Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s stupid to have kids with the wrong person?

208 replies

Fannyproblemos · 21/10/2022 21:49

I have a couple of friends and family members who actively chose to have children with men who they knew would not make good long term partners. Each of them would admit to knowing this at the time. It’s not like the men or their relationships have changed dramatically. Now they are either trapped in unhappy situations for the sake of the kids. Or they have tricky custody arrangements, which bring stress and unhappiness. Whilst I sympathise. I cannot understand at all why these attractive and wonderful women chose these men to procreate with. Knowing they were already unhappy, knowing they would in most cases not make great dads, knowing their relationships wouldn’t last. Surely it would’ve been more sensible all round to leave these rot bags and try and meet someone they do love. Even at risk of not being able to have kids? I just think it’s a really selfish move to pop out a kid because you want one, knowing you’re intentionally bringing them into an unhappy situation. We should teach younger women this is not the way to go, it’s save a lot of heartache and divorce fees all round. And these are not cases of ‘sometime it just doesn’t work out’ they all knew in there heart of hearts it was not going to work out. Madness!

OP posts:
supertato32 · 21/10/2022 23:24

@StoneofDestiny what about single women who choose to have a baby through a sperm donor? Or are you only talking about single women who 'choose' the wrong partner!

Whiskeypowers · 21/10/2022 23:22

strawberriesplease · 21/10/2022 23:19

I knew a woman who was engaged to someone who was convicted for flashing (indecent exposure) at women. She still married him and had children then was surprised when he was caught again. Eventually left him.

Then moved onto a drug dealer as the next spouse.

She had a hugely damaging childhood but her life choices and parenting style were awful.

I think some people are so damaged it's difficult to change. What I've learnt is to avoid such people as they cause so much chaos and grief.

Wow so much judgment
You’ve been acknowledged she had a “hugely damaging childhood”

Just as well you refer to her as a woman you once knew instead of a friend

MsPincher · 21/10/2022 23:22

Fannyproblemos · 21/10/2022 23:13

I think that’s the key thing for me. I don’t believe anyone is entitled to or simply has the right to have kids because they are a woman nearing 40. I genuinely believe babies should be planned to be brought into the world into a loving family. And I live by this rule wholeheartedly myself. I will never have kids unless I meet the right guy. It seems only fair to myself, the kids, and also the guy.

Lots of couples who seem on the surface to be happy have awful toxic relationships with their children. My parents were married (happily to outsiders) but our home life was miserable. There is nothing wrong or unhappy about single parents. As I said, outcomes for kids of single parents are just as happy as two parent families.

supertato32 · 21/10/2022 23:22

@hattie43 I am a single mother who provides for her child and works very hard! There are a lot of us out there. There are also a lot of two parent families that claim benefits too! There are also a lot of people I know that earn bundles, and claim child benefits, tax free childcare when they don't really need to. Your point is so narrow minded. There will always be people in society that make the wrong decisions... Lord knows I know many people who thought they'd married the 'right' man, and he's ended up becoming horrible, abusive and their children (and my friends) are living in a stressed, unhappy environment! This thread showcases the typical pious attitudes of certain people in society! I would LOVE to have lived a life where I made no mistakes and all the right choices. Don't forget to give us a wave from up in the ivory tower you sit in. Xxx

strawberriesplease · 21/10/2022 23:19

I knew a woman who was engaged to someone who was convicted for flashing (indecent exposure) at women. She still married him and had children then was surprised when he was caught again. Eventually left him.

Then moved onto a drug dealer as the next spouse.

She had a hugely damaging childhood but her life choices and parenting style were awful.

I think some people are so damaged it's difficult to change. What I've learnt is to avoid such people as they cause so much chaos and grief.

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 23:19

MsPincher · 21/10/2022 23:16

Single mums do set out to provide the best for their children as do many women in relationships with men who turn out to be crap dads. That’s not womens fault if men are not good fathers

I read time and time again on here about women who have chosen to have further kids with men who they already know are shit fathers. That is on the women.

MsPincher · 21/10/2022 23:16

StoneofDestiny · 21/10/2022 23:12

A happy stable home can certainly be a single parent home and often is

Yes - but may not be, just the way that two parent families might splinter, or be bad examples to children by the way they behave to each other and their children!

The point I made is that it’s better to aim to bring a child up in a loving home with loving parents, modelling good parenting to their children so they can go on to form stable, secure loving relationships for their future offspring.

Setting out to deprive children of that experience seems very odd indeed.

Single mums do set out to provide the best for their children as do many women in relationships with men who turn out to be crap dads. That’s not womens fault if men are not good fathers

Fannyproblemos · 21/10/2022 23:13

I think that’s the key thing for me. I don’t believe anyone is entitled to or simply has the right to have kids because they are a woman nearing 40. I genuinely believe babies should be planned to be brought into the world into a loving family. And I live by this rule wholeheartedly myself. I will never have kids unless I meet the right guy. It seems only fair to myself, the kids, and also the guy.

OP posts:
MsPincher · 21/10/2022 23:13

5128gap · 21/10/2022 22:59

Or young men could be taught to do better?
Unfortunately, unsuitable inadequate men are a dime a dozen, with the ones who make great partners and fathers somewhat harder to find.
The search is in no way helped by the number who fail to reveal the extent of their inadequacy until after the event.
I don't think women can be blamed if they reach a point of thinking if I wait for a decent one I might wait for ever, and if they want children decide to do the best they can with the one they've got.
At least they're going in with their eyes open. The divorce rates would suggest that there are a fair few others thinking (perhaps a little smugly) that they were so much wiser in their own choice, only to get a nasty shock somewhere down the line.

This. 50% of marriages end in divorce and even lots of those that don’t end up unhappy. Imo if men are crap fathers it’s on them not on the mums.

StoneofDestiny · 21/10/2022 23:12

A happy stable home can certainly be a single parent home and often is

Yes - but may not be, just the way that two parent families might splinter, or be bad examples to children by the way they behave to each other and their children!

The point I made is that it’s better to aim to bring a child up in a loving home with loving parents, modelling good parenting to their children so they can go on to form stable, secure loving relationships for their future offspring.

Setting out to deprive children of that experience seems very odd indeed.

5128gap · 21/10/2022 23:06

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 23:01

I don't think women can be blamed if they reach a point of thinking if I wait for a decent one I might wait for ever, and if they want children decide to do the best they can with the one they've got.

women are not entitled to children.

I think you'll find that given the absence of any legally enforced fertility controls, women are fully entitled to become pregnant and have a child at any time they wish.

MsPincher · 21/10/2022 23:05

hattie43 · 21/10/2022 23:00

@MsPincher

You've got a real chip going there .

Yes I do contribute significantly to the countries coffers I've been a higher rate tax payer my whole adult life but this isn't about you as a single parent or me contributing this is about irresponsible women breeding to feckless men with the sole intention of sitting on benefits and as I've said I don't particularly care about them because it's their children I feel bad for being given a shit role of the dice to not only having no decent dad but being raised in poverty . This is a crap start to a child's life

You’re the one claiming that you support single mums. Certainly not me. Why aren’t you suggesting women have jobs or financial security before children? Why is it all about picking the right man?

Whiskeypowers · 21/10/2022 23:04

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 23:01

I don't think women can be blamed if they reach a point of thinking if I wait for a decent one I might wait for ever, and if they want children decide to do the best they can with the one they've got.

women are not entitled to children.

Who is saying they are entitled to children ?
a woman wanting a child doesn’t necessarily equate to a sense of entitlement?

Take that point of view to a board where women are using sperm donors and see where that goes ……

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 23:01

I don't think women can be blamed if they reach a point of thinking if I wait for a decent one I might wait for ever, and if they want children decide to do the best they can with the one they've got.

women are not entitled to children.

hattie43 · 21/10/2022 23:00

@MsPincher

You've got a real chip going there .

Yes I do contribute significantly to the countries coffers I've been a higher rate tax payer my whole adult life but this isn't about you as a single parent or me contributing this is about irresponsible women breeding to feckless men with the sole intention of sitting on benefits and as I've said I don't particularly care about them because it's their children I feel bad for being given a shit role of the dice to not only having no decent dad but being raised in poverty . This is a crap start to a child's life

5128gap · 21/10/2022 22:59

Or young men could be taught to do better?
Unfortunately, unsuitable inadequate men are a dime a dozen, with the ones who make great partners and fathers somewhat harder to find.
The search is in no way helped by the number who fail to reveal the extent of their inadequacy until after the event.
I don't think women can be blamed if they reach a point of thinking if I wait for a decent one I might wait for ever, and if they want children decide to do the best they can with the one they've got.
At least they're going in with their eyes open. The divorce rates would suggest that there are a fair few others thinking (perhaps a little smugly) that they were so much wiser in their own choice, only to get a nasty shock somewhere down the line.

MsPincher · 21/10/2022 22:57

StoneofDestiny · 21/10/2022 22:47

How many children actually have “two loving parents” in a secure home”. Most couples I know have quite a lot of conflict and unhappiness

Many children have two loving parents and secure homes - it’s worth aiming for. Nobody is saying ‘single parents’ are inferior - but it’s not the greatest plan to set out to be one, and certainly not to set out to have children as a product of a dysfunctional ‘shit relationship’ as OP mentions.

I disagree that it’s wrong to set out to be a single parent. Single parents can be just as good as two parent families- once you control for finances there is no difference in outcomes for kids. A happy stable home can certainly be a single parent home and often is.

Whiskeypowers · 21/10/2022 22:57

StoneofDestiny · 21/10/2022 22:47

How many children actually have “two loving parents” in a secure home”. Most couples I know have quite a lot of conflict and unhappiness

Many children have two loving parents and secure homes - it’s worth aiming for. Nobody is saying ‘single parents’ are inferior - but it’s not the greatest plan to set out to be one, and certainly not to set out to have children as a product of a dysfunctional ‘shit relationship’ as OP mentions.

This site is full of women who are rightly lauded for leaving and removing themselves and their children from abusive relationships thereby giving all concerned a better chance of a happier, more stable and emotionally healthier life. They are making the right choices.

I absolutely detest the notion that there is a swathe of women deliberately getting knocked up by “the wrong men”. There are normally a whole range of dynamics - both demographic, societal and cultural - as to why those who fall into this category are impacted as thus. Furthermore it also abrogates the responsibility in every sense of the men most of whom have not had to face the same pervasive damaging artifices society inflicts on girls and women.

I genuinely just despair.
of men were actually expected to be as present and ultimately as responsible as women are for children when the chips are down then we wouldn’t need these corrosive debates

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 22:54

SallyWD · 21/10/2022 22:20

Sometimes women are simply desperate for a baby. My friend got back together with her ex because she was 40 and wanted to be a mum more than anything else. Her ex isn't horrible but he's certainly not perfect husband/father material...

That is really no excuse.

MsPincher · 21/10/2022 22:53

hattie43 · 21/10/2022 22:37

@ MsPincher

You may not but thousands do and it's bringing more children into poverty through the feckless selfish decision of some women not all obviously but many many women make poor choices of partner

What do you earn? Are you a net contributor to the country (you personally not your dh or d dad)? Women are not responsible for men who don’t contribute to their children. I work hard, contribute to society and raise my dds well. Do u?

Buttons294749 · 21/10/2022 22:50

I have a friend who turned 40 and really wanted a baby. The man she found was already a feckless dad so is unsurpringly also crap with her DD. She's quite wealthy so she and DC have a great life but she always worries about her when she's with the ex. She would have had an easier time with a sperm donor but i can totally empathise why she did it and could have seen myself in a similar situation if i were 40 and desperate for a child.

Devoutspoken · 21/10/2022 22:50

So in one fell swoop, you discard all the women who have chosen to go it alone, for what ever reason

StoneofDestiny · 21/10/2022 22:47

How many children actually have “two loving parents” in a secure home”. Most couples I know have quite a lot of conflict and unhappiness

Many children have two loving parents and secure homes - it’s worth aiming for. Nobody is saying ‘single parents’ are inferior - but it’s not the greatest plan to set out to be one, and certainly not to set out to have children as a product of a dysfunctional ‘shit relationship’ as OP mentions.

Devoutspoken · 21/10/2022 22:47

I know, bat shit!

Whiskeypowers · 21/10/2022 22:45

hattie43 · 21/10/2022 22:38

@Whiskeypowers

Nothing of the sort . Truth hurts and my empathy will always be with the children who have a poor start in life and likely poor outcomes as adults .

What do you mean “truth hurts”?
who is that comment aimed at?

why are you assuming that children who have a shit dad have a poor start in life and poor outcomes as adults? That’s by no means always the case.

in any event that doesn’t deal with your awful footing the bill comment as if all these “feckless selfish women” - and I quote you - are popping out children with men they know are unsuitable apparently?

see there is nothing in your posts about the men in question ………

Swipe left for the next trending thread