Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL said my breast milk isn't good enough for my baby

306 replies

goldenroses95 · 21/10/2022 20:43

I have a newborn who is feeding extremely often and my MIL claims that my baby is feeding so often because she's not getting enough nutrients from my breast milk. She says I need to change my diet (this is based on her seeing me eat 1 pizza takeaway on the weekend!) and even said "do you not love your child?"

I have told her that babies cluster feed and you feed breast fed babies on demand but MIL is having none of it. DH has not once backed me on this and her constant interfering is stressing me out. This incident is just one of a long list of things she's said/done.

Not an aibu as such but posting to see if anyone can advise me on how to navigate this situation!

OP posts:
CuriousEats · 22/10/2022 00:12

I'd be telling DH that if he doesn't stand up to his mother and tell her to STFU, she wouldn't be welcome to visit anymore until you've weaned the baby. If you don't show her where the boundaries are now, she's only going to get worse.
Don't waste energy trying to reason with her or show her evidence. It'll only give her 'permission' to argue against it. Put your foot down!

Kona84 · 22/10/2022 00:10

Make your partner read up about breastfeeding from trusted sources like the breastfeeding network, lactation advice pages.
he can even phone the breastfeeding helpline for some education this way he won’t have to just hear it from you.
you clearly know that cluster feeding is normal- feeding on demand is best for newborns.
the only thing I know of to eat to increase supply is oats.
your milk is made from your blood not your stomach contents.

in response to her saying she wishes she could take baby as you don’t know what you are doing.
tell her that she is not welcome to visit if she is not going to be supportive.
then (if practical) leave the house when she visits and don’t return with baby until she is gone

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 22/10/2022 00:09

Pallisers · 21/10/2022 20:59

you need to look her in the eye and say "I know perfectly well what I am doing and don't want your unasked for advice or commentary"

People like this are being rude and rely on you not calling them on it. Call her on it. After that initial statement say "I told you I don't want your opinion on this - it isn't particularly nice for a new mother to hear rubbish like this" over and over.

If all else fails just take the baby and go to your bedroom for her visit.

This. Except I might be firmer and tell her not to come next week because you have plans.

She’s not well meaning but ignorant. She questioned your love for your baby. She’s actively undermining you.

C8H10N4O2 · 21/10/2022 23:59

goldenroses95 · 21/10/2022 21:26

I have spoken to DH about not backing me up and his reasoning is he's never had a baby before so he has no idea what's right or wrong. I have tried to tell him there's nothing wrong with how I'm breastfeeding but it seems he believes his mum over me since she's a nurse.

As I'm sure you know you know this is a DH problem and honestly he is being spineless if he won't at least do his own reading/research on breastfeeding. Its a total cop out to say "I dunno".

Nurses are not automatically breastfeeding experts - not all midwives are unless they have longer experience. If you can find a breastfeeding counselor from La Leche or NCT or similar for advice that might help you, might even convince DH but that will still leave the issue of a DH who defaults to "wot mum says". That is a whole different can of worms which may or may not be liveable long term.

LemonDrop22 · 21/10/2022 23:59

Breastfeeding in the Western world declined significantly from the late 1800s

Was formula available from that early or did anyone who could afford to farm it out to set nurses?

kateandme · 21/10/2022 23:56

BlodynGwyn · 21/10/2022 22:59

Interesting comments. I wondered what was going on with some women when it came to breast-feeding.

I breastfed both of mine and I was breastfed by my mother. I'm almost 70 and my mum was born in the late 1920's. So, no woman in my family, on both sides, ever used formula. My oldest child is almost 50 and I was the only woman in the hospital who was breast-feeding. I was 21 yrs old and nobody instructed me how to hold the baby, or stuff about latch or how often to feed. The only woman who'd seen anyone breastfeed before was my British midwife. I was living abroad away from my family. I just fed him whenever he wanted to. With no outdated advice we did great.

My daughter-in-law was bottle-feed and so was everyone in living memory in her family. Thankfully she is breastfeeding her new baby and loves how easy it is. She got a bit of negative feed back about breast-feeding from her family, who live very far away. They thought it was a gimmick and you still needed to have formula, bottles and some sort of bottle sterilizing machine. Her dad even said he'd come over here to help her with the night feeds and when she needed to 'get away' from her darling little baby. He was told to stay away.

Breastfeeding in the Western world declined significantly from the late 1800s to the 1960s.[21] By the 1950s, the predominant attitude to breastfeeding was that it was something practiced by the uneducated and those of lower classes. The practice was considered old-fashioned and "a little disgusting" for those who could not afford infant formula and discouraged by medical practitioners and media of the time.[2] Letters and editorials to Chatelaine from 1945 to as late as 1995 regarding breastfeeding were predominantly negative.[

fruitbrewhaha · 21/10/2022 23:55

I’d probably tell her she’s not a good enough grandmother.

LemonDrop22 · 21/10/2022 23:52

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 21/10/2022 23:41

She is itching to get your dc to herself isn't she?

Yeah it's interesting that she's said she wants to take the baby (because neither of its parents in her view can look after it properly... while I'm sure you're doing no worse than the vast majority of new parents) and coincidentally wants you to stop doing the thing that most obstructs her taking the baby or having the baby for any length of time.

Goosygandy · 21/10/2022 23:52

goldenroses95 · 21/10/2022 21:26

I have spoken to DH about not backing me up and his reasoning is he's never had a baby before so he has no idea what's right or wrong. I have tried to tell him there's nothing wrong with how I'm breastfeeding but it seems he believes his mum over me since she's a nurse.

Midwife and health visitor gave me the worst advice on practical things. Best advice came from other new mums.

Thursa · 21/10/2022 23:50

My mil told me the same thing. My breast milk was apparently such poor quality it was the reason my son had colic. She was shocked when I decided to breastfeed my second child too.

LemonDrop22 · 21/10/2022 23:49

Your MIL is correct that you should do your best to eat nutritional food ....

A pizza is not not nutritional food. It has carbs, possibly vitamins added to the wheat flour, lycopene in the processed tomato topping, and all the nutrients that are in dairy products. If it has a sourdough base, might have some probiotics.

And op did not even say she's regularly eating pizza, just a once a week or whatever.

And new Mums need plenty of energy from carbs etc.

Mil is clearly crackers.

Weight stability/gain is what is important re feeding the baby. That's up to op and her health professionals to guage and strategise on.

If you even bothered engaging with this mad woman who wants to take the baby away ...n I'd ask for what breast feeding education and experience she had, what training, what courses, what books and other info, web sites she had read etc etc. Where is the breadth feeding knowledge and expertise she feels she had coming from.

Though she'll probably just bullshit about common sense yada yada.

Summerfun54321 · 21/10/2022 23:42

She’s bonkers. “Thanks for your advice but we’ll have to agree to disagree” say that every time she says someone stupid and shitty and rude.

Sounds like you’re doing a great job OP, keep going.

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 21/10/2022 23:41

She is itching to get your dc to herself isn't she?

Milkandhoneybees · 21/10/2022 23:39

Your MIL is correct that you should do your best to eat nutritional food, take breastfeeding supplements etc but the way that she has gone about it is cruel. If she feels you’re going for junk meals (which loads of us did in the utterly exhausting early stages of having a baby) then she should be there cooking you meals and bringing you nutrient-rich food — or telling your DH to do so!

She is most likely suffering empty nest syndrome and is jealous that you’re her grandchild’s mum and not her, so is picking holes.

I think you should work on your DH here, rather than her. Talk to your health visitor about breastfeeding in front of him, or send him videos, articles etc about cluster feeding, so that he is knowledgeable on the topic (which he should have done already, to be honest).

Babies can also breastfeed simply for comfort. Your baby is craving being close to you all the time because they’re teeny and still feel part of you.

You should also be forthcoming with DH about how your MIL’s comments have made you feel, and he needs to tell her that he finds her comments towards you unkind and unhelpful.

You’re a new mum who is trying to get used to so much, so the burden to sort this out needs to be on him, not you. Make that clear. He needs to honour your feelings and look after you now more than ever.

Enjoy your lovely little baby - wishing you all the best 💐

glassfully · 21/10/2022 23:39

Give her a confused look and say "Knowledge has moved on a lot since your day. I'm surprised you don't know that... as a nurse"

JhsLs · 21/10/2022 23:38

ProcrastinatorsAnonymous · 21/10/2022 22:22

Women have indeed breastfed since the dawn of humanity, but with a marked drop off in the 70s / 80s with the aggressive marketing of infant formula. Many mothers didn't breastfeed at all in the 80s, so have no understanding of it - meaning that instead of useful information being passed from one generation to the next, many of today's grandmothers are pushing uninformed views about BF onto their daughters and daughters-in-law. I hear SO many stories about women giving up on breastfeeding because of a mother or mother-in-law who gave birth in the 80s telling them that their milk isn't enough (because that's what they were told). I suspect there's also some guilt mixed up in it: they were pressured NOT to breastfeed, but are now hearing the message that "breast is best".

My HV told me exactly this! I adore my MIL but she made me feel so paranoid when I was in the first few weeks of feeding about my milk not ‘being enough,’ especially because he was up in the night feeding 4-5 times every night until he was about 6 months old. I felt so triumphant every time he was weighed and had gained weight 🤣

TooHotTooColdJustRight · 21/10/2022 23:38

pollyglot · 21/10/2022 22:55

Did your MIL BF? You are doing great!

My mother thought that me choosing to bf dd1 was a criticism of her. She could never get past it. Sadly I had be trained to not stand up for myself. Dh did that with dd2

Cats23 · 21/10/2022 23:35

TheBeesKnee · 21/10/2022 20:46

Is she physically present in your house, or is she harrassing you on the phone?

Kick her out/don't let her in or mute/block her number. It doesn't sound like she'll listen to reason.

You have a DH issue ultimately, does he undermine you in other ways or can he just not stand up to his mother?

100% this...
Why are you putting up with her?
Can you imagine in a few years if she says again ' Dont you love your child? about spmething else BUT your child is old enpugh to understand what was said to you by their grandmother???

Your DH is also a big problem

RainyDayyy · 21/10/2022 23:33

It’s not easy to ignore such comments. They’re really not necessary. You continue what you’re doing, you’re doing great. Create space between you and MIL.

My MIL has an issue and continued to make BF comments. There was a time I went to run errands for an hour and left baby with husband while she was visiting. MIL told DH to give baby formula because he was hungry. DH did to show that baby wasn’t interested in formula and baby got more agitated. I had fed baby before I left, he wasn’t hungry, he was missing his mum.

You are baby’s mum. It’s your choice/opinions that matter, not hers.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 21/10/2022 23:28

Tell her to go fuck herself

Somethingsnappy · 21/10/2022 23:27

bakewellbride · 21/10/2022 22:29

Nc now but I used to know someone a bit like your MIL. I knew I could never convince her or get her to think differently so I used to just agree with her and then quickly change the subject, it used to drive her crazy! E.g "I think it's time your breastfeeding journey came to an end." (Ds was only 1 ffs!) me with a smile "oh ok, I'll stop tomorrow!" then I carried on breastfeeding for as long as I wanted. It worked because it effectively ended the subject as there's nothing more the other person can say. Won't necessarily work with your MIL who does sound a bit more extreme. Congratulations on the baby.

Love this!

katepilar · 21/10/2022 23:26

Thats a nasty thing to say!
Hopefully its coming kind of with a good intention backed up by old-fashioned opinions and she cant do any better.
Of course your milk is the very best for your baby by far!

Unforgettablefire · 21/10/2022 23:22

What does not in the spirit mean?
Genuine question.

StaunchMomma · 21/10/2022 23:14

I'd tell her she is ill informed, and her ideas are well out of date. And I'd insist that DH backs you up on this. He really shouldn't allow her to be so rude to you, child or not.

Pottyhasamommymouth · 21/10/2022 23:12

Wow tell her to shut the fuck up and just stay home from now on. You know exactly what you're doing she will never do any care tasks for your baby.