Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s stupid to have kids with the wrong person?

208 replies

Fannyproblemos · 21/10/2022 21:49

I have a couple of friends and family members who actively chose to have children with men who they knew would not make good long term partners. Each of them would admit to knowing this at the time. It’s not like the men or their relationships have changed dramatically. Now they are either trapped in unhappy situations for the sake of the kids. Or they have tricky custody arrangements, which bring stress and unhappiness. Whilst I sympathise. I cannot understand at all why these attractive and wonderful women chose these men to procreate with. Knowing they were already unhappy, knowing they would in most cases not make great dads, knowing their relationships wouldn’t last. Surely it would’ve been more sensible all round to leave these rot bags and try and meet someone they do love. Even at risk of not being able to have kids? I just think it’s a really selfish move to pop out a kid because you want one, knowing you’re intentionally bringing them into an unhappy situation. We should teach younger women this is not the way to go, it’s save a lot of heartache and divorce fees all round. And these are not cases of ‘sometime it just doesn’t work out’ they all knew in there heart of hearts it was not going to work out. Madness!

OP posts:
Forzatesoro · 22/10/2022 10:30

Exactly @crackofdoom
My experience mirrors this.

Forzatesoro · 22/10/2022 10:29

I grew up in a toxic home environment and more or less married my mother.
I knew tension, arguing, shouting, obedience, too much responsibility, you name it.

The abuse cane in spades after our second child.
We eventually divorced. I was in a neglectful sexless stressful abusive marriage without ever intending on it. I gave my mental health and sanity to protect the children, and eventually I had to end it.

I've little to no respect for him however the children love him and that's what matters.

I can say that the guilt I felt about saddling my children with their dad almost ended me.

crackofdoom · 22/10/2022 10:26

It's completely true. There are far more emotionally sorted, hardworking, committed women than there are men. Sometimes the choices are to either procreate with a loser, or just not procreate.
And there's nothing wrong with being a stable single parent family- my parents are still married and my dad's an abusive bully. If he'd fucked off and we kids had stayed with my mum, perhaps I'd have had the self esteem in my 20s to choose a decent man when they were still available, easier than arriving at a good place, emotionally, in my 40s to realise most available men in my age bracket are woeful rejects.

Monoprix · 22/10/2022 10:11

A surprisingly large amount of people tend to think that women are spoilt for choice when it comes to choosing a husband/father of their children. Maybe for the likes of Angelina Jolie et al, but the reality for ordinary women is different. Lots of women can’t be that choosy or they would miss out on relationships and having a family. It’s not to say have four kids with an unemployed thug with a criminal background and a history of dv but let’s be realistic; most women don’t have a long list of eligible gentlemen forming an orderly queue at their front door waiting patiently for their turn to be the chosen to be the father of miss Ordinary’s future children.

RampantIvy · 22/10/2022 10:05

Yet there are still many threads on mumsnet from women who say they are TTCing for a/another baby with their addict/waste of space/abusive partners.

Whereupon the advice is always to stop and get watertight contraception.

5128gap · 22/10/2022 10:01

KimberleyClark · 22/10/2022 08:42

Its extremely unhealthy to believe that the quality of parenting your children get from their father is down to the wisdom of your own choices.
Women who believe this, and have a lot of investment in their self view as wise and discerning, will be more likely to ignore and minimise emerging problems. As after all, if your partner turns into an alcoholic, an abuser or a cheat, thats your fault isn't it, for not spotting the red flags? Far better to turn a blind eye to cheating, cover for the alcoholic, tolerate all manner of abuses, rather than have people judge you for your bad choices.

what a load of nonsense. I wouldn’t blame myself or minimise emerging problems if my DH turned into an arsehole. I just feel lucky that he hasn’t, we’ve been married 32 years and he is 71 so unlikely to do so now. Unless he gets dementia which is a possibility, but that would not be his fault.

Well presumably by that logic you don't blame other women too and believe they should have chosen more wisely. Which is great.
Very few women chose to have children with completely unsuitable men. In the absence of perfection, they more typically tend to compromise and accept some undesirable traits. Maybe he drinks a bit more than they prefer. Maybe he can be a bit selfish, a bit idle, a bit of a workaholic, gives the eye to the odd woman in the street. But overall, he's a good guy, and we've all got our faults.
Then as time goes by these things can escalate into big problems. Ironically family life can be a trigger point, and before long he is highly unsuitable.
A woman who has set out her stall that an unsuitable man is her own doing, sneering at the inferior choices of others, may feel rather reluctant to acknowledge that and so she and her children may put up with him behind closed doors.
Given that that has never happened to you, and your husband has retained his excellence for 32 years, you have no relevent experience upon which to draw, and are therefore unqualified to dismiss that as nonsense.

deliverooyoutoo · 22/10/2022 09:56

Also yeah. My parents thought they were great parents. They weren't

Mumsgirls · 22/10/2022 09:55

Isn’t why we must try to bring our girls up to be self supporting and ideally able to finance a family if the worst happens. I held off having children until I had a management promotion. My husband and I split and As he returned abroad I was able to support us all with no help from the government in the days when there was no childcare funding. Realise things are more difficult now, but I would never have risked having a child in poverty. I know not everyone camps do this, but at least we should aim for this for self preservation and for the children?

J0yxPeace · 22/10/2022 09:51

And yet my parents definitely identify with being "loving".

It's delusion.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/10/2022 09:51

Parmesam · 22/10/2022 09:40

You are talking about me. And I find you incredibly judgemental. There are many, many reasons why women make the decisions they do. I won't go into my reasons because they are outing, but I do not like your holier-than-thou attitude. No-one, absolutely no-one, can predict how they will change in the future.

Well said @Parmesam Flowers

J0yxPeace · 22/10/2022 09:50

@MsPincher so true.
My two married parents are the reason I had no sense of my self. They are the reason I had such a low bar. The dysfunctional relationship between a defensive adult and a spouse that backs them up no matter what is far far more damaging than one single parent with no other adult and no dysfunctional dynamic projected on to child.

mavismorpoth · 22/10/2022 09:50

deliverooyoutoo · 22/10/2022 09:47

I did. Based on my experience and my experience of life in my home of origin led to me parenting differently too.

Me too. It's a priority of mine but I think on the whole it's not. It wasn't for me. I went with a man who was just a pathetic waste of oxygen and looking back I wonder how/why I thought this person deserved even a second of my time let alone almost ten years.

Then I realised it's because no one ever said to me I was worth more. So this is something I prioritise with my daughter. If I had the self worth back then I have now I would not have entertained him.

I think rather than calling people like myself stupid, even though I was stupid, we should be asking how to prevent this, and really it is down to us as parents to prevent it. Also be hands on and make sure you have and keep a connection with your child, they respect you and you create a functional adult who will be a good partner.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/10/2022 09:48

maybe I should’ve added context. I was talking about professional, successful, degree educated, well brought up, mid thirties women, all with their finances together, nice homes etc. They were never hoodwinked, but knew they were choosing to procreate with someone they didn’t even really want to have sex with at the time.
Here's news OP - middle class women can come from dysfunctional family backgrounds too. Money doesn't stop them from being emotionally screwed by it, & getting a good job doesn't protect them from responding to similarly dysfunctional men as partners. ACE are one of the most common reasons that women end up with abusive or neglectful partners.

I’m so sorry for you guys that have suffered traumatic pasts, have no positive examples of how a family can be, have suffered abuse, or have low self esteem. Raising these valid points has genuinely made me think and made me more understanding and compassionate to my friends choices.
And yet here you still are, equating "nice homes" with "nice lives & ability to make the same choices as me" which shows that you don't have the first clue about how dysfunction is hidden or presented as normality under cover of money & privilege. Or do you genuinely believe it's only the Lower Orders who have fucked up families?

mft.nhs.uk/rmch/services/camhs/young-people/adverse-childhood-experiences-aces-and-attachment/

deliverooyoutoo · 22/10/2022 09:47

mavismorpoth · 22/10/2022 09:45

It's very common.

Let me ask all parents this.

Did you make it clear to your child throughout their life how important choosing the right partner was? As important as a career. How to do it, and instil self worth that prohibits them from selling themselves short in this regard?

I did. Based on my experience and my experience of life in my home of origin led to me parenting differently too.

RampantIvy · 22/10/2022 09:46

Why are people talking about men who start off great then turn shit OR women who cant see that their partner is shit cos of their own issues/trauma, when the threads specifically about when women can see their partners are shit from day one but have a baby with then anyway?

I don't think the OP is criticising those who split with a partner and end up single. It's more the fact that women knowingly have children with someone who isn't ever going to be a good parent.

That is exactly how I read the OP, yet too many posters seem to not want to or are projecting.

I think there are also women who ignore the fact that their partner isn't keen & assume he will step up once the child arrives. Then he never does & they post on Mumsnet moaning about their useless DH.

Maybe they think a baby might be the “sticking plaster” to their relationship?

I just wish women would be taught to have the confidence to tell their biological clock to F off and not succumb to the pressure to have kids with any old sod.

And taught that not having kids doesn’t have to be the end of the effing world.

Exactly @KimberleyClark

mavismorpoth · 22/10/2022 09:45

It's very common.

Let me ask all parents this.

Did you make it clear to your child throughout their life how important choosing the right partner was? As important as a career. How to do it, and instil self worth that prohibits them from selling themselves short in this regard?

Devoutspoken · 22/10/2022 09:41

Worthyornot, excuse, or truth? Deciding not to have an abortion after failed contraception doesn't make you a feckless twat surely?

Parmesam · 22/10/2022 09:40

You are talking about me. And I find you incredibly judgemental. There are many, many reasons why women make the decisions they do. I won't go into my reasons because they are outing, but I do not like your holier-than-thou attitude. No-one, absolutely no-one, can predict how they will change in the future.

J0yxPeace · 22/10/2022 09:38

I agree this question is very relevant.
A lot of men don't want what most women want within the same time frames anyway.

I know this sentence will still offend people but there is a mismatch between what men want and what women want.

There is an element of good luck finding it.
But those women think that walking away from frogs automatically makes the prince's appear. I've been single for about 15 years! Not unhappy about it but I insist that finding a good man who wants what you want at the same time is good luck. Especially if there's no cost to that. Like you are beautiful and he has a face only his mum coukd love, or if he's a good decade older.

Worthyornot · 22/10/2022 09:38

Devoutspoken · 22/10/2022 09:37

There's also the conundrum of failed contraception

On MN it's always the excuse for making bad choices.

Devoutspoken · 22/10/2022 09:37

There's also the conundrum of failed contraception

converseandjeans · 22/10/2022 09:29

@emptythelitterbox

Isn't the real question. Why are there so many unsuitable inadequate men?

Agree with this. I read about so many useless men on here. I think some women just figure that they want children & will have to make do with the men available. Men who take on 50% of childcare are rare.

Mumoblue · 22/10/2022 09:28

Well considering your update saying you’ve thought about it a bit more and feel more compassionate towards them now, I’m not gonna go off on you, OP.

However, I will admit, what I don’t understand MORE is women who are not single mothers, sitting around and saying to themselves “You know who needs some more judgement? Single mothers!” - Hmm yeah we’ve had it too easy!

Look, I came by single motherhood in the most honest way I could. I didn’t expect to be one, and I’m not sorry that I am. Shit happens. I don’t get the point of shaming women after the fact, however they ended up in this boat.

But trust me, nobody is a single mum just because they didn’t have anyone condescending to them. And given a magic choice between meeting my perfect soulmate Nigel who would treat me so good and having the son that I have, I’m afraid Prince Nigel is going in the woodchipper.

J0yxPeace · 22/10/2022 09:24

I never thought I could change my x!! @KILM
I felt that emotionally healthy men were too intrusive, their questions left me feeling invaded or stripped bare. They were only trying to get to know me.

My x had no curiosity about who I was. I hadn't been encouraged to have a self. My x didn't expect me to have one.

It felt like a relief. I had no intention of changing him!!

Then i gained insight,

I feel a lot of people misunderstand how intrusive emotionally healthy men can seem.

converseandjeans · 22/10/2022 09:22

@MissMaple82

I believe children should be taught a whole lot more in schools other than subjects like maths and English, life skills should be taught, confidence building, body image, boundaries, and acceptable relationships, only then will women stop finding themselves in dead-end abusive, love lacking relationships where children are being brought up in, to no doubt repeat the cycle all over again!

They do - it's PSHE. Lots about for example friendship issues and resolving conflict, online safety. Yet students still write nasty things online, exclude people etc...

School can only do so much - essentially it's up to the individual to make their own choice in life.

I don't think the OP is criticising those who split with a partner and end up single. It's more the fact that women knowingly have children with someone who isn't ever going to be a good parent.

A lot of children in single parent households are on pupil premium. So it does cost the taxpayers money. I am personally happy to support children in this situation as it's not their fault. Unfortunately those children are highlighted in school as being pupil premium, graphs on their progress, discussed at meetings. We no longer have photos up on staff room wall but it's on provision map, class charts. Ofsted use as a criteria under disadvantaged. Obviously the aim is to level up and decrease the gap. But to have a child knowing that they will be always at a disadvantage from the start isn't great. I stopped at 2 because I didn't have the money for more.

I think there are also women who ignore the fact that their partner isn't keen & assume he will step up once the child arrives. Then he never does & they post on Mumsnet moaning about their useless DH.

Swipe left for the next trending thread