Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL said my breast milk isn't good enough for my baby

306 replies

goldenroses95 · 21/10/2022 20:43

I have a newborn who is feeding extremely often and my MIL claims that my baby is feeding so often because she's not getting enough nutrients from my breast milk. She says I need to change my diet (this is based on her seeing me eat 1 pizza takeaway on the weekend!) and even said "do you not love your child?"

I have told her that babies cluster feed and you feed breast fed babies on demand but MIL is having none of it. DH has not once backed me on this and her constant interfering is stressing me out. This incident is just one of a long list of things she's said/done.

Not an aibu as such but posting to see if anyone can advise me on how to navigate this situation!

OP posts:
CloudSunLeavesCoud · 21/10/2022 23:09

Don’t let this person ruin your confidence regardless of who she is. Limit interactions with her as much as possible and tell DH if he can’t keep her in line you’ll just have to see less and less of her and don’t accept any excuses. If you do have to see her be clear that she shouldn’t be saying this stuff to you in whatever way you feel best (be direct, laugh and pretend she’s joking,
leave the room, death stare whatever works for you). You don’t have to put up with it.

InsertPunHere · 21/10/2022 23:07

Good on you for standing up for yourself. You're absolutley right and your MIL is full of nonsense.

BlodynGwyn · 21/10/2022 22:59

ProcrastinatorsAnonymous · 21/10/2022 22:22

Women have indeed breastfed since the dawn of humanity, but with a marked drop off in the 70s / 80s with the aggressive marketing of infant formula. Many mothers didn't breastfeed at all in the 80s, so have no understanding of it - meaning that instead of useful information being passed from one generation to the next, many of today's grandmothers are pushing uninformed views about BF onto their daughters and daughters-in-law. I hear SO many stories about women giving up on breastfeeding because of a mother or mother-in-law who gave birth in the 80s telling them that their milk isn't enough (because that's what they were told). I suspect there's also some guilt mixed up in it: they were pressured NOT to breastfeed, but are now hearing the message that "breast is best".

Interesting comments. I wondered what was going on with some women when it came to breast-feeding.

I breastfed both of mine and I was breastfed by my mother. I'm almost 70 and my mum was born in the late 1920's. So, no woman in my family, on both sides, ever used formula. My oldest child is almost 50 and I was the only woman in the hospital who was breast-feeding. I was 21 yrs old and nobody instructed me how to hold the baby, or stuff about latch or how often to feed. The only woman who'd seen anyone breastfeed before was my British midwife. I was living abroad away from my family. I just fed him whenever he wanted to. With no outdated advice we did great.

My daughter-in-law was bottle-feed and so was everyone in living memory in her family. Thankfully she is breastfeeding her new baby and loves how easy it is. She got a bit of negative feed back about breast-feeding from her family, who live very far away. They thought it was a gimmick and you still needed to have formula, bottles and some sort of bottle sterilizing machine. Her dad even said he'd come over here to help her with the night feeds and when she needed to 'get away' from her darling little baby. He was told to stay away.

PortiasBiscuit · 21/10/2022 22:58

Practice the phrase
“When I want your opinion I will ask for it, thank you!”
I suspect this is not the last time you are going to need it OP.

Basecamp · 21/10/2022 22:58

My MIL made some outrageously nasty comments throughout my pregnancy. I cut her out of my life for over a year and when I let her back in it was very gradual and on my terms. It was more than she deserved really.

I've kept her at arms length over the past several years and have never allowed her to look after our child on her own. She's an extremely opinionated, bitchy woman who I don't trust and she's missed out as a result. But that's what you get for being a dick quite frankly!

Honestly you need to put your foot down. Her comments are disgraceful and she wouldn't be crossing the threshold of my house again until she had learned to keep her mouth shut. Sadly old habits die hard and it's not likely that she will see the error of her ways, so you need to set the boundaries here and decide how much you want her in your life.

ODFOx · 21/10/2022 22:55

This worked for me (albeit over 20 years ago):
'I'm all over the place with my hormones right now so please forgive me if I may be interpreting your advice as criticism but the midwife and the health visitor tell me that everything is going really well and our feeding pattern is working so well for X's development. I am tired to be honest but X is doing so far above average we are thrilled. What was it you were worried about?'
Get your DH onside and shut down the negativity. If you are ok and baby is ok then no other opinion matter.

pollyglot · 21/10/2022 22:55

Did your MIL BF? You are doing great!

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 21/10/2022 22:54

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 21/10/2022 20:48

I think she needs to be told in no uncertain terms that her opinion is a) wrong and b) unwelcome. That she can either be helpful, supportive and polite or she can stay away till she figures out how manners work.

This

kateandme · 21/10/2022 22:54

Plus there is zero wrong with pizza or carbs or takeout or any foods.balance op.

kateandme · 21/10/2022 22:53

There needs to be dynamics info here for people to advice better I think op.
because some couod say tell her to fuck off,say nothing else or not come at all,would a smiling assassin approach work better,can you be firm.
how is she normally and your relationship and communication?
you know your doing th right thing op.
your husband needs to listen to you as a mother and his wife.he also needs to support you. And he needs to work with you to find what’s right not with your mil. You need to be honest with him and tell him how much at this time you are so vulnerable and need to no he always has your back.

WizardOfUK · 21/10/2022 22:53

Your dh needs to get a mind of his own and stop taking what Mummy says as gospel

elephantseal · 21/10/2022 22:51

I craved carbs when I was BFing too! You're doing fine. Her ideas are a generation out of date.

But your h is the problem - he needs to stand up to you.

Cluster feeding is totally normal. Keep going!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/10/2022 22:48

Gosh, that posted on its own! Was going to say the NCT was a good support for me, but I was also very lucky with my hospital and community midwives.

RainbowSlide · 21/10/2022 22:47

Ummm no. This is unbelievably insupportive and in your shoes I would tell her to mind her own business. Probably not as kindly. And she's a nurse?!

You are doing a great job, baby is of course cluster feeding and unless there's significant weight loss/ failure to thrive issues (which is not at all in question or what she's responding to), then she needs to butt out.

I would be saying to her "what you're saying is extremely rude and unsupportive, so if you want to keep visiting us you need to stop this"

I'm sorry you're dealing with this, newborn life is hard enough without this crap

ForeverFailing · 21/10/2022 22:45

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 21/10/2022 22:25

I breastfed on demand in the early 90s. The NC

Alas that wasn’t even a thing (in my personal experience) when I had my 1st. Tried very hard to breastfeed but was never given any support or guidance.

Mouscadoo · 21/10/2022 22:44

My MIL audibly gasped when I told her I was breastfeeding my daughter and FIL constantly made snipes about baby wanting "real food". Its such a shame that its such a common theme and I do believe it is unfortunately a control thing.

Pumpkintopf · 21/10/2022 22:40

Unbelievable that she's said she'd like to take your baby.

Talk to your health visitor with your husband. Get him to understand that you are doing all the right things and, importantly you need to be together on this.

He needs to back you up.

EasterIssland · 21/10/2022 22:39

Not sure what is worse questioning your feeding to the baby or what you eat and acussing you of not caring and loving your child. You’re doing the right thing op. Don’t let her let you down. I have a feeling like others have mentioned she wants to bully you into ff so she can feed the baby and “bond” with them. Stick to your guns and don’t be bullied. You’re doing an amazing job

nannync · 21/10/2022 22:37

Get your Midwife or HV to speak to him.
Tell him to google it?
Show him this thread?
Wtf is wrong with him?

Are you oppressed? I don't get it? If my MIL said that to me I'd laugh at her and tell her she's being ridiculous, tell her to do some research, and tell her to get out of my house. End of.

TooHotTooColdJustRight · 21/10/2022 22:31

goldenroses95 · 21/10/2022 20:43

I have a newborn who is feeding extremely often and my MIL claims that my baby is feeding so often because she's not getting enough nutrients from my breast milk. She says I need to change my diet (this is based on her seeing me eat 1 pizza takeaway on the weekend!) and even said "do you not love your child?"

I have told her that babies cluster feed and you feed breast fed babies on demand but MIL is having none of it. DH has not once backed me on this and her constant interfering is stressing me out. This incident is just one of a long list of things she's said/done.

Not an aibu as such but posting to see if anyone can advise me on how to navigate this situation!

My mum did this and completely undermined my experience. I haven't gotten over that. Dd1 is 16 now. Find a peer supportive group and go to that.
Trust yourself too. X

Cw112 · 21/10/2022 22:31

Newborn babies tummies are tiny and only hold small amounts so they will feed constantly plus baby is learning how to breast feed and latch and the more they feed the more your body is able to work out what amount they need to to produce etc. I'm assuming she's formula fed her babies and is expecting the 'milk drunk' effect that bf babies take longer to get to. You know your baby best, you know your body best and the best thing about advice is it's free so you can say thank you and ignore it. I'd recommend joining a bf support group in your area because bf is tough and intense and comments like hers are seriously unhelpful. You need to sit DH down and explain to him that he needs to back you up when she's being pass remarkable and back up your parenting choices as his co parent. I'd also suggest having her over less tbh. If she starts telling you baby isn't getting enough you say thanks for the advice but the health visitor and midwives are happy and this is actually very common for breastfeeding. Then change the topic. If she continues to bring it back just say I'm happy with how feeding is going and if I have any concerns ill raise it with the health visitor. Change topic. She will eventually get the message if you Mel repeating the same line. Well done you on sticking to your guns, hopefully dh will start to step up and get those boundaries in place now.

lunar1 · 21/10/2022 22:30

My mum was like this with ds1. She got one warning, I told her if she ever did it again she wouldn't have a relationship with my children.

Your mil has crossed a line.

bakewellbride · 21/10/2022 22:29

Nc now but I used to know someone a bit like your MIL. I knew I could never convince her or get her to think differently so I used to just agree with her and then quickly change the subject, it used to drive her crazy! E.g "I think it's time your breastfeeding journey came to an end." (Ds was only 1 ffs!) me with a smile "oh ok, I'll stop tomorrow!" then I carried on breastfeeding for as long as I wanted. It worked because it effectively ended the subject as there's nothing more the other person can say. Won't necessarily work with your MIL who does sound a bit more extreme. Congratulations on the baby.

MatronicO6 · 21/10/2022 22:27

Oh OP, I feel your pain, I had something similar with a MIL who knew better as she had raised 5 kids so knew exactly what to do. Kept lecturing DH on what we should be doing. I dealt with it by using actual medical advice and referred to NHS website, La Leche League and KellyMom and asked HV in his presence. Which he then deferred his mum too, sent her all the links and point blank said we would be taking her advice on breastfeeding anymore.

Think her motives are quite selfish rather than interest of the baby and you need to set clear boundaries now but DH needs to be on side and basically put his foot down.

It did work for us, though she has had her moments, baby is now 6 months and weaning and MIL liquidized chicken, carrot and potato seasoned with salt, pepper and garlic and chucked it in bottle with a fast flow teat. Luckily I had DH prepped and he instantly explained how solids are meant to be introduced and why. She had a quick grumble about how all hers turned out fine but give it a rest when DH pointed out DD is one of ours, not hers and we'll do what we want.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 21/10/2022 22:27

goldenroses95, you are right, she is wrong, and I wish you all the very best in the world in keeping her unpleasantness at bay.

This "babies ought to be fed every x hours" thing (when I had mine, in the eighties, it was every four hours rather than three, and we were very strongly encouraged to bottle-feed and made to feel like bad mothers if we breast-fed) was from the advice of a man called Truby King.

Truby King lived 1 April 1858 – 10 February 1938.

He also advised not cuddling babies in case they grew up to be namby-pamby (not his words, but that was what he meant). And if they cried you should ignore them, for the same reason.

He probably meant well....

Nobody mentioned cluster feeding to me when I had my son in 1981, in fact I'm not sure it was really known about, but my son knew about it, and made sure that I found out pretty damn quickly! For the first four weeks of his life he only stopped eating to have his nappy changed and take short sleeps before he started to cry for food again. He's a six foot two marathon runner now, so it doesn't seem to have done him too much harm.

My mother-in-law didn't approve, but luckily she lived 150 miles away so we didn't have to see her too much.

Swipe left for the next trending thread