselves whether they belong, or even if they wish to belong at all. Spaces that are set up to be welcoming and supportive, inclusive and based on self-defined and self-constructed identities. Spaces that have the power to be healing, affirming and nurturing. Those are spaces of which I am proud to belong.

ResisterRex · 23/10/2022 12:54

This fundraiser is worth bookmarking:

twitter.com/succubus_mag/status/1082239082703609857?s=46&t=91FgA9jQ21602SuQZuBaQA

Beneficiaries seemed to include Mermaids, Gendered Intelligence, and Education and Celebrate

mamabear715 · 23/10/2022 12:52

It's horrendous. :-(