Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s stupid to have kids with the wrong person?

208 replies

Fannyproblemos · 21/10/2022 21:49

I have a couple of friends and family members who actively chose to have children with men who they knew would not make good long term partners. Each of them would admit to knowing this at the time. It’s not like the men or their relationships have changed dramatically. Now they are either trapped in unhappy situations for the sake of the kids. Or they have tricky custody arrangements, which bring stress and unhappiness. Whilst I sympathise. I cannot understand at all why these attractive and wonderful women chose these men to procreate with. Knowing they were already unhappy, knowing they would in most cases not make great dads, knowing their relationships wouldn’t last. Surely it would’ve been more sensible all round to leave these rot bags and try and meet someone they do love. Even at risk of not being able to have kids? I just think it’s a really selfish move to pop out a kid because you want one, knowing you’re intentionally bringing them into an unhappy situation. We should teach younger women this is not the way to go, it’s save a lot of heartache and divorce fees all round. And these are not cases of ‘sometime it just doesn’t work out’ they all knew in there heart of hearts it was not going to work out. Madness!

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 24/10/2022 21:58

You are right of course, OP, but the fact is that even smart people sometimes make foolish decisions about relationships.

I think that when something is so close, it can be difficult to think clearly or do the logical thing even when you know what it is.

Some of the dumber things I've done were related to men.

Duchess379 · 24/10/2022 19:01

I'm with you on this one, op. I couldn't imagine anything worse than being stuck in a relationship with a guy who's useless because of kids. But some women wholeheartedly believe they have the right to have babies, regardless of the situation they're in

housesk · 24/10/2022 17:07

Not read the whole thread @Fannyproblemos but I think this is a really interesting point you’ve raised. I was that person. Why did I do it? A mixture of reasons and i can’t say one was the ‘main’ reason either.

I was mid thirties and with a man who ticked many boxes but not necessarily the dependable family man box. He said he wanted a family very much. I wanted to believe him and I think he did want that, but I knew that actually he was unlikely to be capable of the long haul. So… why did I carry on? Hope, I think. Genuine hope that he would change and rise to it all. He was decent in lots of ways and I thought that would come through with a baby too. I weighed up that I could be with someone else like this and be 38, 39 etc. There’s no guarantees.

What I will say is that those who are happy with someone in the long run, it’s largely luck - not entirely, but you have to accept that there IS an element of luck. Similarly, some people stay together after a one night stand, for instance, that’s luck. We can only make the choices we think are best in those moments and often, if there’s a time limit for women in their thirties, taking that risk is not a wildly irresponsible thing to do, in my opinion. I knew on some level it may not work out, but at the same time I knew I had put my heart into the relationship and it COULD work out. I hoped it would.

Another point that I think is relevant is that a lot of men who are ‘good on paper’ don’t actually want or feel a need to settle down until they are in their forties. It’s unusual for a women even at 30 to want to be with a man in their forties as they have all the thirties men to date. You do fine then that a 42 year old man will happily breeze through a relationship with a woman in her mid to late thirties with no acknowledgement of biology. It is a sad state of affairs that society does not value stable families in the way it perhaps should, and therefore whilst it is ultimately down to the woman if she goes ahead and rolls the dice with a man she isn’t sure is wholly committed, we have to ask why her choices are so limited, and inevitably, an analysis of male behaviour has to be considered.

Those saying women are not entitled to have kids… no they’re not. There’s also other things in life as posters have pointed out. But let’s not pretend there isn’t often a genuine, instinctive need to have children. There is no shame in weighing up what matters most and what risk you want to take with it.

For what it’s worth, my ex was clear he wanted a family. ‘Desperate to be a dad’ he said. He’s never met dc… that doesn’t answer your question as to why a women may make the wrong choice of father but I think it tells you that many relationships are nuanced abs on balance, whilst I wasn’t 100% sure my ex would step up, I never in a million years would have thought he would entirely abandon a baby he said he wanted. It really isn’t as simple as women picking a man knowing full well they won’t stick around - that happens of course, but it’s rare.

Whiskeypowers · 24/10/2022 13:17

*more to not too

Whiskeypowers · 24/10/2022 13:17

RampantIvy · 24/10/2022 12:22

Instead of being brainwashed into thinking that their happiness, self-esteem and status are all dependent on getting their man, young girls should be taught that staying single for the rest of their lives would be far better than being with the wrong man. And that they don't owe a romantic relationship to anyone - certainly not to man, and not to their family either.

Spot on @Fairislefandango
Also they shouldn't be brainwashed into thinking that having a baby is the only pinnacle of success in life. There is much, much more to life than having children.

Of course all of this is true
There are millions of women who have known that there is more too life than having children but when they wanted a child that was no longer the case. For many of these women no amount of education, career, lifestyle or opportunities necessarily overrode that.

it would help if alongside all this rightful raising the bar stuff for women and girls boys and men were raised in a society where women being treated like second class citizens, experiencing pervasive misogyny, treated as sexual
Objects and abused was deplored and condemned by everyone not just feminists.

then wanting a child wouldn’t be so “stupid”

RampantIvy · 24/10/2022 12:22

Instead of being brainwashed into thinking that their happiness, self-esteem and status are all dependent on getting their man, young girls should be taught that staying single for the rest of their lives would be far better than being with the wrong man. And that they don't owe a romantic relationship to anyone - certainly not to man, and not to their family either.

Spot on @Fairislefandango
Also they shouldn't be brainwashed into thinking that having a baby is the only pinnacle of success in life. There is much, much more to life than having children.

FrippEnos · 24/10/2022 10:14

OP

I think that you are correct, I know that some women may not realise until its too late, but several of my friends knew the person that they were dating was not a good choice when they had the first child with them. But then went back to them after a break up to have a second one.

greenteafiend · 24/10/2022 10:10

When the time comes, you turn 39, desperate for kids and no decent man in sight, you really have no idea how you will act.

There is indeed a serious dilemma here. Like, men have (Generally) less agreeable personalities than women; personality disorders, addiction, criminality all seem to be commoner in men than women. Don't want to get into controversial stuff, but the "Living with ASD" threads suggest that a lot of men who are on the spectrum are VERY hard to live with as well, and there are a lot more men who are significantly affected by autism than women.

What if there is, in fact, only a limited number of men with the sort of personalities than make them easy-to-live-with husbands and fathers, and if the numbers of these are lower than the number of women who'd like to get married and have children? If that is the case, then it will actually, for many women, be a genuine choice of: have kids with crap guy, or have no kids at all (or get a sperm donor).

Is it better for women to remain childfree rather than having children with a less than ideal man? That's a genuine question, rather than a rhetorical one; I actually don't know the answer.

Or is wider adoption of sperm donation/single motherhood by choice, the way forward? I know that if I was late 30s with no decent partner in sight, I'd go for SD with a reputable donor rather than settle with some shocker of a guy....

FrozenGhost · 24/10/2022 10:03

We all know women who have multiple kids by horrible men and we just think why?

But OP you said
And I live by this rule wholeheartedly myself. I will never have kids unless I meet the right guy.

So you haven't actually made that sacrifice yourself! You are sitting there saying that you'll only have kids once you meet the perfect man, but that's really easy to say when you (maybe secretly, maybe even subconsciously) believe that he's just around the corner. When the time comes, you turn 39, desperate for kids and no decent man in sight, you really have no idea how you will act.

Itstarts · 24/10/2022 10:01

Anyone can make poor judgements. I wouldn't believe anybody who said they hadn't. Getting so swept up by the desire to have a baby, even with the wrong man I can sympathise with.

But when you're on baby no.3 with father no.3 and not 1 of the fathers has stayed even long enough to be at the birth... yes, it's stupid and think you are an absolute idiot. There's a new man on the scene now so expecting baby no.4 to be announced soon and man 4 to disappear shortly after. (ndn)

Mumoblue · 24/10/2022 09:49

dontsweatthesmallstufff · 23/10/2022 23:09

It would be interesting to hear your son's perspective.

On what? Being born? I think he’s pretty happy with it. As I said, I’m one of those who didn’t choose single motherhood (and generally the type people say “Oh I didn’t mean YOU” to when they make this kind of thread), so what do I need to be sorry for? I’m not.

I’m happy, my boy is happy, he knows he’s loved by his mum AND his dad, and we don’t need to suffer in loveless relationship to make it so.

All of our children will judge us for the way they’re raised, and right now I can hold my head high on that matter.

peaceandove · 24/10/2022 09:43

There are huge swathes of the population who are utterly feckless and live from day to day with zero thought to the future, or the consequences of their actions. Twas ever thus.

Whiskeypowers · 24/10/2022 09:39

Whatsleftnow · 24/10/2022 09:12

It’s so easy to blame women for this (and all of life’s evils) and I think if you can you should count yourself very lucky that your life experiences haven’t given you a kinder perspective.

Absolutely agree

so much smug armchair criticism on here it’s tragic

Devoutspoken · 24/10/2022 09:35

Dontsweaththe small stuff, the choice I made for my child was not to have an abortion after failed contraception. Call me a feckless selfish idiot

Alltheprettyseahorses · 24/10/2022 09:25

It's very easy to be judgemental. They might think he's the right person and be blind to his faults. They might also be sitting at home saying the same thing about you - 'how can she be with him? Look how he acts!'

NameChangeLifeChange · 24/10/2022 09:19

I agree to an extent if you’ve chosen to have a baby with someone you already know is going to be a shit dad.
From experience with family and friends the partners who turn out to be shit disappointing dads and end up splitting came as no surprise to anyone who knows then other than the woman/mother who was blind to the issues until a baby sadly exacerbated them.
No it’s not down to women and no onus on men but ultimately if women made good choices and thought ahead all those shit men would be single and unable to sew their shitty oats and fail those poor children forever.
I met DH when I was 19 and was hugely aware he would be a lovely father from the start even years away from considering starting a family. I knew I’d want children and when it came to the crunch and we decided to move in together etc this was part of the decision. I don’t consider myself particularly lucky or any more intelligent than anyone else. But I did actively choose to be with someone who’d be a good partner and father.

Whatsleftnow · 24/10/2022 09:12

It’s so easy to blame women for this (and all of life’s evils) and I think if you can you should count yourself very lucky that your life experiences haven’t given you a kinder perspective.

UWhatNow · 24/10/2022 09:10

IHateFlies · 22/10/2022 15:31

I think the issue is that it's completely socially acceptable for a man to walk away from his family and never pay for his kids.
It should be shameful.
Of course, I'm not saying that couples should stay together, but a father who walks away from his kids should not be normalised by society.
When men realise they have roles and responsibilities within the family that are permanent, it might change them.

Absolutely. The govt ought to be pursuing costs for the children they’ve conceived instead of the taxpayer picking up the slack.

You fathered it - you pay for it.

This idea of ‘single mothers’ is wrong - it should be non-cohabiting parents and they are both responsible for the well-being and welfare of that child irrespective of who does the day to day.

Bringing a child into the world should be considered a solemn and serious responsibility for which you as a parent are accountable. This includes the feckless and the dumbshit of either sex.

Fairislefandango · 24/10/2022 09:06

Amazing how many are ignoring what the OP is asking about. The thread is not about women who meet someone who seems decent and have children with them in good faith

This is a chat forum, not a survey. Conversations develop and move on from the starting point.

Phrenologistsfinger · 24/10/2022 09:05

I waited for the right person and now I’m too old to have a baby with him!

Started ttc at 37 now 40 after 12 losses, no issues except age! IVF is yielding minimal embryos as my elderly eggs cannot do much. I now wish I’d had more unprotected sex with unsuitable men when I was young.

I have learnt not to judge others’ life choices. We all walk our own path.

Fairislefandango · 24/10/2022 09:04

For her, me marrying anybody, even if he was abusive prick, was the most important thing in the world. I was happy to stay alone all my life.

Exactly. Instead of being brainwashed into thinking that their happiness, self-esteem and status are all dependent on getting their man, young girls should be taught that staying single for the rest of their lives would be far better than being with the wrong man. And that they don't owe a romantic relationship to anyone - certainly not to man, and not to their family either.

PeaceX · 24/10/2022 08:56

Cuppasoupmonster · 22/10/2022 14:44

A lot of posters on MN will say ‘that’s why I didn’t have kids until I was 38, when I found the right person’ but in my experience, it’s older mums who pick the wrong man in a rush to settle down. I don’t think this issue is the remit of young or ‘irresponsible’ mums necessarily. It’s difficult being a woman now as men are total commitment phobes who see themselves as ‘too young to settle down’ before they’re 40.

So true. With a younger woman it's often, whoops, shit!
With a 39 year old, it's now or never after years of rumination, seatching and settling. Missing the slot for motherhood is not something that can be fixed later.

There is a lot of judgement on single mothers but I have been a better parent to my dc than my married parents were to me. They had some dysfunctional dynamics, their repressed emotions were projected on to me. Im ok now because I stand firm in my interpretation of family history but my married parents best left me anxious, lacking in confidence, fearful, all the good stuff. It's taken therapy to undo it.

So a lot of judgement placed on single parents is void in cases where they were the ones brave enough to make changes.

Conventional people place value on married parents when all the studies show that it is poverty not single parent families that negatively affect outcomes.

I think women who are cornered in to the now or never decision are usually sensible have put it off as long as they could. I was "responsible" and sensible for as long as I had those options.

Low self esteem was a big factor too but I was responsible and sensible.

KimberleyClark · 24/10/2022 08:52

Amazing how many are ignoring what the OP is asking about. The thread is not about women who meet someone who seems decent and have children with them in good faith and they then reveal their true colours. It’s about women who knowingly choose to have children with men they already know are arseholes.

Pancakestoday · 24/10/2022 08:44

I'm not quite sure I understand this.

Everyone on here commenting saying it's stupid/selfish must themselves all have excellent relationships, be setting a perfect example and be 100% certain that their children's father will never put a foot wrong.

There's a relatively short window for a woman to have a child and truly good men are in short supply. Working in a certain industry in my 20s I knew a hell of a lot of married fathers who were cheating on their wives with younger single women from the office. It really eroded my trust in men and the idea of the perfect family. Don't be quite so smug.

There seems to be a lot of blame on the woman too. Does the man have any part in this when he choses to get a woman pregnant knowing that he's not going to stick around?

I can honestly say that most of the single parents I know of do a fantastic job.

RampantIvy · 24/10/2022 06:54

I couldn't agree with you more @CJsGoldfish.